Simple unpolished cuisine the staff takes great care of me every time I'm their like I'm some big baller so many places around here try and be to creative with their food and it just makes it unapproachable in my opinion at least these guys make simple great pizza with quality ingredients still haven't tried the wings but they pizzas the bomb read more

Fresh, delicious, take-and-bake pizza. A Boulder institution! Pizza by the slice is baked there, so you can have a quick yummy lunch in the restaurant. A few years ago they started doing chicken wings and rotisserie chickens. Both are amazing. We regularly do the rotisserie chickens for family dinners. The hot-sauce is incredible! read more

Why I've gone to this Nick -N-Willy's for 20 years: 1. Great pizza. The Magellan is our favorite. 2. Great people. I walked out without paying once, when my head was in the clouds. When I rushed back , all apologies, they didn't have me on their Deadbeat list. Quite a change from some businesses! 3. The lunch specials make it easy for me to eat salad and a slice. read more

Nick and willy's is a complete rip off. They charge you a ridiculous amount of money to take a shitty pizza home that you have to still bake once you get home. You can go to abos and get better pizza and have it delivered for less than N&w shitty pizza that you have to bake. We ordered wings as well. This was a huge mistake. They gave us cold wings with no sauce. Apparently we have to take their shitty wings home, sauce them and then bake them. While we waited for our shitty pizza to get made (not baked) just made. The manager of the place was arguing with an employee on how she didn't correctly charge credit cards. This is a huge concern. Can N&w employees not be trained properly to charge a credit card? Apparently so. I would highly recommend to NOT ever go to nick and willy's. Ever. read more

Feel like I just got swindled...canned pineapples and canned oranges on top of grocery store ham? Pizza you have to bake yourself? I'd rather eat cardboard, it might be more appetizing. read more

This is the best damn pizza you will EVER EAT. fresh ingredients and yuh just pop it in the oven for 20. Simple and clean. - AWESOME!

Hole-in-the-wall place. Amazing pizza AND salads. Quick, efficient, clean, friendly, and delicious. Highly recommend the Mediterranean slice of pizza! Many options to choose from! Fresh ingredients and made with love. Feels like a community pizza shop! read more

When it comes to pizza, you have an incredible number of choices in Boulder. Nick-N-Willy's gives you a choice of eat-in or take-home pizza. I love their eat-in pizza (slices only) which comes in lots of delicious topping combinations; their take-home is something you design, with help from the staff, if needed, take home and bake at your leisure. Lots of fun, either way! read more

I probably should give this place another chance, but they were offering free pizza slices at Pearl St. bars so my friends and I decided to check it out after closing time. This pizza reminded me of carnival pizza. The mass produced crust, blah sauce, and sub-par cheese. Now maybe it was because I got a free slice, but there were plenty of other people ordering slices there, and Nick N Willys just used slices that had clearly been sitting out for a while, piled on an incredible amount of toppings - too much to even be enjoyable - on the old slices. Not exactly appetizing or attractive. read more

Finally stopped in here the other day after I've walked by tons of times. I ordered their small Mediterranean pizza to go. I like the idea of a take and bake so I can cook at my leisure and have a chill night in. So, I did exactly that. I followed the instructions listed on the pizza package to a tee but apparently my oven is not up to par because it took a lot more time to cook the pizza than they said. The pizza was good, not wonderful but good. I plan to go back to try another pizza I have in mind. I thought it was interesting that you can also order rotisserie chicken there too. read more

I have been in love with Nick-n-Willy's pizza for many, many years. When I was recently diagnosed with a gluten allergy, I figured my Nick-n-Willy's days were, sadly, over. However, my parents, in a brilliant "why not?" moment, asked them if they might be able to do a gluten-free crust. They. Said. Yes. Turns out, I'm not the only person in the world with this difficulty. And N-n-W wasn't about to let me leave their loyal entourage. I can get a gluten-free crust from them with any of my many favorite pizzas. I've got my eye on the Little Nell. Barbecued chicken with delicious sauce, paired with some red onion. It is the thing. I highly recommend these guys, even for those of us with a bit of a wheat aversion. They are wonderful, accommodating, kind, funny, clever, and fabulous people, who also make some of the world's greatest pizza. Do stop in. read more

This place was delicious! The slices are as big as your face and worth the cost, which wasn't much at all. Clean and enjoyable outdoor seating in beautiful Boulder. read more

Really not impressed with my experience at Nick n' Willy's on pearl. Totally overpriced for the quality of ingredients and time it takes to cook yourself. Why would I ever spend $20 on a pizza here when I could walk a few blocks to pizzeria locale and buy something 10x as good for $5 less? Owner is overbearing and just a bit too eager, if I have a question ill ask thanks. Confused how they've lasted so long and been voted best of boulder at all. read more

Owner is a jerk. I tried to order pizza and they were closing and not only they refused to fill my order but he was a complete jerk about it. Too bad the pizzas good but the owner at this Pearl Street location is a jerk. read more

Yum! We ordered the Fior di Latte with added chicken on gluten free. The fresh basil, tomatoes and red onion combined made each bite a tasty delight. Perfect salty meal after a day of hiking in Rocky Mountain National Park. read more

Pizza in Boulder is sub-standard. Unless you come here. Romero is awesome, the ingredients are fresh and locally sourced.. If you are a food snob and like a good pie, this is the place to go. read more

The best slices of the thin crust, pesto with toppings. Customer service always remarkable. Low key. Outside dining in good weather. Great condiments including pepper flakes, hot sauce, parmigiana, and oregano. read more

Still the best pizza in Boulder after all these years. You just can beat the taste and friendly staff!

As usual, I always think I'm a pizza hater until I come here. This is the best and freshest pizza I've ever eaten.

Lately I've been going here at lot more because it's nearby and I'm a fan now. I have to remember my own mantra - don't just a pizza place by its cheese pizza. Actually I do like their cheese more than I thought but their specials... oh man they're good. Unfortunately it's a bit overpriced for slices and I'm not into the whole take and bake thing (I rather have my pizza cooked in a professional oven), but they got the flavors spot on. read more

This is a really nice little shop. I should have reviewed it sooner, but I forgot last month. Stopped in for a quick slice of pizza and a drink. The entire bill came to about 6 bucks. The pizza was tasty, and I wolfed it down quick. I would come back again when in Boulder. read more

A really bad attempt at pizza. You might have to take out a loan if you want two slices.

Awesome pizza but awesome pizza is not terribly rare. What is rare is awesome pizza and wings and this place has that down. Think they put crack in them or something, not sure but they are highly addicting. Do yourself a favor go for pizza then order a big pile of wings with it, you can thank me later. read more

Delicious pizza, friendly environment, indoor and outdoor seating, and good prices. I had 2 pizza slices and a drink for $8.50. I would rate this 10 stars if I could. read more

Liars!! No check in deal. They look at you like your nuts too when you try to redeem it. When I suggested they at least fix it on the site the looked at me like I was speaking another language. read more

I remember eating and Nick-N-Willy's years ago but I must have forgotten how amazing it is. This may well be my favorite pizza on the hill/pearl street and it's an amazing value. Toppings are piled high and my one slice of pizza had more prosciutto than a whole pizza at Mod Market. The "half salads" are huge and made fresh in front of you. The staff was very friendly and upbeat which was refreshing compared to the vegetarian, protein deprived or high school degenerates that seem to populate a lot of the service industry in boulder. I'll be back and I would recommend N-N-W's to anyone whose tired of the pizza options in Boulder or anyone who simply enjoys good food. read more

Great variety of custom made Pizza. Freshest ingredients ever! Love the chicken wings too- spicy enough and not over the top. Salads- superb! Try the homemade Caesar dressing. Easy take n bake solution for family dinners and casual parties. Love it!!! read more

Ok take and bake pizza or pizza by the slice. A little over priced but you are in Boulder. The chicken is surprisingly good. Ask for hot sauce with the chicken. read more

Guaranteed happy bellies, I used to come all the time as a kid and came in for the first time in a while tonight for a quick slice and had a great experience! The staff was great, especially homegirl Michelle who served us. Will be making this a frequent pearl street pit stop read more

The BEST pizza in Boulder hands-down. Sincere, hard-working staff that makes some amazing pizza with the freshest of ingredients. Definitely a step ahead of the other pizza places in Boulder. read more

Pizza is fine but pricy. But I actually go here for the chicken. Believe only the Boulder location can sell it. It is really flavorful and love the wings. If it is hot and just came out it is incredible how juicy it is. But if it's not you can tell. You get the flavor but it is a lot drier. Wish they could cook these to order. Next time I'm gonna call ahead and see if that helps. read more

Really great pizza. The crust was just right, not too thick and not too thin. There is a great choice of toppings and their combinations are well chosen. They're very helpful in giving instructions to a first time buyer to cook it perfectly at home. The salads are tasty. read more

Take and bake is a great thing for us mountain dwellers. I count on Nick n Willy's when I want a casual night in front of the TV with my husband, and we've been hooked on the International for several years. Quality is dependable, owner rocks, staff is friendly and efficient. What more could I ask?! read more

Why would I order an uncooked pizza? Please be more transparent on your partner websites about your product. Unclear from HungryBuffs website this would be uncooked. Rude manager, and I would not order again. I could make this pizza at home. Absolutely ridiculous a frozen pizza took over an hour to receive. read more

Delicious. :-) Great selection of sauces and toppings. The BBQ chicken is especially good. read more

I just ate Nick-N-Willy's pizza for the first time and it kicks pizza azz! I love that it is take and bake and therefore makes you feel like the master of pizza as you pull it out of the oven bubbling hot and cheesy (just follow the instructions, a pizza stone doesn't hurt though!)! This is no toaster oven, dorm style pizza, mind you, this is the real deal; thin crust superb quality toppings, gourmet pizza. The Downtown location is a trendy corner store with a great counter for ordering slices. They are friendly, cool and nothing less than pizza professionals! I also saw take-and-bake cookies that look equally scrumptious! I am in pizza eating heaven right now. Match it with red wine or beer and you have yourself a luxury home-pizza experience! Thank you Nick-N-Willy's, You Rock! read more

THE WORST CUSTOMER SERVICE. As a first time customer at Nick N Willys, I was treated with disrespect and was given multiple excuses as to why my TAKE N BAKE pizza took an HOUR AND A HALF to be delivered on a Thursday night. When it was finally delivered, the pizza was not even what I had ordered and the "Greek salad" was only a box of lettuce. I will never go back. One of the worst experiences I've ever had at a restaurant. read more

Please get this amazing chicken flavor off of mind, it's so addictive! Haha Seriously, I can't think of a better quality pizza and/or rotisserie chicken in boulder. We like to take home the gluten free pizzas for the family. Thanks, Nick & Willy! read more

As my next door neighbor, I find myself at Nick N Willy's often and I'm always happy about it. They have amazing pizza and surprisingly, my favorite chicken wings in town. Their food always hits the spot. YUM! read more

The original and best Nick-n-willy's! Terry Jones knows how to do it right! Eat in slices or take fresh gourmet pizzas and bake at home, Boulders best handmade fresh pizza and the salads are awesome too! I love it! They also have amazing fresh seasoned Red Bird Rotisserie chicken and hot wings too! read more