Who really rated this place two stars? This has to be top four pizza places in Cleveland area easily. I appreciate that they don't try to be anything other than their own original of pizza, not New York, Chicago or Detroit style. Had the paradise and the basic b. Both were fantastic. Ordered extra sides of sauce for dipping because we are a sauce family. The cookies were a pleasant surprise when I went to pick up. I can't wait to go back and try the other pies! Keep in mind this place is new and very popular so you will have to wait and keep calling to get through. Hard work and perseverance pays off though! Order early as they sell out, watch their social media pages for updates. Staff and owners are extremely down to earth and nice as well read more

People were raving about this place on local page. I read on the business fb page how they sold out so quickly. As a food enthusiast, I was curious and gave it a try tonight. I called around 5pm to place an order and was given a 45 minutes wait. My first disappointment is that they only have one crust option, no thin crust!! :( Ohio Pie is located in the same plaza as WF, on the strip near Penn's Station. From the aroma, the pies smell just like the ones from Pizza Hut (sorry!). Upon opened up the boxes, I noticed how greasy they are (again remind me of PH). Here is the kicker. The pizza sauce on the cheese pizza was extremely, crazy sweet! My kids are pizza fans, but they couldn't even finish their first slice. I also tried a slice of cheese pizza and found it was indeed too sweet. Did I mention the dough was really chewy??! The crust was more chewy. The Basic B was alright but a bit bland. It was missing something acidic (maybe glazed balsamic sauce) to balance it out. The cookies are soft, but overly sweet. They are too greasy. At the price of 2 cookies for $5, guess I can save the money and calories. Overall, it's just not as good as everyone has made it out to be. I don't get the hype! Maybe everyone just wants to support local business, but I was quite disappointed. Sadly, we won't be coming back. There are better options in surrounding area (won't name names here). read more

See all

Never, ever again! You just lost a longtime customer. One of your lady employees was extremely unprofessional when I called in my order for pickup this evening. Someone needs to tell this Neanderthal that you treat customers with respect! You don't answer the phone, "YEAH?". You say "May I take your order please?", and the like. And then to talk over me then hang up when I wanted to simply confirm the order, precisely because I wasn't sure that you took it accurately in the first place because of your rushed, brush me off attitude, is just wrong. The ONLY reason my wife came in to pick up the pizza after I was treated like this, is because our special needs daughter was so intent and happy to be getting her favorite pizza! I am changing my original 5 star review to 1 star. Please learn some decent customer service! read more

I go to Whole Foods all the time but never got around to Ohio Pie Co until now. All I have to say is I wish I could've been here SOONER!! Sauce is delicious with a hint of sweetness, crust was perfect! Also they didn't disappoint with the chicken topping!! Please keep up the great work! read more

Ohio pie - Cookies!!! - Pizza Near Me - Rocky River, Ohio

See all

Great pizza! I could eat it every day! Everything is always fresh! The service is always quick! There are many choices here as well! Buffalo chicken pizza is very good! The garlic bread is excellent! When you order pizza, be sure to order garlic bread with your pizza! read more

Tried Ohio Pie Co a couple weeks ago. The pizza was great, I loved how creative they are too! We tried the After School Special which I was super nervous about, but it was really tasty! I also appreciate that when you call to order the first thing they tell you is the wait time. Would totally recommend to anyone looking for a great pizza option or if you're into trying different toppings! read more

Ohio pie - After School Special - Pizza Near Me - Rocky River, Ohio

See all

Called and ordered on the phone...I had the Parasdise pizza, super tasty, definitely recommend !

They put peppadew peppers on your pizza! Enough said! Love it. Will be back for more pizza!

Best pizza in Ohio hands down!! I've never had a pie from here that wasn't absolutely delicious. Make sure you save room for a cookie or two!! They are just as yummy as the pizza!! read more

Ohio Pie is the only place our vegan daughter will eat. Every visit has been on point. And the cookies, you must get the cookies!

Amazing pizza. It's worth the drive for us and love the fast service. The speciality pies are so creative as well. Our favorite specialty pie so far was the sausage and peppers. We ordered that once a week when they had it. The sauce splashed on top is amazing. The sauce is sweet and garlicky. We order here at least once a month and love this pizza. read more

After reading reviews I thought I'd give it a try. Too bad my car wasn't low on oil, I could have wrung out the pizza and box. I have never had a pizza soaking wet from grease. Several people mentioned that their pizza is greasy, but it was disgustingly wet. From the little bit I had, I could tell it had good flavor, so I know they have potential. If they could only figure out how to reduce the amount of grease I'd be back. For now, I'll pass. It's unfortunate because I'd rather support smaller businesses but I threw most of it away. What a letdown. read more

See all

Best pizza in town, I didn't even know about the 1 at this location! I was used to going to the Brunswick location

We get pizza here all the time. It's kinda like a Detroit style in a round form with lots of toppings. Def get the Heartburner. It's soooo good and juicy!! read more

I give the Ohio Pie Co Rocky River five slices! I didn't want to love "The Basic B", but I do. The Fiestada might be a secret menu item, but this pizza is also a hit. Sometimes it looks a little overdone, but it taste just right. I recommend this pizza joint to anybody, especially those who think they already know what the best pizza is. read more

By far, this was the best vegan pizza I've had -- I ordered the "Earth Crisis" and my husband ordered "The Kennedy." Both were delicious, but the Earth Crisis was my favorite (The Kennedy has a slight "kick" to it, for those who are sensitive to spicy food). There are chairs inside where you can sit while you wait fit your pie to be made, and Whole Foods is conveniently in the same plaza. The staff were also very friendly. Overall, would highly recommend! read more

Ohio pie - The vegan "Earth Crisis" pizza -- so delicious! - Pizza Near Me - Rocky River, Ohio

Really tasty pizza. Definitely different than anything around here. I've never had Ohio style pizza before but now that I have I'll be having it again. read more

Hands down the best vegan pizza out there. Vegan cookies available too. A bit more expensive than your standard carry out pizza, but SO worth it! read more

Great pizza, amazing brunch pies and cookies. Also, the owner seems to treat his staff really well and for that reason alone, I feel great to spend my money at this place. read more

The chicken and barbecue pizza was amazing!!! We ordered on a Sunday and our pizza was ready for pick up within 20 minutes. The pizza and the garlic bread were amaZing!!! Definitely will try this spot out again. read more

Definitely the best pizza in the Cleveland area. Called on a Friday night around 5:30 pm - was about a 45 min wait but well worth it. Got 2 pizzas - a veggie and a pineapple + peppadew peppers. I loved the pineapple pizza. Easily 10/10. The veggie was about an 8/10. We also got party bread, which is not your average cheesy bread. Do yourself a favor and get some cookies with your order. They are easily the best cookies I've ever had. Recommend it all. read more

My favorite local Cleveland pizza that I've discovered so far! Delicious! Two tips for the best experience: (1) Get at least one sauce cup, preferably two for a large (the first is free). Their sauce is delicious, but I've never got a pizza from there with sauce evenly applied. Some pieces are just right, others are completely dry. (2) Put it on the floor of your car riding home, not the seat. Serious grease leakage out the bottom. Now you're good to enjoy their awesome pizza! read more

Heard they were good so I tried them out. No wait like other posts stated. Amazing pizza. Loved the cookies too.

Great pizza - a whole lot of pepperoni and sausage - a refreshing change!! Will definitely get pizza here again.

Cookies are great. Can't go wrong with the Buffalo chicken pizza as well. Just wish they had delivery. Everything else about Ohio Pie Co is phenomenal including service. read more

I was so intrigued and excited to try this pizza and boy it didn't disappoint! We ordered the Heart Attack and the Basic B and both were delicious! The toppings were generous and both the white and red sauce were fantastic! I can't wait to order from here again! read more

Been waiting for the river joint to open and Voila!! ordered the "Heart of it all" and the "Piggy Bird". both were really really good! I can't wait to try other pies on the menu along with the brunch pies!! thank you OPC!! read more

When this business first opened I thought it was OK, but after eating there enough it's not for me. The sauce is too sweet and there's no other sauces to choose from other than a white sauce I believe. Speaking of the sauce they put it on top of the cheese which is fine, but it seems like the cheese just gets mixed in with their dough and you don't taste it. I've asked if they can make a traditional pizza with the sauce on the bottom cheese on top and cut it into triangles they would not. That's another issue I have I like square pizza, but they won't cut it any other way for you. The one great thing about this place is the cookies. I cannot complain about those cookies they are delicious and the staff very friendly. My score is solely based on the pizza. read more

The best pizza I've ever eaten. Excellent vegan options, they even go out of their way to make their specialty pizzas vegan friendly. This is the only restaurant that I've never been accidentally given something non-vegan when ordering vegan. Super friendly staff, super fast service even when it's busy. read more

This place Never disappoints. Pizza is absolutely DELICIOUS. Regular staple at our house.

Love love love!!! Vegan options and regular are amazing! They have specials too they post on their Facebook page. And don't forget to get a cookie! read more

Not sure I understand the high ratings. I tried it for the second time just to make sure but it disappointed again. I will say their ingredients are good quality but they need to learn how to cook their pizza and that's not easy. It's a bit to greasy for me and way too chewey and the crust is below average. It's not a fun pizza (especially the middle pieces) to eat as it is messy. If they went with a thinner crust and cooked at higher temps and made it a bit crispier they would have a winner. Still looking for a good pizza place on the west side but this isn't it unfortunately. read more

Got the pepperoni and the white pizza. Sauce I found was very sweet which was good at first but then became a bit much. the pizzas were very greasy and undercooked as they were very doughy in the middle Thought it was good but not great. But I woukd definitely try it out to see if you like it read more

Awesome stuff! I recommend trying a half and half with their sausage and vegan sausage. Order a little extra sauce, too. Grab a few cookies. Enjoy the vibe! I get their Thanksgiving pizza knowing full well I can't eat more than a couple pieces - and freeze the rest. It will literally taste just as yummy a month later, if you know how to treat a frozen piece of pizza. Enjoy in Brunswick OR Rocky River!! read more

This place has pretty okay pizza, I'll give them that but wow I can't with the workers here. First, we called the store to order a pizza. We haven't been here except for 1 other time so we didn't know about their pizzas very much. We asked the girl what the most popular specialty pizzas were. She listed off like 2. Then proceeded to tell us that we'd have to look at their menu because she doesn't know what else they have. She was extremely unhelpful and even disrespectful for the one not knowing their own food and acted like she didn't know anything about their pizzas. She acted as if we wasting her time. Then we called a different time weeks later to order pizza again. This time we had simply asked what her favorite pizza was there. She listed off a vegan sausage pizza? After discussing for literally 20 seconds to see if we were down for a vegan pizza, she told us we needed to get off the phone if we didn't know what we wanted and that she had customers waiting. She told us to call back when we were done figuring it out and then hung up before we even got the word "bye" out. This is funny because we pull up outside the restaurant and call back just to have a different girl answer while the other one takes an in-store order. Why couldn't they have done that before instead of basically telling us we're wasting their time and to get off the phone. All I have to say is, get better workers. read more

The Heartburner and the Buffalo Chicken are both great choices if you are having a small gathering. They are the perfect amount of cheese and toppings. The Heartburner has a good ratio of meat to cheese. The BC has a kick, which is true to what a Buffalo chicken should be. For sure pick up one of the cookies at the register. I loved the Cinnamon Toast Crunch one. read more

This is the best pizza I have had. Crust is great and you actually want to eat the edges instead of feeding the dogs.

This pizza is absolutely amazing. I live near so Collinwood and choose to come to rocky river for great tasting pizza. My daughter and I bought 4 pizzas. 1 large and 3 smalls (one was for granny). Not only did I want to leave a great review but I called back to the store to say how great it was. Staff was pleasantly surprised at a favorable comment. We had 4 different specialty pizza pies. Keep up the great work! read more

In love with their vegan options!! So many to choose from and so good that I get nervous they aren't vegan. Same goes for the cookies! I'm so grateful they opened in Rocky river! read more

I've gotten pizza from here two times. The pizzas were delicious! Both times I ordered, there was so much grease it leaked through the box onto my shirt and seat. So when you order, place the pizza box on a towel or something. read more