I've been to many college football stadiums, and they are all exciting in some similar ways, yet some are more unique than others. There's no other way to experience the Buckeye Nation than at the Horseshoe, and I don't regret my visit but I'm not sure that I would ever return. On the positives, it's historic and it's always thrilling to visit a place in person after having seen it so many times on television. Any sport is more fun live and in person. This stadium is almost twice as big as Northwestern's home field, and about 10 times as loud.
I've had a career in event management, and the security here is excellent. I notice these things. From the ushers to the police, the in-house to the subcontracts, this place is run well. Concessions are only slightly overpriced and service is quick. As you might expect there are no healthy food choices, though I'm not sure that I would choose healthy at a football game anyway. As you might not expect, you can get beer here, though that is more overpriced than the food. In spite of the crowd, minimal wait for restrooms, signs and directions are clearly posted, sightlines are mostly good unless your friends get you tickets right behind the band, score boards and sound system are top notch. You don't need a sound system to enjoy the OSU marching band, they are elite and should not be missed. Come early and stay late to hear and see. Don't waste time at halftime standing in line for a hot dog, use the rest room earlier or later, instead see and experience the halftime show.
There are two negatives, one common, one unique. As is the case in all the Big Ten stadiums I've sat in, the seats are uncomfortable and too narrow. The assumption seems to be that all fans are about 135 lbs. At capacity, and this place is always at capacity, this means that if everyone is sitting, not everyone can sit. At an exciting game, this isn't a problem, we spent a lot of our time standing. At any given time, some people are not at their seats, so it sort of works out, but the comfort difference with professional football stadium seating is notable. Maybe this is just part of the college football experience.
The unique negative is Ohio State Football Subculture, in some ways very different from the rest of the Big Ten. I've been to away games wearing Northwestern Purple and every place but here I've felt safe and welcome. Good-natured teasing never trumps good sportsmanship elsewhere, we're all graduates of excellent research universities (well except for the University of Illinois). We're all Big Ten fans, and we all know what it feels like to be disappointed by our teams. Probably most Ohio State fans are also like this, but in a crowd of 100,000, if one in ten are rude and obnoxious, that's a difficult environment if you're one of the 5% of attendees wearing visiting team colors. I experienced an uncomfortable amount of verbal abuse on the way in and out (which is a long process on game day Saturday) well beyond the friendly trash talking fan banter acceptable elsewhere. I'm not talking about drunken college students, I'm a college professor, I'm well used to disrespectful 20 year olds, but rather actual adults who should know better. Inside the stadium the crowd control workers make everyone feel safe, and sitting near the band family and guests is different because there's a musician sense of camaraderie and respect that transcends football.
I'm a pretty brave guy, generally. I used to work an ambulance serving the Stateway Gardens Housing Projects in Chicago's South Side; for a while I was the sole overnight security guard in a doll factory. But here, I was reminded of the advertising tagline for "Aliens" when it first came out: "There are some places in the Universe you don't go alone." read more