1. Newark Garden Hotel

0

Newark, NY

Cancel

Open app

Search

Newark Garden Hotel

3.1 (16 reviews)
ModerateHotels
Open • Open 24 hours

Newark Garden Hotel Photos

You might also consider

Recommended Reviews - Newark Garden Hotel

Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
Yelp app icon
Browse more easily on the app
Review Feed Illustration

Reviews With Photos

Close-up view of the pool area.
Melissa R.

We stayed at Newark Garden Hotel last week. We live out of state and were visiting a family member in the nearby Newark-Wayne Hospital. Pros: - We were able to make last minute reservations without any trouble. - Staff was very friendly. - Hotel was dog friendly. In fact, whenever the staff saw my husband walking the dogs, they offered a treat. It was very thoughtful. - Pool was very clean. One day we were there was very warm and the whole family enjoyed a swim. - Breakfast was very nice. There was a lot more variety than I expected (bread, bagels, eggs, sausage, bacon, waffles, cereal, fruit, coffee, juice, etc.). - One day we were running quite late for breakfast. We probably arrived 10 minutes before closing. The owner was very gracious and accommodating. We were able to sit and enjoy our meal without being rushed. - They have a nice gym. I didn't get the opportunity to use it, but I peeked in and was pleasantly surprised with equipment variety. - Rooms were clean and neat. Included fridge, microwave, and coffee maker. My kids (2 & 3 years old) got a kick out of "living" somewhere new. They were especially fond of a kid-sized fridge. - Water pressure and temperatures in the shower were great. - Price was really reasonable. Cons: - In the pool area there were some random puddles of water. I think they were in the process of addressing some leaks from the roof. It'll be nice to see if it is fixed before our next stay. - The hallway smelled a bit like smoke near our room. We were by the back entrance; so, I assume people were standing outside smoking. Nothing the hotel could really do to fix this. Overall we were really happy with our stay. We visit the area a few times a year to see family. We'll definitely consider staying again.

Exterior photo 2017

See all

Photo of Robert M.
2
113
35

5 years ago

Helpful 1
Thanks 0
Love this 1
Oh no 0
Photo of Eddie L.
86
78
65

7 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

6 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

8 years ago

Helpful 1
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

5 years ago

Helpful 1
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

9 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

9 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

8 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

8 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

7 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

9 years ago

Family run property. Excellent value for money. Friendly staff. Very clean. Nice indoor pool. Good breakfast. Would stay again.

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

9 years ago

Helpful 1
Thanks 0
Love this 1
Oh no 0

9 years ago

Helpful 2
Thanks 0
Love this 1
Oh no 0

8 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

9 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

7 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

Ask the Community - Newark Garden Hotel

Review Highlights - Newark Garden Hotel

“Also this hotel has a really cool indoor pool with heating which the kids really enjoyed.”

Mentioned in 2 reviews

Read more highlights

You might also consider

Peppermint Cottage Bed & Breakfast

Peppermint Cottage Bed & Breakfast

(3 reviews)

We came here for a bachelorette low key get away with a few of my sisters friends. It was lovely,…read morewe kept saying how the place seemed straight out of a hallmark movie. We can see why this is so popular in the winter. It's just simply perfect. I could picture being snowed in like in the movies and loving it. This is located on a nice road very easy to get to. Not far from the bustling downtown of Geneva. But far enough to be nestled in the country. We even got pizza delivery here which was an awesome surprise that the local pizzeria offers. We enjoyed the clean and wonderful hot tub. The interior had everything we could have needed and more. Thank you for the eggs and the coffee creamer! The beds were comfortable and everything was very clean. For being a historic home everything had such nice charm and style. The bathroom was fully updated and the downstairs bedroom had the perfect vibe I'd love in my own home. Beautiful flowers galore. The host Diane was friendly via the app and self check in was a breeze. We were left alone and felt totally safe and comfortable. I'd love to come back with my husband for a get away. This is a great place, highly recommend. Note though... when trying to locate it. Our gps took us up the hill along the backside of the owners house.. this was a dirt pathway - not the right way. The sign was deceiving. The cottage is directly next to the house, right off the paved road. Bonus points to the host for having the awesome array of dvds and games. This was so fun for us girls.

If you want to just get away for a bit with your significant other (or whomever really, even by…read moreyour damn self) and just stay in, read, cook, have some much needed alone time, all while enjoying a hot tub, fireplace - with the option of going out to wineries, breweries, Rochester, and Sodus Point and Lake Ontario - I highly recommend this venue. The owners are kind and nice. You may get a fun visit from a black cat named Salem (loves milk and pets). The fireplace was my favorite. I sat and drank beer in front if it and did some coding and was totally lovely. It has a little warming nook and a rack to hang a dutch oven over the fire if you really want to go old school and cook on it. Just as lively was multiple champagne drinking sessions in the hot-tub. Lots of dry wood to burn. Recommend that you bring a bit of your own firewood just to keep the supply up as well as a bit of spring water if you're gonna cook / drink a lot and stay in.

Belhurst Castle and Winery

Belhurst Castle and Winery

(111 reviews)

$$$

Absolutely beautiful building, grounds, and views. We ate at the restaurant and the server was very…read morefriendly and helpful. The food was delicious, and the decor was lovely. Very child friendly, also with good kid menu options.

We came for a wedding in Penn Yan and stayed at the Ice House and in the main castle. For such a…read morelovely property it is terribly neglected. The mattresses are old and worn out. I mean really old where you can hear the springs creak and you wake up dozens of times in the middle of the night. The bathroom and foyer of the Ice House smells like feces because the septic tank is so old and not working properly. Stepping from the foyer into the living room shakes the entire floor. The gas stove in the kitchen doesn't work and isn't hooked up to anything. Why bother having a stove then? There were no full length mirrors in either the Ice House or the room in the main house, very inconvenient for getting ready considering many people come here for weddings. Septic tank for the Ice House needs to be replaced and the house needs to be renovated so the building doesn't shake when you walk around. I like a rustic charm where things look old but at least do some upkeep to maintain the property. In the main building, you can smell the septic tank from the lobby. They sprayed a ton of perfume to try to cover it up but the perfume smells awful and now it just smells like perfume and feces. Also spraying that much perfume is disruptive for people with sensitivities and migraines and will give you a headache. For the amount we're paying, we shouldn't have to smell shit during our whole stay. The continental breakfast is pathetic and definitely not suitable for people with dietary restrictions. They have plastic wrapped bagels and pastries and sugary cereals. All refined carbs. Everything has sugar added, including the cream cheese. No almond or oat milk, they only have dairy milk. That felt more like a "f*ck you" than an oversight because dairy intolerance is so common and every place has non-dairy milk these days. The yogurt isn't even vegetarian! It has gelatin in it. The fresh blueberries were nice. We ended up eating in Geneva. Again disappointing considering the price, you'd expect a better breakfast. Overall not worth it considering the price. I do not recommend staying here unless they renovate the property. Shameful as it's so beautiful.

Lancellotti Dining Room at Geneva On The Lake - I was a bellhop here back during the 90s when I was 15!

Lancellotti Dining Room at Geneva On The Lake

(77 reviews)

$$$

Lancellotti's is absolutely beautiful. The grounds are breathtaking! I would highly suggest dining…read more around sunset. My husband and I were celebrating my birthday and this could not have been anymore perfect. Our waitress was wonderful, even those who simply stopped by our table to make sure we were satisfied were absolutely wonderful. Our cocktails were divine our dinner was splendid. We really enjoyed the outdoor seating with live music. We could not have asked for a better ambiance & service for our dinner.

$2,000 Stay, Poor Room Condition, and Refusal to Refund Unused Night…read more Beautiful setting, but disappointing room conditions and an even more disappointing General Manager response. My wife and I prepaid the $2,000 required for a four-night stay at Geneva On The Lake in the Finger Lakes in Geneva, New York. Unfortunately, an unexpected medical emergency at home forced us to leave after our third night. We notified the hotel management on our third night and requested a refund only for the fourth night that we could not use - approximately $500. We stayed the third night since we learned of our emergency at 5 pm and could not handle the 7-hour drive home as seniors. The hotel refused to refund the unused night, citing its 14-day cancellation policy, even though we had not cancelled our stay before arrival. We had already stayed three of the four nights and left only because of an unforeseen emergency. There were no public statements on the hotel's website regarding early departure penalties. Their site only spoke to "cancellations made less than 14 days of the arrival date are not refundable". After further correspondence, management offered to refund only 30% of the unused night -- $148.46. I asked them one final time to reconsider and refund the unused fourth night. Nearly three days later, I received no response at all. Unfortunately, that was not our only disappointment. I also took photographs of the condition of our accommodation. They show: * stained carpeting * a torn main sofa cushion * large stains/marks on several pieces of wood furniture * very dirty window glass * substantial cobwebs between the windows and screens which prevented opening the windows I am posting the photographs with this review so prospective guests can judge the condition for themselves. I initially chose not to raise these room condition issues with management because I was trying to resolve the unused night issue privately and reasonably. Geneva On The Lake is in a beautiful location and has considerable potential, but at the prices it charges, I expected considerably better maintenance of the accommodations and, equally important, a more reasonable and responsive approach from management when a guest faces a genuine emergency. The most disappointing part of this experience was not simply that things went wrong. It was how management handled them afterward.

Carriage House Inn Bed & Breakfast - The Eagle Island Room is a peaceful place to rest

Carriage House Inn Bed & Breakfast

(7 reviews)

Jerry took great care of us while at the B&B. It's a short…read morewalk to the old lighthouse and really close to the Main Street too. Breakfast was great! Really intimate surroundings with only four rooms so you could have chats in the morning. West coast warning: if the fire dept needs to be called a loud siren goes off and it is super loud, especially when asleep. We found this out in the morning. I thought for a second we were being invaded by Canada! Lol.

Jerry and Claudine took such good care of us during our stay! The breakfasts in the morning were so…read moredelicious and changed daily! There is always coffee available in the dining room (courtesy of the Keurig machine), and in the afternoon/evening, there are fresh cookies! This charming B&B only has 4 rooms, so you'll never be overrun with people. You're very close to the old lighthouse and the water, as well as the 'downtown' area of restaurants, bars, ice cream, etc. The rooms are a bit small (especially the bathroom), as that was the way rooms were built in the 1800s, but our room served its purpose of giving us a close location while visiting family. **If you are not from New York (or a small-ish town?), you must know this information!!! In small towns like Sodus, the fire department is all volunteers. When someone calls for them, to alert all the volunteers that they are needed, they set off a crazy loud air siren!! I'm all for nostalgia and quaintness of years past, but come one people, everyone has a cell phone. Call those volunteers! When the first (of 3) sirens went off at 11:00pm, Jim G and I didn't know what to think! Was Canada finally sick of our bs and coming to invade? Was the nuclear power plant not too far away melting down? Was a tornado a-comin'? No one was leaving their homes or driving off in a panic, so we tried to ignore it and sleep. Then another one a bit later. Then the final one at 4:00am! Our fellow travelers found our fear hilarious at breakfast! We can laugh about it now, but seriously, catch up with the technology, lol! Thanks, Jerry and Claudine!

Hampton Inn Geneva - Restaurant

Hampton Inn Geneva

(30 reviews)

$$

My stay at the Hampton Inn was pretty decent. It's definitely not a lake view like the hotel…read moreadvertises but the lake is within walking distance. The staff was friendly, rooms were clean, continental breakfast wasn't half bad, it's within walking distant to several restaurants and bars and there is plenty of parking. Called to make a reservation the day of, it was a Wednesday and they were able to accommodate us. We got a room with a queen size bed and it wasn't huge but it was good enough and the bathroom was spacious. The pillows on the bed might be the best pillows I have ever slept on in any hotel, EVER, and I have stayed in many hotels. So fluffy and wonderful. So one thing I have to say: they have coffee downstairs in the "lobby" area 24 hours a day and they also have cookies. Yes, soft, wonderful, delicious cookies. They are enormous and stare you right in the face when you walk in the hotel. You may think you have willpower, but when you are coming back to this hotel after a night of drinking in Geneva, willpower gone. Those cookies were darn delicious. Yes, cookies, plural. They have a pool and a little fitness center too, which we didn't utilize but maybe you will. Their continental breakfast was definitely impressive, for the most part, as long as you didn't intend on eating very healthy. Their hard boiled eggs were bad, two mornings we had continental breakfasts here, both times, the texture just wasn't right. They had oatmeal in a crackpot, which was my go to because it was one of the only healthy options. The toppings they had seemed healthy until you really looked at what it was. There were "almonds" but they were coated in loads of sugar. There was cinnamon sugar and there were also candied fruit. Luckily there were some peanut butter packs and I added that to my oatmeal with a banana and was set. They had make your own waffles, turkey sausage, omelettes, cereal, bagels, muffins and toast. Their coffee wasn't my favorite, but it also wasn't the worst. They had 2% milk, skim and half and half out. I thought the rooms were a tad expensive for what they were, but it was convenient that we didn't have to get a cab to go to the various restaurants and bars in the area. They even let me leave my car in the parking lot overnight while we headed to the end of the lake and stayed in Watkins Glen. I would definitely stay here again.

the toilet was 13 inches off the ground Ada - suggests 19…read moreinches not good for recent hip replacement Rug wet under air conditioner Not noticeable till you stepped on it bare foot ! No Liquid body soap Renovations. everywhere will look nice - but We forgot they would start at 9 Guy outside was very friendly ( on 3rd) floor

Newark Garden Hotel - hotels - Updated October 2026

Loading...
Loading...
Loading...