Great food! We had the asiago cheese dip and now I need to find the recipe. This was an all around great experience and will be back. We just left Big Whiskey because after 20+ mins we watched 2 large groups be seated after us and have drinks and appetizers as we left to come here! Thank you Old Chicago Pizza and Taproom! read more

Food is subpar. At least 3 of 5 visits, I've had to send my food back for inaccurate order. It's became pricier while food quality has decreased. Not a good combo. Over the past six months (we meet there to socialize-that's the only reason we go!), food service has noticeably declined. There are plenty more options in the area now, No need to settle. read more

Old Chicago Pizza + Taproom - Nashville Hot Chicken Wrap - Pizza Near Me - Rogers, Arkansas

If you enjoy wine with your pizza, this is NOT the place. It is a shame because I love their pizza and atmosphere but they recently started only carrying canned wine. When I brought my own and requested they charge me a corkage fee, new management said "no". Very disappointing as if you don't offer a decent wine selection, why not allow people to bring in their own and charge accordingly. Makes no sense. Fortunately I went up the road to another pizza place who gladly took my wine and charged a corkage. read more

This is going to get a little confusing but stay with me. I will explain. I ordered pizza here last year some time and just now realized I didn't write a review so here I am. First off, when I ordered over the phone I asked if they had Chicago deep dish, since it is called "Old Chicago Pizza" you would think of course they do, right? Well, let me continue. The girl on the phone said yes, we do. Just to double check I asked "It's the classic Chicago deep dish baked in a pan, the dough is pressed into the sides of the pan, and it's deep with lots of cheese, sauce and toppings right? I also, said "I'm not talking about pan pizza with the thick crust baked in a pan. I'm talking about the classic Chicago deep dish pizza. She said yes. We have that. So, I ordered one regular hand tossed and one Chicago deep dish. Get there, get my order, and the "deep dish" is not deep dish. It's pan pizza. Talk to a manager and he apologizes. Proceeds to tell me that they used to have deep dish but when people ordered it they thought they were ordering "pan pizza" and would send it back, so they took the deep dish off the menu. This makes absolutely no sense to me. Just put a very clear description of each style of crust on the menu with a picture. How difficult is that? The manager agreed to make me a true deep dish pizza (off menu I guess?) but it was going to be at least another 30 minutes. So, I said fine. I will come back. Came back, went to pay and he said no it's on me. So, that was very nice of him. However, not one of the three pizzas were good. They were all lacking in sauce toppings and flavor. All three of them. It wasn't the worst pizza I've had, but it was definitely not good. Furthermore, I'm looking on their website right now and they have cauliflower crust (I know what that is), tavern crust (I know what that is), Ale crust (which I had to google. It's their signature hand-tossed, and OC Thick (what is it?) So, is the OC Thick the thick pan pizza I was served last time? Or is it your regular hand tossed crust just extra dough? More confusion. Needless to say, I will not return here. I was tempted to get my tip back from the take-out hostess who gave me wrong information but I didn't. I just let it go. read more

This place never lets me down! The service is friendly and fast, and always willing to build my custom BBQ chicken pizza for me. Ambiance is a sports bar feel but quiet enough to have a date. I will always be back here for a pre bike race carb load! read more

See all

I've been going to Old Chicago for years--long enough to earn a mug--and it used to be a great place. Unfortunately, things have changed. The food is still generally good, but the atmosphere and management have become a real problem. It's become a toxic place for both employees and regular customers. The absentee ownership seems more focused on money and seems to have lost sight of the people who helped make it successful. After being a loyal customer for years, I'm disappointed to say I won't be going back. read more

Old Chicago. It is what it is. Not a special, have to go kind of place. Just in the neighborhood kind of place maybe if I was a beer drinker it would be different, but am not. The dry rub chicken was good! Service ok. Ambiance noisy and busy with too many TVs. read more

Nice selection of craft beer, a deep dish, Chicago type pizza that hit the spot Service was average, she was more occupied with the regulars on the other side of the bar, then checking back with me with regularity. Although, I did not have to wait too long for a beverage once my glass got empty. I will definitely come back when I'm in the city for my Chicago pizza cravings read more

I bought like 5 songs for 12 dollars on the music thing and they turned the music all the way down. Not cool!!!!! I am #pissed!!! Money grab. It wasn't even inappropriate- it was prologue of the Harry Potter soundtrack read more

Old Chicago Pizza + Taproom - My angry friends - Pizza Near Me - Rogers, Arkansas

The pizza and wings are solid here but I would not call it a true deep dish - the crust is a bit thicker but more like a thick hand-tossed vs a Chicago deep dish pie. That said, it is certainly a LOT better than a Dominos or Pape John's (albeit at 2-3X the price for a pie). I would recommend getting one of the party packs which gets you an appetizer, large 2-topping pizza, and cookie for ~$30. read more

We were looking for manga at Roger's Vintage Stock when we suddenly got a craving for some thick pizza. I had only been to this place once before with my mom, years ago when it first opened. After telling my lady about it, we decided this was the spot. The décor isn't anything to rave about--I'd actually prefer a little more personality. Nothing about it really screams Chicago pizza place; it just looks like any other sports bar in the area. That said, the service was great. Our waitress was very attentive and sweet. I'm a sucker for good fried pickles, and trust me, this place delivered. This was the highlight of the meal. The portion size was actually pretty satisfying. As for the pizza, I got the OG Thick Pan Crust personal pan Chicago 7, minus the pepperoni, but with Canadian bacon, pineapple, and jalapeños instead. It was good, but for the size, it felt a little pricey--that's a knock. Overall, it's worth trying, but probably not something I'd eat all the time. read more

See all

We stopped in as a family prior to a volleyball tournament. We were not greeted or seated right away but after we got to our table, the host came by to apologize for the delayed service and a complementary appetizer would be brought to our table. The manager then stopped by to make sure we were satisfied with our appetizer. CJ was our service. She was very welcoming, was funny, and made us feel at home. The restaurant was clean, well light and a cool place to hang out and watch the game. Can't recommend this place enough! read more

Awful service. Took us waiting 40 minutes and leaving before someone came to take an order.

Absolutely the worst service I've ever received. The bartender Jessica was so rude to us.. and verbally racist to our party. She refused to serve two members of our party, pretending that she didn't see them. I cannot understand why she is still employed. read more

Spinach and artichoke dip was nothing but grease and oil, Pizza was good, but "mid." Not coming back here....

We went in this place for an advertised happy hour. We were greeted by a rude hostess who could careless that we were guests. It only got worse with waiter. When asking about happy hour he treated us like we were being rude. He acted like we were morons for bringing it up and said the ad was out of date. To make a long story short... the customer should never be wrong. We were treated like crap even when we decided to stay by a apathetic staff. We will not go back after our sad, pathetic hour that they should advertise.., read more

Old Chicago Pizza + Taproom - Do not advertise a Saturday Happy Hour online if you don't have one - Pizza Near Me - Rogers, Arkansas

This place is a consistent favorite for my family. We usually go to Old Chicago once a week. I enjoy the atmosphere as it is very lively. It's a great place to go with friends especially if you want to watch a game. You can ask the workers to throw a game up on a tv for you. The service is always very quick and all the workers are so nice. I have not tried the beers, but I know it is a popular place to get beers on tap. They have so many different types and they have an award they give to those who try each one of them. The food itself is delicious. We always start with the Macaroni and Cheese Bites and the Bavarian Pretzels. Both of them have always been cooked well and have been enjoyable. They are very consistent. I have not had a bad pizza there. You can order the pizza on four different crusts and my family each gets a different one. I typically get the OC thick with pepperoni. It has a buttery crust that is cooked to perfection. You really can't go wrong here! I highly recommend getting a meal here. read more

Best grilled chicken sandwich in NWA Consistently good Ambiance is sports bar and fab!!!! read more

We had the most amazing service there tonight. Our server was kind and attentive. When our app didn't come out before our main meals, he and the manager corrected the situation promptly without us even asking. The pizzas we enjoyed were fabulous. Fresh and full of flavor! We ordered the Thai pizza and Tuscan chicken and enjoyed both. The cocktails were delicious and so reasonably-priced! Really everything was reasonably priced. It's a fun sports-bar type vibe all around. It was my first time there, and it won't be my last! read more

I am a vegetarian and ordered their 7 veggie something option. When I collected it it was nice and hot but when I came home and took a bite I realized veggies are not cooked at all. And this has mushrooms as one of the veggie. So not very happy and won't go again. People are courteous and helpful. Quantity is less compared to price you pay. read more

My wife and I stopped here for lunch last week. I knew they had outdoor seating, it was hot out and we had our dog with us so we got a table outside. We each had a lunch size pizza .my wife also had a salad with hers. The deep dish pizza was very good and she enjoyed her salad and thin crust pizza. The waitress was so nice and filled a bowl of water for our black lab twice. I would recommend Old Chicago Pizza. read more

We have eaten at this location a few times and thought it would be a great place to have my daughter's birthday. We decided to call and see if we could make a reservation. Our party was only 8, I believe the guys name that I talked to was Austin. He was not helpful and was trying get us to pay 1500$ to reserve the upstairs room. He was very short with me and did not understand what I was asking. We didn't need an entire area and if they don't do reservations he should have just said so. We went to a different pizzeria, it was great. read more

We ordered from Old Chicago today because we didn't want to go out. We ordered a Thick crust Veggie 7 individual which arrived cold and an Apple Walnut Salad WITH NO NUTS because my wife is allergic to walnuts. We ordered through Door Dash. (That's a different story) Suffice it to say, that the Dasher DIDN'T pick up the order. When they did, the order was an hour late and the salad was remade WITH nuts! We spent 30 minutes picking the nuts out of the meal, and there were STILL some in there! We TOLD them verbally to make sure there were no nuts, and yet...our evening was ruined because we wanted to relax with an appetizing meal and that was not what we received. This was quite a surprise, because typically they are not that inattentive. We will NOT order from them again anytime soon. read more

I recently moved here from CA and was excited to try this place. The food was good but the service we received at the beginning is what caused me to write this review. My friends and I went in 45 minutes before closing to sign in with the hostess, who immediately looked bothered and rolled her eyes before proceeding to ask how many people were in our party. I asked her if they were still open and she very rudely replied yes, I then said "ok because it seems that you're bothered and I just wanted to make sure you haven't stopped seating", she then roll her eyes again, grabbed some menus and started walking away. That was her way of sitting us to the table. It was all very uncomfortable. The rest of the staff from there on out was amazing though. I ended up finding out through her own colleagues that her name is Brooklyn. If you ever go here just beware of her as your hostess/server or maybe her manager can provide her with better customer service training to avoid situations like this moving forward. read more

My family had been here a few times and we have nothing but good things to say about this place! We always have had good service and extremely helpful! We have tried a few different pizzas here and they are all so yummy. We especially love the pepperoni rolls. They are so tasty! We like to come with our friends and it's family friendly too! Definitely worth a try. read more

See all

Pizza was very good and we had really good service their. Much better than the Old Chicago I tried in North Kansas City read more

The greeter at the door wasn't great or welcoming, but my waitress , Yasmine, more than made up for it. She was very nice, very attentive and had the best attitude! Great atmosphere, excellent food and I'm sure I had one of the best waitresses in the place. She had several tables but managed them all well and kept a smile! The only reason I didn't give 5 stars was the person at the door. read more

As always the food was hot or miss. The service was just so so even though the business was not very busy. Half the TV's in the place contrast/ color was blue. When we asked the server she said they had been like that and had not been able to fix it. read more

See all

Ordered the Spaghetti pie, I think I ordered with Italian sausage last time. It was better last time, I will make sure to order with meatballs or Italian sausage next time Kent had the Hawaiian pizza. He enjoyed it We also had the Prohibition lemonade, not our favorite adult drink Until next time read more

Old Chicago Pizza + Taproom - Prohibition lemonade - Pizza Near Me - Rogers, Arkansas

See all

I will NEVER order from here again. Overpriced for small portions, hardly any toppings. The fried donuts for dessert were small, hard and cold. I am disgusted and will spread the word. read more

The food was great! Megan was our waitress and did a great job! Everything came out quickly and tasted great!

They made a mistake and corrected, but sent the pizza that had the mistake with us in a box. Our server, Carson, was great! The kitchen manager was great! We all make mistakes, but they did more than make it right! read more

Amazing! I have loved the Pizza, the waiters were so kind, and the service was amazing, the Interior had a cool, rustic vibe that I would recommend. My waitress, Christa was so kind, and offered some of the best service I have ever received! read more

We were in on Tuesday and Jordan always takes great care of us. When we come in, she gets our drinks to us right away and gets our order in promptly. She always knows exactly when to refill our teas and when to bring our bill. She is the best! read more

The food and beer at Old Chicago is consistently very good. We went today 2/2/2025 and had cheese bread, boneless chicken wings and mozzarella sticks. It was all very good and would recommend 10/10. The service was excellent, Megan and Cassidy were very kind and helpful. read more

This is not any Chicago style pizza I've ever had (and I lived in the upper Midwest). So, yeah, I've had "real" Chicago deep dish. Old Chicago is just overpriced and pretty lackluster tasting. You could get a better tasting pizza at Pizza Hut or Dominos easily (and it won't cost over $30 a pizza for a small). Eat at your own risk, but be prepared to be underwhelmed and feel overcharged. read more

Our server, Skyler, was amazing! He explained things really well and was very friendly. 10/10 experience, I would be more than happy to come back. The food was good, very flavorful and the portions were very nice and filling. Usually sports bars and whatnot aren't my style, however the ambience and friendly atmosphere of the restaurant made me feel comfortable. read more

We ordered a pizza to go. The best thing about it was it was ready a little early. The thin crust was soggy, there was very little beef on the pizza. All in all, disappointing pizza. We won't be back. read more

Awesome selection of on tap beers, including local craft options. The menu is fun with a buffalo chicken appetizer and Mac and cheese entree options. They also offer the usual bar food that you can get to go with a couple beers. We went with a deep dish pizza. Tried to order pineapple on half, but our server told us they wouldn't do that, so we decided to order it for the whole pizza and pick it off half. Our pizza came out wrong and didn't have any meat on it, but it was so delicious, we ate it anyway. We didn't see our server for quite awhile, so we didn't wait around to eat. Although there was a period of time where our server was MIA for about 20 minutes, we enjoyed sipping our beer and eating our pizza while watching the games on tv. The view from the upstairs seating is nice and I will definitely be back in the warmer weather to enjoy the open deck style seating. I would recommend that they add some live music on the weekends to jazz it up a bit. read more

Old Chicago Pizza + Taproom - Pizza Near Me - Rogers, Arkansas

First time to eat at an Old Chicago Pizza. Arrived during their slow hours- a little before 3pm so suffice it to say, I was about one of 4 other customers. Asked to sit at a booth with an electrical outlet nearby if possible- done. The inside is two levels, TVs everywhere, booths & hightops. Menu has great variety- sandwiches, burgers, make your own mac & cheese, stromboli, salads, oh & pizza. It was still lunch (until 3) so ordered off the lunch menu (only difference I could tell was a personal pizza & endless salad special- other items were about a $1 less than dinner). Server was friendly & attentive (but again, he may have had 1 other table). Still, he recommended a yummy drink -like a Long Island Tea -on special for $4.00. Sure. He recommended the Crafted Beer Burger- "steak burger cooked in light lager w/carmelized onions & a cheddar cheese made with Guinness." They also ask how you'd like it prepared. It was good - not sure about the steak & beer taste but it was tasty. Fries were great. Good prices, specials, service, atmosphere. Food kinda reminds me of Applebee's (meh) but a level up. Would definitely come back to watch football. read more