It's been 10+ years since I've been in the piercing chair...I was definitely overdue! Upon walking in I was immediately greeted. I spoke to Jess about what I wanted, and explained an issue I was having with a current piercing. Jess listened to all of concerns and about what I wanted for my new piercing. She didn't rush me and actually listened and gave me feedback. Then, in the chair I was. Before I knew it Jess took care of one of my piercings and then I had the new piercing I wanted. Jess had such a gentle touch and made sure I was comfortable. We even made some small talk during the short piercing process. I will absolutely be back for all my piercing needs as well as when I decide what my next tattoo will be. The shop itself was very clean. Great music playing as well. 5 stars all the way! read more

Shoutout to Heidi! She helped me figure out what was wrong with my navel piercing and create an action plan to get it right. She recommended cream, explained and throughly answered all my questions, and was an overall delight! If you have issues with a piercing definitely go to her! read more

Visit Date: March 22, 2021 I wanted to come to Notorious since I noticed the name. I'm a hardcore old school hip hop fan and I felt like I needed to because of Biggie. Coincidentally on Biggie's death date I walked in for a booking after getting a haircut nearby. I met Austin, he's 22 but I was secretly calling him the 5 year old because I knew he was on the younger side. I'm 38. If he reads this review now he's going to know I called him the 5 year old. I showed him what I wanted and he booked me for the 22. On the day of the tattoo we only got the outline done but that is not Austin's fault, it's mine. I didn't know the tattoo was going to be so big and take so much time. I wanted to see the guy I'm seeing now (he was at my friend's house) and I had to run back to Baldwin to get my son from his father by 7:30. So Austin just completed the outline of the tattoo. I was going to schedule with him to come back for color but than I decided I'd like to have it colored in here and there by the two main artists I see regularly along with any other artists I encounter before it's all colored in for other work. So I probably won't be back to Notorious tattoo but my experience there was a good one and I can't complain about it. I also got a tank top on discount because I was getting tattooed that day and I appreciated the merch discount. I'll proudly wear the tank and maybe that will get one or two new clients their way. Thank you Notorious and Austin for a good tattoo outline. read more

Notorious Tattoo - My tattoo outline! - Tattoo Near Me - Centereach, New York

This was my second tattoo here. I got my first with Gary and second with Genaro and they both were amazing! Highly recommend. All of the staff are super friendly! I'll definitely be coming back here for my future tattoos. read more

This is my third tattoo here and this is THE place to come for a tattoo and piercing! My son came last week got his ears pierced by Jess and she was amazing, the Erick did both my and my wife's tattoos! He's so easy to work with, extremely talented and somehow has a way of making a superb tattoo in a virtually painless way! Phenomenal artist and very fair prices! Above all, very clean and professional!! read more

Shout out Notorious tattoo Co. I'm very particular and they made sure they got my drawings just right before we inked it. Great customer service. I will definitely be a repeat customer. The shop is very clean, and everyone there is friendly and professional. You will not be disappointed. read more

Notorious Tattoo - Tattoo Near Me - Centereach, New York

Had my third hole pierced here while my sister got her tattoo! The staff was absolutely wonderful and patient! The piercer Jessica was so thorough and kind, making me feel comfortable with every step of the process! She is extremely talented and has the perfect eye for what she does! I can't recommend them enough! read more

I have a little OCD and I'll tell you that shop is very clean. Joel and Erick are good people and Erick did a nice job on my tattoo. read more

Notorious Tattoo - Shamrock and Hearts - Tattoo Near Me - Centereach, New York

This place is super cool! Joel and everyone made me feel so welcomed for my first ever tattoo. The piece came out better than I imagined! Even got to listen to some Billy Joel while talking about our dogs:) Shop was extremely clean and professional. Definitely recommend! read more

Notorious Tattoo - Tattoo Near Me - Centereach, New York

Although I've had several pieces done by Joel at Notorious, this was my daughters first. You will not find a better experience than dealing with everyone at the shop. The were all professional and made absolutely sure she was comfortable for her first one! Heidi worked with her on scheduling and although Joel did the work, there are so many talented artist there for both tattoos and piercings! Can't wait to schedule my next tat! They're the only ones I'll let do work on me! read more

See all

I got my septum done here and the service was amazing the piercer's name is Jessica! she is so sweet and very understanding when I told her I had some anxiety so she gave me water and a little fidget toy to keep me calm. I'm 100% going back for my belly button soon. If you plan on going soon Jessica is your girl! read more

today I felt it was finally time to get my tattoos for my aunt and grandma and I couldn't be happier with them I went to Gary good as a walk in and he was phenomenal patient took his time very clean and such a nice and sweet welcoming guy. Everyone in the parlor was amazing had beautiful work and was so kind I didn't feel like a stranger. Two more to add to my collection today and I'm beyond grateful and happy with them to carry my ladies on my arms with me forever. I could not be happier with them thank you to notorious tattoo and Gary Good for the amazing work the patience understanding and kindness you showed today I'm forever grateful and happy to say I have found my forever artist I could not recommend this shop anymore every artist has amazing work! read more

Notorious Tattoo - Tattoo Near Me - Centereach, New York

See all

I got my septum pierced by Erin today! She was super sweet, and very helpful. She answered all of my questions before the piercing and shared more knowledge after. I previously had been to cliffs for my piercings and it was fine. But recently they leave a paper outside their door, which you sign your name with your number and what you want and they eventually call you. If you leave you lose your spot, but no one will speak to you for hours. I sat there for an hour last night just to have them call me and tell me their piercer didnt do septum piercings (???) and to come back tomorrow. When I got there today I had asked a girl sitting outside how long she had been waiting. It was after 7pm, she said she wrote her name at 4 and they called her at 6. No one speaks to you while your waiting and no one answers the phone. Go here, not cliffs. read more

Notorious Tattoo - Septum piercing - Tattoo Near Me - Centereach, New York

I've come to this tattoo parlor several times to have my body jewelry placed and removed. The first thing you notice is that it's very clean and well decorated. Heidi, the body piercer, Is a total doll and so sweet. One of the many times that I came in, big Joel started talking to me. He was extremely friendly and I felt comfortable with him right away. I had been interested in getting a watercolor tattoo over my port scar. He was extremely professional, and listened to everything that I wanted for this Tattoo. It was a very important tattoo for me Because I wanted it to celebrate my strength through my treatment of breast cancer. Big Joel drew up a beautiful watercolor hummingbird, he showed me what it would look like on my chest using the IPad before he placed the tattoo design. He gave me many different options of what angle would look good and what type of Hummingbird would look best. He's a great conversationalist and I felt extremely comfortable talking with him throughout the entire Tattoo. He was also very gentle and listened to what I wanted as far as the beautiful color palette. He's a very kind Person and very well-known in Centereach and obviously in the tattooing business as well. His awards are all throughout the studio and this made me feel confident that I made the right choice. My tattoo came out gorgeous. I'm so proud to be wearing it forever. I plan to never go to another tattoo artist. I have found the only person I want to go to now and I have 14 tattoos! I only wish I had found him sooner. Thanks Big Joel! read more

See all

Went today to have my tattoo done by Gary.. very pleased how clean the shop was. Gary did an amazing job!! I loved how he covered up my tattoo perfectly. I got numerous compliments on my tattoo already. Thank you again Gary!! read more

Notorious Tattoo - Tattoo Near Me - Centereach, New York

Notorious is my go to spot whenever I'm looking for a new tattoo. I've gotten all 3 of my tattoos done there and I couldn't be more happy with all of them. The artists have one thing in mind, keeping the customer happy. The talent in this shop is far beyond anything I've ever seen. Every artist is so dedicated to their craft and everyone in the shop is so kind. If you are looking for an amazing tattoo, please look no further, this is the place for you. read more

Me and my husband have been coming here for a while now and I absolutely love how kind everyone is here. They always make us feel welcome and happy to have us. Everyone's work is absolutely amazing! I 100% recommend this place to anyone. read more

Love Notorious Tattoo! Been seeing Joel since he was at Tattoo Lous! Always recommend seeing him at his tattoo shop to everyone I know! The absolute best! Even the other tattoo artists are great! Very clean and professional. They make you feel comfortable and actually have good conversations with you so it's not silent and awkward read more

They don't pierce. Maybe they should remove that from their ad. Not sure how they do on tats.

My daughter has been asking for her naval to be pierced for some time now. I finally gave in. We asked around where other people have had good experiences but I came back to Yelp for the advice. Big Joel's was immaculate and attractive. The staff there is so incredibly accommodating and skilled. The walls are covered with awards from various shows they have done. Heidi, the piercing artist was phenomenal. As my daughter is a minor, she even arranged for a notary to come down and do the necessary documents while we waited. Big Joel gave me a very nice deal on a beautiful piece of jewelry, one that will last forever. And he even gave her a tee-shirt! Heidi is so professional. She was meticulous with her sterile technique, and nurses like me love that. I am not someone who has tattoos but I can certainly see why people would come here for their work because it is definitely not a tattoo parlor, it's artists at work. I would definitely recommend them for piercings and tattoos. read more