Nicolletti's is a local, much-loved staple, and rightfully so. Good service, tasty pies and a clean, chill dining area. Lots of space for parties or work functions, plus a great, consistently-stocked pizza bar that doesn't skimp on the toppings or slice sizes. Two big thumbs up from me. read more

Family lunch while visiting Maryland. My daughter in law ordered simple fries and pepperoni pizza for us all, but man.. that pizza was good! The crew were all nice and friendly. Good came out quickly. On the tables they have little buckets with pop trivia cards which kept us all entertained!! All you can drink soda machine which is nice! No waiting for someone to come back and get you a refill! Over all it was good! Next time I'll have to check out the menu (my daughter in law had us sit and she ordered). read more

Nicolletti's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - California, Maryland

See all

We were visiting southern Maryland to check out a local college and soak in the Chesapeake Bay experience. Pizza is my first love (and true love never dies), and Nicolletti's was pretty much the closest pizza joint with decent reviews. The service we received was subpar at best. We entered the door and stood, looking for any signage or indicator that would instruct us to next steps. After appearing (very obviously) confused for a few minutes and being completely ignored by the staff, we eventually went to the counter and inquired about protocol. We were curtly informed that we were to order at the counter, pick a table, and the food would be brought to us. The food we ordered (pizza, pasta, and a chicken parm sub) was very good. Though the pizza seemed to be *trying* to be NY style without fully succeeding, it was still very good, flavorful, and loaded with cheese. The fries and chicken parm were basic, but the alfredo sauce on the pasta tasted homemade with strong heavy cream undertones. Overall, the food was good but the service wasn't. Our experience would have been vastly improved by friendlier staff. Would we go again? Maybe. But only if I really wanted pizza. read more

See all

Just recently my family and I went to eat at Nicolette's pizza. My 30 year old adult daughter order a beer and was asked for her ID which she gladly presented. The Manager who was working the register subsequently asked her to smile because as she said she looked a little different from her real ID license photo. She actually would not let it go either she insisted that she smile. Who does that?! We have never experienced the kind of harassment and disrespect and out right racism that we experienced. It was obvious profiling. We have been eating at this place for the 5 years that we have been living down here and to be treated with such disrespect and borderline racism was absolutely horrible and we will not be coming back and will be sure to tell everyone we know not to come back either. I will not even bother giving this place one star! read more

Veggie pizza and potato skins were great! The staff were attentive and knowledgeable plus the restaurant was very clean!

Food was decent. Large chicken salad so hard to mess up. Service was fine. They just took an order at the front and dropped at the table. Relatively quick... Ambiance was nom-existent... lol... similar to a fast food spot. Not bad for what it is... read more

Very good gluten free pizza. They are extremely quick to get the food out, which is a bonus.

Nicollettis is a St Marys Co local pizza/sub restaurant. I have been eating here since I was a child. The food is always amazing. Most of their food, sauce, rolls, dough, lasagna, and more, is house made, I know this, because it was my first job. I love the lunch buffet, it's a great price for all you can eat salad, pizza and drink. read more

If you're looking to eat food that has absolutely no flavor at all then you would love it here. They don't use any salt pepper oregano basil ... NOTHING. lol this is not true Italian style. They clearly have a steady clientele but my family and I will not be back! It also smelled like dish water when I walked in to pick up which is always a bad sign in my book. read more

The food was amazing. The lasagna was the best lasagna I have ever tasted, and I have been to a few establishments from Arizona to Texas, even to Germany, and this was truly the best. I can't wait to come back down to try this local establishment again. It is truly a gem in this part of Southern Maryland!! Two thumbs up read more

Nicolletti's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - California, Maryland

Best pizza and calamine in Southern Maryland!!! Friendly atmosphere! Extremely clean! read more

This place needs to be famous best pizza I have ever had! The staff is polite and kind and the pizza is just amazing

Went here for the first time, we got pizza, a calzone and a brownie. Was a relatively long wait in my opinion and for the wait I feel like the food could've tasted better. I can't speak on anything else on the menu but the pizza seemed undercooked to me and was too cheesy/oily for my liking but the crust was really good. The brownie from the front counter was incredible and the calzone was just okay. It's a cute little place but it didn't really stand out to me. The employees seemed uninterested in customers and preoccupied. They could've just been having a bad day but I feel like the customer service is also lacking. Probably wouldn't go again but if you're in the area it's worth a try. read more

See all

I ordered takeout for a large ricotta pizza. When I went in to pick up my order, I asked if I could add fries. I understood I was going to have to pay again, and when he turned the screen to me he hovered over to look with me. I didn't appreciate that, and with my tip selection not being 25% or more he told me, "close enough". I did not think that was professional. I also had to wait an additional 10 minutes for my fries because nobody notified me they were done. I understand they were closing up, but you would think that would incentivize you to get me out sooner. The fries were ok and the pizza itself was a good 4/10. I do not see myself ordering from this place again. read more

All the food here is delicious. They have the best pizza in St Mary's County! All their subs are very tasty and filling.

Wow. I ordered a large pizza. One side vegetarian and the other everything. Boy was it packed with everything. Tasted great. You have to deal with paying a lot. read more

Today was pizza day and we wanted to switch it up from the typical spots and support the Local Gourmet Pizzeria. We receive very good service. They were very polite and courtesy to me when placing the order and picking it up. The pizza was fresh and hot all the way to the house, just need it a little more crispy. But I would recommend this spot to if you're in Southern Maryland area.. read more

Nicolletti's Pizza - Large pizza half all the way and half meat lovers. - Pizza Near Me - California, Maryland

As always pizza was delicious! I called it in, it was ready when I arrived, hot and delicious

They have closest to NY style pizza in the area! Way better than Domino's and the others.

5 stars for the taste of the pizza. The lunch buffet is quite a good deal for Adults, as it gives you a plethora of options. The pickup system is a bit flawed, as someone grabbed by order as they just sit them around the restaurant, but the food is worth it. Tis pricey. read more

Food was great. Service was fantastic. I had a clear view of the street while eating my nice pizza with Parmesan cheese & lemonade.

I went to Nicolletti's yesterday for their lunch buffett. I could hardly believe it when I paid and was given a plate. I got a salad, ate it, and went back to the counter for a new plate for pizza. I was old that they give out one plate per person for both your salad and your pizza! WHAT KIND OF A RIDICULOUS POLICY IS THAT????? I like to eat my salad and pizza at the same time and with the plates the size that they are there isn't really any room for both on the same plate. Also, I'm one of those people who doesn't like my food touching, (I know that's pretty finicky but I'm not the only one). Come on Nicolletti's - YOU CAN DO BETTER! read more

Counter service at first would give the appearance of maybe But the overall customer service was great the food (pizza) was awesome and well worth the wait. Will be coming back for sure. read more

Very ordinary pizza. Nothing I'd good back for. Staff is excellent and friendly and very clean.

Best pizza in St. Mary's! The pepperoni and sausage pizza is my favorite. The sausage they use is so much better than your average chain pizza place. Their pizza is fresh and tasty. The mozzarella sticks and pizza rolls they have are delish too! read more

Nicolletti's Pizza - Pepperoni and sausage pizza - Pizza Near Me - California, Maryland

Great place for multi generational family get together over good pizza & I understand the awesome salad bar they had is making a comeback soon. Plus, beer - while not a huge selection, they have a good core variety. Oh, cheesesteak I had was legit last time I visited. read more

This place is now officially on my do not patronize list. The food is good but the service sucks. People are rude and don't even understand their menu. Today I wanted a salad. They were just finishing up the pizza and salad buffet but apparently they no longer offer the salad buffet separately. So there sat a bowl of iceberg lettuce tempting me. We asked if the side salad had iceberg lettuce and the "charming" counter person said it did. The menu said it did. It did not unless they have changed the name of romaine to iceberg. So I had to take my fluffing salad to go so I could go buy iceberg lettuce to add to it. So Nicoletti's can do one because I'm sick of their terrible service, I'm sick of their unpleasant staff, I'm sick of their lies, I'm sick of their ridiculous prices, and I'm SICK of them! There is no food on earth tasty enough to deal with these people. I'd rather drive nine hours to Ohio to have Reino's because they are similar pizza but the Reino family and their staff aren't a bunch of jerks. read more

Nicolletti's Pizza - A salad NOT made with iceberg lettuce as advertised. - Pizza Near Me - California, Maryland

Just over $30 for two small pizzas, that were average. Ingredients seemed OK, crust was average, sauce was average, service was good, for pick up anyways. If you like extremely thick crust with more than just a couple of toppings, this restaurant will not do that. (Some pizza restaurants cannot accommodate because they don't have the right pounds, or don't want to risk serving what could be conceived as undercooked dough.) I had Hawaiian with jalapeños and mushrooms (thick crust was what I'd call regular). They didn't have shrimp. My husband had the white pizza with hamburger, thin crust. He didn't really like the hamburger, saying it was bland, and I'd have to agree with him. He ate a couple pieces, and the rest got tossed. We just moved to the area, and our property management company said we should have gotten a "welcome" discount of some kind, which we didn't get at this restaurant. To be fair to the restaurant, we are still investigating on our end if perhaps we misunderstood from our management company. But I felt really stupid asking for it and trying to explain to the manager what I'd understood from our property management company. I got the impression that the restaurant/manager/employee thought I was trying to pull a fast one on them. It just didn't feel very good. Not ordering from here again. read more

AMAZING FOOD! I ordered the chicken Parmesan, the rest of my group ordered pizzas, and everyone was impressed! It was quite a bit of food for a great price, enough for leftovers the next day. I'll definitely be back! read more

Nicolletti's Pizza - Chicken Parmesan - Pizza Near Me - California, Maryland

Fabulous slice of pizza! We ordered 2 mediums - half cheese/half bacon & pineapple (top notch flavor combo if you haven't tried it) and a meat monster (not the name of it but it should be). The meat feast was overflowing with all the meats (Arby's who?)! The crust had the perfect crispy but soft pillowy texture that a pizza bone should have! We will for sure make this our new pizza spot in town! read more

awesome pizza and sides. Highly recommend the pepperoni knots with added mozzarella cheese. Won't find a better pizza place in Southern Maryland read more

Pretty good buffet on the weekdays. Took my daughter and she was able to try some stuff she doesn't normally eat. (She 1;)

I'm only writing a review because that was the best pizza I ever tasted. I woke up this morning, thinking about it...my dinner last night was blessed from above. Thank you read more

Best pizza in the county. Don't sleep on the Italian sub, that bread is everything. The steak and cheese is pretty good too.

Excellent quality. I'm from NY and I know good pizza. This is good for Maryland for sure. We have been in the area for the summer and have gotten Nicolleti's 4 times. It has not disappointed once and I'm very easily dissatisfied lol. Cant wait until we are back in the area to indulge again. read more

Nicolletti's Pizza - Pepperoni and Cheese Pizza - Pizza Near Me - California, Maryland

They don't honor their online deals. The online system is difficult to navigate and the manager is not pleasant to deal with and quite argumentative. I have had pizza from there and they are good but overpriced. read more

We really enjoyed our pizza! Good service. Just what we expect from a pizza restaurant... Deserves the five star rating from us! read more

Nicolletti's Pizza - medium half mushroom pizza and a gluten free pizza. - Pizza Near Me - California, Maryland

Last time I went here the cups were dirty, the pizza was nasty, and the service was bad. This was once a good restaurant, but they have gone down hill through the years. read more

The quality of food is great but the attitudes and treatment the workers have for customers is way too low and unexpected! In addition to that, they card people who are clearly old enough to drink! read more

while it was a Wednesday and my grandson was down and wanted to have lunch at Nicollettis we got there at ten after two. the clerk said no buffet it stopped at 2. I hadn't asked himmanyth8ng about buffet or anything else. while I was at the ordering location my wife and grandson were look8ng over all the entire buffet complete available and they asked if they could have what was already there. The clerk said no the buffet was over. we ordered a large pizza and left very unimportant. it wasn't handled as well as I would have appreciated. that's not good for Nicollettis reputation read more