Every time I have been here, during the short three months I've lived in Bismarck, I have loved everything about Nardellos. And I ain't even had the pizza. The staff is notably good at their job. Consistently. They seem happy to be there, they're joking around with each other, genuinely they provide a fine atmosphere for a local pizza joint. The consistency is solid. I order online every time, every time they get my order right. And every time I order my food is on point. The food itself is about what you could expect from a top local pizza joint. This ain't no highfalutin chicken Parm, but it's a solid sandwich. It'll get you a good meal with enough left for lunch the next day. The meatball subs always on point with meatbulbs that are too big for a single bite. An enjoyable mess every time. The sides are tops. Order a side of cheese fries and it ain't no small bag of fries with a 1 ounce cup. It's a full on side, a full respect appetizer size. Worth every penny plus a little gratuity, because they always do it right. I think I've only had six meals from this joint in the last three months. I'm guessing over the summer months I'll have another six. One of these times I'm gonna have to try their pizza. read more

I've been craving New York style pizza for years, and had no idea this existed! We had a HUGE pizza and it was delicious. The staff was also very friendly. read more

If you like NY style thin crust, this is your place! Really good sauce and cheese too. read more

Nardello's Pizza - Best pizza in ND hands down. - Pizza Near Me - Bismarck, North Dakota

It's fresh pizza and it is fast. Service is good. Not much more to say than that... I guess I am the point in my life where I seek more....

Good pizza, our teen likes it a lot. Four and a half stars, if I could! We have been there a couple times and will go again.

Im from Jersey. Any time I come to Bisamrck...Nardellos is a must! Reminds me of NY style pizza that I ate growing up on Jersey. Cheesesteaks are the real deal. Best pizza and maybe best cheesesteak (toss up with Jersey Mikes) in the whole damn state! read more

Nardello's Pizza - Legit NY style slice - Pizza Near Me - Bismarck, North Dakota

See all

Best pizza in Bismarck by far, never disappointed, always right on. The sandwiches are pretty awesome too.

I tried their Philly steak sandwich. Being a chef in Dallas to come and spend $18 on this was crazy but open mind but it had no flavor what so ever so seasoning on the meat. All I could taste was green peppers. I was thinking in my head I should have went and had a ribeye at Texas Roadhouse for few dollars more. That's sad read more

I ordered a plain 14" with extra cheese to go. it was fantastic and way too much food for one person. I think I knew that going in. The flavor reminded me of my favorite pizza place in Cincinnati, Vic Cassano's. Thin crust with an emphasis on flavor. Nardello's has this in spades. Extra cheese was probably too much, but the silliest thing of all was because it was hot out of the oven, the cheese had a mind of it's own on the drive to the hotel. If you're going to get a pizza to go, bring someone with you that can hold the pizza box steady. Next time I think I'll eat in and I think I'll stick with just ordering pizza by the slice. read more

Nardello's Pizza - Plain 14" pizza w/ extra cheese. Notice the 'cheese swirl' that occurred sitting in the passenger seat on the way home. - Pizza Near Me - Bismarck, North Dakota

Delicious food, we did carry out and called our order in and then headed to pick it up, took us like 10 min to get there and the pizza was done and ready. We got an 18in pepperoni, absolutely the best pizza I've eaten, and I've been to NYC . So much cheese it melted in my mouth. The crust was pretty thin and soggy from the extra sauce we ordered, but it made it more delicious truthfully. Next time we come through Bismarck we are already planning on returning here. read more

The BEST New York Style Pizza in the Mid West!!! I order this Pizza multiple times when in Bismarck, ND! Best kept secret! read more

Nardello's Pizza - Best New York Style Cheese Pizza in Bismarck, ND!!! - Pizza Near Me - Bismarck, North Dakota

I just don't have words. Wanna know how good this place is? Sorry, I can't describe it. Try it yourself. Upset about the wait? What wait? Wait it out, ya impatient North Dakotan! It's that good, seriously. This is New York pizza in little Bismarck. Get some, trust me. Please please please please trust me. This is worth every penny and then some. Speaking of which, time to share some of that ag/oil money on your next tip. I dare ya to try out a 30%er. They deserve it, lol! Thanks Nardello's. You rock for real and roll to steal my heart and tummy. Lol!!! Thanks again. So good. Such good food. Such good service. I'm rocked. read more

See all

Awesome locally owned eatery! Food is tasty and service is top notch! Nardello's is our neighborhood go-to for great pizza!

Great pizza plus fantastic cheese steaks and Italian beef sandwiches. Good prices as well!!!

I can't tell you enough... if you're looking for New York style pizza, Nardello's is THE ONLY place in Bismarck you will find it. They're extensive menu ranges from appetizers, salads, calzones, and pizza. Don't miss their garlic knots, too. They brushed with an amazing blend of roasted garlic and olive oil. I always get their calzone that is stuffed with the best ricotta on the planet. Where do they get it from? I could eat that stuff in my sleep. Grab a slice or a whole pie with an assortment of delicious toppings. Their antipasto salad is heavy on the onions and peppers. Be warned so you may want to consider it when you order. The caprese salad contained fresh tomato slices and fresh mozzarella cheese topped with fresh basil. The only bummer is their closed on Sundays. Nardello's has amped the pizza competition in the marketplace and is my favorite in the area. read more

See all

The owner offered a pizza. I will try it again. I appreciate that there is good ownership. I have done the same thing in my line of work.

We came to this restaurant in Bismarck because it was so highly rated. Maybe I came on an off day because of the holidays, but I wasn't nearly as impressed as other diners. They mixed up our order on a few items. The Philly cheesesteak was HUGE, and you can add any toppings you would like for a fee. It is definitely enough for two meals (or two people). I will also give them props for the gluten free crust, as it's the best I've tried. It was served on a cheap paper plate, however. Two of us ordered it to share, but we should've each ordered our own. The antipasto salad was also very tasty and covered in toppings. It was a nice addition to a pizza. read more

See all

So good! Reminded me of a big slice from NYC. Our whole family loved it! Can't wait to be back in Bismarck and order from here

This place got an extra star because the staff were very nice and there were vegetarian options. And the wait time wasn't too bad either! We started with the caprese salad which was sadly underwhelming. The greens were good once, but they had bits and pieces of other greens that had wilted and turned black and slimy all mixed in...not very appetizing. The tomatoes were flavorless but it's hard to get good ones in ND in April. The mozzarella was good! And I liked that it was served with balsamic and oil. The pizza crust was great. Perfect amount of chewy and crispy. Again, tomatoes were flavorless but it's hard to get good ones here. It needed a bit more basil. Overall a little flavorless and I hate to compare it to Fire Flour but that is Nardellos' competition and frankly it just isn't as good overall. This could be just our experience. I got a cannoli and I've never had one before so I have nothing to compare it to but I liked it! It wasn't too sweet which was nice. And it presented very well. Lastly, my dining companions were very worried when they saw a staff member with a very long beard who was not wearing a "beard-net" but I know that beards don't tend to shed like head hair so I wasn't worried - and there was no hair in our food. Plus he seemed like a pleasant, hard worker :) Overall this place is very good and I hope it keeps going! They have a good menu, it just needs some perfecting. read more

See all

Had this a few years ago and couldn't remember the name so I never reviewed it. This place literally has some the best pizza I've ever had, and I've been to some authentic pizza spots. You won't regret trying this place out! read more

The mark of a good pizza place is a solid slice of cheese. This place has it, and I'm glad I bought a whole friggin' pie, ay-oooo. Staff is really nice, my pickup order was ready early, and they gave me enough crushed red pepper to start a damn pepper farm. read more

Delicious! I have made a special trip to Nardello's each time I travel to Bismarck for business. It was recommended to me from a colleague that stated he would order the Philly Cheesesteak everyday when he was traveling in Bismarck. I'm not a cheesesteak fan, so I tried the meatball sandwich and it was one of the best I've had. As I said, I eat there every time I'm in town, so I've also had their pizza. Very good New York style pizza. Not the best that I've ever had, but right up there! Good enough that I'll make a point to order pizza from there on future visits. read more

Well I've been living in Mandan ND for almost three years and just now tried Nardello's pizza. I was born and raised in New York and it's difficult to find a place in the Dakota's that sells good quality New York style pizza. I have been to two new spots in Bismarck, Cascade's and New York to Go and I have to say Nardello's beats them both on what a New York style pizza should be. Cascade's is good and New York to Go is good but very expensive. But hands down Nardello's beats them both on taste and cost. Great job keep it up. read more

We have eaten here a few times and for the most part our experience has been good. Nardello's pizza is what they are known for. Tonite was the exception. I found the pizza not up to expectations because of the lack of adequate ingredients on the pizza. I ordered a Hawaiian and each piece averaged two or three very small cubes of pineapple and just one thin slice of Canadian bacon per slice. For the money it left me wanting read more

After visiting twice, we were left slightly disappointed. The 1st visit had us enjoying the subs. Flavorful, filling and we'll made, however, the 2nd visit left us waiting an additional 30 mins for our order because the wings were forgotten by the staff. In addition to that, the toppings were wrong. In the end, we simply didn't enjoy the dough or seasonings. For this area, A&B Pizza will have our business. read more

Last night, I ordered a large pepperoni to go. I've lived in Bismarck for more than 20 years, so I understand what I'm about to say is blasphemy. Nardello's might serve the best pizza in Bismarck. Yes, this includes A&B. I guess I'll have to try Nardello's a few more times to find out for sure! ;) read more

My turn, happy to write my review here. I am a former New Yorker of many years, Manhattan and Brooklyn, now in the great plains. When I came to Bismark for my day in town I came here and was thinking: I hope those reviews are right. A happy crowd of people inside, families, kids and all sorts and people coming in and out for their pizzas. Seems like everyone local was in the know. When I got my single slice and garlic knots, well - can I say I got a little nostalgic and choked up? How many times did I eat pizza in the many small shops in the city? same thin, crunchy crust, sauce and cheese. If I closed my eyes, I was back in time. Ok, so maybe others don't have my memories - and it's just a good pizza shop. That's ok, too. I will definitely be back. read more

The pizza is great. But more importantly, the cheesesteaks are fantastic. I have found what I feel is the ultimate cheesesteak - grilled onions, cheese whiz, provolone, siracha and black olives. They have tons of toppings for cheesesteaks. Worth trying! read more

AMAZING!!!!!!!! The pizza, calzone, and service were all Perfect! Haven't been? Then it is a must visit. The service was beyond what you would expect and the food will have you ordering it every "pizza night". read more

Whenever we are in Bismarck, and want a pizza this is the place to go! Very good pizza cooked perfectly, and very friendly staff! Keep telling myself I have to try their sandwich's, maybe next time we are there! The Cheese Fries are a must get here! read more

I will never buy another pizza from this place. I could have got a better pizza at a cheaper price from the frozen section of a grocery store. The dough and sauce was bland, the toppings seemed like cheap knockoff items. I might try the Philly next time I'm in town, saw them making one and it looked good, but then again so did our pizza. Not sure if it would be worth the stop to try it though. We stopped to get connoli and try the pizza, it was stated they make fresh cannoli but they was out of the shells for them. Not a very good first impression! Only reason I get them 3 stars is because the service was good and the pizza came out quickly. read more

Incredible all around. You are instantly greeted with a smile and welcomed. I ordered a sub and it was amazing. The bread the awesome! The place was packed at lunch and now I see why. It is evident they care about the customer and they care about the quality of their food. The restaurant was also very clean and organized. This is not just another pizza place. 5+ stars! read more

Anytime I'm in Bismarck this is a spot I stop in for lunch and/or dinner. Pizza is lights out. I'm a New Yorker and what I'd call a pizza snob. This is as close to authentic as it gets. The hero's are great too. Plus they are making cheesesteaks like I love with whiz. The staff is always friendly and the owners are putting out a great product. They keep it simple and fresh. See ya all in a few weeks again. read more

You generally can't go wrong with family owned businesses and this is no exception. The pizza is amazing and they always have good deals. My four year old loves coming to see the pizzas in the case and picking a slice out out. They are about as big as his head! read more

This is the best pizza I have had in this area. Today, I had the meat lover's calzone and I am completely happy watching football and chowing down on it! read more

NYC style pizza in Bismarck. Awesome concept, pizza by the slice, Strombolis, and garlic knots are a simple take on pizza. Usually have 6-8 pizzas up and you order your slice. Always ate in, great cheap place to eat for lunch. Quick easy and locally owned. Beer special tonight, 2 slices, 2 knots and a beer for 8$. Gave my kids a free desert, kudos sir! read more

Nardello's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Bismarck, North Dakota

By far, the best Pizza in town! Their Philly cheese steak sandwich ! My go to on this sandwich: Green peppers, onions, mushrooms, American and provolone cheese= They staff definitely has customer service --other food services should take a page out of Nardello's playbook. read more

Best pizza in Bismarck (New York Style) hands down. Awesome all-day special gets you two slices, two knots and a small drink for $6. You can upgrade and get a beer for $8. read more

What can really be said about Nardello's that people do not already know? Well, for anyone that is new to Bismarck, I say this is the place to go for a quick bite. Slices are always available, and if your favorite is not out, chances are they are making one fresh. Their philly's are the best as well. Most times they are filled with people, but never that long of a wait at all. Check it out, because no review can really do it justice. read more

This pizza spot was on the recommended list for best pizza in the area while staying at a hotel in the Bismarck area. Unfortunately I wasnt able to drive due to the icy slipper conditions caused by an unbearable blizzard so I had to have a hotel attendant take me there. When I got there and tried their slices, I was so amazed that it was like NY style pizza that I kept stacking up on more slices. It was definitely worth it. If Im in the area again, Ill be sure to swing by here again. read more