I had the best experience with the most positive crew! They were respectful as well as funny! Best drive through experience I have ever had. They got my food out quickly!! read more

A night little eating spot right near Oklahoma State University's campus. The bagel and schmear are lovely. This was my first time eating there and at the chain. Nice for a snack or quick lunch. Gets really busy. I wouldn't recommend for the extremely socially anxious. read more

Old School Bagel Cafe - a variety of bagels - Cafes Near Me - Stillwater, Oklahoma

Great breakfast. I had the breakfast bagel on jalapeno (not the cheese one) it had a nice kick to it. Hubs had the lox and onion bagels. Very tasty and the service was very good! read more

Every single thing i tried to order they said they were out of. This is not okay. i ended up leaving and eating somewhere else. Also, the kids working there were so weird and awkward. read more

I ordered a four cheese bagel and added sprouts, avocado and Mayo and mustard. When I got home the bagel only had cheese and avocado and an ungodly amount of Mayo and mustard. So we go back. We were immediately met with a hostile and defensive attitude instead of just wanting to make it right. They claimed the menu has changed and did not want to own up to the mistake. I pointed at the menu where it clearly says cheese with lettuce and tomato and they girl talked over me and started to yell at me. There was no reason for this at all. If your menus in store says lettuce and tomato and I checked two different websites (uber eats and yelp) say lettuce and tomato then it should come with lettuce and tomato. Or if the menu really has changed (which I highly doubt since they also forgot the sprouts that I paid for) then you should let the customer know ahead of time. All in all horrible attitude and I truly think a manager needs to stop by and have a talk with them. Oh, and I got my new sandwich and they still forgot the sprouts that I paid for. I have left pictures of everything below. I will not be back because of this incident. read more

See all

Stopped in for some bagel sandwiches one morning and, they were certainly bagels - however they didn't blow me away. A really nice perk was how friendly and amazing the staff were. I would get another bagel for the experience they gave. read more

Old School Bagel Cafe - a bagel sandwich with cheese and guacamole - Cafes Near Me - Stillwater, Oklahoma

Cute little place with great food and hot coffee on this cold morning! Can't go wrong with an Asiago bagel toasted with cream cheese and a Caramel Macchiato read more

Old School Bagel Cafe - Caramel macchiato - Cafes Near Me - Stillwater, Oklahoma

See all

Foods great and staff is great for the most part- the girl who reads her book while taking orders is kinda rude tho.

I order online when I leave the house so that when I get to Shawnee for work I just stop by and grab our breakfast. It's always spot on in terms of quality, consistency, and ready to go! It's become a once a week ritual for us! read more

Service is good. The place is clean with plenty of places to sit. The breakfast bagels are good. I don't care for the sausage they use. My favorite is the ham egg and cheese. read more

All I ordered was a plain and toasted cream cheese bagel. It took forever to receive. It was okay. *they do not offer a military discount. Not a big deal, but good to know. read more

Old School Bagel Cafe - Cafes Near Me - Stillwater, Oklahoma

I am for a good bagel and these guys hit the mark. Came in from out of town, I had the ham/egg/cheese and my husband had the sausage/egg/cheese bagel sandwich. Both of ours were great and left us craving for more. We will definitely be back! read more

The food is always good and the coffee delicious. I just wish the opening staff was a little more friendly. I like to come here to get breakfast after working the night shift and when I walk in I'm usually just greeted with blank stares instead of a 'hello' or 'good morning'. With 2-3 people behind the counter you would think that at least one of them would have the decency to acknowledge the customer instead of staring at you until you tell them what you want to order. read more

Not sure they really wanted my business... went in for coffee and a bagel... both were cold. Girl behind the counter offered to 'nuke' the coffee...Didn't seem to bother her one iota that the coffee they were serving was ice cold! read more

Good bagel but it almost took a hour to get my order and the service wasn't good. I have been here before but the service used to be superb.

I've been to this location twice. I would say their food is just ok. Nothing to write home about. The restaurant is clean and it is a nice atmosphere. The staff is very friendly and they get the food to you quickly. Also you get 10% off if you like them on Facebook. They have lots of bagels to choose from and different sandwich combinations. Some look fun-such as the turkey guacamole, the cowboy, the reuben, to name a few. I just wanted a really simple sandwich. An everything bagel toasted (not sure if they really "toasted" it? It was warm) with just turkey and cheese. I also had lays chips and an iced tea. It tasted ok but it was just standard bland turkey meat and the main gripe was how little meat and cheese was on the sandwich. I wouldn't even really call it a sandwich. Sad because I love to support local businesses but they need to give back too! read more

Old School Bagel Cafe - Everything Bagel with Turkey and Cheese at Old School Bagel Cafe in Stillwater. - Cafes Near Me - Stillwater, Oklahoma

See all

Popular spot for breakfast and lunch with a nice assortment of bagel sandwiches for any time of the day. If you're really hungry, try the meat combo breakfast sandwich (or split it with a friend if you're not). The French toast bagel is awesome and their cinnamon rolls are the perfect shareable. Service is pretty fast and on this Sunday they had a busy crew of 8 working behind the counter. Don't want the carbs from a full bagel? Order yours scooped and they'll scoop a trough out of each side of the bagel. Normally I'd give this place 4 stars but today only 3. My toasted cranberry walnut bagel with maple walnut cream cheese was tasty but I was really looking forward to the flavor of the maple and it only came with a very thin coating of cream cheese, more like what you'd expect of mayo on a sandwich. Still, I do recommend this place but maybe more for the sandwiches than the bagels and cream cheese. read more

See all

Order the French Toast and they gave me some other bagel. I assured the person it wasn't the French toast from the other old schools in the city. read more

#1: if you advertise a lox and cream cheese sandwich, please put a reasonable amount of cream cheese on there. not the thinnest layer possible. #2: no cutting the sandwich in half?? #3: why did the contents of my sandwich spill into the bag due to the bagel being poorly wrapped?? I've worked in food service. I get it. Not always fun. And I don't like writing bad reviews. Ever. But at least do the bare minimum. I've worked at two different bagel shops and yes, this one included, in the past. Nothing has improved since I left, and honestly maybe even a little worse. Please put more care into making your sandwiches. read more

See all

Not that great anymore. Have been here many times and most recent visit was disappointing. Out of most bagels at lunch. When my husband ordered chicken salad they said "we don't make that because only like one in 500 people order it." So then he chose egg salad- same answer. We heard the lady behind us try to order egg salad also with the same response. Easy solution- just take it off your menu! read more

Staff acted extremely annoyed and bothered when I went to order. I ordered the first and was asked if I needed anything else. Then, she let out an additional loud sigh when I ordered my second bagel. Ruined the experience read more

My cinnamon roll was a little stale, but I did get it in the afternoon. The environment is friendly and the bagels are yummy, and much larger than expected. read more

Great jalapeño cheese bagel, had it toasted with cream cheese- yum! Next time I'll ask for it a little more toasted though.

Old School Bagel Café The slogan says "There's no NEW YORK in the name but the bagels are the same" ..... Well that's NOT COMPLETELY TRUE ! The only thing that is same.... is the Recipe for the bagels. Even with the ghost of times gone by THE BAGELS ARE NOT THE SAME . Said to see that this location falling short. I hate to say it but, the bagel is not cooked the same .. No Corn Meal on the bottom of the bagel, it doesn't look like there boil or baked in a oven... It does not have the density of that the NEW YORK BAGEL SHOP had .... The portions that they put on the sandwiches are the size of what a school child would eat. Gone I guess are good times of Brooklyn Bomber ... the Cowboy Club they severe isn't even close the the MAMMOTH ones the NEW YORK BAGEL SHOP used to serve .... People back in the day would Save theirs last $10. 00 just to buy a Brooklyn Bomber or a Cowboy Club at the end of the night of drinking at Eskimo Joe's . At least the staff is kind and prompt. It the best Stillwater can do ! So give it a try ! read more

See all

They used to be really good bagels, but every since the move downtown (or maybe there was an ownership change) the bagels have become pretty bad. They must of changed the recipe or process (shipped frozen to the store?). read more

Everything bagel was great! Boyfriend enjoyed his cinnamon bagel. Coffee was kind of bitter. It was quite and empty in there, around 10am, but I was okay with it. read more

Old School Bagel Cafe - Cafes Near Me - Stillwater, Oklahoma

Disrespectful staff, high prices, average quality food. Also don't offer to-go orders.

They are gone from Main St and moving to the Strip, between Wooden Nickel and Nooki. Sign on front door there says opening January 2020 (not yet, Jan 16, fyi). Good for students. Not so sure about community. Will update once parking evaluated. Maybe since they are morning-oriented the parking won't be as horrific as otherwise. read more

this place has gone down hill so quickly after the switch in owners. tables are constantly disgusting & floor needs to be swept so desperately. they are out of options way earlier in the day. bagels are terribly dry & poorly made. there are no lids or straws for fountain drinks anywhere to be seen. also, the price increase is RIDICULOUS & there is no reason to charge as much as they do for what they serve. there is a reason it's empty when it used to be busy. read more

I think this is a really good breakfast place to eat at and it's very unique and offers a lot of different bagel options. I have been to other bagel places and they don't compare. The staff is really nice and they prepare there bagels well! I recommend getting the bagel sandwich or if you are a Nutella lover getting the plain bagel with Nutella cream cheese.!! read more

Used to eat at the one in Tulsa on Peoria all the time, so I was thrilled when I learned there was one in my new hometown. Best everything bagels always! I do have one huge complaint though. I ask every time for this condiment and even the staff "wish we had some too!" It's called Tabasco! Get a large bottle and put it out at the condiment table already! How many times do we have to go through this?! The Peoria location has over a dozen bottles of varying brands and styles of hot sauce. read more

Very welcoming, thorough, and attentive! The cafe is clean and well kept, they were sold out of a lot of pastries which tells me that they must be delicious. The croissant I got was toasty, and doughy on the inside: just perfect. read more

Bagel shop that does not have a toaster. They have a sign that says "Toaster down" that has been up since they reopened months ago.

If you've been to Einstein Brothers or something similar, then you should know what to expect. OId School is pretty much identical. A great place to grab breakfast and sit for a while. read more

Close to campus. Fresh chewy bagels that don't need to be toasted. Reminds me of an east coast bagel. Large selection of bagels and fresh made cream cheese. Freshly brewed teas. read more

See all

It's ok. Not great, nothing to super complain about. Weird toaster issues the few times we've been there. First time, the toasters were broken. Other times the bagels were overtoasted and a little burned. Always seems a bit chaotic behind the counter. Because they're the only bagel place in town, we'll keep coming back...probably. It's no Einstein Bros though. read more

I love a good bagel Sammy so I went to check this place out and while their bagels are good they messed up my orders entirely .. Used the wrong bagels, left off the additions I paid extra for etc .. like a 2am post bar McDonalds trip, hits the spot but gotta check you got the extra nugs too. read more

Usually love this place. Yummy food. But we're from out of town and we stop here specifically for their iced tea. It is currently 1pm and after paying for drinks, there is no more iced tea left. We asked an employee if they were going to make more and he replied that "it's too close to closing time." Even though they close at 3. So that is two hours until they close, but he refused to make more tea. I have worked in several restaurants and know that the price of tea is relatively cheap. Very disappointed and wish the employee had more respect for his customers. Update: A female employee made more tea. Thank you. read more

Love this place, one of my favorite places to go for breakfast in town I highly recommend the breakfast sandwich bagel, it's great. Service has always been friendly and fast, and I will definitely continue to hit it up for breakfasts. read more

Good place for sandwiches or bagels. Overall the staff is friendly and the meals are made quickly and well! Come for coffee and a bagel or come for lunch. The old smokey is the best thing on the menu! read more