Pasta dinners are huge. You can get at least two meals out of it. Chicken fingers are really good too. Love the French dip sandwich. Help is always friendly. Pizza is ok. read more

This is a typical sub/pizza place. It was very clean. I ordered a pizza, sub, salad and chicken fingers along with some fries. The food was excellent and there was plenty of it. It is a bit pricy but I found the quality excellent. They give you condiments as well. I ordered online and picked it up. I only had to wait about 5 minutes when I got there. Service was very busy and the phone was ringing off the hook, they were very pleasant to deal with. I will definitely try them again. read more

I love this place. Staff and owner is great! Food spot on. Menu is huge! Great seafood too. And best chicken fingers around.

Staff keep the building & inside very clean. They make delicious subs ... calzone & salads ... we eat here about once a week... It would be nice if the young lady answering the phone would relax & not rush you while you're placing your order. This is when mistakes happen. I ordered a side salad $6.99 w/ x feta & an error of an extra dressing ... the side salad totaled: $9.90! See picture to see how small this salad really is. While I know prices have increased & salaries have increased the price of this salad was already high! But an additional dressing and some feta increased it by almost $3.00. Ugh! I'm giving them 3 stars due to the price of this salad. Good is fresh & yummy but ... ouch! read more

Nick's Place - Side salad - Pizza Near Me - West Newbury, Massachusetts

See all

This place has my favorite cheeseburger literally out of every cheeseburger I've ever had anywhere. It's not too greasy like most places burgers nowadays. It's just perfect. Of course with lettuce, tomato, ketchup, and mayo. I don't know if it comes up the toppings but I always ask for them anyway. The staff is always very kind as well! read more

Delicious steak and cheese subs- the best I've had of anywhere on the northshore. Fast, efficient and reliable. We also had them cater a birthday party and the manager did an excellent job. Responsive, exactly on time, and professional. My guests all commented on the excellent food (hot and cold subs, chicken fingers, salad, Mac and cheese). read more

Went to this place today to get roast beef sandwiches, the meat was over cooked and tastless and expensive. I ordered regular and a Super 3 way plus a bottled beverage-$31.05 They also had a place to add a tip, here's your tip, don't rip me off and expect a reward for taking my order and handing me a bag, this world has gone crazy with this tipping bullshit, Everyone thinks they deserve a tip just by having a job. read more

Went there for my first time last week and plan on going there again. I had a pastrami sub that was the best I've ever had. What a great place and really nice people. read more

A little bit of everything in a small pizza shack. It's close convenient and they usually get the order right.

They have completely lost their mind. I was just quoted $44 for a GF cheese pizza and a large half cheese half nicks special. A whole nicks special is $19 and GF $14 on website. New management necessary. read more

They deliver. They were on time. The shrimp scampi pizza was over cooked had little to no garlic and barely had 1 shrimp per slice. the next morning I see I was charged $2 more than I should have been - was told "delivery fee" but they advertised free delivery. Never again. read more

Nick's Place - Shrimp scampi pizza should have at least one shrimp per slice and not be over cooked. - Pizza Near Me - West Newbury, Massachusetts

See all

My dad and I are fans of your steak bomb sub. We get one a few times a month. We have tried some other shops but we think yours is the best.

I have been a loyal Nick's Place West Newbury customer for years. The food has always been excellent and we order there often. Tonight I got take-out for the first time since the new ownership took over. I am so disappointed and will be taking my business elsewhere in the future. Nick's was always known for their homemade chicken fingers. We ordered a buffalo chicken finger sub. The chicken fingers are NOT the same, much smaller pieces, cold, and was given regular chicken fingers instead. Clearly not made to order. The fish and chips plate was small pieces of flavorless haddock with a thick disgusting coating. The fries were soggy, cold, and tasted like they were cooked yesterday. Overall our food was incorrect, cold, and small portions. Nick's was the best food joint this small town has seen, and now that has come to an end. Petition to bring the old Nick's back! read more

Absolutely amazing food with even better service, I go there everyday before basketball to get food and the owner is already waiting which makes it even better, 10/10 totally recommend read more

Consistently good quality food ... clean store with friendly employees. Definitely recommend the steak subs

CATERING REVIEW!!! Ordered catering for a baptism party. We looked all over in the area for catering on a Sunday, disappointed to only find many places closed or unreasonably priced. We drove to Nicks, met with 2 managers (I believe) and they helped put together a spread for 30 people. We ordered a tray of chicken fingers, that appeared to be hand cut and hand breaded. They were cooked perfectly and Nick's Place provided enough condiments for a years worth of chicken fingers. They were intended for children, but were so delicious they ended up on the adult plates too. We also ordered a tray of meatballs (that had melted cheese, probably mozzarella), that came with 6" rolls to make 1/2 subs if we pleased. Included were 2 containers of grated cheese. I am not sure if the meatballs were homemade, but they sure tasted it. There was a green leafy ingredient within, either basil or oregano, which suggested that they were indeed homemade. If they were frozen, they were the best frozen meatballs I ever had. They really tasted like a homemade crock-pot meatball. In addition, we ordered a tray of chicken, broccoli, ziti (or penne, I forget) with a garlic oil that was delicious. It could have used a little more broccoli for aesthetics, but it was loaded with garlic and delicious. It also had huge chunks of delicious marinated chicken. Lastly, we ordered a tray of sausages, peppers and onions that also came with finger rolls. The sausages where cut the long way/diagonal, yielding nice big pieces/slices of sausage. The peppers and onions appeared to be fresh and hand cut. All of the components were grilled and returned to a tray where they continued to marinate in a flavorful sauce/oil. Not to forget, but I can't remember if we ordered garlic bread, or if it came with it....but it consisted of sub rolls, cut in half, that were buttered, spread with garlic and seasoned. It doesn't sound fancy, but it was delicious with the meatballs. When the order was delivered, the driver carried all the food inside and helped place the items where we requested. Everyone absolutely loved the food, and a couple guests said they would be contacting Nick's Place to set up future catering events. FYI, what I described in this review, was MORE than enough food for our party. We were sending guests home with to-go containers. If I could do it over again, I would have asked Nick's Place to provide styrofoam containers in the event of leftovers. Do not turn a blind eye to Nick's Place for catering because it's a sub/pizza shop. They did an amazing job catering our event! read more

Place is not worth it. Just spent $48 dollars on two small calzones. Added some things to a steak and cheese calzone and they jack the price way up and food even isn't that good. Like it would be one thing if the food was phenomenal, but $48 for two small calzones like that's craziness. I could get so much more food for $48 dollars read more

Food is really good Great calzone and pizza Subs are very large and salads are also large read more

The food is consistently good. They have a large menu. Th people are friendly and they have good specials. We have ordered for birthday and other parties and have never had any issues with a large order. read more

Extremely great food!! Never been here before but I popped in and bought the haddock platter and chicken fingers. I fed 3 people with all this food and it was delicious and worth the money. Will definitely go back again and I highly recommend! read more

The food is alright but good luck getting any if you don't want to walk in and order it there. I swear they must get off on making their customers hate them because no matter what time of day I call I'm either hung up on, get the machine, or get put on hold indefinitely. I dead ass think there's a better chance of winning the lottery than there is getting them to take your order. 3:00 PM on a Wednesday and I'm on hold for over half an hour. Either get your shit together or start taking online orders again. read more

We ordered a catering order saturday and have nothing but nice things to say! The order was a cold cut platter which came with all the fixings you would want on an Italian sub, diced onions, tomatoes, shredded lettuce, red onions and all the condiments you want. We also got a large Greek salad which was not your average salad ! It had everything including red leaf lettuce peppers and tomatoes with red onions and feta on side! Nicks house dressing is amazing in itself ! The sub rolls were fresh as well and cut into 6" rolls. Lastly the spinach pie was fantastic a true crowd pleaser. They made a large tray and cut it up into fours . The staff are wonderful and very professional. This is our third time getting a catering order from them and it will not be the last! read more

I've ordered many items off the menu & have yet to be disappointed. From the bowls to the steak to the burgers & pizza, everything is great. Only complaint, I draw a map to get to my building & still there's always an issue finding it. But, it's nothing my convection oven can't fix in 3-5 minutes. read more

My bf's husband recommended we try their roast beef sandwich since we grew up on Harrison's in North Andover and I was very happy with my sandwich! I would def go again and the customer service was A+ Keep doing a great job!!! read more

I absolutely love the chicken Caesar here. Everything I've ordered always comes stacked to the Hills hot and delicious!!! The staff here genuinely cares about their food quality and customers. It shows in every meal I've ordered Since they opened! Thanks!!! read more

After seeing so many places leave this location, clearly Nicks is doing something right! Food is fresh and tasty every time. Giving it 3 stars ONLY BECAUSE I ordered a takeout chicken Caesar salad there and received raw chicken. It's only happened once, but that has the potential of getting someone very sick. Who ever checks the food before it goes out needs to look out for things like that. Cut into the chicken before sending it if you have to read more

Don't expect to ever call them and speak to anyone that sounds the slightest bit professional. John... The manager... Is the most unprofessional and immature of them all. If any other place employed these people they would be out of business. Ill give 2 stars because their food is good. But don't ever order the mac n cheese cuz its frozen dinner and their salads are wilted and brown half the time. Actually I'm giving it a 2 star because I really like their asian chicken tenders but that's about it. read more

Great! They even gave me a free dessert! Excellent place. Food was good. I highly recommend if you're in the area.

Food was a little soggy as it was put in styrofoam and not vented. ok atmousphere. not really kid friendly. food was just ok. wouldn't give this place a second look. read more

I have ordered from Nicks I'm very secure. The pizza usually arrives at the house called. I normally call my order in and it's always delivered but this time I decided to put the order in online and was told that I could just order pizza I had to order a sandwich. So I decided to order an Italian so I could have it for my lunch the next day it came with nothing on it I ordered a fried fish dinner and it was horrible. I don't know what's happened to Nicks food was really great when they first opened but I really think it's gone downhill and I'm tired of getting cold food delivered read more

My wife and I usually pick up pizza or steak sandwich or salad with chicken---did not know they had FRESH HADDOCK----Baked---so... I asked the owner was the Haddock Fresh and he said "Yes"... so .. I tried it... WOW... yes is was FRESH and moist and tasty .... Baked just right and quantity and quality.... my wife ordered a salad---tuna salad salad... and she saw my Haddock and took a piece and said.. "I am going to order that next time".... got to try the Prime Rib.... Great place... we have not a problem with our orders... Enjoy read more

This was a pleasant surprise. Food was very good and service was good also. The wife and I both the haddock plate. I would recommend it

So far so good for the latest Italian place to take up shop across from Pentucket High. Only ordered pizza once --a combo--that was pretty good, not greasy, and, best of all, delivered. Hoping Nicks makes a go of it, although our heart is still with West Newbury Pizza Co. "Downtown." read more

I love this place. The portions are ridiculous, you can share or save 1/2 of just about everything. I get the chicken kabob salad (which has mixed greens not just ice-burg, love that!) and eat it for 2 days. Chicken salad, always fresh, all white meat, never drowning in mayo. Then there is the Fisherman's platter...haddock, shrimp, clams scallops & LOBSTER TAIL? Brilliant! Huge fan. read more

Go for the roast beef and salads, very good service and staff! Check out their daily specials that are good for the wallet and the belly. They do delivery and pick up very well! read more

Best sub shop in the area. They have reasonable prices and they take pride in their food. My favorite is their chicken cutlet salad not the chicken kabob. The chicken is so damn good. Kind of reminds me of my mothers famous "smashed chicken." We live within walking distance of another sub shop but choose to go here instead. read more

My bf and I have ordered from here twice now. The first time we had mixed feelings. We got a small pizza. Toppings were loaded on. I mean loaded. They definitely don't skimp on that aspect. Which is good and bad. Lots of flavor is a positive but it's so heavy that the dough becomes soft and you can't eat it like a normal slice. It's somewhat of a turn off actually. Today we gave it another go. We got the veggie pizza and a calzone. Pizza was again packed with toppings and, therefore, too soggy to eat. The calzone is hard to explain. It's like they took a pizza crust, put toppings on it, then put another pizza dough on top, cooked it, and cut it like a pizza! It wasn't terrible but I wouldn't order a calzone or pizza from here again. I'm not impressed by this place at all. read more

The food here generally is not the weak point. We ordered delivery recently and were stunned at how long it took. I work as a chauffeur. My wife placed an order after I dropped off a party in Portsmouth NH figuring we would both arrive at the same time. She was told the pizza would take 45 min to arrive. I dropped my party off at 7:00 and they had a brewery tour and a private function. By the time I had to leave to pick them up at 9:15 the pizza from Nicks had just arrived, cold as a dead fish. Moral of the story is? Drive to Red Hook, take a tour, eat, and be home before your pizza arrives! read more

Salad is always fresh and delicious, it comes with fresh pita bread and always extra dressing if you need it. The Nicks Special pizza is very, very good as well, Seafood is great too, and the pasta is amazing. I love this place! read more

This place has excellent food from the calzones to the pasta to the salads. We love doing half price pasta on Wednesdays and they have lots of options. Their salads are very fresh and the Cesar has homemade croutons. They also really have their stuff together and are very organized with their pick up orders. I have yet to be disappointed at Nick's. read more