Reminds me of home in NY. Always love coming to this place. They nail the crust and their sauce is the best I've had period.

Excellent NY style pepperoni pizza...crust was perfect. Thin yet still foldable and chewy... nicely browned on the bottom. Great flavor.....your lucky Tulsa. Wish this place was in Rochester, NY. Will be back in Tulsa next month and will definitely make it a point to come back. read more

This is our go-to place for pizza within 10 miles of 51st and Harvard. I have to agree to a little inconsistency, but they continue to out do the competition. Warning, their jalepenos are HOT, and they are not skimpy with them. A must have. Stepped out and tried their lasagna. It was really good. I know we fed at least two people with a order. Small place, maybe 6 tables, easy parking, worth dealing with the construction to get to it. read more

We moved from Queens to Owasso a few months ago (10/2014) and have been trying to find good pizza. Success!! Trust me, it's authentic. Love this place. Excellent crust and perfect mix of cheese and sauce. Delish!! read more

NYC Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Tulsa, Oklahoma

food=deeelishhhhhhhh service=eh they forgot my pizza losing two stars in my booj#poorservice#dobetter read more

One of the best pizzas in Tulsa. Ive had pizza every corner of the US, NY, Italy, Naples, etc. The sauce is just right, not too acidic or sweet. The crust is just the right thickness, foldable but not too thin. The garlic knots are made with the same dough as the pizza and delicious when not burned. Two drawbacks which prevent a 5 star rating: skimp on toppings and little to no salad choices. read more

Big slices, crispy crust, cold pepsi. Not really worth crossing town for, but you have no excuse not to grab lunch here if you're in the neighborhood. Do yourself a favor and let your slice cool a minute before you bite into it; they serve them up scalding hot. read more

Good pizza, good prices. I am a bit embarrassed though cause the cashier has an amazing New York accent and I had trouble understanding. read more

NYC Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Tulsa, Oklahoma

Authentic East Coast style pizza pies. The restaurant has a nice divey feel to it which reminds me of the same pizza joints from NE PA. Good prices and friendly employees. Only regret is that Tulsa is a 45 minute drive from where we are at. I highly recommend this place for great pizza. Only one I have found in Tulsa area. read more

I grew up in the south Bronx. It has been 37 years since I have had a good slice. Until now. NYC pizza IS New York pizza. It is amazing! I drove 35 minutes to get there and worth every minute! And the strawberry cheese cake was awesome. If you like pizza you have to make the trip there! Its worth moving to Tulsa for. read more

NYC Pizza - Too late its all gone. Go get some!!!! - Pizza Near Me - Tulsa, Oklahoma

It's a good pie...Close to what I can get back in NYC. Depending on who's making the pie it can be great or so-so. They need to work on consistency...and please make the pie well-done. read more

I spent 15 years eating Brooklyn pizza, and this is my #1 favorite pizza I have found in the Tulsa area. I have two complaints. #1 they are too far from my house at 25 minutes each way. WAHHHH. #2 They tend to be heavy handed with the oregano, I always order a pie, no oregano, and they laugh at me, but really I can add my own IN MODERATION and it is FANTASTIC, Everything a pizza should be. Just right chewy flavorful well-developed crust, tangy homemade sauce, dripping cheese. I need some. Right now. read more

We have been going there (Harvard store) for a few years since our favorite pizza place closed. On most days it's excellent but once in a while it's poor because it's over cooked. Hit and miss. The soda dispenser ice maker is broken for several months and they are out of one or more selections almost every visit. Sadly it's strange to go for pizza and hear all the employees speaking Spanish. If you want to feel like you're in America, go to the one on south Memorial. It's always good there. read more

Great place to get the dessert cannolis. You can get the original or chocolate versions. The original is the best. Perfect place to a to go item. read more

I want a 10 star for this and sorry for saying this but the best fuc*ing pizza in so long I am from up state New York an havnt had that good of pizza in 10 years holy shit if you havnt had it yet best get your grease filled pizza now caz you won't have any better omg I will be back soon coming from shreveport read more

We went 05/29 on a Friday night. It was very busy! We still had our pizza ready in 20 min. Price point : $15 for six decent slices with two topping (Pepperoni and bacon) The pizza; Fresh, hot and pretty decent. The toppings weren't skimpy. The crust we good, Chewy and good texture. Sauce was good, we went light. The bacon was very good as was the Pepperoni. Ive read reviews saying it's not as good as andolinis or pie hole...not a fair statement or comparison. Each pizza is unique in its own right and not comparable to one another. So, no.. Nyc pizza is not like andolinis. NYC Pizza isn't chain pizza and knocks it out of the park when it comes to a really decent Friday night Pie that isn't cookie cutter or chain. To me the pizza was a cross between sbarro and pie hole. The staff was very friendly, the lobby was packed with people and everyone was laughing. It was a very friendly, warm, relaxed environment. Highly recommend you try it. read more

I used to like this place but tonight the pizza was horrible- soggy uncooked crust. I will not go back read more

So living with a true nyc'er who is a pizza snob this place rocks!!! The most authentic nyc pizza you can find! The secret is in the dough and they know what's up. Every time we pass through Tulsa we stop to get a Sicilian to go!! This is a must to stop in for!! read more

This is the best pizza I've ever had. It puts mazzios, pizza hut, and any other pizzeria in Tulsa to shame. Highly recommend the garlic knots too. read more

I really dont see what the hype is all about the pizza place. I came here and had peporoni , cheese pizza ans a salad. The salad was pieces of riped lettuce thrown into a clear box with mushroom and tomatos. The pizza really tasted bland with tomato sauce. Will not be back again. read more

Fantastic Pizza! Super cheerful staff (especially for just a bunch of guys). The kids devoured it all. I loved the thin crust sauce and toppings ratio. Great work! read more

I am from Boston, Ma orignally and have been craving good pizza in oklahoma, which I haven't found until today. This place is AWESOME.. if you love and know NYC pizza, then you will love this pizza. The sauce, the cheese, the dough is all on point. I met the owner and he as NY as his pie's. You have to try them. It is worth the drive, and I live almost 2 hours away. ;) read more

NYC Pizza - Best pizza in Oklahoma - Pizza Near Me - Tulsa, Oklahoma

We literally just had our pizza delivered- AMAZING!!!! It was quickly delivered and is by far the best pizza we've had since moving to Tulsa. We will definitely be ordering from them over and over again! read more

NYC Pizza - Half tomato & basil, half cheese. This will be finished off within the next 2-3 minutes! - Pizza Near Me - Tulsa, Oklahoma

This 5 star review is relative: Is this the best pizza you will ever eat? No. Is this the best pizza in Tulsa? That's subjective to your pizza preferences. Is this really "NYC style" and is it the best "NYC style" pizza in Tulsa? Definitely. I was born in NY and spent 35+ years living in NY and Chicago. Pizza is also my favorite meal. Therefore, I think I have pretty good informal credentials on the subject matter. I think the best compliment I can give this place (being in Tulsa) is that if you brought this home to me in NY from a "new place" I don't think I would have batted an eye that it was genuine. I understand why most of you natives feel the need to put ranch dressing on your pizzas - its because you don't really have good pizza and feel the need to mask the flavor with something else. We went to Andolini's in Broken Arrow once and the pizza was pretty good. Though the service was bad and a little pricey. Our "everyday" pizza here in Tulsa is Costco or Sam's club. While it isn't amazing, it is better than the chains (Little Caesars, Mazzios, Dominos, etc) and a rough approximation of NY style pizza. At about $10 for a combo or meat pie it really is the best value for the money while feeling like something that didn't come out of a frozen box. For the amount of pizza we eat on a monthly basis I can't really justifying paying $20+ for a 2 topping 16" pie every time (what NYC Pizza costs). But when I'm willing to treat myself and have a taste of the "old country" as it were, I will definitely be going back to NYC pizza. read more

I'm a Southern boy from Louisiana...I went on a trip to NYC and had a pizza slice from there and absolutely loved it then and to have a slice of pizza 20-25 years later that took me back to that time was absolutely phenomenal...big slices, fold the pizza in half and greasy...staples of a good pizza is the taste, the greasiness and the quality of the food which this company hit on all marks. I had the pizza delivered and while the estimated time was surpassed it was made up by the overall quality and taste of the pizza. I also got the bread knots which were good as well...add cheese to those and they would be killer...A+++++ across the board and a definite return customer when back in this area read more

This was one of the worse pizzas I've ever had. First I asked for thin crust cracker style extra crispy and the crest came out still raw looking. Very little topping on pizza overall taste of pizza was very salty. This was my first time eating at this pizza place and will not be coming back again. Honestly store brought pizza taste better then what I got from here. read more

I love being able to pop in and get an authentic slice of NY style pizza at a great price.

Possibly a coincidence but I got very sick after eating here. The pizza was ok. It was a decent price for a 16" pizza. For me the risk vs reward is not in a favorable place for me to risk getting sick again for decent pizza. read more

Best Nee York style pizza in Tulsa that I have had so far. Some say they serve NY style but it's not quite true to form. NYC Pizza is legit, hence the name! This is coming from someone who grew up in NY and knows the difference. read more

Haven't been here in a few years, Tulsa if your still eating Mazzios pizza and your just getting by with it I have a question...WHY!!!??! I guess it's the same reason people go to 71st and Garnett to wait an hour to have mediocre Tex-mex made by a bunch of gringos in high school when easy Tulsa is literally filled with better options....Anyway! Pizza was hand tossed(yes no rolling machine here) and the sauce was awesome, service was friendly and prices were very reasonable! Try it...you'll like it! read more

This is without doubt the closest you will get to New York style pizza in Tulsa. There is another restaurant in town that used to hold this title but when the owner retired, they quickly went downhill. When I say New York style I mean the thin crust pizza with slices that are big enough to fold and eat. Also good are the garlic knots and the white pizza is also very good. It's not fancy but that's exactly what you would expect when going for pizza. read more

This is excellent NY style Pizza. I took an authentic New Yorker who is a classmate of mine here and it's he says it's the best in Tulsa. It's a great place to stop by for lunch or dinner because you can buy it by the slice. Be sure to grab a few garlic knots as well (also sold individually and also delicious.) read more

Hands down my favorite pizza place in Tulsa. I CAN say first hand that this is real New York pizza - the kind you fold and eat all the way to the crispy crust. There are other places I like, but this place I love. read more

This is a great option if you live in the Southern Hills of Tulsa. They deliver and seem to have good, competent help. The best thing is the pizza. It is as close to NYC style chewy lovely pizza. The pizza arrived hot and ready to eat. The delivery guy even came to the back door because I was hanging out on the patio becuse I didn't expect teh pizza to arrive so quick. read more

This is not only New York style pizza, it's a New York style pizzeria! Nothing fancy, the food speaks for itself. It's better when the owners are there, some of the help aren't that quality oriented. This is way better than the last pizza I had in Manhattan. Not for Pizza hut fans... read more

such good pizza! Probably the best New York style pizza I've ever had. It was served fresh and right out of the oven so it was nice and hot. Also, the cannolis are amazing!!! read more

New York style pizza. Stop by for a slice or a whole pie. Very good!

The main complaint I have about NYC pizza is very telling: for the life of me, on a Friday night I cannot get a pizza delivered because they are so overloaded with orders. It's easily one of the best places in town for pizza and I would while heatedly recommended of to anyone. The pizza is quite well done, and the toppings manage to be deliciously salty without skyrocketing your blood pressure (unless you just really really like pepperoni). They consistently produce high quality pizza that doesn't break the bank. If you do like pepperoni, get the pepperoni twist, my family calls them pepperoni cinnamon rolls (no actual cinnamon, just a metaphore) and just devour them. Lots of pepperoni and cheese rolled up and baked to golden brown. Mmmm. They do have cannoli which are quite good but maybe a bit too sweet, if you like sweet have at it, if you get a racing heart after a couple of oreos... Maybe just a bite. All in all, in an age where chain pizza places have sprouted everywhere like unwelcome weeds it's a relief to find somewhere that doesn't try to distract you with flashy deals and celebrity endorsements and quipy slogans from what really matters. Melted cheese. Savory tomato sauce. Crisp crust. Good toppings. read more

So, I can't really say I know firsthand what authentic New York City pizza tastes like but both my step mom and future in-laws grew up in Brooklyn and they say this is as authentic as it gets! The folks who run it are real New Yorkers so don't expect much in terms of down home Oklahoma friendliness. That's not to say that they are unfriendly though... they simply take a "matter of fact" approach to their customers. The interior is understated but I recommend dining in rather than delivery or pickup. This pizza lives up to its billing ONLY when consumed right out of the oven! If Pizza Hut, Mazzio's, Papa John's is your thing, this may not be for you. BUT, if you want to try a pizza which is timeless in its appeal or if you want to expand your pizza horizons, try NYC Pizza! read more

If you're looking for authentic NYC pizza, this is hands down the place to go! I stumbled into this local gem a few years ago, and it is the only pizza I truly crave. I periodically take advantage of their pizza by the slice. The service is friendly and fast, and if you're really lucky you'll get to hear stories of working in the pizza business in NYC. Today I tried something new - a white pizza. I'm normally a one slice girl. I'm slightly embarrassed to admit that my friend and I ate an entire pizza by ourselves! It was that good. read more