I ordered a large pizza from here the other day and it was not how I remembered their pizzas tasting. I will them a positive for their pepperonis because it tasted really good. But it seems like their dough and their cheese has changed since I last ordered from them. I'm not telling you not to order your pies from here, I'm just letting you my recent experience. read more

New York Pizza - Just a good ol' pepperoni pizza - Pizza Near Me - Alameda, California

Came in with 18 people, bought like 6 large pizzas, drinks for everyone, wings and more. A small pizza was made wrong. Asked for it to be remade and the register person goes "either pay for the other pizza or we aren't remaking it". Receipt clearly showed we ordered correctly. Seemed silly to not just make the pizza for my 13 year old after messing it up. We come in maybe 4-5 times per year for tournaments and will never come back here. read more

The pizza is horrible and the customer service is zero star specifically the lady i went there and ask for my order which i was ordered like 15 minutes ago and she said 5 minutes more and i said o ordered 15 minutes ago then she said we didn't confirm it if you want you can leave read more

Classic NY style pizza. Big slices. Pizza place ambiance. Good quick service. Made to order toasty and cheesy. Family friendly read more

I've been eating pizza from here for about 20 years. My tip: I prefer to ask them to cook the pizza "well done." I feel it helps the dough/crust. Never have had a bad pie from here. Big slices, tasty cheese. Slightly salty dough. A dependable, very good pizza. read more

Fresh pizza, delivered HOT in the City of Alameda. That's what I got on a cool Sunday evening. I had a $10 credit on my Seamless App, so I used it on a Medium Combination Pizza with Extra Mozzarella and extra ground beef. Whoa, what a nice combo pizza! I added extra mozzarella to insure it had a creamy blanket of cheese. Last time there wasn't enough cheese. The extra ground beef was there to balance any salty pepperoni. Now, I don't know if this is legit New York style pizza. My friend in NYC says ONLY pizza made in New York can be a NY Pizza. According to him, there's no transplants. But this is a good combo pizza. NY Pizza uses their own drivers, so you don't pay any extra service fees. Seamless gave me free delivery. So you just pay for the pizza, sales tax, and tip. Cheaper if you order directly. New York Pizza is at 1528 Park St, between Lincoln & Webb. read more

See all

We ordered delivery from our hotel. While the pizza was good, the salad came with no dressing. Very disappointing, no one wants a salad without dressing. We notified them with no response. Will not use this place again read more

I was glad to hear that New York Pizza delivers without having to go through Door Dash or GrubHub service. This would have been a good option had the pizza been good. Their combo didn't have a lot of the toppings you would get in a typical combo and you can't fold it like a New York slice as the crust was thin but also stiff too. Also got some wings which i thought was better than the pizza but i specifically asked for the wings to be dry and with sauce on the side. Price for these items was like $50 which i thought was a little pricey. May need to go through Door Dash to get the pizza I want or drive myself. read more

New York Pizza - Combo/Hawaiian mixed Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Alameda, California

See all

ALMOST THERE!!! I'm a New Yorker and this is the closest thing to New York Street Pizza I've found out here. No wonder.... the owner is in New Yorker! The cheese and the crust are perfect and that is no small feat! But it is definitely short on tomato sauce, which is too bad because it would be the perfect blend of the flavors if it had an extra schmear of the tomato sauce underneath the cheese. There is also a mysterious slightly sweet flavor, like sugar... not sure why or where that comes from, but NY Street Pizza lives and dies on its Savory blend of flavors. Please think about a little more tomato sauce and you have recreated that rare majik! Thank you! read more

Yes, the pizza is good here. But I do think the joint is in need of renovation. They have lots of topping options, but I usually order just a place cheese. If you want to picture yourself in a grungy, New York pizza shop, you're in heaven here. Parking is quite difficult. This is a busy location The owners here are unpleasant and ruin the experience. I will not be back. read more

Mediocre pizza. I expected a crisp, thin crust New York pizza. The dough was chewy & undercooked. Also they use sparse & cheap toppings. There was burned paper from the meat on my pizza. Round Table has better pizza. Also they use paper plates & plastic cutlery. What kind of restaurant does not have proper plates & metal cutlery? read more

This place does not honor deals that they post. Our Uber driver tried to advocate for us but they wouldn't budge. He texted me "they should've given you your second pizza, bad customer service". The pizza itself is gross and an insult to NYC pizza. read more

I am a big fan of this pizza place! Pesto cheese pizza made fresh daily. I usually don't like too many toppings on my pizza, and so this one is perfect. The pizza isn't too cheesy or saucy, but the perfect balance. This place takes a little bit longer around 20 minutes for the pizza to come out, but it is well worth it! read more

New York Pizza - Pesto Cheese Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Alameda, California

It's OK. Atmosphere is not your typical warm and welcoming place to hang out. It was quiet with only the ceiling fan occasionally making a thumping sound as it spun. They had very few soda options (almost all of which only available in a 2 liter bottle). We opted for fountain sodas, but the machine looked old and falling apart. None of the soda brands were anything we've ever heard of. After we ordered and paid we never even got our drinks we had to ask for them. It was only then that they told us they had no diet soda. I don't know how you can have no idea that you have no diet soda in a fountain dispenser that is behind your register. So there was zero diet soda in the place unless you wanted a 2 liter. Anyways.... I originally wanted a slice of pizza but they had none ready. Bizarre because that's what they advertise. So we ordered a medium 14" veggie which was about $26. While it was not bad, it was definitely not what I expected for New York style. I wanted that thin, crispy crust. It was more like doughy bread. I wanted extra sauce, if it was there it wasn't evident. But what took away stars for me was the total lack of tomatoes, and overkill on the olives. It was like he ran out of tomatoes and thought he could get away with not cutting more. (See pic for our 2 end pieces of tomato on pizza). And wheres the mushrooms? Overall, just meh, and probably not going to come back. If they ever do have pizza by the slice, I would try that instead. It seems to look more like NY style, large thin slices, than the whole pizzas. read more

New York Pizza - 2 lonely end pieces of tomato on a veggie pizza - Pizza Near Me - Alameda, California

The people who work here are extremely cold and not at all welcoming. I was just stared at upon entering and not greeted until I went out of my way to say hello. When I got my pizza, I was just given it in a box with no invitation to stay and eat it there which I was planning on doing. Even when I started eating there, there was no offer for plates or anything like that. I had to ask. The place also had dirty tables. Definitely go elsewhere. read more

LOVE NYPizza Alameda! The best in delivery and specialty pick-up. Today we stopped by and ate in-house. We love the ownership and food! read more

See all

Delivery order. First time ordering from this place. Decided to give it a try. Ordered a medium mushroom and olive pizza. Crust was very light and cooked perfectly. Pizza was really lacking with the ammushrooms and they were cut so thin couldn't taste them at all. Disappointed in that. All in all the pizza was good but nothing spectacular. Not sure if it's one I will order again or not...but happy I tried it. read more

I remember when they opened but after today I won't be coming back. The owner no longer works in the pizzeria and has hired staff (it's been like this for a while now). The tall skinny man in charge of the cashier and calls is usually kind. But has been quite rude the last few times. Tonight he snatched my money out of my hand when I went to pay. After I gave him the money in his hand, he put the money back down on the counter rather than giving it in my hand. I said "Hey you must be having a pretty bad day. I hope it gets better, but please don't be rude to me. I'd appreciate it if you place the money in my hand." Looking sheepish he proceeded to avoid eye contact and doubled down snatched the signed receipt from my hands and with a smirk he says "Well you didn't give it to me in my hand" like an elementary kid. He had nothing else to say, except lie. I just took my pizza and left. I just won't be spending my money here. It's not worth being treated nasty by wildly unhappy people. read more

We got delivery one night from these guys and it was YUMM !!! Very interesting sauce that had sneaky heat, our pie was perfectly gooey on top with a lilting crunch at the edges, and all the toppings were premium and flavourful I highly recommend their pizza for those nights when pizza is the choice :) read more

Pizza was ready on time ordered 4 large pizzas as soon as they opened I asked them to double slice them it was enough for 40 people needed them for a kids party at 12! Every last slice was gone so that speaks for itself. read more

DELICIOUS Pizza from the sauce to the breading to the toppings. There's an OG and possibly his son who run the shop. The OG was very pleasant. I only ordered a basic sausage & pepperoni over white sauce & the 2nd time was with regular red sauce both were great. The only issue was there was barely any pepperoni but the pizza & service was still good read more

Yo! How 'ya doin! New York Pizza on Park Street is giving The Star on Park a run for its money! As simple, underrated, and inconspicuous as this place is, New York Pizza clearly has the best New York-style pizza in town! Hands down! I would've taken a pic of the pizza that I had, but I just ate it. My two centavos. read more

Great service and food. Delicious and far better than other options locally. I enjoy getting their cheese slices as well as which offer enough food for several people for an affordable price of about 6 to 8 dollars per person. other places locally tend to be very oily and expensive, but this place is a hidden gem read more

This place is on the way home from work, so I come here physically to pick up my pie. Since everything is fresh and delicious expect a wait time, but you're right on park street so there's a ton of different stores and things to do to entertain yourself while your pie cooks. Owner is a great man, wonderful guy to talk to if you can find the time since he's on the line working as hard as his workers, that's when you know the store owner cares about the quality of the food they're giving out. I got a large combo and brought it home on a Friday and was hoping for some leftovers for the weekend too. It didn't even last until Friday night when I got it home. Food was absolutely amazing with fresh and delicious ingredients and masterfully crafted. It might just be me, mainly living in Oakland but I can't find a good and affordable pizza place that delivers to save my life anymore. New York Pizza is absolutely amazing and the fact that I can pick it up before heading home is a huge plus. Parking is street parking but there's usually always a spot available luckily. Although I think it would be best if I order my pizza before getting off work to help with the time. Inside the restaurant it's a pretty small place and has maybe about 4-5 tables? They also serve beer so a good place to head to if you're out partying on Park Street and want some good ass pizza afterwards. Great place, I really need to go here more often. Love to support the owner and also getting good pizza out of it. read more

Loved it & they were so kind and prepared a heart shaped pizza at my daughter's request.

I love pizza . This little pizza place is a neat spot to just sit down and have a few slices. I ordered to go but i would definitely dine in . To drink i got 2 root beers and they were nice and cold . read more

New York Pizza - Small pepperoni pizza - Pizza Near Me - Alameda, California

See all

The pie bits you want - while on West Coast early-close schedule. 9pm done. Get it early or slide in later. All good. Cannot emphasize how close this is to upper West side slices. Even up to 20 minutes before close, they throw down fresh mushroom, or any kind you want, piping hot fresh - not tired reheats, mind you, Serving up the big fully fold-enabled slices in a couple mins. And these guys are family kind all hours. It's your place cuz. Not clear? Hit me. read more

Went here a week ago to grab a few slices of cheese and it was pretty good. Service was quick and the older man running it was nice. Went back today and a different pie guy is chatting away with a buddy completely ignoring me. I ask for a couple slices of cheese and he says they don't have slices. There is literally a giant banner and lettering on the glass saying "Pizza By The Slice". So I ask for a medium cheese and he says it'll take 30 min. THE PLACE WAS EMPTY!! I don't know what his problem was, I guess my cash ain't green enough. Guess I gotta find another NY style local. read more

Better and cheaper than dominoes but still the same low end pizza from 8 years ago when I first tried it. I SPECIFIED "WELL DONE, PLEASE BURN IT." Then came the delivery. Half cooked, doughy, random sandwich cheese and an obviously rushed "pie." Go elsewhere or starve, ITS NOT WORTH IT. They have no quality standards and it shows in the RUSHED pie they deliver. Caveat Emptor, you've been warned. read more

1 star off for slightly rude experience, but then in my mind I created a story to justify this behavior - if this is NY pizza and these guys are from NY, then it's fair game for them to be rude lol. I just popped in for a casual slice of cheese pizza for a snack lol. It was $3.55 + tax = $3.90. At first, I asked for it and I felt like they weren't super customer friendly which is why I mention the slightly rude experience. But actually, later when the guy wrapped up my pizza, he was nice and said "have a nice day" or something to that effect. He wrapped it all up but then I had to reopen it to add red pepper flakes, parmesan, oregano - ya know, the spices! The good stuff! They were just in little glass shakers on the counter. I used them and then used a bottle of hand sanitizer right there, so I appreciated that being there. I walked out of there (of course, no indoor dining at this time), and happily ate the pizza like a classy lady does, whilst walking along the sidewalk! Lol I was so satisfied. It was pretty bomb, hit the spot, and was pretty on point for a New York slice. I recommend the cheese slice on taste! read more

They have the greatest NY style Pizza They have great service which i like it The Place is old but it's Friendly read more

Real Italian pizza made by Italians. And they don't skimp on quality ingredients I can tell. I'm pretty discerning about the food I eat. The pizza is thin crust and not too heavy on the cheese. This is a pizza that you might find in North Beach San Francisco. It's a pizza the way pizza should be made. read more

ABSOLUTELY DELICIOUS!!! Great pizza, thin and fold-able, just like the New York Pizza I remember. I loved the clean atmosphere, this is a new location for this place. They front guy open since "1987" but I have never seen or been in this restaurant, in any different location here in Alameda. Great selection of beverages, including alcohol. I noticed they have the Adolph Coors short stubby bottle beers, the banquet beer. Very unique, and cool. The sauce has a delicious taste, and texture, great ingredients, and great crust. I can always tell a good pizza by how "delicious" it is the next day, and this pizza was awesome, the next day, when my family finished it. I thought pricing was very good, comparable to many other fancy pizza places. I also love the "by the slice" availability, another "staple of New York style pizza joints. I remember places like Blondie's here on the West Coast doing that, and many others, but nothing like a true Pizza joint offering slices. I will likely take them up on it, whenever I head over to the movies, or some other walking activity. I was by myself on this visit, but I can def. see my family returning there in the next 4 weeks or so. RECOMMENDED!!! read more

New York Pizza - 1st time here!!!! - Pizza Near Me - Alameda, California

See all

If I could give them a 0 I would. We waited over an hour for our pizzas and when they arrived, it looked like they were dropped or smashed. When I called to file a complaint I asked for the owner and the owner which was talking on the phone said that he is an employee and he can't do anything. We waited 2 hours for them to bring our new pizzas and they didn't bring it and they wouldn't refund our money so we could order from another place. read more

DO NOT BELIEVE THE 1 stars!! They are the nicest people taking there time to ensure your pizza comes out right every time with LOVE. This place has the BEST PIZZA on the FLIPPING ISLAND, if I'm at home, and it's 10pm, and I see I have time to go get a party size pizza for myself, then ima do it,and yes it. Why you may ask would I get the larger pizza? Because it's ONLY 23$ that's a fricken steal Here in the bay. It may take time to make your pizza but the guys behind the counter really remind you of getting a 2$ slice in NY. Go big tomorrow read more

Ordered through DoorDash, and New York Pizza made our order with the wrong topping, which unfortunately included something we couldn't eat. I notified DoorDash and went with the solution of having the pizza remade to give New York Pizza another chance. When the dasher arrived to pick up the reorder. the restaurant refused to make the order because "it already had been picked up" and cancelled it. I called and the employee on the phone both denied cancelling the order but at the same time kept saying they already made it - despite me telling them they made it wrong and DoorDash sent them an order to remake it. We're 2 hours past the time we ordered with no resolution. It would have been one thing if they admitted the mistake but he just kept arguing. read more

The owner stayed a little longer so we could get some pizza to go. He was very kind and very pleasant to talk to. His restaurant is very comforting as it smells delicious throughout the whole place. The pizza was fantastic. I would highly recommend this place! read more

How can you be out of pizza by the slice 3 hours before closing and yet you advertise you offer pizza by the slice? Ordered wings that were a bit undercooked. Ordered mozzarella sticks that were overcooked. The place was so hot could not sit inside to eat. Cashier was unwelcoming. read more

Great service and yummy pizza! Very friendly staff and was so helpful when my friend lost their phone. Decent prices and fills the pizza craving, and a plus... $2 sodas! Thank you so much read more

It's pretty good. I will try them again. Dough is good, so I'm happy with that (hand tossed). read more

New York Pizza - Small pepperoni - Pizza Near Me - Alameda, California