No menu online and the menu online i accessed was old and when i got to the store it was 40% more money. Website was not active. I ended up later finding some menus on their facebook page it looked like a customer uploaded but it was not current pricing. I asked for a menu in the store and they didn't have any to give me and said i could just take a picture which is uploaded here. 7/28/23. Pizza was mediocre at best and will probably not return. The cost to benefit did not warrant a repeat business as competition provides better service, better pizza, competitive pricing, and more for your dollar. Ordered 2 large pizzas and garlic knots for $41. read more

See all

Love their pizza, to go or to stay, usually 1 piece for me and 1 for my better half. If I need more the garlic knots are great.

Ordered the cheesy bread, an XL Combo Pizza with half anchovies, a slice of cheese cake, and a slice of tiramisu. It seemed a little pricey, $43 total, but I miss this aspect of NY, so had to give it a try. We couldn't wait until we got home to try, so my wife and I both tried a "slice" of the cheesy bread. Her first statement was "holy cow, their cheesy bread is even better than mine!" Basically, it is a cheese pizza without sauce, add garlic and the right amount of grease...WONDERFUL! By the time we got home, the pizza was cold, but still really delicious! I will have to give them some serious cred points, there stuff IS authentic. Great job guys!!! read more

NYC Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Tulsa, Oklahoma

See all

This is by far the most authentic NY style pizza in Tulsa. It's also one of the more affordable pizza options we've found here, which makes for a great combination if you ask me. This place has become our go-to for Friday night pizza night. We also love their cannolis, and the garden salad is huge and completely sharable for two or three people if you're also eating pizza. That said, I would recommend ordering dressing on the side. We tried the caesar salad once and it was super overdressed. Dressing on the side = problem solved. Whenever we order over the phone for pick-up our order is always ready exactly when they say it will be and always accurate. read more

Best pizza I've had so far in Tulsa! Great floppy flavorful slices. This place has definitely lived up to their name! read more

NYC Pizza - Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Tulsa, Oklahoma

Best NY style pizza I have had since moving from Raleigh, NC. Great crust, delicious sauce, tangy cheese combo. No very greasy, carry out was ready in 25 minutes It will be my #1 place to get carry out pizza in Tulsa here on out. And I eat a lot of pizza read more

Great pizza. Takes about 55 minutes for delivery. Fresh toppings and a great taste. Guy on the phone was very friendly and answered questions. Delivery guy was very friendly. NYC Pizza....go get some!! A read more

See all

(Review is from my July 6th July 8th visit) As a former Jersey/NY resident it is hard to find pizza that I grew up loving. Thanks to Yelp I was able to locate NYC Pizza. According to the sign, this pizza spot is open 24/7. When you first enter, you aren't really greeted which reminds me of good ol NY lol. The gentlemen who makes the pizza is from the Bronx and he has been at this location about 27 years. At first he does not appear friendly but if you strike a convo with him, he is very nice and engaging. My fiance and I ordered a 16 inch pie (half cheese/half pepperoni & sausage) and he ordered a fountain drink. The total came up to about $19, which isn't too bad. The ambiance of this place is lacking but again it reminds me of a lot of pizzerias from back home lol. Our pizza came and it was absolutely delicious!! I could not stop gushing over how delicious it was. It truly tasted like NYC pizza!! So why the three stars? We decided to go back on July 8th and the gentlemen who makes the pizza was eating a slice. After being rung up by someone else, the gentlemen who was eating the pizza dusted his fingers off and proceeded to make our pizza without washing his haNds!!! I feel terrible taking off stars as I really enjoyed this place but I cannot get over that. The ambiance of the place is already a bit sketchy looking but to see that happen completely turned me off. Taste of pizza: 5 stars Customer service: 3 1/2 stars Cleanliness: 0 stars read more

See all

I will never return to this restaurant. I was waiting for my order to be ready and another customer went to the counter to complain that the slices she received did not have the same amount of toppings as the slices she had selected from the case. She wanted more meat put on her slices. At this point the owner raised his voice to her and told her he'd just give her money back. She said she'd rather just have more meat on the slices instead. At this point, instead of reasonably discussing her request, the owner exploded at her, yelling "get the fuck out!". As she turned to leave, I told her his behavior was uncalled for. This comment caused him to start yelling at me to "get the fuck out too"! I had already paid and at this point my food was ready and I said I just wanted my food so I could leave, but he refused to give it to me and threw it in the garbage instead. So I had to then wait awkwardly for him to refund my money. I can't believe the owner would scream at his customers like that. I will never go back there and I will tell everyone I know in Tulsa of my experience. read more

While I thoroughly enjoyed the pizza, I do have a couple of points to make. Being from the NE Area I had tons of NY style pizza. I ordered 2 slices of cheese, because if you can't get that right, then find a different line of business......just saying. In my opinion the sauce and cheese were the perfect ratio. Crust thin like it should be. Only one small difference, size! They say size doesn't matter but a NY style slice is much bigger. Thus the 4. read more

They screwed up our order for the upteenth time, refused to deliver the correct pizza, and then was insulting and rude very unapologetic. No manners whatsoever. This had happened countless times will not be ordering from them ever again. They are a trashy bunch over there. read more

Just like a NY pizza!!! Delicious! They don't have all kinds of stuff, they stick with a really good NYpizza

This place is quite solid! Even as a New Yorker, I can attest to this place's quality (especially considering it's nowhere near the East Coast). The slices have a great sauce-to-cheese ratio, and the cannolis are a sweet treat to have at the end of your meal. I wish the crust were a little crispier, but the Italian seasonings and affordability of the slices themselves more than make up for it. A lovely dinner to have on a Friday night. read more

Love the pizza here. It reminded us of our trip to New York City a few years back. It took us a while to get our order (extra large thin crust combo pizza) on a Sunday evening, but it was well worth the wait. Love the toppings, cheese and crust. Think we would dine in the next time to see if it tastes better fresh. Don't forget to try their cannoli too. The crust was crunchy and the filling was not too sweet. My husband and I were sad that we only got one to share. I thought the seasonsed spinach pizza twist was only alright. We only had it the next day, so YMMV. read more

See all

As always, this is our go to for pizza. Called in while driving through town and they were busy and still had mine ready in 20-25 minutes. These guys fly. They are always moving. Good NY style pizza and I'd say the best in Tulsa. Keep up the good work fellas. read more

The Best NYC style pizza in town. The owners are NYC transplants and apparently have brought everything with them to make proper pie with them, except for the water. Order by the slice or call in for a take out order. At some point they had delivery, but whenever I tried, the driver was unavailable. However their pizza is still worth the drive for a take-out order. Crust is thin, has just enough char on it to make it flavorful, crisp, yet still foldable. The balance of cheese, sauce and toppings is just right. I'm also partial to their pepperoni rolls and cannollis. read more

NYC Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Tulsa, Oklahoma

Maybe it's because we miss Joe's Pizza on Carmine SO BAD but - wow - we just tried NYC Pizza on Harvard - takeout 1 cheese and 1 pepperoni hand-tossed - and the whole family loved it. The crust is very much like NY style. Reasonably priced and really good. read more

Went here because of Yelp reviews and was pleased with the whole experience. The cashier kept calling his "Ma" she was scurrying around filling drinks and taking people anything they asked for. They were all very nice to me, I am pretty timid, especially when I hear New York accents! The place is bigger than it looks and they do a big business in dine in, carry out and delivery, they were coming and going continuously, but it wasn't annoying. Staff and customers all seemed very happy to be there. The pizza was easily folded, like they do in NYC. Soft brown crust with lots of cheese, pepperoni and a few anchovies. Nice taste and very filling. The chocolate cannoli thing was very good. I have pizza for at least 3 meals and desert for 2. read more

NYC Pizza - Pepperoni and anchovy - Pizza Near Me - Tulsa, Oklahoma

See all

I've eaten here in person. It was pretty good. Called the other night for delivery and the guy rudely said he wouldn't deliver to our home. We don't live that far and we were going to order a huge amount of food. Probably won't be back. I'm no Karen, but I hate rude people with a passion.. especially when they're in a business that should focus on the happiness of their customers. read more

Definitely some of the better pizza in town. The white pizza is great and so is the Sicilian style. Very unpretentious.

Excellent! The white pizza on hand tossed crust was delicious. Exceptional delivery and customer service.

It's a small place but the pizza is excellent! It tastes just like pizza in NYC. The service is always fast and courteous. The garlic knots are some of the best I've ever had! They even have Jamaican beef patties which are so delicious and very authentic. read more

In my opinion strait to it , For a fair price pizza for the fam or group at a good price this is a good stop and I would agree with that. The pizza was good at a fair price. Now , that said I ordered the "meat lovers" and one "supreme ". Or two of their specialty pizzas. I've had some great fire oven pizza and this is not it. BUT not advertised as such either. Blend of common cheese with reasonable spread of toppings. Can't bitch other than the sauce is a little sweet for me only meh... I ate it. So for a fair price pizza for the fam or group at a good price this is a good stop and I would agree with that. read more

Awful tasting, burned wings, burned pizza. Worst ever pizza honestly and that's a sad thing to have to say.

I'm a NYC style pizza fan. The guys who make the pizza are boisterous, fun, and very New York. And their pizza is also very New York (a.k.a. GOOD). read more

Amazing pizza! Crispy all the way through with great flavor! This has got to be the best NY "style" pizza in Oklahoma. Possibly the best PIZZA in OK. Whenever I come back to Tulsa, this is definitely a must. read more

NYC Pizza - Thin crust 14" sausage - Pizza Near Me - Tulsa, Oklahoma

Good pizza. Great to have a place where you can get just a slice. Nice staff and great hours

Great tasting pizza, fresh wide slices that folds well. Love that NYC PIZZA sells by the slice, sometimes one is not that hungry for a full pie which seems to be the only option for pizza in tulsa though I am aware some (hipster?) places are starting to follow suit. What truly makes NYC PIZZA an authentic nyc experience is the service: Ever been in a situation where the customer ahead of you is finished paying for their order and they decide to do a wallet/purse inventory right at the register when they should move over?, that happened at NYC PIZZA but the employee just looked over the person's shoulder and asked for my order (the guy got the hint and moved away from the register). BAM! classic, efficient, nyc style service! read more

The food was good but it seemed like it was a little dirty the tables were dirty and everything wasn't very clean but it was acceptable

I have struggled to find a pizza place with a decent crust. The crust makes the pizza. This is excellent crust. The topping were good. Sauce is good. I wish they had a cheese pizza with four cheeses but, no - mozzarella. Sigh. Also a little pricey. I'll be back! Thank you! read more

You can't get a better pizza this side of town Square. If you are a pizza connoisseur you will love this place

We've been a couple of times and have walked away disappointed each time. :( If you decide to try it and are disappointed - don't make the mistake of trying again. It's not you. read more

This is the place to come when you are far removed from NYC and you crave a slice of a thin crust pie. There's a couple of places in Brooklyn and Queens that I have to hit for NY style pizza when I'm back east and I would say that these guys could compete with them. I typically dont get much in the way of toppings with this kind of pizza because I like the margherita style. Big cheesy and saucy slices to fold up and chew on while sucking down a couple of Peronis. They also have some shakers with garlic powder so be sure to sprinkle it on before you leave and by the time you get your food home it will not only taste great but smell great as well. read more

Holy Canoli Batman! Have you ever eaten at a place and then walked away planning the yelp review you were going to write? To me - this is one of those places. Small. Unpretentious. Fantastic pizza (no seriously - it will put a lot of New York, NY joints to shame), and sent-from-the-heavens canoli (not too heavy or light). Must go. read more

Sadly, going to have to ding them a star for not being open during their regular posted business hours. This is the 3rd or so time we've showed up and the place was dark and locked. Another time the lights were off and the door was locked but someone was inside. We weren't sure if we were supposed to knock or just assume they'd turn on the open sign when they were ready. When you have a competing pizza restaurant literally 2 minutes from your location, this is not a good way to run your business. The pizza is still good but I recommend CALLING before making the trip as the posted business hours are not kept. read more

NYC Pizza - 2/14/2014.....Friday night at 6:15pm...closed. - Pizza Near Me - Tulsa, Oklahoma

I stopped by this place while I was in Tulsa for a weekend after reading all the good reviews about it. I didn't find the foods to be anything special like all the other reviews said. I ordered some garlic knots and a cannoli, they are very good to eat, but not anything extraordinary. I tried a thin crust slice of regular combo and meat combo, they are good as well but not anything extraordinary like I thought from reading other reviews. The environment is of a small diner. I dine in when I was there and notice a lot of people do take out too. Either way works. I notice though it took them a while before my foods are ready while the people that came in to order for take out has their foods ready before me, and that's several people too. Some had small orders but there were others with large orders as well. I ordered to dine in but they had our foods ready in to go boxes. I wasn't very happy with these 2 problems. It was a one time stop by while I was in town to see what all the fuss is about, probably not going to come back here again. read more

See all

Very good New York style pizza! They sell slices. read more

NYC Pizza - Pepperoni & sausage slice with a cheese slice - Pizza Near Me - Tulsa, Oklahoma

See all

Finally! Coming from Boston, new york style pizza was more readily available. This place definitely hits it, great selections. However, I find Mario's to have a more lively atmosphere and somewhere I would want to sit down and eat. read more

Excellent, delicious, and truly NY style. It's not for everybody, but if you like New York style fold-it-to-eat-it pizza then check em out! And don't forget to try the pepperoni rolls. They do delivery to the nearby areas but not very far. read more

Pizza was honestly not that good. Wouldn't travel to NYC if pizza tasted like this. It had some serious ny flop (see picture). They forgot the dressing that goes along with my salad too. Would have to rate this pizza at a 4.3 out of 10. Your standard pizza chain restaurant (ie Pizza Hut) is better. read more

NYC Pizza - Terrible New York flop going on here. Need to cook the dough a lot more or change it so it's not like sponge cake. Smh. - Pizza Near Me - Tulsa, Oklahoma