A gem of a restaurant, serving authentic NY style pizza. You might miss this place if you don't look for it, but the community vibe and excellent pizza make it worth seeking out. Since I've been commuting to Ocala/Marion Oaks from Atlanta, it's one of the places that makes me look forward to every trip. So don't wait, head on down there and have a slice, and say hi to Christian and the gang there, you won't be disappointed! read more

We moved in the area and wanted pizza. So gave this place a try. The best part they delivery you don't have to go through Uber. My husband is picky he's from NY. If you say pizza is NY style it better be! He did ask to make it thin. I had the supreme and he had the pepperoni and side of mozzarella and salad. It was surprisingly good! Not the best but it will do. read more

See all

This is a delicious pizza amazing service in a very cozy atmosphere to eat it on love this place

I ordered a small pizza, wings and a Stromboli. Only was given a small pizza and wings. This restaurant is so quick to take someone's money but not quick to make sure they give you the correct order. Staff was not focus clearly. I didn't realize til I got home. My Stromboli was missing. I Called that establishment and no one answered the phone. Very unprofessional. If I could give them a blank star I would cause a one star rating is a little much for them. read more

I've lived in the area for 2 years and have gone here over a dozen times, their pizza is absolutely amazing and I crave it regularly. My family has gotten all kinds of toppings and no one's ever been disappointed, smiles all around. I've only tried the garlic knots once and they were delightful. The employees are always super friendly and very efficient with completing orders in a timely manner. If you're thinking about ordering, definitely order - there's 2 other pizza places in the neighborhood and I always pick this one. read more

See all

Not New York pizza at all. It's hit or miss sometimes it's halfway decent other times not so good. It's edible.

Great Pizza and quick service. I move to the area and that is the place to go for my family.

Pizza was quite delicious! Meat toppings were plentiful. Staff were pleasant. Prices were fair. I highly recommend!

Good is excellent, best pizza since I moved to Florida. Service quick and easy. Ambience is what you'd expect in a strip mall restaurant.

UPDATE: The pizza dough is hand tossed. Their lasagna is good and the Chicken Alfredo is also good! Their food does not disappoint! No complaints from us. Updating to 5 stars their delivery was fast. read more

See all

Really good pizza. We especially like the supreme on thin crust. Best pizza and closest to home which is a plus. Thinking about trying the fish & chips. It's hard to find good fish and chips. read more

This was our first time here and so glad we took a chance on a new place. Ordered takeout which was a medium sized supreme pizza, a Greek salad, and a cannoli. The pizza was very tasty with fresh ingredients, the sauce is very good, and the thin crust was perfect for us. Unless they gave us the wrong size, the pizza seemed extremely large. The Greek salad was really good, but not the usual ingredients I'm used to. Homemade dressing, large portions of tomato, seasoned feta, and black olives with romaine lettuce. Glad to know their restaurant is close so I can swing by and do a repeat order. Now the cannoli was okay, but I have had better. This is one lady's opinion and maybe the next batch will be better. read more

I have been a loyal customer at the us establishment for years. however the girl who lacks any ttoe of professionalism or customer service that works the phones and the front desk make the experience horrible. she's rude over the phone and when yoh make an order I'm person she gets distracted with other people or having a personal conversation to bother to put your order. place has gone downhill ever since that chick was hired on SMH fire her and get you a better cashier read more

First timer..best wings I've had in a long time!! Pizza was good too. My new spot! Definitely recommended.

Food is fantastic. Pizza is great and lives up to the name!! Service is fantastic and restaurant was clean and welcoming.

Place is rlly nice I like the furniture. but they don't use gloves I am rlly weird about that. It is good for family's of four well the tables only fit four but you can put I guess. Looks good smells good taste great read more

Number One New York Pizza - Pizza - Italian Near Me - Ocala, Florida

Well as I said 11 months ago in my other review, Top notch authentic New York Pizza and we're still returning happy customers. Highly Recommended for excellent quality and outstanding service. read more

Number One New York Pizza - New York meat Lovers with pineapple , onions , Bell pepper - Italian Near Me - Ocala, Florida

I've ordered from here for years. They have a different flavor than your average pizza/Italian food. No matter what I've ordered, it's always been good. read more

We found this place on Yelp, while looking for something to eat. It was really close to where we were staying so we decided to try it. Upon walking in, we saw what they had on display and ordered something with different type of meats, I can't remember the exact name, but it looked like a stuffed roll a big one. It was very yummy and filling. There were 2 people working and they were nice and fast we were in an out in less then 10 min. We ordered to go. If you are in the mood for some pizza and are close to this place I totally recommend it. read more

This place is pretty bad! I am starting to think all these fast food and restaurants around Marion oaks is terrible. I went into this pizza place ordered the lunch special the customer service was good. The girl at the counter was prompt. She gave me the pizza with one of the slices crust hanging out of the paper bag. This made it hard to carry and place in my car for my ride home. The pizza where do I start. Flavorless and bland. Lukewarm when i got home.I live less than 5 minutes away. This is the second time trying this pizza restaurant and it is by far the worst pizza place I've been too! I'm originally from NYC and moved to Clermont FL and then to Ocala. Even Clermont FL got better pizza. read more

Number One New York Pizza - Lunch special - Italian Near Me - Ocala, Florida

Ordered Chicken New York and Chicken Francese AMAZING and the price was right! They forgot to give me a slice of pizza that I ordered. I called, spoke to Orlando very nice and funny guy... he said to stop by the next day, which I did and he gave me two slices for the price of one. Very family oriented place! Will definitely be my first stop next time I am in Ocala! read more

New York style pizza in the back door of Ocala, Florida. Tastes very authentic and worth the money!

Great pizza; better a year ago but still good hot and fresh if it makes it to the address! Other than that really good mom and pop kinda place read more

I love their pizza!!!! Even though there's nothing like NEW York Pizza!! They have delicious

Pizza is okay they need to update their online menu prices you get one price online then when you pick up it another price and they won't honor the online price it's just a scam read more

This is nothing close to NY pizza. When i came in the first thing I noticed was how the staff is unsanitary, same person was handling the money and the food, saw no hand washing going on and the people handling your food do not wear face coverings. This place is definitely one to avoid if possible. read more

Try the chicken parm.....WOW Smelling the pizza, especially the meat lovers, made want to order that too read more

I'm from New York and this is as close to New York pizza that your going to get in Ocala period. Very good and great service.

The pizza is excellent. We very much enjoy there many types of pizza. There salads are also fresh and tasty. Highly recommend this place. You can order by the slice or buy a full pie. read more

I live in the neighborhood and eat here all the time. My first choice for pizza anywhere in Ocala. You can tell them Craig sent you. It won't do anything for you though. read more

Number One New York Pizza - Italian Near Me - Ocala, Florida

When you walk in, right away if feels like New York. The service is great and the food is amazing!! Tastes just like New York's pizza. It has the perfect amount of sauce and cheese! The crust is crunchy and delicious. My husband and I definitely cleaned our plates. This place is definitely the place to go to if you want pizza!! read more

They advertise offers across their website, when you get to the store they tell you they don't offer said advertisements. Overpriced as it is. Won't be returning. read more

Ordered for pickup. One large for 13 bucks and when I asked about sides like garlic knots they said their guy in the kitchen had left since they were about to close even though it was an hour and 20 before they actually closed so they didn't have any sides. Got there to pick it up and 10 people were in there working. Confused. Pizza was mediocre at best. Crust is super crunchy. read more

What I found about this pizzeria is that the guy who makes the pizza during the day makes a great pie. Real NY style but whoever makes it at night is not so good. So I would say get it during the day but not at night. Of course it depends on how you like your pizza. We like it thin and a little crispy with just the right amount of sauce and cheese. That's what you'll get during the day. At night it's really doughy and mushy almost like a dominos. Again it depends on how you like it. That's our take on it for what it's worth. read more

We were truly surprised at the quality and taste of the pizza. Sometimes the small hole in the wall restaurants are the hidden gems!

I'm sure the food would've been decent if the server didn't display the most ignorant attitude from the time my family and I walked in the door. It was 40 minutes until closing and before they served us he sat and argued with his employee who was going to ring up the order. I asked for a Stromboli with only steak and cheese and he said he doesn't have that. I said ok if you don't want to make it then just say so. We then asked for a Gyro and asked if the meat was fresh and he said yeah I'll go out and kill it fresh. He clearly wasn't trying to be funny but completely cynical in his response. When we finished ordering he asked for here or to go and we said for here and he said look at 9pm we close and that's it. I said to him look I'm not trying to be here all night, I've been driving and just wanted to eat a couple slices and not hold you up. Which he then proceeded to continue to be rude and say my guy in the back is ready to go. At that point I was at the point of getting ready to get out of character so I just decided that he clearly didn't want my business or money and left. If my kids were not with me I'm sure I'd have choice words but it wasn't worth the energy. I'm sorry I didn't look like the customer he wanted to give the time of day and not have to deal with but they never have to worry about my business any more. read more

If you've ever been to Manhattan you would definitely know this is not New York style pizza. It's okay pizza, nothing great. The crust is to thick and the sauce is to sweet. read more

Nothing like New York style pizza at all overpriced place is always extremely busy and no one helps you

Awhhhhh, I love it when places claim to have real NY pizza. Have any of these folks ever even been to NY? lol---No way is this place a four or five star NY pizza place. Now do not get me wrong, it is not the worse pizza I have ever had. (even though the crust was burnt on my slice which is a big "No, No" for me) However, this is nowhere near four or five stars. It is good for NY style I suppose with that extra greesy, oily cheese on top but the crust is bland and the sauce is just average. Sammy's and Pavarotti's are way better. I find it interesting that the real NY places run by Italian families have less stars. Perhaps Floridians like other types of pizza? I do not know and am at a loss here. On the visit I also bought an order of Garlic Knots and they were not great at all. Another thing to note is the location. I dropped my initial three star review to two stars for that. I was warned this is a bad neighborhood. I was literally pretty paranoid walking from my car to the shop. I find this interesting since I do not scare easily. I had to think on that for sure since I live and work in the inner city. On the walk from my car rental to the door of the Pizzeria I was approached by four homeless guys and a shady drug dealer guy who tried to sell me a laptop. (WTH????) The restaurant itself is small and was kind of dingy and dirty upon my visit. What really bothered me though was how unfriendly the staff members were here. If I was on the fence before, the rude staff pushed me over. Customer service counts. I would never go back. Sorry, I love Sammy's and will stick to them especially since the atmosphere is so much nicer. read more

I'm from New York, I know pizza and I admit I'm a bit of a pizza snob. I'm sorry. We stopped here simply due to the name and were astonished we found the #1 New York Pizza!!!!!!! Say what? On the back road of some Podunk Florida road we found the best NY pizza. I was skeptical but open to try it cause I enjoy pizza and trying other people attempts at NY style. Went inside to find a nice clean pizza place. Impressed that the pizza looked great sitting behind the glass on the counter. Ordered 2 slices and waited patiently. Pizza came out and I was actually impressed and ready to try it. First bite was just ok. Good amount of cheese, crust looked pretty good and the size was nice. After the first bite, it was evident that the sauce is not a big priority down here to this pizza joint. It was bland and tasteless. It seemed like the lack of good pizza sauce was more covered up by cheese. I added some spices and tried to fix it up, but good pizza needs some good sauce and STOP OVERDOING THE CHEESE. Moderate cheese with good sauce. Cmon people. I'd try this place again and just be sure to say easy on the cheese and add a little more sauce. read more