Amazing pizza! I ordered a 20" pepperoni to go, and it was one of the best pies I've ever had. The crust was perfect--chewy on the bottom with a super crispy outer edge. Three huge slices just about did me in. This is officially our new favorite pizza in Bismarck. The staff were friendly and helpful. I chatted with a few employees, and everyone was in a great mood--which is especially impressive for a crew working on Independence Day. read more

See all

Authentically delicious. I am selective about the pizza i like and this is fantastic.

Ripped in to this 'Bronx' pizza the minute it was delivered to our hotel room. The pizza was hot, delivered on time as told, and very good. I'm a bit of a pizza snob, only because I was in the business for many years, still love pizza, and make my own. I loved the crispy yet chewy crust, really liked the sauce (just not quite enough for my taste), toppings were enough and very tasty. I would definitely order this again but will ask for more sauce. I give it a 4 1/2. read more

New York To Go - Pizza Near Me - Bismarck, North Dakota

Wings were okay, but the pizza is not New York pizza though it looks like it. The crust was about like cardboard. Won't try again.

Ordered a calzone and was a little skeptical on the price. The calzone was HUGE, didn't even fit on the paper plate. Full of meat and toppings and was piping hot. The crust flavor was significantly better than average. Another review said this place is on par with little ceasers, that is laughable. Seems to be family run, the folks were super kind and friendly, and felt like a classic pizza place. I'll be back! read more

I was amazed to find authentic New York food in North Dakota. I took my friends there and we had a bit of everything. The pizza and hot beef sandwich were outstanding. The tzatziki sauce is so good that I could splash some on before a night out and come home with a date. read more

THIS PLACE IS AMAZING. I do not recommend the pizza BUT I have not had a Gyro and this it the spot. Everything was so fresh and flavorful, it will be extremely hard to go somewhere else to eat in Bismarck. We got a couple to go, and they were still Delicious later. read more

The pizza is great the lamb flavor came through on the pita I will try again yeah yea

Grabbed 2 pepperoni and a soda. Big slices and tasty. Definitely return when I am in town.

This is blatant misuse of the name and an insult to New York pizza. I am from New York and this was just awful. While it actually looks pretty good, there's no depth. The flavors and textures are all wrong. The crust is weirdly crunchy and doughy at the same time. The sauce and cheese are merely passable. Pepperoni had no flavor to speak of. Apparently the folks who own this place believe New York pizza is just how it looks and then toss in tons of grease. If this is the best pizza in Bismarck, I truly feel bad for you all! read more

Definitely a Top 5 Pizza Place in Bismarck. Ordered a pepperoni pizza and it was delicious and warm. Would give it 7/10 (That's pretty good). read more

Best pizza i have had. And my son works there. Real good price for what you get. Love the crust and toppings...

Great local spot for take out that added their spin on New York style pizza. Buy it by the slice or a whole pie. It's locally owned and operated (not a chain) with a variety of pizza that uses delicious, fresh ingredients. My favorite is the Bronx. If you're not up for pizza, try the gyro. A mix of thin sliced, tender lamb and beef with a mouth watering Tzatziki sauce. Yum It hasn't been open long and they seem to be adding new items. Nathan's Hotdogs were the latest I've seen but haven't tried. At first you might think the prices are a bit high when buying a whole pie in comparison to pizza chains but don't let that discourage you. The fresh ingredients with lots of unique toppings makes it one of the best pizza shops in town and worth the price. Go have a slice, you won't regret it. read more

New York to Go is THE best of the best when it comes to pizza in Bismarck. Veteran owned and operated is a huge plus. If im wanting pizza i wont regret eating afterwards i go to them. When it comes to options, adding the hot honey to any slice is a game changer. read more

The best pizza I've had since leaving the east coast!!! Very nice staff and clean restaurant. This is literally the closest to a slice of New York pizza I've had since I've had a slice in New York! 10/10 recommend!!! read more

Excellent customer service with Darrell and KELLEY, they're lucky to have such a great staff. Pizza was perfect with a delicious chewy crust. They did a great job, we definitely come back again. read more

Horrible overpriced pizza. Go to Little Caesar's instead, even their's is better. Gross!

Best pizza in Bismarck! Fast delivery, hot pizza and they offer contactless delivery if you prefer.