Buckeye gave us an incredibly reasonable estimate on the new roof for the house, TWO flat roof…read morereworks, plus gutters AND they repaired the shady fascia board between the first and second floors, under one of the (no longer) flat roofs. Everything looks so good! We chose the same shingles for the house that we had put on the carriage house/garage, and although it's hard to see up top, they do look amazing. And the drainage around the house is SO MUCH BETTER. At the time the crew was out, we were having other repairs inside the house, and everyone did the trades shuffle with grace and humor. You haven't seen a crew work like these guys did until you realize they roofed a 7,200 sq ft historic house in just 3 days--including the flat roof rebuilds. So much attention and care was paid to the fabric of the home, and each flat roof got its own plan and treatment. They did our carriage house in early spring 2026, and the same attention to detail means we now own two very spiffy historic structures. Call Buckeye, you can't go wrong.

Salesperson was late for initial consultation for a bathroom remodel. When he arrived, he first…read moreasked me if my husband was available. He then went on to ask a myriad of questions unrelated to our bathroom project, in addition to again asking if my husband could join us. I told him he was busy and could not join us and that I was the point person for this project. He asked a third time if my husband could join us, citing that I might not be able to remember all the information I was given. I told him if he was not going to provide a consultation/estimate for me, the project owner, unless a man was with me then we can cancel. I led him out of the house 30 seconds later.

Great experience! Everything was explained completely, different options were offered and the…read moreresults are fantastic. I decided to get additional services (gutters) after seeing the roofing work. Highly recommend CPM for any home repairs you need. Thanks,CPM!

I do not recommend. James responded quickly enough. I have a driveway over 500ft. He stated his…read moreestimates are $110/hr. I agree. He said he would be over in an hour to salt the driveway. The day comes and goes. He texts the following day the traffic was too bad. He'll be there soon, but a flat tire post pones that. Clears the driveway in 20 min, then states the initial charge is always $150. Get everything in writing before hiring.

Roof Smart is great to work with. Sean kept me updated on how things were going. Cameron did…read moresuperior work. They both were so nice and a delight to work with. If you are looking for a roof company with great workers and high quality work your search is over.

{EDITED BELOW} After a wind storm on Mother's Day, half of the seamless gutter on the rear of the…read moresecond story fell to the deck below and twisted requiring replacement. At first, I was impressed with Roof Smart because they were prompt in providing an estimate and willing to a job that another company refused to do unless we wanted to replace all of our gutters. The first frustration was an attempt to repair a seamless gutter with a two-piece gutter, but for the same price. They did, however agree to install a seamless gutter, so I was still happy to work with the company. After over a week of no information I reached out to find out when the job would get started and was told, "by the end of the week." When Friday evening came and the work wasn't started and I wasn't informed by the company, I reached out to find out if the plan was to work on a Saturday or if it would be pushed back to the next week. I was informed that the repair would be done on Saturday, which was inconvenient as we had plans on Saturday, but wanted the gutter hanging from the house to be fixed. Saturday was another no call, no show and while I tried to wait patiently, I had to reach out the following Wednesday reminding them that not only was the gutter unsightly, but it seemed dangerous. I was told the gutter would arrive from the manufacturer by Thursday and that the repair would be done that Friday. When I reached out Friday morning to find out what time the work would be done (losing confidence in their ability to communicate), I was informed that Roof Smart received the wrong part and that the new part would arrive the following Tuesday for installation, but that the repair would begin on Saturday to remove the dangerous gutter. I asked about a time for Saturday and was told 3:00, again inconvenient on a Saturday. I rushed to get home on Saturday at 3:00 so I could be there for the repair and once again, no call no show. After 40 minutes of waiting I reached out to Roof Smart and was simply told they were reaching out to the installer. After waiting an hour and a half with no response, I communicated that I was done waiting as it was 4:30 and we had other things to do. I anticipated a call or worker to show up by Tuesday as that was what I was told. Tuesday came and once again there was a no call no show so I sent a message asking if they were planning to do the job. Roof Smart called me and apologized stating that they had to fire the installer and would need to hire another and that I could wait another week or two for that. While I appreciate the difficulty of hiring a subcontractor who doesn't show up, the customer should not have to initiate all of the communication. This company strung us along for a month and left us with a dangerous gutter hanging from the house and we are now at the back of the line for other estimates that we received, which could be another 3-4 weeks. {EDIT} *Roof Smart's apology came with a $50 gift card. Classy move and worth upgrading from 1-star to 3-stars.

Jim and Roman did a fabulous repair of our roof after wind damage. They were quick, knowledgeable,…read moreprofessional and kind. this is a respectable , honest and wonderful company to use for your roofing needs.

Our gutters were falling off our house and anytime it rained, no matter how little, our basement…read morewould get water. We called Mater Roofers and they were there the next day to inspect them and give us a quote. Our house has had a few additions so it has really weird gutters and a lot of downspouts. It is also surrounded my pine trees so getting gutter guards was an absolute must as well. They gave us a quote and it was very reasonable for the amount we would need replaced and the labor to do it. It did take them three weeks to get all the material and schedule the install. They showed up with 5 guys and had all the gutter taken off and replaced with full gutter guards in 5 hours. It was very impressive. They had someone come out a few days later to do the final inspection. We also waited until it rained to let them know if everything was working properly. Since we've had them replaced, we have not had any water in our basement. The only thing we didn't love is they were not very careful during the install. They completely trampled our flower beds. I would understand if a few were to get stepped on, but yearly every flower was smashed and killed. They also left a nail from the old gutters on our driveway. I'm sure this was just something they overlooked, but if we didn't see that it could have caused some real damage.

I had great service with MVR. Stevan was friendly, professional, and dealt with the job I needed…read morefinished very promptly.

Miami Valley Roofing recently completed my roof on my home in Centerville. I couldn't be happier…read morewith the process. Anthony was extremely helpful and worked with my insurance adjuster to get my roof covered. They are by far the easiest contractor I have ever worked with. Thank you!

Worst company I have ever dealt with. Multiple issues including leaking. very poor workmanship. Now…read morethat the roof is leaking they won't respond to calls or text. I also reported them to atty general. Possible legal action soon.

Homeowners, beware. We ( along with our insurance company ) paid Ohio Roof Masters -- nearly…read more$300,000 -- for a roofing job that remains incomplete, leaking, and riddled with issues. Despite receiving full insurance funds for a complete roof replacement with premium materials, the company left major sections untouched and instead used cheap materials worth a fraction of what was paid for. The owner, Marc Ross, was informed of these problems repeatedly -- including serious misconduct from his crew -- and not only failed to correct them but continued to make the situation worse. Workers were caught on video drinking on the job, stealing copper, and even trying to blame an innocent young woman for the theft until video evidence cleared her. They destroyed a custom, expensive birdbath, tore up our yard, and showed an astonishing lack of professionalism. Marc Ross was fully aware of these issues and lied to us multiple times, failed to supervise his crew, and was paid for work in areas that were never even touched. In my opinion, this is not just poor workmanship -- it's deceptive business practice. We are now starting legal action and reported the company to regulatory agencies ( including the attorney general , insurance company , police department ,licensing board , BBB , and a few others ). I strongly urge others to steer clear of Ohio Roof Masters and Marc Ross. This has been an exhausting and costly experience -- don't make the same mistake we did!

Recommend very highly. All reviews are accurate. My complete roofing replacement experience was…read moretrue and exceeded my expectations. Al Pierce, Xenia OH

Fine Line Roofing came highly recommended to us by a friend. James and his crew did excellent work…read morefor us too! He is very knowledgeable about the different types of roofing materials, and explained well what would be the most beneficial for our house. The cost was reasonable, and very close to the estimate. Clear communication before and during the day of the project. The crew arrived on time, they were respectful and polite. They worked efficiently, cleaned up all around the house. It's definitely worth your time to call James with Fine Line Roofing!

in October of 2025 Mr Moore had a crew come out out a roof on my garage never finished never came…read moreback to put the roofing on the porches or repair gutters I gave him a chance to come back and complete several times alway promise never came it will be a year in October 2026 and now won't answer his phone I'm getting a attorney and filing a complaint against him and the company I trusted you and you took our money like there wasn't a problem I should have went with my gut instinct and not trust you but this is what I've come to see you in court Mr John Moore the 111.

paid nearly 20,000 for a new roof that leaked within the first year. Tried to contact John Moore…read moreand he promised to send a crew, never did. We are having to hire an attorney to recoup too and soffit repair PLUS the 2 floors of plaster we lost in our newly purchased Victorian home we are restoring. DO NOT TRUST this company. Ruined our home, cost us money, lied, now we have an attorney.