Top That Pizza

Food and drinks were great! We had the garlic cheese knots and Roman square pizza. Both awesome!…read moreBeware, the pizza is HUGE!! We could barely finish one "slice" each. Be ready for leftovers. The gelato was tasty as well. Definitely a great place to try if you're in Tulsa and like good pizza.

If you are in Tulsa this place has some of the best pizza you can find. Quality ingredients really…read moremake the difference.

Lovely bar area.

Garlic knots with smoked mozzarella

See all

Triple Pepperoni Jamfest pizza

Lofi

4.5(71 reviews)

4.2 mi•Cherry Street

two years of consistently visiting + supporting lofi, i've tried a majority of the menu at this…read morepoint. none of the pizzas were a letdown. my favorite, shockingly, is the northern exposure. housemade canadian bacon, cherry peppers (so good), broccoli rabe pesto, smoked provolone & maple. the maple is very subtle, it's more of the auroma being inhaled that gives you that flavor. i really enjoyed the cherry peppers. i've gotten that pizza more than once & i'll get it again. there's also a monthly series of pizzas called pie for a cause. a few months back, my #1 favorite by them was the el luchador. it was: chipotle/orange salsa, luchador sausage (like chorizo), mozzarella, cotija, roasted corn, lime crema & salsa verde. flavor on top of flavor on top of flavor. speaking of monthly, you can catch djs spinning vinyl on fridays and saturdays. a lot of date nights & groups come in often so it would be best to get a reservation, unless you get lucky & find a couple of seats at the bar. the staff at the front of the house & the bartenders are super cool & always treated me nicely.

Such a cute lunch/dinner spot! My fiancé and I went around 3 pm on a Tuesday and it was pretty…read moreempty but started to fill in at the end of our meal. We started off with drinks and my cocktail was pretty good. I will say the Pino noir was on the pricey side (which is ok). I then got the east coast oysters and they were definitely fresh. Then came the Caesar and o my God dare I say the best one in Tulsa? The crispy lettuce with that spice oil made it a 10/10. The pizza was a solid option and i definitely want to try the other flavors. As a whole, Lofi was the perfect vibey spot for a causal lunch or dinner and we will definitely be back!!

Music turntable and bar area. Pretty cool indeed.

Cheese & Pepperoni pizza

See all

Pepperoni pizza

Andolini's Pizzeria Sliced Blue Dome

4.1(379 reviews)

5.4 mi•Downtown

My favorite pizza in Oklahoma !…read more The downtown location is such a vibe and they also have free garlic knots on wednesdays and pizza by the slice Always gets me right

Delightful time trying Andolini's for the first time. The Blue Dome location is exactly what you'd…read morewant to find downtown. The pizza is more of a New York style pizza. (we tried the big one, not the Roman style) Unlike NY pizza, it had a beautifully, light crunch on the outside and light and airy on the inside of the crust. We ordered the Demarco of Brooklyn and it certainly did not disappoint. It was made with the most delightful flavors that spoke to the quality ingredients all on its own. Our server, Becky, was absolutely a delight and helped us on our journey through our first time here. She gave suggestions, history and tips about Andolini's. She even brought out us some samples of the gelato that I wished we had any room left in my stomach for a cup of my own of the lemoncello gelato.

Andolini's Pizzeria Sliced Blue Dome - Clean and bright interior. Even better with the smells of baking crust and toasting cheese from the pizza oven behind the counter .

Clean and bright interior. Even better with the smells of baking crust and toasting cheese from the pizza oven behind the counter .

Diavolo Pizza

See all

20" DeMarco of Brooklyn

Copaneazi’s Pizzeria

4.4(53 reviews)

5.2 mi•Downtown

Great little wood fired pizza shop in the heart of downtown Tulsa! It's small but the service is…read moregreat and all the pizza we had were delicious! Favorite was the Tulsa King and Fughettaboutit! Their drinks were good too, we got the limoncello mojito, Italian Paloma and Italian mule all very good drinks. The pizza crust was perfect, not too thin, not too thick. They also offer orders to go for pick up. No deliveries though. Probably one of our new favorite pizza shop in town!

The Fughettaboutit is a pizza I can imagine being a veggie lover's dream. I've never had a pizza so…read morecompacted with veggies, in this case: artichoke, roasted red paper, arugula & wood-fire mushrooms. Being 6 slices, I must've been super hungry because I ran right through it. Again, so much veggie, I really enjoyed the red pepper (had a subtle sweetness) & mushroom. I enjoyed the way I open the pizza box & the pizza is just about completely covered in arugula to the point you can only see the crust. Very filling & has me curious about the other vegan friendly pizzas, like the Wise Guy, which has grilled cauliflower. I placed an order over the phone (it was NFL Sunday). The individual who took my order over the phone was super nice & just as nice when I came to pick up my order. I ordered closely after they opened, which was a good time because when I'm in the area, I usually see a good number of people inside. I'll be back, way too many pizzas to choose from.

Bada Bing

The Irishman

See all

Dining area

Empire Slice House - Tulsa

4.2(120 reviews)

5.9 mi•Downtown

Fun fact. If you have a teacher ID, you get 25% off your order. (If you're more daring and want 50%…read moreoff for life, get a slice tattoo!) Recently went for a weekday lunch and the place was not crowded at all. Super friendly staff. Great pizza. Good place to go with a group so everyone can get exactly what they want. We tried the garlic knots. I liked that they weren't deep fat fried like some places. Cool spot!!!!

The midnight cow at was sweet and tangy and had a little kick to it, very slight. The Notorious…read morePIG was a little overpowering for one kid with the Canadian bacon. But was ok. The Fat Tony was good, I liked it. All in all pretty good. Ordered it through Uber Eats, so didn't visit the actual location. These definitely remind me of New York pie! Also, I didn't pay attention to the size of the pizzas, they are 20". BIG! Would I order from here again....Yes!

Gluten free vegan cheese pizza

See all

Bar

Savastano's Pizzeria

4.0(536 reviews)

6.7 mi

Savastano's is my number one choice for pizza in the Tulsa area. Just thinking of it makes my mouth…read morewater. The crust is perfect and the ingredients it is loaded with are top notch. Personally we prefer The Landfill which is the name for basically a supreme which includes sausage, mushrooms, pepperoni, green peppers and onions. There is just the right amount of cheese that is topped with a delicious sauce. We have eaten inside once which was a pleasant experience. The service and atmosphere were great. We order carry out often and they bring it out to the car which is nice. There are other pizza places I like but given a choice it is Savastano's!!

A group of people and I decided to go here. It's been years since I had tried it. Several people…read moregot pizza and all said they really enjoyed it. I appreciate they have thin crust and not just the deep dish because deep dish is not my cup of tea. I decided just to do the all you could eat salad bar. However, it was interesting that you fill out a piece of paper and they make the salad for you. I liked that they made it very pretty and it was unlimited. But because we were a large group it was difficult to get the waiter to come back around and if we wanted another salad, it got a little complicated with having to constantly flag Someone down to help us. Also trying to get refills was challenging. They weren't that busy and yes, we were a large group of 16 people, but I still felt like the waiter should've been more attentive and should've helped us more. The space is upstairs but it's a nice space. The salad was good. Nothing special. I probably won't be back, but this is not my type of food, but I think most people did enjoy what they had.

Dining room

Deep dish pizza

See all

Andy's birthday pizza and I had the taste of Italy

Tortoise Pizza

4.7(16 reviews)

4.5 mi•The Pearl

Might be the best crust in Tulsa. The new walk up window is super convenient if you're having brews…read moreat NL!

So the trailer is gone and the walk up window is here. The best thing about their pizza has to be…read morethe crust. Amazing. The four star review is because they were out of pepperoni. ??? The bacon and fig pizza and the sausage and onion pizza were delicious and I might order them both again instead of pepperoni.

Tortoise Pizza at Nothings Left

See all

Tortoise Pizza

East Village Bohemian Pizzeria

4.2(315 reviews)

5.1 mi•Downtown

4/17 Lunch Server Jayni…read more Service was perfect, Jayni was an amazing server, she was very helpful and attentive! Appetizer Lemon Pesto Shrimp Very great combination between the richness of the pesto and tangy goat cheese, it complements the shrimp very well. It also just a great dip for the pizza points. Only down side is, since it is a super rich flavor, it makes you want a different taste after a while. I recommend eating half before and then the rest after or during your main. 8/10 Main Margherita Bohemian What can I say, the sweetness of the grape tomatoes and sauce goes perfect with the mozzarella and basil. Crust was great, personally would have requested a little more well done if I went again, but that didn't take anything from the experience! 9.25/10 Dessert When I say Jayni did an amazing job, I mean she did great. She offered the tiramisu and although it wouldn't have took much, convinced us for a slice. No complaint there, delicious. 9/10 Perfect spot for a date or just a mid work lunch. Would recommend!

Busy night but we got a great table in the front. We had the spinach-artichoke dip and it was so…read moregood, especially with the flat bread pieces. I had the Blum's Knees---one of my favorite cocktails. You can't go wrong with the Mt. Vesuvius! Service was stellar!

Beautiful decoration

Mount Vesuvius

See all

Looking out window

Empire Slice Shop

4.7(38 reviews)

4.3 mi

Empire is a staple spot, especially if we are going to Cain's. Check the rotating slice menu each…read moreday to try different options. I'm a big fan of the 'fungus among us", but I don't know that I would've order a whole pie of it had I not tried it when it was one of the daily slice options. The garlic k its and pink sauce are so good here! It's really a fun atmosphere with the 80s theme and the staff are pretty friendly and helpful with opinions on the menu.

First time customer, carry out. Since they're in the hood, I have no idea how we've missed them…read more Our 20" pizza was 1/2 1/2 No Sleep Till Brooklyn and Joezilla, with garlic knots and pink sauce. Many reviewers mention the crust and I would agree to its perfection. The garlic knots were hands down the best I've ever had -- a really, yummy yeasty dough, drenched in butter and parm'! No Sleep was my 1/2 of the pizza and it was everything I expected -- love the arugula and vinaigrette. Hubby said he liked the Joezilla, especially the Sriracha drizzle, but would order something else next time. There are so many choices, why not? I cannot wait to order another. I see there are many ways to have delivery. They have no beer on tap. They offer gluten free pizza and NA beverage. They offer loyalty rewards and if you get a custom Empire tattoo, you will get half off pizza for life. What??

Menu 5/2023

Hot in Herre

See all

Love the elephant

NYC Pizza

4.1(157 reviews)

1.6 mi•Midtown

I stopped by NYC Pizza and grabbed a slice of their supreme. I like that you can either order by…read morethe slice or get a whole pizza, so it's pretty convenient depending on how hungry you are. I went with a slice, and it was straight-up that classic NYC-style pizza. Big, thin slice that you can actually fold, with a crust that had just the right amount of crisp on the outside but still soft and chewy. It wasn't floppy or soggy either, which I appreciate. The sauce had a nice, slightly sweet tomato flavor, and the cheese was melted perfectly stretchy and not overly greasy. The toppings were solid too. It had a good mix on there meats and veggiesand they didn't go overboard, so every bite felt balanced instead of overloaded. You could actually taste everything instead of it just blending into one thing. The place itself was clean, which always matters, and they had two different seating areas so you've got options if you want to sit and eat instead of just grabbing it to go. The service was great as well. Overall, it was a really good slice. Nothing crazy fancy, just a legit, well-made NYC-style supreme done right. Definitely a spot I'd go back to.

Real NY pizza. Drop in, eat a couple slices and wash it down with a cold Pepsi just like when I…read morelived in New York. I highly recommend NYC Pizza.

Inside, smaller seating area.

Large pepperoni and cheese pizza with garlic knots $41.80

See all

Outside

Why does Yelp recommend reviews?

Hundreds of millions of reviews are posted on Yelp, and our automated recommendation software works in the background to showcase the reviews that it …

5 reviews that are not currently recommended

The reviews below are not factored into the business's overall star rating.

Kamlesh C.

7

2

5

9 years ago

New management is far better than old rude employees. Friendly staff, mangers make better pizza than employees. Subway of pizza

David C.

34

6

4

3 years ago

best pizza i have had in a long time !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Kacey C.

13

9

0

10 years ago

Visiting from out of town and ordered through the Yelp app. Not good at requests. Delivery was good.

Indigo I.

0

6

3 years ago

Great place to go if you want the place to call you names and ignore what you ordered.

Liz M.

8

2

0

6 years ago

The 41st St. location did not offer out door dining.

Top That Pizza - pizza - Updated September 2026

People who viewed Top That Pizza also viewed

Piehole Pizzeria

(124 reviews)

10/10 pie hole experience. PER USUAL…read moreI don't know why I haven't left them a review sooner, I think it's because the first time I had it was when my dog got attacked by another dog and we were spending an extended amount of time in the waiting room at the emergency vet next door. (My dog is fine btw) And even though I was going through it I was like DANG THIS IS A GREAT PIZZA. And that has held true every time I've had it. It's amazing pizza with amazing options and an AMAZING STAFF thank you all for being such a treat in my hours of need.

fantastic pie! our first time. Finally a great pizza joint. had a garlic, tomato, mushroom, dried…read moretomato large. the sauce is perfect. and the crust was perfect. Wish you all would open one in BA.

Doro Pizza

4.2

(60 reviews)

I was craving pizza and decided to give D'Oro Pizza a try. We went with the Gourmet pizza. My…read morehusband picked it up and mentioned they had plenty of great vegetarian options, so I'll definitely want to try more next time. What really stood out was the thin crust. It was so good! Even my husband, who usually skips sausage on pizza, really enjoyed it. It was $13.99 for a small pizza, which felt a bit steep but I get it. They're a small business, and I'm happy to support local spots!

Drat, no more pizza by the slice! Take out only. Pepsi products. Little dingy but the guy was…read morefriendly.

Uncle Vinny's NY Pizzeria

(105 reviews)

Craving a Home Alone style XL cheese pizza "just for me"?…read more This is the spot to get it. Thanks for being that new old-school sidewalk shop from the City in a town with lesser options.

Happy to see another NY style pizza in the area. The staff was super friendly when I talked to…read morethem. It was cool to see NYG signs inside the pizzeria! I ordered a large pie with half margarita and half supreme. The margarita was good. Sauce was tasty and flavorful, few pieces of basil with melted slices of moots. The undercarriage was nice - def New York style with the crunch. Although I'm not a crust eater, but I thought the crust was good as well. The supreme was ok. I liked the sausage on there, but I thought there were way too many olives and I didn't like the mushrooms (might have used canned mushrooms? Not sure) I also had the chocolate cannoli and liked it.

NYC Pizza

(157 reviews)

I stopped by NYC Pizza and grabbed a slice of their supreme. I like that you can either order by…read morethe slice or get a whole pizza, so it's pretty convenient depending on how hungry you are. I went with a slice, and it was straight-up that classic NYC-style pizza. Big, thin slice that you can actually fold, with a crust that had just the right amount of crisp on the outside but still soft and chewy. It wasn't floppy or soggy either, which I appreciate. The sauce had a nice, slightly sweet tomato flavor, and the cheese was melted perfectly stretchy and not overly greasy. The toppings were solid too. It had a good mix on there meats and veggiesand they didn't go overboard, so every bite felt balanced instead of overloaded. You could actually taste everything instead of it just blending into one thing. The place itself was clean, which always matters, and they had two different seating areas so you've got options if you want to sit and eat instead of just grabbing it to go. The service was great as well. Overall, it was a really good slice. Nothing crazy fancy, just a legit, well-made NYC-style supreme done right. Definitely a spot I'd go back to.

Real NY pizza. Drop in, eat a couple slices and wash it down with a cold Pepsi just like when I…read morelived in New York. I highly recommend NYC Pizza.

Old World Pizza

4.4

(68 reviews)

I got two pizzas for carry out, and both were amazing! Pizza's were hot and ready in about…read more10/15minutes. I was impressed with the amount of cheese on the 4 cheese pizza. I would order here again!

This place is a gem! The staff were friendly and helpful. The cheese bread was fantastic and the…read morepizza was really good too. I think it was wood fired and cooked really well. The homemade ranch is so good but does cost a little extra. The store is very open and clean. I was excited to see the dessert selection also and will need to try some next time.

Minuteman Pizza Parlor

(54 reviews)

Great pizza. It's worth the drive over to Prattville…read more Really good sauce toppings and excellent crust

I generally give Minuteman a favorable review for their consistent quality. Today, my supreme pizza…read morehad little or no topping ! Wait, my $27 pizza had few toppings!

LA Roma Pizza

4.5

(173 reviews)

Tonight was a bit of a wait, but my husband I didn't care. We LOVE their food. We love their…read moreLebanese food and their pizza. We had the hummus and tabouli with a pepperoni pizza. My husband is Lebanese and he says this is the best tabouli. Tastes like his grandmas. I don't make it at home very often because it's a labor of love. We love supporting this family owned restaurant and go out of our way to have their food to support small business and because we love the food so much!

Has a couple we went on a rainy day to visit this fine establishment, on a Saturday…read moreOrdered large pizza with everything Two cabbage rolls which showed up first as an incredible appetizer, fresh hot flavorful Pizza came next. Which fed us with plenty left. I've been coming here with my family for almost 5 years and their food is never disappointing. It's a family run business for many years and even grandma is back. They do play music from back in the day in the 60s on up and it's a great setting to enjoy a great meal. As a reminder on Saturday, they do close at 1 PM for a few hours and get wrapped up for the Saturday night action.!

Empire Slice Shop

4.7

(38 reviews)

Empire is a staple spot, especially if we are going to Cain's. Check the rotating slice menu each…read moreday to try different options. I'm a big fan of the 'fungus among us", but I don't know that I would've order a whole pie of it had I not tried it when it was one of the daily slice options. The garlic k its and pink sauce are so good here! It's really a fun atmosphere with the 80s theme and the staff are pretty friendly and helpful with opinions on the menu.

First time customer, carry out. Since they're in the hood, I have no idea how we've missed them…read more Our 20" pizza was 1/2 1/2 No Sleep Till Brooklyn and Joezilla, with garlic knots and pink sauce. Many reviewers mention the crust and I would agree to its perfection. The garlic knots were hands down the best I've ever had -- a really, yummy yeasty dough, drenched in butter and parm'! No Sleep was my 1/2 of the pizza and it was everything I expected -- love the arugula and vinaigrette. Hubby said he liked the Joezilla, especially the Sriracha drizzle, but would order something else next time. There are so many choices, why not? I cannot wait to order another. I see there are many ways to have delivery. They have no beer on tap. They offer gluten free pizza and NA beverage. They offer loyalty rewards and if you get a custom Empire tattoo, you will get half off pizza for life. What??

NYC Pizza

3.5

(15 reviews)

I recently got back from a 3 week NYC trip and I was CRAVING some NYC pizza. I found this while…read morebrowsing through Yelp and I'm so glad I did! We ordered a large "the meats" pizza and garlic knots with marinara sauce. The pizza was freaking delicious. It still amazes me how little sauce is needed and it still taste that good. The cheese was awesome it's really hard to describe but it was just perfect. Now onto the garlic knots. Like really, freaking speechless. Ha I love me some carbs and these did not disappoint. They were so flavorful and cooked perfectly. The marinara sauce is to die for. Anyways this is definitely a place to try if you are craving that NYC pizza. You will not be disappointed

Place was pretty dead when I got there. It's always dead when I drive by. I go in and see what they…read moregot for slices. The pies were sad looking and downright ugly. I ordered a pepperoni and a cheese slice with a Mountain Dew. With a tip it came to an even tenner. I went to fill up my tasty beverage and the ice was out. I went to go pee and there was no label on the Mens restroom door. The Tv was on to a wallpaper. The staff was very nice and immediately put the ice in the machine without anyone telling them to so that was neat. The pizza came out piping hot. And the flavor was really good. Not the best mind you but better than grocery store heat at homes. Once you get to to crust expect no flavor. All in all I'm not impressed. There's much better out there.

Goodfellas Pizzeria

4.2

(38 reviews)