First the good. Service was great. Attentive and friendly. The manager even stopped by to welcome us as this was our first time. Restaurant is clean and bright. A good spot to gather with friends or watch a sports game. Now the bad. I disliked all the food that we ordered, unfortunately. My husband and I shared a salad, pizza and lasagna. Salad dressing was too tangy. For a brick oven pizza, this was not what I expecting. This is NOT a traditional Napoli style brick oven pizza. No fluff on the crust. The dough did not have any chew and fell flat when picked up. The flavor was nothing special. For the price, I dont think this pizza is worth it. The lasagna was also not traditional. It tasted healthier than a typical lasagna. I was not a fan but by husband enjoyed it read more

I am a pizza snob so this review might not apply to you. I thought the space was inviting and open. Walls had many TVs so it's probably great for game days, etc. I did like that their wines were all reasonably priced. Food: Farm house salad - 3/5 - decent. The dressing was a bit too acidic on my tongue. Psycho shroom pizza - 3/5. Alright, so brick oven pizzas are always a plus in my book. In my opinion, the dough had no crisp, it flopped too much, way too much flour on it because after each bite, I had to wipe the flour off my lips, which was annoying. The topping sounded nice on the menu, but it was meh. Yes, you do smell the truffle oil and the mushrooms were good although basic. I can't remember how the cheese was. Now, it was not a bad pizza by any means. I actually do think most normies would enjoy this. I just think the price did not standup to the quality. Lasagna - 4/5. This is a version that I've never had before, so I thought it was quite interesting. The layer of spinach was prominent and it was more forward than I expected, which I liked. Service: great service - thank you Bobo read more

Upper Crust Wood Fired Pizza - FIVE-LAYER LASAGNA - Pizza Near Me - Tulsa, Oklahoma

See all

We've been here several times and love this place! This last visit we ordered the wrong thing (our fault), but Jenna (our server) and John (mgr) were so kind to make the pizza we really wanted and provided outstanding customer service. The atmosphere is fun and the food is top quality...not your average pizza joint. HIGHLY RECOMMEND!!! read more

Upper Crust Wood Fired Pizza - Inside - Pizza Near Me - Tulsa, Oklahoma

See all

Great food great atmosphere we will definitely be back. Lots of seating rather it's at the bar or seated at a table. Service was great from the host to the server they did it all with a smile. We went during lunch time right as they opened so they were very attentive. We had the fried mushrooms and the fried calamari to start both very good. I had the psycho mushroom pizza the wife went with the soup and salad all of it was very good. read more

See all

Always delicious food and outstanding service! Also love the ambience and the dress code for the wait staff! read more

Excellent food and service, good price especially during happy hour. The owner when he found out it was our first visit gave us a coupon for a free appetizer which we used within a week. read more

What an amazing restaurant. I'll just say this; the food here is amazing. I especially love the pasta. It's just so good. Also, the service here is amazing. Our server, Jackson, would always satisfy our needs. This particular upper crust is located in an amazing place that is very lively. I highly recommend coming to this restaurant. Also, the cheese sticks are amazing. read more

See all

One of my favorite pizza spots in Tulsa! Even though the farmer's market salad is my favorite thing on their menu, the pizza is perfect and delicious everytime! read more

We were stunned by the Amazing fish,fantastic salad and a scrumptious 5 layer lasagna. But the star of the evening was their pan-crisped fish. IIt was such surprise to find it on the "pizza" menu and serving was huge. It's such an inventive recipe filled with flavor that you might possibly (if lucky) to find at a 5 star restaurant. The farmers market salad was also delicious, flavorful and perfect blend of flavors. I highly recommend this restaurant in Tulsa. Also had a wonderful waiter "Kam" who steered us through the menu with lots of helpful info. Serve was excellent. read more

See all

My husband and I had occasion to travel to the south side of town for a show and wanted to try something we've never had before. Upper Crust has been there for as long as that shopping center has been there, so we figured it was obviously holding its own and doing good business. When we arrived, we told our waitress it was our first time and she recommended the social hour specials. I ordered ERWO and we got the fried mozzarella to share. Sorry, no picture of that! We devoured it. We asked a few more questions of the waitress who was knowledgeable and enthusiastic about the menu, including letting us know we could order the pizzas in a smaller size for a lesser charge which wasn't obvious from a cursory review of the menu. We decided to share the Numbers pizza and the classic NYC Grinder. We did ask for the pizza to be well done. Everything arrived promptly and I would say the only note is we would have preferred the pizza more well done. Shortly after we asked for a box, the manager came over to check on us. The waitress had alerted him that it was our first time and he came over to check on our experience and leave us with a free appetizer coupon to use on return. We will be back. The service was excellent and there are other items we want to try out, and we loved that they were enthusiastic and welcoming. By comparison, when we went to another long-standing Tulsa restaurant for the first time recently, we were treated with condescension and basically ignored because we weren't their weekend regulars. Upper Crust welcomed us, fed us well and asked us to come back, with an appetizer on them. THAT is good service! read more

See all

We visited Upper Crust while in town, and the food was amazing. We ordered the dill pickle pizza and I'm still thinking about it almost a week later--it was so unique, had incredible flavor, and the sauce was delicious. My mother-in-law had the pan-crisped fish and loved it so much she's already talking about going back. Great food and a place we'd definitely return to! read more

Upper Crust Wood Fired Pizza - THE REAL DILL - Pizza Near Me - Tulsa, Oklahoma

The pizza is always amazing but I encourage everyone to try their fried mushrooms, wings and sandwiches. It's much more than just a great pizza place. Even on a busy night the service is always outstanding. read more

The food was good and our waitress was awesome. Only problem was I had a Visa gift card and they were unable to apply the card to my bill since the gift card was for $20 and the bill was over $65. Not sure why, as other restaurants have been able to apply gift card. read more

The food was amazing! The ambiance was sort of sports bar (which i wasn't expecting) but we had a good time. I got the strawberry Italian soda which was really good, and the appetizer was a goat cheese, fig mix. It was really good as well, our server was sweet & I would go back! read more

See all

The service was excellent. I dropped in on a Friday afternoon. I had the hummus plate to start out with and it was good. I believe I had the supreme pizza (personal size) and it was ok but not great (to me). It was my first time there so I plan to go back and pick another pizza. They had a lot of options so I'll try again. The atmosphere was nice too- don't want to forget to say that. Overall, I liked the place and will go back next time I'm in Tulsa. read more

The food is buss, the service is great, the maverick is the best pizza and the chicken parm is the best thing on the planet. read more

Upper Crust Wood Fired Pizza - Chicken parm - Pizza Near Me - Tulsa, Oklahoma

My husband and I tried something other than the great pizza. I had the pistachio crusted white fish and he had lasagna. Both were so good. Also the "house" salad w apples and candied walnuts was great as was the tomato soup. Our server at the bar was super friendly and helpful ( sorry cannot recall her name). We will be back! read more

The general manager and staff have always made me feel welcome there. They've been several occasions when we have reached out to them for various needs for events and our parties and they have always done well with flying colors. The food is some of my favorite. They will work with you to make sure that you have the best dining experience. In my opinion they own that corner at 91st and Yale if you're ever in Tulsa. The nachos are amazing and same for the grilled cheese and tomato soup. The zucchini chips are incredible. The fish is incredible, especially when you're looking for great places to find fish during lent. The haddock is amazing! It's just a great place to come hang out on the patio as well during the summer and spring!Thanks, Jeremy and team for all that you do for your customers and community! read more

The bricked chicken, pasta dishes, and pizza are outstanding, and the farmer's market salad has never let me down.

I am really hopping I have the right upper crust. first off love this place. food is always amazing and lets be honest. brick fire pizza...come on nowww it' delicious! last night I came in. walking in, atmosphere 100, hosts greeting 100. got sat, got greeted in the first 30 seconds. Sarah k I believe was her name, came to the table and I already knew me and my date were going to be well taken care of. she said it was her first serving job and had been there about a year or soo. Honestly couldn't tell. she did amazing . I reallly enjoyed her presence and she brought a positive energy to the table. I truly enjoyed the experience last night. PS. I will say. I was sat next to these two lady's. first I will say I hope it wasn't a Karen situation and HOPING these lady's where kind. but a pizza was messed up a few times. (doubt it was the server's fault) but it was fixed both times and fairly quickly. so props To the gentlemen server who was taking great care of them and keeping a positive attitude at least FOH. and props to the general manager for showing face to the table and make sure the pizza came out correctly. honestly truly A wonderful place to enjoy a meal with friends and family. read more

Upper crust is fun ! Friday night rush wait was 20 minutes. I enjoy the fact that the girl running the gate knew the exact wait time ! This place is crowded and loud with assortment of bar tables community tables. We had a reasonably priced bottle of wine with a couple of pizzas and a salad 4 people in and out for 100 bucks. I noticed a lot of TVs on the bar wall so I'm sure there's lots of sports going on in there at the bar is open seating. They were so busy we had to wait a few minutes on the wine glasses but the manager brought them out personally and apologized ! read more

See all

This is our go to for wood fired pizza in Tulsa. My favorite is the Margherita with the Farmers Market salad. We like the ambiance and the service is consistently good. read more

4 stars because all the red wines are refrigerated, not a little chilled but cold. The Tito's tonic to replace the wine was good. The bricked chicken is delicious!!!!! read more

First time visiting Upper Crust! I stopped by on a Monday night and our group of 4 was seated right away. Food Rundown Italian Nachos - Flavor was interesting, but the presentation wasn't very appetizing. Grilled Cheese with Tomato Soup - The Grilled Cheese could have had more cheese on it, and the soup was pretty basic. Tony's Italian Pizza - This was my favorite thing we ate. The roasted garlic sauce, pepperoni, and banana peppers combined for a great savory taste. The booth we sat at was comfortable, and the service was friendly. Overall it was an ok experience, and would recommend sticking to the pizza if you give Upper Crust a try! read more

Upper Crust Wood Fired Pizza - Italian Nachos - Pizza Near Me - Tulsa, Oklahoma

I love this restaurant! The staff is always friendly and me and my husband always get something new and it is ALWAYS good!

I enjoyed my visit to Upper Crust. We ordered the meat supreme pizza. The pepperoni was crispy and the bacon was delicious. I just personally don't like soft pizza. I expected it to be more crispy. Our waitress Hunter was very attentive and knowledgeable about the menu so service was awesome and we sat outside which made the ambiance romantic. read more

The atmosphere is amazing! Cory the manager is involved with his employees and customers to maintain a high level of service and food quality. He treats you like valued customers! We have had different servers that were really good! Jason, Dante and Conner have been the best we have experienced anywhere! The food tastes is very good! Well prepared and fresh! We also enjoyed the dessert-Naughty Knots! Wonderful. We recommend this restaurant for sure! It is very clean, friendly and professional . The tables are kept clear as you finish even when other servers walk but they pick up the dishes that were used! read more

Love this place!!!! Great food great service!! Good for Date night Get on the Yelp waitlist!! read more

I have lived in the area for many years and I had never dined at Upper Crust Wood Fire pizza before. My 3:30 arrival was conducive to lite traffic and fast service. I was greeted very politely by the floor manager and seated in a section in view of the big screen entertainment and following that, "Sarah Sunshine " welcomed me in and took my drink order and explained the pizza and salad specials. She returned with the drinks and took my order. The ambiance and decor of the restaurant had a welcoming Italian feel and the food presentation and flavor were exceptionally good beyond category! Thanks "Sarah Sunshine " for making my first visit to Upper Crust Wood Fire Pizza a great experience. read more

Cannot say enough good things about this place. Wife wanted the Red Pepper Hummas. It did not spind good to me. I was dwad wrong. The Pita served with it was warm ...... like it just came out of the oven. The Maverick pizza was the best pizza that we have had since the Pepperoni Pizza at the Brocktwon Brewery in Bricktown. The manager (awesome guy) came by and chatted us up. He suggested the Sweet Berry Tart from the season feature menu. DAYUM! This was the best meal that we have had in Tulsa since moving here 3 months ago. We will be returning and I highly suggest this place. read more

Upper Crust Wood Fired Pizza - Sweet Berry Tart - that pastry melted in your mouth - Pizza Near Me - Tulsa, Oklahoma

See all

The food was spectacular. The mozzarella sticks are the best I have ever had. Braden was an amazing wait. Took his time and answered all our questions. read more

Really good food and drinks. Friendly atmosphere. Wait time for us is rarely an issue. We do get greeted immediately upon being seated. This place is very neat.. I'd say it is loud at times, so prepare for that. A lot of folks like do enjoy themselves here, and I do not blame them! Give them a try!! There is a good food menu selection for all tastes as well as the adult beverages, I tried a golden ale. Crisp and fresh!! -can't remember the name, but I only had one!! Very unique too... the restrooms are clean. read more

I had ordered a mini pizza for $15.00 it was over priced I did not enjoy the pizza it was all black underneath and had left a bad taste after words. It was for pick up and had a given me a handfuls of peppers but no parmesan cheese packets. This place used to be so good what happened? read more

The food was good. I got the margarita pizza and it was delicious. The place has a nice vibe. The service was good, not too long of a wait for food. read more

Very disappointed - we ordered the brick chicken with a side Caesar salad and a 12" pizza with two toppings to go. The brick chicken was a small chicken breast with a wing. Not what we expected - 17.00 for a small chicken breast and side Caesar with ridiculous and the chicken was dry, The pepperoni and Italian sausage pizza was good but the Italian sausage was barely noticeable. Would not go back. read more

Pizza was great. Great wood fire grill taste with fresh toppings. Salad was large and fresh. Cheese sticks were crispy on the outside and chewy on the inside. Heated leftovers up in air fryer and they were still great. read more

Gluten free crust is amazing for those who would benefit! Very pleasant environment and the food is very very good.

Pizza is outstanding and salads too. We got half some like it hit and half numbers. Our order took way too long but other than that the service is great snd you'd delish read more

Upper Crust Wood Fired Pizza - Half some like it hot, half Numbers - Pizza Near Me - Tulsa, Oklahoma

Service was good, Hunter was wonderful..she was seriously great. However...the bar and the drinks were horrible. We ordered martinis and they were a terrible pour...not even chilled. The olives had slime on them. We asked to talk to the manager (Andrew) and he didn't see any issues with the drinks and walked away. Rude!!! Wow!!! read more

My husband and I were in town the other day and decided we wanted a pizza. I was sat at one of the tables close to the counter and witnessed my pizza get cold without being brought to me while the manager stood on his phone...maybe don't seat customers where they can watch your manager yell at his (very busy) servers while he stands around. I will still give it two stars because the pizza (kitchen sink) was fantastic and our waitress was so kind and helpful, I just felt so bad watching her be disrespected by her manager. This place has potential, but what I witnessed was very unprofessional and disappointing, do better. read more