To be honest the reason I chose to eat at this restaurant is because my baby sister (34) yrs old nickname is Nini and I miss her so much, so that is why I picked to eat here. I'm glad I did the square pizza slices are huge, one slice was beyond filling! I ordered the mushroom, onion, with balsamic and it was fantastic. The crust was toasted perfectly, crunchy but soft with every bite. My hubby came with me and he is not a fan of boujee pizza (balsamic on pizza) so he got the pepperoni, I thought it tasted great, he said I will stick to little Cesar's, but again he is not into different foods. So of course I took a bite of his pizza and I loved the amount of mozzarella and sauce combination, I would have enjoyed more than 4 pieces of pepperoni on it but it was still good. I'm not sure of the ingredients in the sauce but there is a subtle little kick to it and I like that! Now one thing you have to order is the chef salad there is ian up charge of $2.00 but it is yummy! This restaurant does not skim on portions and quality products! I will come back here and have a slice of (boujee) pizza with a glass a wine many times! read more

I knew it would be good but I wasn't expecting the most perfect experience. The atmosphere is very comforting, offering good seating and relaxing tunes. Customer service was quick and very friendly. I ordered a mortadella/pesto and a mushroom balsamic with a chopped salad. The pizza slices were rather large and extremely flavorful. The ingredients were fresh but the dough stole the show. It was fluffy, airy, and crispy. The ingredients tasted very fresh. No need for parm or chili flakes. Even the chopped salad was great. If I could give this place a 10/10 I would. The price to food ratio was exceptional. Very kind business that I will be going back to! Great work! read more

Cute spot to stop in if you are craving pizza! The pizza and salad were full of flavor and the pizza slices were larger than I had expected them to be! The staff are friendly and are knowledgeable of the menu. The pizza toppings offered changes regularly. If you are craving one of their special pizzas it may be an idea to call in to see when it will be on the menu. There is seating indoors and outdoors. This is a quaint spot in the heart of Fairhope. Will definitely be back! read more

Nini Squares - Pizza Near Me - Fairhope, Alabama

Unique pizza options, mostly sold out, in a casual setting indoor and outdoor. Slices are squares packed with flavors. There are whole pies as well. Service appeared to be efficient. read more

Best pizza in Fairhope IMHO. Interesting options. Fresh salads. Owners are super cool. read more

See all

Nice little restaurant hidden off the main path. Nice to find a place that has really good food without the crazy Fairhope price markup. Fresh high quality ingredients and fast friendly service. I tried the 2 slice special and was extremely impressed with the taste and portion size. Will definitely be back. read more

Nini Squares - Pistachio Mortadella and Pesto and pepperoni pizza slices w balsamic salad. - Pizza Near Me - Fairhope, Alabama

Finally managed to pop in here for a quick lunch and all I can say is I'm glad I did but mad at myself for waiting so long. Full disclosure...I definitely prefer a slice of round pizza over a square, but I'm from NYC originally, it's in my DNA. That being said, this is about as solid as a slice of pizza as I have had since moving down here 6 years ago. The crust is light, airy, crispy and ever so slightly greasy on the bottom, just like you might get from an old school Sicilian slice in the Bronx...minus all the dough which is never a bad thing. The sauce is fresh and I'd be seriously surprised if it's not 100% homemade from scratch. I tried both the everything and the mushroom squares, both are LOADED with fresh, fresh, FRESH toppings. Didn't I mention fresh? And DO NOT LEAVE WITHOUT THE TIRAMISU!!! Don't say I didn't warn you...I'm a fan! read more

Great pizza. Fantastic salads to go with a large square of pizza. Pasta, burgers, chicken nuggets --- something for all. Tiramisu or soft serve ice cream for desert. Downtown Fairhope casual atmosphere. Several tap beers and full bar read more

The pizza, salads, and overall environment was fabulous! A very fun spot with fun twists on pizza that doesn't break the bank. Highly recommend coming here!! read more

Rainy night and wanted easy, quick meal. Ample parking close by. Friendly staff and owners. Had two slice plus salad deal for $13. Lots of food. Bonus was homemade strawberry tiramisu!!!! Got the last one and it was delicious! read more

Great! Food Great! Service Great! Ambiance. My bride and I just ate lunch again at Nini. They have a lunch special that is perfect for 2. The salads are fresh and the pizza is delicious. Bonus! They carry Coke products to drink. Need I say more? Go there...EAT & ENJOY! read more

Burger was "meh", but i guess that's my fault for ordering a burger at a pizza joint. Service equates to delivery of food. A touch on the noisy side. read more

We love Nini Squares! Delicious pizza, salad, and cold beer! Service is always great! We love sitting outside under the trees when weather permits. Sweet family owned, cozy little spot in Fairhope. read more

Great pizza Nice, welcoming owners/employees $3 tall PBR - deal ! Will put this high on the goto list read more

Awesome outdoor seating areas with patios! Great atmosphere, food, and drinks!! Pizza by the slice with unique ingredients, full bar with wine, beers (draft and pitchers available) and liquor cocktails! They have additional food and drink options written each day as well. read more

See all

We love Nini Squares! Awesome daily variety, not too much crust, and creative toppings. We have not tried the pasta and salad yet but I hear great things. And you can get a slice or two for under$10. Great addition to our little foodie community! read more

They have the best food and the cutest atmosphere for a good price. The staff is very friendly and the girl who works up front is the sweetest. read more

We tried Nini's today and it was a great experience! It's on the corner of Bancroft and Magnolia in Fairhope. It's a one story dark green building. We have tried all the pizza in the area and this pizza is hands down the best in Fairhope. Their dough is handmade and not frozen. The crust on the pizza is exactly how pizza crust should be. The sauce is delicious and the cheese is gooey! I had the pepperoni and my hubby had the supreme. We loved it. We got the 'square deal' which is two large pieces of pizza and choice of two different salads. We had the chopped salad and it was 10/10! They make the dressing in house. It's creamy Parmesan and it is amazing. My son had the Alfredo pasta and he said it was delicious. We tried the homemade tiramisu and with the crushed coffee beans on top, it was the perfect taste. The atmosphere is relaxing. There is music but it was nice and not over the top loud. Their craft beers are good too. Pricing is reasonable. 5 of us ate and had drinks for $78. We added a tip and thought it was super affordable. You get plenty of fresh, delicious food for your money! Their kitchen is open concept and you can watch Cameron, the manager, cooking his heart out. We will definitely be back. Don't pass on this pizza joint. You won't be disappointed. read more

Great chopped salad and the tiramisu is the best around! The prices rock! Repeat customers!

Tiipped above 20% for stand in line orders and self serve drinks, (nice girl took our order and it's the holidays) to only be helped one time (when our food was brought to the table.) We informed the waitress that the Diet Coke machine wasn't working as it was flat/no carbonation, to no avail. I guess the staff was too busy waiting on the owners and their many relatives. The owners and their big family allowed their kids to run amuck all over the place, multiple times. The youngest even sat on the floor by our table as he threw a second temper tantrum. No apologies, no offer to comp the soda or fix the machine. read more