Cancel

    Open app

    Search

    Off The Bay

    3.2 (5 reviews)
    Open 12:00 pm - 1:00 am (Next day)

    Off The Bay Photos

    You might also consider

    Recommended Reviews - Off The Bay

    Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
    Yelp app icon
    Browse more easily on the app
    Review Feed Illustration

    5 months ago

    Helpful 1
    Thanks 1
    Love this 1
    Oh no 1
    Photo of Stephen H.
    149
    110
    113

    5 months ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 1
    Love this 0
    Oh no 1

    1 month ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 1
    Love this 1
    Oh no 0

    5 months ago

    Very nice people, the service was amazing and we had no issues with anything. Highly recommend if you just want to have a bite and relax.

    Helpful 1
    Thanks 1
    Love this 1
    Oh no 0

    4 months ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 1
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    You might also consider

    Verify this business for free

    People searched for Seafood 2,120 times last month within 15 miles of this business.

    Verify this business

    Brunch Sayville - The Smattering

    Brunch Sayville

    3.9(69 reviews)
    0.2 mi
    $$

    Visited Brunch Sayville today with my husband and we had a nice breakfast. There was a bit of a…read morewait to dine inside, and once seated, we had to wait a while for our order to arrive. Although, we enjoyed the service and atmosphere very much, we had mixed feelings on the food. There were a few hits and misses. The All Day Sammie was huge and difficult to eat. The scrambled eggs were good, but the bread was crumbling with every bite. The hash browns were too hard, and the house-made sausage lacked flavor. That being said, I did enjoy The Smattering. I really liked their griddled bread with berry jam, and the breakfast potatoes and eggs were seasoned well. The bacon was fried too hard, but once redone, it was good. Our beverages were really quite good. The Butterfly Effect and the Elderberry Healer Tea were both nice options. We would return to try some of their other offerings.

    Another great experience at Brunch Sayville. I got the Brunch Pot Pie. Delicious!! Husband got the…read moreall day Sammie. He said next time he'd order with bacon. We also got a giant chocolate chip cookie and double chocolate chip. Both were excellent. This time, it wasn't as busy and the two people working that day were super warm and friendly. This is not to say my first experience, they weren't but I think the chef was also helping with serving. Our server this time was Colleen who was very attentive. We were greeted with a big welcome from Nick, who also gave me a crocheted heart. That made my day! Love Brunch Sayville!! I could easily become a regular here but next time, I'm trying something new!

    Photos
    Brunch Sayville
    Brunch Sayville - Ricotta Toast

    Ricotta Toast

    Brunch Sayville - Delicious coffee

    See all

    Delicious coffee

    Sunflower Cafe & Bakery - French onion soap

    Sunflower Cafe & Bakery

    4.7(59 reviews)
    1.6 mi

    Had our first dinner there last night and will def return! The French onion soup was delicious and…read morebountiful. My wife had the salmon and I had the jumbo shrimp risotto. Both were excellent! The risotto had asparagus and bits of shrimp in it. The salmon was tender and tasteful. Our friends had clams casino and halibut, which they loved! For desert we ordered the Silk 'n' Satin, which is cheesecake with a "dome" of chocolate mousse. And they meant a dome! It was one of the best deserts I have ever had and the 2 of us had trouble finishing it! Prices were all very reasonable for such quality French food. The waitstaff (all women) were knowledgeable and attentive. And both the owners (mother and daughter) stopped by to talk to us to make sure we were enjoying our experience. The restaurant setting itself is nice with calming, soft colors. Highly recommend!!

    The bad and the good. It was very cold, we spoke up and they made the AC a comfortable temp…read more Arrived at 5:00 & sat immediately. From time of seating to receiving entrees took an hour. The seats are wooden and some found them uncomfortable. The food was good. The striped bass was really tasty. The spinach was delicious with a hint of garlic. The au poivre sauce was a little too salty (2 people stated) but not inedible. If you are the type that orders salads or appetizers then you might be ok with a long wait. Some in our group were painfully hungry by the time entrees arrived.

    Photos
    Sunflower Cafe & Bakery - SUNFLOWER INTERIOR

    SUNFLOWER INTERIOR

    Sunflower Cafe & Bakery - Filet of sole menuiere

    Filet of sole menuiere

    Sunflower Cafe & Bakery - Escargot

    See all

    Escargot

    Buttermilk's Farmhouse

    Buttermilk's Farmhouse

    4.1(481 reviews)
    3.7 mi
    $$

    Super cute inside and our server was outstanding! Highly recommend this location!…read more - nice drink selection, homemade fresh-squeezed lemonade was refreshing and strawberry milk was nice to see for the littles - eggs cooked perfectly but the hashbrowns could've been more crispy and golden - breakfast burrito was filling and fresh - eggs benny had good real hollandaise but the biscuits were a little heavy - Really loved the decor (I see you staring at me goat) and comfy booths. Love the blue curved bar chairs! Lots of metered Street parking on main road and side streets.

    Buttermilks absolutely nailed breakfast! The Eggs Benedict were cooked perfectly--the eggs were…read moreexactly how they should be, and everything came together really well. Although there was a wait the service was great. They are able to accommodate anyone from large groups down to a single person and it's the perfect family/friendly get together spot for breakfast/brunch. The real home run, though, was the bacon and peanut butter pancakes. Such a great combination of sweet and savory, and the fact that they were able to prepare them gluten-free without sacrificing the taste or texture made them even better. You'd honestly never know they were gluten-free. Great breakfast/brunch spot with creative options and food that actually delivers. Buttermilks is definitely worth a visit, and we'll absolutely be back!

    Photos
    Buttermilk's Farmhouse - March 2026

    March 2026

    Buttermilk's Farmhouse - Rye

    Rye

    Buttermilk's Farmhouse - March 2026 Dining area

    See all

    March 2026 Dining area

    Toast Coffee + Kitchen - Storefront

    Toast Coffee + Kitchen

    3.7(50 reviews)
    5.0 mi
    $$
    23 years in business
    Family-owned & operated

    This was a great location! We were on our way to Fink's Farm and decided to stop here for…read morebreakfast. We started off with lattes, coffee, strawberry lemonade, and apple juice, everything was delicious! For our food, we got the omelet skillet, French toast, and the rancheros quesadilla. Let me tell you, the portions are huge! There were four of us and we only ordered three plates, and it was still plenty of food. The service was amazing; our server checked up on us regularly, and even the manager came over to make sure we were enjoying everything. The restaurant is clean, very well decorated, and makes you feel truly welcome. I definitely hope to come back again soon!" to Fink's Farm and decided to stop here for breakfast. We started off with lattes, coffee, strawberry lemonade, and apple juice--everything was delicious! For our food, we got the omelet skillet, French toast, and the rancheros quesadilla. Let me tell you, the portions are huge! There were four of us and we only ordered three plates, and it was still plenty of food. The service was amazing; our server checked up on us regularly, and even the manager came over to make sure we were enjoying everything. The restaurant is clean, very well decorated, and makes you feel truly welcome. I definitely hope to come back again soon! ¡Este lugar estuvo excelente! Íbamos camino a Fink's Farm y decidimos parar aquí a desayunar. Comenzamos con lattes, café, limonada de fresa y jugo de manzana, ¡y todo estaba delicioso! De comer pedimos un 'skillet' de tortilla/omelet, tostadas francesas y la quesadilla ranchera. Déjenme decirles que las porciones son gigantescas; éramos cuatro personas, pedimos solo tres platos ¡y aun así fue muchísima comida! Nos encantó que el servicio fue increíble; nuestra mesera estuvo muy al pendiente de nosotros e incluso el gerente vino a la mesa a asegurarse de que todo estuviera bien. El restaurante está limpio, muy bien decorado y te hace sentir verdaderamente bienvenido. ¡Definitivamente espero volver pronto!

    First we were seated at a table that was sticky and gross! I had to ask for extra napkins because…read moreit was so sticky my hands were sticking to the table. The Waiter agreed and recleaned the table. Orders were placed. Took 40 mins for our food to come out. The other people in my party made modifications to their order and I ordered exactly as it was listed on the menu . After waiting for 40 minutes for the food, my order the unmodified one was completely wrong. We tried to tell the food runner, he ignored me and put the plate down. He walked away. We waved him back over and told him again this was not the order. He took it back and then went to speak to our waiter. He came over and said what happened? We explained this was not what I ordered. He then went and looked at something and then came back and said I will have them remake this. This whole process took long enough that my friends were already eating. 10 minutes later the food was still not out. I called the waiter back over and told him to just cancel it. He said the manager was coming and she came over a few minutes later with the food. I told her I didn't want the food I was too annoyed at that point to eat. She said take it home. What I had cannot be reheated. She said well I'll leave it here because I'm throwing it out either way. Crepes with fruit on top just don't reheat well! At the point that the manager finally came by to bring the food my friends were 90% done with their meals! Everytime I looked at this manager she was on her cell phone, talking, texting or staring at it. I went to the bathroom and came out of the stall and the manager was doing talk to text in the bathroom. Perhaps if she stayed off her phone orders wouldn't be getting screwed up or patrons would not be sat at dirty sticky tables! Her whole attitude and demeanor ruined our whole experience there. She truly didn't seem to care. My friends picked at my dish but I was too annoyed to eat. I have eaten at Toast in Patchogue and Bayshore and enjoyed both experiences on every occasion that I have been there. I have eaten at this Toast three different times and every time I have left disappointed by the service but this is by far the worst! For all that aggravation she took my meal off and that was it. So thank you for ruining our nice girls lunch!

    Photos
    Toast Coffee + Kitchen - Nashville chicken and waffle

    Nashville chicken and waffle

    Toast Coffee + Kitchen
    Toast Coffee + Kitchen

    See all

    Cafe Joelle

    Cafe Joelle

    4.0(238 reviews)
    0.2 mi
    $$

    I love finding new favorites so close to home! After a few tastings at LI Salted Spirits…read moredistillery, we took a quick walk into town for dinner at Cafe Joelle and wow, the atmosphere alone caught me off guard. Such a gorgeous, hidden gem vibe with plenty of seating whether you want the bar or a table. The food was genuinely unforgettable, we were still talking about it days later. If you love bold flavor with a little heat, this is your spot. We got the Bruschetta (grilled herb crostini, mozzarella, plum tomato compote), P.E.I. Mussels (chorizo, cherry pepper, riesling white wine), Wasabi Calamari (sesame crusted, spicy soy ginger sauce, wasabi aioli), Shrimp Mezze Rigate (pesto, sun-dried tomato, asparagus, breadcrumb, ricotta salata), and Cherry Pepper Pork (pounded, breaded, pan-fried, lemon cherry pepper sauce, melted parmesan, green beans, roasted potato), every dish was packed with flavor. Don't sleep on dessert either: a chocolate shell you crack open to reveal mousse inside, we were fighting to get the last bites! Bonus: they carry LI Salted Spirits cans and cocktails right at the bar, so you can keep the tasting going. Plenty of parking, super friendly staff, and a great spot for everyone. Highly recommend, ten out of ten!

    Amazing dinner celebrating my sister's 70th birthday. Everyone was so friendly and chipped in with…read moreservice. Cocktails and draft list pretty solid. Their specials sounded amazing and their food is fantastic. Myself, I enjoyed a cherry pepper pork chop cutlet. It was huge, and I loved every bite of it. They even came out to sing when we ordered dessert and the entire restaurant chimed in which was pretty special. I would gladly return on my next visit to the area. Highly recommend.

    Photos
    Cafe Joelle
    Cafe Joelle
    Cafe Joelle

    See all

    Shands General - Eggs Benedict

    Shands General

    4.3(69 reviews)
    3.7 mi

    Good food Great service…read more Love the ambiance The people are very friendly and it's a warm feeling to go to a local place!

    This was our first time at Shands since the location was the brewery. The restaurant is beautiful,…read moreand we were looking forward to celebrating our 40th wedding anniversary there. I expected more of a high-end dining experience, but it felt somewhat casual, especially where we were seated in the front section next to a window. The restaurant was fairly quiet, so perhaps they were keeping everyone in one section, but for an anniversary dinner I would have preferred the more formal dining area. I made the reservation through OpenTable, indicated that we were celebrating our 40th anniversary, and even sent a separate note to the restaurant. There was a small "Happy Anniversary" place card with our menus, which was nice, but unfortunately there was no other acknowledgment of our special occasion. I was also a little surprised by the menus. They had nice leather covers, but inside were several separate sheets of paper, which seemed unusual for a restaurant positioned as upscale. I ordered the three-course prix fixe special. The website listed it at $55, although I believe the restaurant menu said $57. I had the Korean wings, which were huge and very tasty, although extremely messy, followed by the salmon, which was good. My wife had the rigatoni and said it was very good. Overall, Shands is a beautiful restaurant and the food was good. I just expected a little more from the overall experience, particularly since we were celebrating such a special milestone

    Photos
    Shands General
    Shands General - Pistachio tart

    Pistachio tart

    Shands General - Necessary Evil

    See all

    Necessary Evil

    Off The Bay - seafood - Updated September 2026

    Loading...
    Loading...
    Loading...