I've been eating Nutbelly for years and feel that the quality of food has really gone down hill but the extreme price points are still there. My salad toppings were the same components as my pizza toppings ($17 salad...). The pizzas were pretty bad...we ordered 4. No debit or credit cards even though the sticker is in the window. Only Cash and Venmo. Kinda weird... Service was mediocre with only two groups in the restaurant. Really unfortunate considering the location. Won't be returning. read more

This is a must try spot if you are looking for a high quality delicious pizza. The chef hand prepares the pizza dough there and from the first bite you can tell. I decided to try their Avocado fiesta pizza and I knew I would be coming back for more. The avocado fiesta pizza has hot sauce, corn, avocado, and lots of cheese. It all pairs perfectly and melts once you take a bite. I also decided to try their Hawaiian pizza and it became my favorite one out of the pizzerias I have tried. Everything tasted delicious! This is a must try spot in Carpinteria. They have lots of indoor and outdoor seating as well. read more

Nutbelly Pizzeria and Deli - Hawaiian Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Carpinteria, California

See all

I'm here on a raining night parking on street or behind building off of Carpenteria. Greeted when I came in. Not crowed tonight but inviting atmosphere They do table service or order to go. Local delivery through grub hub 20 dollar min. Menu is reasonably priced sandwiches and pizza. Look up for the specials on the board and the craft beers my pizza was ready in an unbelievable amount of time so it's off back to home to give it a try. The smell is great so I'm assuming it will be fantastic and the fact that the service was friendly and fast. What more could you ask? Return home enjoyed a really good calzone packed with eggplant and chicken. I'd go back. read more

Nutbelly Pizzeria and Deli - Calzone - Pizza Near Me - Carpinteria, California

OK, my first time here, a restaurant/bar that features full size bicycles, bicycle parts, photos of bicycles, and other art work curated by the owner, many for sale. Lots of wood, a nice seating area and a bar with several seats. Service was pleasant and attentive. I ordered the warm spinach salad. How did this leafy food reviled in my childhood become such a personal favorite food. It did not disappoint. I just had the salad and a sparkling water as I read a book, snapped of few indoor shots, listened to the mostly folk and country soundtrack playing (it fit), then wrote this review. Will try the pizza next time but the take away here is that I walked away happy and satisfied. read more

See all

Good location in downtown Carpinteria. I had the Hawaiian pizza. Loved it. On the sweet side with a little bit of heat from the chili sauce. My wife had an excellent half portion garden salad with balsamic dressing. The service was excellent. The young waiter was very attentive and kept our water glasses full. Pricing very fair. read more

Nutbelly Pizzeria and Deli - Hawaiian Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Carpinteria, California

Came in during the very busy Avocado Festival as we saw a sign out front -- Avocado Honey Ale - 5 bucks! A full pint too - so we sat outside and enjoyed a few while the mobs were paying 11 bucks for a 12oz pour outside at the "official" beer tents. I can see why they don't want other restaurants to sell beer nearby their tents! But they can't do anything about it as the restaurants have a right to make money. Pizza looked good -- we'll try it next time! read more

Looking for early dinner in Carpinteria, the cute name and squirrel logo drew me in. Service is super friendly, the outdoor patio dog-friendly with pup water bowl. Ordered the veggie wrap, added grilled chicken, and the nutbelly side salad with it. The salad was ok, the fig balsamic dressing delicious! The wrap came out looking gorgeous and still warm, good taste and big portion! Thanks for putting happy in my Nutbelly read more

See all

I'm bummed. I spent every summer in Carpinteria since I was an infant. Now a mother of teens and one with celiac. This came up on my app as a safe place to eat. She wanted pizza. We were eating with my Father who was treating us to dinner after a long day at the beach I inquired about the safety for allergies and the young man told me "ahhh.. yeah.. I dont know. We cant guarantee anything but we do have a pan for the pizza" I was asking the right questions ... is the pan solely for GF ? Is it a shared pan with other gluten pizza? is there a special oven just for GF? The minute I have to ask and ask.. I'm leery. Then I asked what the crust is made of. "I dont know" Sigh. Our waiter was much more alert to our allergy and made us feel a little better about ordering. Cue to my order: the warmed spinach salad with add on of chicken. Daughter and Dad both loved their pizza. Here we are 24 hours later and my daughter is ok. That's the good news . the MEH news: I received my salad and the chicken was the biggest disappointment of my life in Carpinteria. It tasted like microwaved Tyson frozen chicken from smart and final sale selection. I actually questioned what I was actually eating. If you are a parent of a celiac child. Your dinner is last. once you are feeling OK to feed them outside food and somewhat reassured they will be safe... you're left with .02 energy on feeding yourself. I didnt have the energy to ask the waiter what mystery meat I was eating and ruin everyone else's dinner with my complaint. I'm not sure I'd come back. Waiter was great. Pizza was liked and my daughter is fine after. so that's a plus. The chicken. utter disappointment. read more

DELICIOUS pizza. Great beer selection. Great service. I was honestly a little concerned about coming because the ratings weren't all that amazing. SO glad we did. read more

Nutbelly Pizzeria and Deli - Avocado Fiesta - Pizza Near Me - Carpinteria, California

Great experience had at this restaurant! Warmly greeted and attended to throughout my stay at this restaurant! Great array of specialty pizza, sandwiches and salads! Plus wine, beer and ciders! The small pizzas are more like a personal pizza. You may want to get a salad or appetizer sharing with another. There is also a family pizza. Personal pizzas are about 17 dollars! Truly some unique toppings! Parking on street or behind the restaurant. There is a good size lot behind! Restaurant has both indoor and outdoor seating! We look forward to trying another pizza! read more

Nutbelly Pizzeria and Deli - Seating area - Pizza Near Me - Carpinteria, California

Stopped in after an afternoon at the beach. Staff was really friendly. Sat at the bar area as I was dining solo. Opted for a personal pizza as it was after 5 and sandwiches are not available sadly. The pizza was ok. Think cardboard like crust with not much flavor. Seems like a local spot. Plenty of parking in the back parking lot which was a plus. read more

See all

Had there soup of the day and it was really good. They have good local beer on tap. Our server was very kind and the restaurant was very clean and the lights and decorations made it very inviting! read more

Food was good. Had the Tree Hugger with vegan cheese and it was solid. Veggie sandwich was just okay. Bruschetta was Ahhh-mazing! Service was great and it was definitely a cool vibe. Always stoked to have vegan options! read more

See all

First time trying Nutbelly's and we could not be happier. We were greeted and seated right away. Our sever was Devin and he was on point. Offered us beverages and made some recommendations. Our table had 2 pasta dishes, 2 calzones and a salad. The Rincon calzone and the spinach, mushroom and Italian sausage calzone, were the best I've ever had, and I'm picky! All fresh ingredients and the crust... oh my word... that was so fresh, baked to absolute perfection! Seasoned with just the right amount of seasoning and lightly crisp but soft, every bite! Not doughy soft but.... The pastas were the Nutbellita and the Rich Farmer. They looked amazing and fresh. Our dining companions throughly enjoyed every last bite. We also all tried the soup of the day, White Bean and was delicious. But the star of the experience was definitely our server. Extremely nice, attentive and friendly. All of this is my way of saying... Nut Belly is an absolute must! Try it! read more

Crust nice, tomato sauce tasty Service nice Expensive for what it is and nothing really special read more

Gluten free pizza is out of this world. Casual atmosphere and fast friendly waitstaff. Am never disappointed.

Food was great. The bruschetta was absolutely amazing. Definitely coming back when I'm in town.

Can't say much about their other menu items, but regarding the pizzas; pricey, but very worth it. Super unique ingredient combinations, addicted to their avocado topping and sauce. Service is mid, and their decoration is unique. TRY THE PIZZA. read more

Great gluten-free pizza! And it wasn't one of those small personal cauliflower crust pizzas either. Can't wait to try another, had the Nutbelly on gluten-free crust. Yum! Also enjoyed the warm spinach salad with the hubs, he had the Purple Love and truly enjoyed the crust. Great service and funky atmosphere with good tunes. read more

So many great things to say about this place! I'll begin with the amazing customer service. Devon helped me veganize my order, he was so helpful, patient, and knowledgeable, which is so greatly appreciated! Caden was also an amazing server :) The ambiance is very warm, authentic, and welcoming. The decor and warm lights accompanied by the perfect tunes set the mood for an amazing evening. The food is just as great! Flavorful, fresh, and made to your exact liking! I ordered a vegan version of the avocado fiesta pizza and my daughter had lentil soup with a side of cheesy bread- everything was delicious! Highly recommend! read more

Nutbelly Pizzeria and Deli - two people standing in front of the counter - Pizza Near Me - Carpinteria, California

See all

Was hiking in the area and Yelped to see what is near by, came across this restaurant. Omg!!!! Such a bomb place! Ordered the Sophia pasta dish, it is loaded with mushrooms and the noodles absorb the sauce so well! The sauce, I want a glass of it to drink! It comes with goat cheese, make sure to stir it around with the noodles so the sauce is even more enriched! It came with cheese toast, that it self was such a compliment. Thick bread with crispy parmesan shield. I was getting misty eyed for finishing it, ordered another to go! Ordered a small rincón pizza, full with topping and each individual topping gives a flavor to the pizza.. Vs some pizzas having toppings that exist but it taste like air! No no not here! Loved the thin crust, and the sauce was so tangy. Glad I have left overs! Had a side nutbelly salad and their dressing is homemade, The fig balsamic was thick and sweet with a subtle fruity flavor. Ordered tiramisu, they know what they are doing! Each bite was like true loves kiss. The employees are very sweet, friendly, attentive and knowledgeable of their menu. The facilities is clean.. they have plenty of inside and outside seating. Parking is free at the lot behind the building. Will totally visits this restaurant again. read more

Nutbelly Pizzeria and Deli - The picture does not give it justice, I'm not a photographer.. Eat it like an eater! Sophia pasta and rincón pizza. - Pizza Near Me - Carpinteria, California

I really want to like this place but my expectations seem to fall short each time I go here. This time, I ordered food for delivery. I got the garden salad, buffalo chips, and Nutbelly Pasta. I had added meatballs to go with the pasta (extra charge), but they were missing which was a huge bummer. The pasta itself was ok but I would prefer Guichos or Tharios. The buffalo chips weren't really what I expected - essentially a flatbread/pizza versus chips. Flavor was also meh - could have used more sauce. I will note that I ordered this on the last night of the avocado festival so maybe things in the kitchen were busy. read more

Nutbelly Pizzeria and Deli - Buffalo Chips - Pizza Near Me - Carpinteria, California

See all

best margarita pizza I've had we need this place in my town, I will def go here again when I go back to carp

The service was excellent and pizzas were tasty. We had the besto pesto and the rest of the party had Hawaiian and chicken alfredo. It's a cute spot! read more

My grandma and I ordered their BBQ pizza and it was bit too oniony for my liking, but still good. The waiter was very attentive and quick and that was appreciated. The music, however, was killing me. They were playing all the classics - Pink Floyd, The Beatles, Led Zeppelin, Fleetwood Mac, etc - except they're all bootleg covers and it was painful for me personally. It was also too loud and it made conversation somewhat difficult. read more

The staff at Nutbelly Pizza is super friendly and energetic. They go above and beyond, any special request we made was met with "Of course, no problem." If they didn't have ears, they'd probably smile in a circle :) Food was great too. The pizzas are crunchy thin crust and in addition to the staples they also have exotic combinations I haven't seen anywhere else. Overall a great place to have a pizza (or salad or pasta if that's more what floats your boat). read more

Nutbelly Pizzeria and Deli - Small Nutbelly Pizza (with added goat cheese) - Pizza Near Me - Carpinteria, California

Ok! Called in an order for a kids spaghetti noodles with no sauce with 1 meatball which comes with toasted bread for $12.00. Was told it would be ready in 15 minutes. Arrived to pick up the order. Paid $12.50 with a $3.00 tip! Got home. Time for dinner. Open the container and no meatball. Called and asked to speak to the manager. Two hours later no call from the manager. Called back. Javier stated 'the manager is in a meeting.' 3 stars because... (1) I am a regular customer. Have ordered from them since I moved to Carpenteria especially during COVID. (2) Love their food which is a good alternative when I'm not up to cooking. (3) Have ordered this same meal many times. The waiter went from the register to the food and I had to ask for a bag. Sanitary conditions??? So good customer service means nothing? The manager is too busy to call a customer back! Come to think of it last Saturday I stopped in and ordered a bbq chicken pizza and was asked to pay for it before I sat at a table. At the time it didn't register... single woman must pay up front? Or is it people of color? Pitchfork time! Ridiculous!!! read more

The ambiance was so cozy and felt very authentic. The food was perfect. We got a Margarita pizza and it was so fresh. The service was very accommodating. read more

Nutbelly Pizzeria and Deli - Margarita Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Carpinteria, California

I have been searching for a great pizza for the past five years and today I found it at Nutbelly's in Carpinteria. We had a small pepperoni and sausage and boy did it hit my pizza spot. Cute and beach with great service. Highly recommend. read more

Nutbelly Pizzeria and Deli - Nutbelly's - Pizza Near Me - Carpinteria, California

We got take out from here! It says on their door the have brick over pizza so I have been excited to try it! Friendly staff, cute little establishment. We got the bbq chicken pizza... solid 4/5.... Only docking it one point because I'm a saucy girl and the pizza was not saucy. Obviously that is just a personal preference, I just didn't feel that the bbq was presented as much as chicken/ cheese ratio. We also got the calzone- the price isn't on the menu but it's BYO. The calzone was HUGE. Def could feed two. The crust is great... i wish the veggies were chopped a little more? They came out in long pieces. But none the less it was good! Huge portion of veggies/meat too. It really filled the calzone. Both were delicious. I will definitely try the Nutbelly again! read more

Nutbelly Pizzeria and Deli - Bbq chicken pizza - Pizza Near Me - Carpinteria, California

See all

Quality pizza with quality ingredients with decent prices. The crust was perfectly charred on both of our personal sized pizzas. Our waitress was harried but friendly and other than one loud drunk customer it was a pleasant experience. We'll be back. read more

Nutbelly Pizzeria and Deli - Pizza Near Me - Carpinteria, California

See all

Stopped in for pizza on a Thursday. Outdoor seating and excellent pizza. Very generous with sausage and great selections of local brews. read more

Great staff, service and love the pizza and beer. They have a great happy hour with nice outside seating.

Pricey, meh pizza and pasta. Dry Chicken in the Alfredo with very little sauce. Came from the yelp reviews, the pizza was so-so.

We stopped here for dinner on Saturday night. Everything was really delicious. I ordered the Nutbelly pizza, which had a great flavor. My son had a gluten-free pizza--always thankful when gluten-free crusts are offered. My girls ordered chicken alfredo and really loved it. The servers were friendly! Really enjoyed the vibe. Prices were a little expensive, but loved the experience! read more

Very pleasant dining outdoors...our lovely young service person did a special strawberry lemonade, not on the menu, requested by grandson. She got our order, with modifications, perfectly and the food was delicious ! read more

Good food ambience Great service , will definitely come back for the pizza !! And drinks. read more

Nutbelly Pizzeria and Deli - Happy Hour - Pizza Near Me - Carpinteria, California

Ordered the rincon pizza on the way to the beach and it was yummy! We devoured the whole thing. Didn't get the chance to go in but highly recommend it you're looking for something good and affordable! read more

Solid pizza joint in Carpinteria. We're not local, but we're always going to get a pie at that belly.

We love a good cheese or pepperoni pizza from here! Their sausage is sooo good too! Prices are not* too pricey for the quality