Absolutely love the quality of work shown by Jay! Thrilled with my new tattoo!! New location is great! read more

Nobody wants to have a bad tattoo but unfortunately my tattoo here with Charlie did not go well. I was left with severely scarred and torn up skin, and my tattoo was not able to be fixed until 10 months later. My skin scabbed far more heavily than I have ever seen and while I have never bled at all for another tattoo I bled heavily for this one. There were also issues with lines not being straight and coloring going outside the lines. I have healed several other tattoos of similar size with similar amounts of ink and never had an issue. I spoke to multiple other artists after having this work done and each confirmed the issue was with the artist and not my aftercare. I have finally had the tattoo repaired (which of course was extra cost) but it will never be free of flaws. Other artists here may do good work but unfortunately my skin is permanently damaged read more

Just got a new tattoo done by John. Great artist! The place is very clean and everyone in there was extremely polite and helpful.

Have always went here for my tattoos! Jay is amazing at what he does precise lines and great healing!! Got my nose pierced here too and couldn't be happier! Will only see jay for my artwork from now on! read more

After getting several piercings at Masquerade Tattoo I was happy to go back to get my first tattoo there ! Charlie was very straightforward regarding the tattoo i proposed and was able to explain the issues behind it and tweak it so it would be better. Not only did the tattoo come out just as I hoped but Charlie was very friendly and I would be happy to come back for another tattoo! read more

I am a very particular person and I had very specific requests for my tattoos. My first large tattoo was on my thigh and it was done 100% to my satisfaction. It is beautiful and John Lally adhered to my every request. (Two tiger Lillies joined with a Fleur du Lis) For my second, even larger and more detailed tattoo, Ganesha), I gave John Lally some photos and inspirational color choices and his finished product yielded an unbelievably gorgeous tattoo that people stop me to admire. His talent, patience, and creativity are phenomenal. My next tattoo is a couples tattoo (Lion & lioness) and we will go to him as well. I trust him as an artist and I have no plans to seek out any other tattoo artists. read more

For anybody that's looking for somewhere good to go and get tattooed, look no further than Masquerade Tattoo. This is a great shop to check out and get your work done at. The owner is Jay Baxter and he's done my last two pieces and I couldn't be happier with the results. There are three artists there and they are all very good. I put off getting tattooed again for a long while because I didn't want to do the cliche Cliff's or Lou's thing again. Finally I got around to going down there and talking to Jay and I knew this was the right place for me. This isn't one of those tattoo parlors where they peel and stick a tattoo on you from one of the many pictures on the wall just like the dozens of other people there before you. They will meet with you and go over ideas and draw you up your own custom one of a kind piece and you will love it. It is very professional here and the shop has a friendly and relaxed atmosphere. All egos in check, unlike some other shops. It is also very clean and the artist's areas are neat and orderly. I highly recommend going down and meeting with Jay for a consultation and tattoo. read more

Very clean and the workers are very nice and informative. I am extremely happy with how my tattoo turned out

Went here to get an old tattoo that had bled through fixed. My friend had gone the day before and raved about how great of a job they did. I was so pleased with the job that Dave did and finally can love my tattoo again! Clean place with friendly and knowledgeable staff. 5/5 would recommend to a friend. read more

If you are looking for honest tattoo artists with professionalism and amazing detail to their work you found it with This spot. Phil is my artist and I was so amazed with the level of detail and expertise he put into my piece. His opinion and knowledge is exactly what I come to expect from tattoo artist. The shop is clean, fun and decorated so cool. They guys were all funny and professional and even catered to my 6 year old daughter while I was in the chair. Went above and beyond to keep her entertained. Dave and John are cool guys with amazing works under their belts as well. Highly recommend spending some time here. You will not be disappointed. read more

Just got my fifth tattoo and two more piercings from masquerade tatoo. First let me say how professional, clean and talented jay is. What I love is, he gets and knows my style and everyone of my tattoos are absolutely beautiful and I'm honored to wear his art! I will never go anywhere else. His wife is a beautiful, professional women inside and out and has done all of my piercings. She takes the mom approach and guides you every step of the way. I love her suggestions and my piercings are beautiful. I'm a well educated woman who appreciates and respects their craft and I highly recommend them. Jay will never steer you wrong and will tell you if something will not look right or if he is uncomfortable doing something. His wife is wonderful and her suggestions and foresight is amazing. I love them both! I'm thinking I need to keep them on a retainer!!!! read more

I have coming to see Jay for all my art work since 2013. Every time I walk in the door it is like walking into a old friends house. Very welcoming atmosphere and professional. My first tattoo with Jay was a coverup on my hip. From that first session on I knew I had found my artist for life. My sister has since been here for her first ever tattoo after seeing Jays work on me. Right now we are working on a back piece and every time I get in the chair I'm so excited to see the end results! Very highly recommend all the artists in this shop! Phenomenal portfolios and work. read more

Masquerade Tattoo - My cover up with Jay Baxter start to finish. - Tattoo Near Me - Patchogue, New York

I lost my nose ring so i went to Masquerade's. I explained what happened to the guy in charge and he gave me a free nose ring! It made my day. read more

I've been coming to this shop on and off for almost 10years, jay Baxter is a honest and amazing artist and very compassionate and takes a lot of pride into his work. I had terrible scarring that he was able to cover up perfectly and even wanted to see it in person before even taking my appointment, most shops will just say yes and take your money, if your looking for quality you found it. -J read more

I got my 4th holes pierced here last year and they healed great. I recently went back to get my cartilage pierced and yet again another great experience. Its very clean and sterile, and the staff is friendly and informative. I highly recommend coming here. read more

I recently got a tattoo @ Masquerade and I could not be happier! Jay did my tattoo and it came out great. I recommend this place to all of my friends. Very clean establishment and professional staff. read more

I have gotten 2 piercings done by Asia. The first was extremely painful but it was her first time doing one and it was of no cost to me, so no complaints. However the nipple piercing I received I have since learned was placed entirely wrong- too deep and through the aeriola. I am taking it out to heal and getting it redone by a more experienced piercer. Just make sure you know exactly what you want done as she is not very experienced and I was not asked about placement. read more