First timer here! Absolutely love that you can customize the pizza with 2 flavors!! You could even do that for a small pizza like we chose to do. For our pizzas we got: -golden gate and meat supreme -cable car and roma garden. My favorite was the meat supreme and the golden gate! The flavors were balanced for all. One thing I'm not too much of a fan for is the crust. Maybe it's their style? As for the caprese salad, it was amazing! Had all the veggies I liked, even the dressing was great! read more

See all

This place was amazing but recently they have let me down and the quality has gone down. I don't know if it's the new chef or the young crew but the food doesn't taste the same. I ordered a Hawaiian pizza and it's impossible to mess up but it came with the typical ingredients but also came with ground beef, red peppers and jalapeños. I live in Hayward and I wasn't going to drive across the bridge again to return it. I've ordered multiple pastas in the past and they only give 2-3 pieces of bread for the 4 orders of pasta, I was told it comes with 2-3 per pasta order. read more

Always solid food here: from pizza's to sandos to salads. Everytime I've had a salad here; it's crispy and fresh tasting. Their pizza's taste just made too. Portions are good sized; good sized for the money. Tip: get the Sando; most come with either fries or salad. Heard they have some Brazilian foods too. Keep it up North Beach Pizza SM !! Tip #2: look for the multi level parking lot just behind the store; low cost parking is here. read more

Never order açaí from them; you'll end up paying for something completely poorly made. It's a disgrace to send something like this out $16 for a shoddy product! I can understand a delay, but receiving something like this is unacceptable! I ordered three açaí bowls the total came to $68.93 and this is the disappointment I got! read more

See all

We went here because they offer a clam and garlic pizza and gluten free crust option. We had 2 pizzas and a calzone and they were all very good. The restaurant is very small and simple booths. I held back one star because, while the food was good, the prices are very high and the seating does not match the prices. read more

I came here to pick up food for a customer. I called first to make sure it was ready and when I arrive, it was ready! 7 pastas for pick up. I expressed to the staff that I was the delivery person for Uber Eats and that the customers ussualy pay very little tip, especially delivering to million dollar home in Hillsborough. Anyways, Alex offered me a slice of pizza and when I was shy to accept, he insisted. I felt good coming in here and hospitality is great. Store really had a positive vibe. First time tasting the pizza and I think i will buy next time I'm hungry. Thank you. You won a customer a your friendly hospitality. read more

North Beach Pizza is my favorite in the early 2000s. My go-to were Golden Gate pizza and San Francisco Pizza. Where else you can get clams on a pizza? :P And their crust is decent! I recently visited this place for a weekday lunch. Kids were getting a haircut nearby and we needed a place for lunch. We ordered a small pizza, half cheese and half Golden Gate. We also got their wings. They were both really tasty. Their wings were juicy! Service was decent - there's one waitstaff and he took care of us really well. We obviously left with leftovers. And the pizza still tasted delicious on the following day! Skip the fries though. My kids could read the menu and they made sure I ordered fries for them. If you must order fries as a vegetarian starter, get the potato wedges instead!! I am surprised by how few patrons this place receives these days. I saw a decent amount of foot traffic as we were seated at the booth by the window. But I guess office workers don't want to have pizza for lunch these days anymore. The booths look dated but they are still comfy! I feel like this location has been an anchor/icon in the San Mateo 3rd Ave commercial corridor and I would hate to see this place go. I hope I just come in during an unusually slow day! read more

The pizzas were good. Service, could have been better. I like their pizzas, not my first choice but was still worth it. I just wish servers would check on the table once, maybe fill the water...never asked how everything was. Other than that if you don't care about any of those things, the you're good to go with this place. There was another person that was waiting on a few tables, constantly checking in, smiling, asking how things were, just simple basics help a lot. read more

North Beach Pizza - Coit Tower Pizza $20 - Italian Near Me - San Mateo, California

See all

This is a coit tower crispy crust so beautiful and just as delicious as it looks. Best pizza in san mateo not greasy like the other parlors around! Ingredients flavor on point this place never dissapoints!!! read more

North Beach Pizza - Such a beautiful pie - Italian Near Me - San Mateo, California

First time ordering deep dish from here. I would say that the deep dish is an "okay" imitation of Chicago style, but certainly would not be accepted if it was actually served in the Windy City. Flavors are okay, but I prefer the deep dish from other spots in the Peninsula: The linguine with clams in Alfredo sauce was surprisingly delicious. I would have preferred it to be a little bit less heavy, but flavors were nice. read more

Regarding food quality: The fried calamari was not acceptable. It tasted like chips, extremely dry, undercooked , and lacking the soft, tender texture calamari should have. From both the taste and appearance, it seemed poorly prepared and not fresh. Not worth spending money here. never get calamari Pizza- always tasting good ‍ FYI i Made the mistake of ordering online on their website instead of a third party like DoorDash, and now I can get a refund for the calamari! Order on DoorDash read more

North Beach Pizza - Fried Calamari - Italian Near Me - San Mateo, California

See all

Yummy food, big portions, reasonably priced! The meat supreme pizza was delicious- piping hot, cheese, flavorful. The carbonara pasta with tortellini is perfect amount of dough and sauce. Spaghetti shrimp Diablo was just a right amount of spicy. The Italian chopped salad was a bit too salty read more

See all

I'd give the pizza a weak 4/5 star (better than a strong 3/5). The restaurant seemed focused on premium prosciutto and other kinds of meats, which my husband is really into, but I'm not that excited by. I think this was probably the best pizza we've had so far in downtown San Mateo, but it was so much more expensive than other pizzerias that I think I'd rather go back to other restaurants instead. The ambience was definitely great for a fancy date night or dinner celebration, and the weight staff were clearly aiming for an elevator experience (the waiter we got was a little bit overly enthusiastic, and somewhat socially awkward). read more

See all

Quick slice to grab if you want pizza at the park. Nothing more nothing less. Better than chain restaurants. Gets the job done. read more

See all

Incredible how far this place has fallen. So many times I tried to buy a slice of pizza at lunchtime, they have signs everywhere advertising it. Every time it is "we don't have any slices" Dude has a terrible attitude. Only go to NY pizza by the slice now. At least they actually sell slices read more

First time and definitely it is a come back place! Food tastes delicious, excellent size of portions, staff is very kind and the place is clean and so comfortable!! D e l i De l I read more

North Beach Pizza - Italian Near Me - San Mateo, California

See all

Came here near closing and were seated immediately! Daniel was super welcoming and helped us for our first time here. The pizza was phenomenal on top of having homemade cheese and woodfired pizzas could not ask for more! Very clean interior as well. read more

We ordered through too good to go, everyone was super friendly and the pizza was really good, definitely recommend!

I am not entirely sure why this place has a low rating because their food is on point! Well...mainly the pasta is delicious and I have no complaints. The pizza on the other hand, I wish the dough was a little bit more crisp and not have a lot of flop. The garlic bread loaded with tomatoes and cheese is delicious and I would say it tasted better than the pizza. read more

See all

Just look at that cheese! Honestly, this is exactly what I imagined pizza would look and taste like when I was a kid. Beyond the incredible cheese pull, their pizza is easily one of the best I've ever had in terms of flavor. The staff are also incredibly kind--they even surprised us with a free cheesecake for my fiancé's birthday. read more

North Beach Pizza - Italian Near Me - San Mateo, California

Very disappointed I live right next to them and the pizza came completely different then the pictures I saw so very disappointed I even pay more for the extra cheese and that's what they send to me read more

North Beach Pizza - expectation - Italian Near Me - San Mateo, California

See all

This is another solid spot where if you're craving Italian food you'll enjoy this place. We didn't realize there's a diverse menu however we were just there to get some quick slices. We arrived around 7p on a Friday and were surprised they were out of 3 of their toppings of single slices. We went for the faithful pepperoni. It did not disappoint, the right amount of grease and chewy crust. Parking is downtown San Mateo lots, and you can grab plenty of fun desserts after and walk around if the weathers nice. read more

North Beach Pizza - Pepperoni pizza - Italian Near Me - San Mateo, California

Discovered this place by accident and now it's my favorite italian restaurant! Food is great, the place y very cozy and the attention we received was great. First time I came here tried the frutti di mare pasta and was DELICIOUS, dolores park pizza is my fave and the ricotta calzone is also amazing read more

North Beach Pizza - Dolores Park Special Pizza - Italian Near Me - San Mateo, California

Got some pizza on Pi-day. First time here, The cheese they use wasn't my favorite. Might have been different if I got a full pizza instead of by the slice. read more

Stopped by on our way back home from the giants game. Really not busy looked like the employees were waiting to work so I'm sure they had fun for a table of 15 of us lol. We order some pizza wings mozzarella sticks salad and pasta dishes. To be honest this place had nothing special to it all the food was alright the inside was small and the ambiance was pretty chill. Our server was amazing he did a good job taking care of us just wish the food was more exciting. One of the pasta dishes I got was a spicy Diablo pasta and let me tell you it was sure spicy this place was easy to walk to from the Caltrain station we gave this place a try but just wasn't for us. read more

Delivery - Horrible! Ordered three crispy pizzas & two apps. Placed the order 2hrs ahead and still arrived almost 20mins late. All items were almost cold. The crust was not crispy at all, but little dry. The fried jalapeño poppers were soft. Being in business for decades and still doesn't know how to pack fried food - FYI to the restaurant, the container for fried food should have holes so food don't get soft or soggy!! Do NOT order for delivery. Absolutely waste of money. Dine in. read more

One of the best pizza places in San Mateo! Hearty delicious flavors. Good portions. Fast delivery. Great staff and customer service. Manager is very friendly and helpful. read more

Service was great. They were on it right away very professional, friendly and no complaints. Like you would expect a Monterey chowder house Pacific Grove is awesome . read more

Two stars but an extra for service. Was not a fan of the quality of the pizza. Just order a simple pepperoni pizza so my expectations are not that high. Unfortunately it was worse than expected. At least my growing boy finished it all for me. Thank you! read more

North Beach Pizza - Italian Near Me - San Mateo, California

Casual neighborhood pizza place with sit down service. It's family friendly and they have a couple of televisions on. I tried a salad and pizza with a beer. Toppings are good and they put on plenty of cheese. They have some cool pictures and drawings of San Francisco around the dining area. read more

See all

Ordered a medium Coit Tower pizza, large Caesar and antipasto salad, fried raviolis, and garlic bread. I'm amazed how terrible simple dishes could be. The biggest upset was the pizza. Not only was it not even cut properly, but the cheese and toppings slid right off the soggy pizza. The fried raviolis were soggy, and unseasoned. The antipasto salad was old lettuce, literally covered in slices of pepperoni and or salami, chunks of mozzarella, and whole olives. Nothing chopped or mixed up. Garlic bread was basic and bad. Spent almost $100 for horrendous food. Will never return. Keep up the bad work. read more

North Beach Pizza - Terrible pizza. Soggy and horrendously prepared. - Italian Near Me - San Mateo, California

See all

This place has gone downhill FAST! I ordered online only to have my food not arrive 2 hours later. Then they made some excuse that the driver didn't arrive and they can't manage the online orders blah blah blah... So much for watching the niners and enjoying pizza! read more

Was walking around in San Mateo around 10 PM at night on a Friday. Not as much options were open but pizza sounded pretty delicious! It was super slow, so we were able to be seated. The server was super nice and friendly. The space seemed a bit older, but it gives you an old school pizza parlor feel. We ordered a small margarita pizza and half with chicken. We just wanted something quick and simple. When the pizza came out after 20 or so minutes, it didn't even really come out super hot as pizza is expected to be right when it comes out of the oven?? The sauce ratio was also soooo limited. They barely put any marinara sauce on the crust.... The cheese also was low quality. We also asked for more marinara and they advised they didn't have any so they put some in a tiny mouthwash sized cup.... The pesto on the side also did not have a great taste. My trip was pretty unsatisfying and probably won't be coming back... read more

North Beach Pizza - Italian Near Me - San Mateo, California

Stopped in last night for the second time in 20 years, looking forward to trying it again. We were cheerfully greeted by the young man behind the counter. I let him know we wanted to dine in and asked if we needed to order at the counter first, or if we sit down to order. (I couldn't recall.) He told us we could sit down, and looked over at the young male server who was standing near us and asked him if he could help us. He said, "why me?" then quickly followed it with "sure, I can help them." I asked him if we can sit anywhere and he muttered, "nothing is stopping you." Not a great way to start our visit. He continued to be sarcastic and condescending as he took our order. We ordered the Coit Tower pizza, two draft beers, a soda, and large Greek salad. The drinks took a while to arrive, and when they did, neither pint was full, and they each had a different amount in them. Our food was great, thankfully. The large salad arrived with no serving utensils and our server disappeared, so we used our forks to serve it. (One of our forks was dirty and had to he returned for a clean one to another worker walking by.) We would have ordered another drink but our server didn't check back in with us until we were finished eating when he said, "anything else from this table?" He seemed annoyed to bring us boxes for leftovers. As we were eating I observed his interactions with other tables and they seemed similar, and I viewed similar frustrations on the faces of other customers. The check indicated his name was Eric. We would come back for the food but I would first look into the windows to be sure that server was not working. read more

Went for Lunch Food - 5/5. Pizza had a good ratio of gooey cheese, zesty tomato sauce and savory pepperoni. I enjoyed that the pepperoni were cut into big circles as it had better coverage thus more evenly spread out. Their dough was on the heavier side in an enjoyable way. It was doughy with a nice bite rather than doughy meaning under cooked. Service - 4/5. Quick and friendly service. Value - 4/5. Small pizza starts at $16.45 and is of good size. The toppings can get very expensive as the pepperoni alone was $2.50. The pizza had good flavor and the quality of the toppings seemed high so the price feels fair. Parking - Street/Municipal Garage (Metered) read more

North Beach Pizza - Pepperoni Mozzarella Cheese & Tomato Sauce Pizza - Italian Near Me - San Mateo, California

Been coming here for years but sadly don't think I'll be back, there pizza options have always been good as well as there plate dishes, service has also been decent but just recently what the hell??? Stepped in on a Saturday night with the family only one other family was there already eating, not sure if our server was new or just hard of hearing but come on why do I have to ask for something that is supposed to come with my dish, or at least check up on your patrons, do you need more water, a refill, napkins anything??? The kids are easy usually just order a small cheese pizza but this time we ordered a personalized cheese pizza but I had to ask the server 3 different ways will a personalized pizza be enough for 2 kids, he kept saying its 6 slices, I know it is 6 slices but will it be enough for 2 kids, kept repeating himself??? And yes a personalized pizza will be enough for 2 kids, just an FYI Ordered the prawns and fries for the table to share. I've ordered this before so I know it comes with tartar sauce and lemon slices. I know the ketchup you have to ask for, oddly no tartar sauce or lemon slices, had to flag server down he came back twice never brought it, another server if not the cook came by and dropped it off saying sorry?????? The breaded prawns sadly were not edible, over-seasoned outer layer and the breading would fall apart on touching???? The fries were good piping hot and slightly crunchy but the prawns??????? The chicken parmigiana was good we have ordered this before so it stayed consistent and was good. Hmmm no bread or butter? I know we got this before? Is this something new, you have to ask for everything you ordered? The spaghetti and meatballs with bolognese sauce again this dish was good, portion was helpful, flavorful and delicious. But where is the bread and butter????? At this point I was just fed up, server never came back to check if we needed anything, water was close to empty since the beginning of the meal, needed more napkins but again no server, refills again you need a server for that???? Had to go to front to ask for the bill and surprise surprise the bill they handed me to look at was correct the bill they charged me for was incorrect, sure I don't mind paying less for someone else's meal but come on, refunded then paid the correct bill, they took off the prawns and fries off my bill I think they knew it was made incorrectly smh. Sadly when in the area kids loved this spot, won't be back Food ??? Its good if they give you everything you ordered Price $$ Service ??????????????? Da hell happened Ambiance *** tight seating, bright, clean read more

Cynthia at San Mateo NBP was sooo nice and the rest of staff friendl. Meat ravioli met my expectation and . So full and satisfying the whole meal. We Had the North Beach pizza as well as a small salad. Recommend this favorite spot. read more

I asked for extra sauce Called 25 minutes before When I got there they put the extra red sauce on top of the toppings. I asked why they did that and cashier said I don't know. I had to wait another 15 or 20 minutes because I like it well done read more

North Beach Pizza - Waiting for pizza to be done smh - Italian Near Me - San Mateo, California

I have been ordering this pizza for months and it is always so delicious. The staff is very friendly and the service great! I also order some pastas and I love it. It was easy to place my order and the delivery is always fast. Thank you everyone read more

North Beach Pizza - Chicken catupiry - Italian Near Me - San Mateo, California

I usually go this pizza place 3 times in a month, they always have a great costumer service, but yesterday I went to dine in and they didn't bother to take my order I had to call the guy to take my order, they took to long and when I ask to make my order to go, he was just joking around. For this time I'll give 0 stars the ambiance was uncomfortable. read more