Had the Margy pizza and a "Mint" Lemonade. The pizza was delicious! Worth the price? Eh, no. But, it was still really delicious. The "Mint" Lemonade, on the other hand, was the opposite; that, I absolutely cannot recommend. The service was just alright. We stood waiting for someone to appear to take our order for a while... I only kept waiting because I was meeting some friends. I did love that it's in the outdoor courtyard, so it was nice to sit outside to eat a good pizza and enjoy the sunset. Happened to score a parking spot in the coveted little lot behind The Cheesecake Factory, so walking practically right up to Mikey's from there was fast and easy. I'd definitely eat here again if the prices weren't so dang high. The pizza is good, but not good enough to justify the high cost... read more

We always order this! Pepperoni, broccoli with fresh mozzarella! I don't know why, but this combination is so good! read more

Mikey's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Westlake, Ohio

BEST DANG THANG...LEMONADE!! Buy two they're fantastic!!!!! Service was friendly and we enjoyed meeting them. I hope they sell it in the stores !!!! read more

Best pizza around! We always get the hot honey and add sausage. Crust is thin and crunchy. You won't be disappointed!

Mikey's is easily one of the very best pizzas in all of NE Ohio! The crust, aromatic sauce, and cheese all taste fresh, and make for a perfect, well balanced slice (or whole 'pie')! If you are in the mood for a delectable, proper, authentic NY or NJ style pizza, Mikey's hooks you up. Walk up to the counter with swagger, and say "YO LEMMEGETTASLICE"! read more

Order a pizza with green peppers... Got jalapeños! Everyone at the house absolutely hated it the kids were cryin! On top of that the pizza was cold and greasy. I would not recommend this place... especially at the price ($34)! read more

Mikey's Pizza - Kinda crappy pizza. - Pizza Near Me - Westlake, Ohio

Amazing Pizza!! Wonderful Staff! 5 Stars! Never skimpy on ingredients! Broccoli is not frozen read more

Mikey's Pizza - I am in Heaven!!!! LOVE LOVE LOVE Mikey's Pizza!!! - Pizza Near Me - Westlake, Ohio

Stopped by for the first time during Cleveland Pizza Week so I could try the "Cheeto Inferno" pizza. While this is a regular menu item, this was their special for pizza week as it was only $8. When pizza week was announced, I set out to try a few places I haven't had a chance to visit, and this location was my first stop of the week. I don't normally get out towards Crocker Park, so I didn't know what to expect from a location standpoint. Once I found street parking, I found the Mikey's stand, which is located in a cluster with a few other businesses. I called in my order on the drive over, and only had to wait a few minutes once I arrived. The pizza itself was very interesting with the almost crusted flaming hot cheetos on top. The slices held together very well, as I didn't have a trail of flaming hot dust all around my apartment. Taste wise, it wasn't as hot as I was expecting, which was a good thing, and the ranch drizzle offset the flaming hots. The crust was thin with minimal flop. I likely wouldn't try this particular pizza again, but would like to return and try some of the other pies. Looking forward to coming back. read more

Mikey's Pizza - Cheeto Inferno - Pizza Near Me - Westlake, Ohio

Sometimes you just need a slice of cheese pizza, a single slice - no fuss or frills. If the slice happens to be the size of my head who am I to complain? I love this place because it satisfies your pizza craving while you wonder through Crocker Park without it being expensive or forcing you to buy an entire pizza. If you want to buy an entire pizza, that is an option and who am I to dissuade you. They have several types to chose. Though if you just want a slice, not all of the choices are always available. That day I had a craving for cheese, simple and the the point. A friend got the pepperoni. We happened to come on a day where it was buy 2 slices of cheese for $5 or so, so of course I had to. Was this the best pizza I've ever had? No. But it was a decent slice. The sauce had a bit of sweetness to it, the cheese adequately covered the pizza and yes it was greasy. It hit the spot just right and the service was quick which is great because I could've eaten a bear at that point. We were lucky enough to come on a sunny day that wasn't too cold because this little place is located at the center of Crocker so the seating is outdoors. You can try to walk and eat but the pizza is a thin crust and, as mentioned, the size of your head so that may be a bit difficult. But if you can manage that, kudos to you because you are more skilled than I am. read more

Mikey's Pizza - Two slices of thin sized cheese pizza for $5 - the size of your head, I see no downside. - Pizza Near Me - Westlake, Ohio

See all

All the years I have been to Crocker Park and have gotten this pizza, and have loved it everytime! They are at one of the kiosks outside by barnes and noble. They serve pizza by the slice, and also by the pie too. Last time I went I got the Devils Demon slice of pizza. It was delicious! If you haven't stopped by, you should! read more

Mikey's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Westlake, Ohio

The pizza here is fantastic. The dough/crust is the standout. The red sauce and all the toppings have been delicious too. Look out for their specialties and pizzas of the month. Unique twists on pizza that are just as good if not more so (try the rueben). The service has been great too, they have always been able to cater to ingredient restrictions without hesitation. Wish they had a brick and mortar so the pizza can be enjoyed straight outa the oven but the location definitely works in Crocker Park. read more

Mikey's Pizza - Sausage, No Cheese - Pizza Near Me - Westlake, Ohio

See all

Mikey's is the latest, for a couple years now, pizza stand at the designated outdoor pizza spot crocker Park. It's good thin crust pie. Reminds me of the NY style pie from pizza king at the old millcreek mall in Erie where I grew up. Big slices, the pepperoni oil slick kinda drips off which is what u want for this thin crust large slice. 2 x pepp for $6, 2 x cheese for $5. Paper plate napkin place. They have drinks & take credit cards. Whatever that system that remembers u is what they use. Sit out in the sun at tables that are usually clear of debris. today first day of fall they have the fake fires roaring. I enjoy it. Never a long wait. Easy peasy. I don't get the fancy pies or salads but they have them. The meal deal seems like a decent price but I've never done the math. It's the weekend what do u want everything. 3 stars it's good. read more

Still great every time I have it. Now that I'm local it is my pizza night go to.. Service is friendly, location is a summery pop up vibe with fire pits for cold weather. A little pricey but well worth it. read more

Sometimes on my way back from work, a couple NY style slices from Mikeys is what hits the spot. Solid pizza with great ingredients. What's not to like one of these days I'll get around to trying their wings read more

Very mediocre pizza. We were looking for a good NY slice you could fold in half and eat and this was not it. Crust was cardboard like and the cheese was rubbery. read more

This place is a great spot for delicious and unique pizzas! The classic pepperoni is great but we really enjoyed the Devil's Demon for a spicy flavor! On the second trip, our order got mixed up and Mikey called us immediately to fix it and included some M&M cookies for the kids too. We really appreciated the customer service and will be back for more pizza soon! read more

Brought this pizza to Siblings Rivalry Brewery!!! Amazingly delicious! Cheese pizza was perfect with our beer! read more

Mikey's Pizza - two slices of pizza in a box - Pizza Near Me - Westlake, Ohio

My son was doing a landscape project and the homeowner ordered the guys a pizza from here. It was an unusual combination, but she ordered pepperoni & broccoli. They loved it, so the next time we ordered a pizza at home, we got it from Mikeys with same toppings...yum! This is the remaining half! Gotta get the large with " fresh mozzarella! This is our go to when we order from here! read more

Mikey's Pizza - a half eaten pizza in a box - Pizza Near Me - Westlake, Ohio

Good slice of pizza and usually quick, but service is questionable. If you don't mind just ordering a slice and a drink with the cashier having some attitude, this place is perfect. Chicken waffles was different and the taco slice was delicious. read more

Delicious pizza and salads right in the heart of Crocker Park! Natural and locally-sourced ingredients always attract my attention. Hubby and I stopped here on our way back to Cincinnati - wish we had Mikey's at home. Love the concept of a walk up and being able to sit outside and enjoy the summer weather. The slices are HUGE (try the 4 Brothers) and their salads a' plenty (love the pear vinaigrette) Very reasonable prices and delicious food! read more

Horrible customer service. Placed an order around 6:10 on a Saturday night on an App. Got a note that it was in progress at 6:25. Got a note that it was cancelled at 6:40 (when it was supposed to arrive at 6:45). Called for the customary 'we're closed' noted in other reviews. If they don't want to deliver or interact with Apps, they should end the relationship, not cancel orders that people think are 3/4 complete. read more

Worst customer service I've experienced in a while. A family member called to see if they could accommodate a large group of us to come in to eat and the woman on the phone responded "no, but we could seat you outside" ... It's currently snowing. That's fine, we said we'll place an order. We placed it a minute later on the slice app in order to use a coupon. I waited 20 minutes only to get an email saying the order was cancelled. I call to follow up and I get a rude "we're closed" I responded with: I understand that but I want to make sure that the app didn't cancel my order because your website says you close at 9 on Fridays. "Yeah well it was a slow night so we closed at 7" So in summary, they had a slow night but couldn't accommodate our party. When we told them we were going to place an order they didn't tell us they were going to close soon. We ordered before 7 (regardless of knowing they were closing early) and after 20 minutes of continuously checking the app to see if the order was ready I get notified at 7:14pm that the order was cancelled. Either the pizza could have been done in that time or they could have called so as to not waste 20 minutes of my time. If an emergency happened that they had to close early I can understand that, there's other pizza joints around. It would have been nice to not feel like we were inconveniencing them both times that we called though. read more

I ordered the notorious from Mikey's... Absolutely delicious!!! The pizza fed me for the last 3 days and each day was just as good as the first! read more

Great spot for lunch if you are at Crocker Park or you can get it delivered with Uber Eats. The slices are huge and they regularly have special pizzas. read more

Mikey's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Westlake, Ohio

Tried the General Tso slice. Great flavor and the dough had great texture. Love the added Semolina for crunch.

Good pizza, generous portions and great price! I ordered 2 slices of cheese pizza for $5. The only complaint is the same guy who took my card in his hands, used his hand to help guide the pizza to the oven and also used this hand to play with his phone. Maybe a glove? read more

Mikey's Pizza has the most original pizza in Cleveland, but dont let that fool you their traditional styles will beat or compete with the very best. Mikey's is always fresh and original, and always comes with a friendly smile. Highly recommend read more

Great pizza! Crisp crust with loads of toppings. Sauce is prefect. Second time eating here and we will be back! Italian sub is one of the best I've ever had. read more

Terrible costumer service terrible. The dude was just plain rude all I wanted was a cheese pizza a single cheese pizza thats all but he insisted I got 2. So I was like what ever and made another transaction on a different card for my friend because he wanted a coke but didn't want to come with, after I got my coke but instead I received a cup of ice with a straw full of coke. I remembered I forgot to get ranch which is a basic necessity for my cheese pizza so he tells me it's 50 cents and I was like woah but I here go pull out my card because I don't carry cash on me and he says "it's 50. We need cash don't give me a card" so i didn't care I brushed it off and just waited for my pizzas. He grabs them and literally drops them in front of me saying "oh sh*t" and basically folded my pizzas literally looked at me and didn't offer me new ones so I was furious and left. Oh and the cup was dirty smh straight disgust. read more