Nancy's Pizza is one of my favorite pizza spots in the Chicagoland area. I have heard that some locations are better than others. I've only eaten at the Tinley Park location and they have never disappointed. The thin crust pizza has so much flavor as well as their chicken wings. I've also had it delivered for family parties and everyone enjoys it! read more

We ordered take out from this restaunt for a family gathering. We got a TON of pizza and everyone was so happy with the many options they had! Lots of fun combinations of toppings and the deep dish was a big hit. My biggest complaint would be the pricing. We ordered a lot but it was far more expensive that I would anticiapte for pizza. So just something to consider! read more

I ordered a 10 inch stuffed with sausage and green pepper. The flavor was very good. My slice had way more green pepper than sausage and I would have preferred equal amounts. I think they are pretty expensive compared to some other local pizza places. This pizza was almost $40. I would return, but next time I would try a thin crust. Service was good and the take out area was clean and quiet. read more

Nancy's Pizza - 10" Medium Original Stuffed Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Tinley Park, Illinois

The pizza was very good but the prices are outrageous. I can't see them staying in business much longer at those prices.

This was my favorite pizza. I noticed the last time I was there they changed the pizza sauce. Please change it back. read more

Good pizza at a relatively decent price, but who the hell cuts a pizza like this? Literally bite-sized pieces lol read more

Nancy's Pizza - Photo of bite-sized pizza - Pizza Near Me - Tinley Park, Illinois

See all

This location seems to burn thin crust pizzas . The last 3 times I ordered the top and crust was burnt . When they first reopened even my stuffed pizza was burnt which I got credit for since usually after you wait an hour to eat pizza you don't want to start all over. I am disappointed for repeated ruined dinners. Something is wrong here. read more

I ordered family size and a small BBQ chicken pizza no bacon and they put bacon on it ..had an argument with the manager which he saying it's not there fault ...had to throw away the pizza and 90 dollars down.the drain...never ordering again read more

Very good pizza! The deep dish, the stuffed and the thin crust had them all. And let's not forget the baked rigatoni!

Ordered a thin crust pizza, arrived 20 minutes later than promise time (delivery). We decided to give it a try. The top (cheesy) part was burnt and the crust was so greased up it was totally adhered to the cardboard pizzas are put on to the point of not able to separate, we took one bite and before throwing it into the garbage called the location. Asked to speak to the manager on duty and the phone person asked what was the issue. I explained and she said that's how we cook our pizzas normally dark, i asked burnt? she said she would speak to MOD and put me on hold.....returned after a quite a bit of time and said the MOD said he would give 15$ credit (paid aprrox $40). I would think I should be entitled to refund and she disagreed. I said i would reach out via email to customer service.....its been a week or so and no response from customer service. I will not and advise not to order from Nancys pizza.. read more

Amazing! I got the RUSTIC cut, because I like it thicker but I have had the classic and it's also great. Was fast fresh and awesome. So happy I found a go to pizza place !! read more

Nancy's Pizza - a pizza in a box - Pizza Near Me - Tinley Park, Illinois

After being referred to Nancy's by my dad's friend I finally tried this pizza for the first time and I wish I had tried sooner, it's one of the BEST I've ever had in my life. Addicted already!!! Friendly staff also. read more

Nancy's Pizza - Small Sausage (thin) - Pizza Near Me - Tinley Park, Illinois

I ordered the spaghetti and meatballs and the meatball sub last night. It was very disappointing, the meatballs in the pasta and the sandwich were overcooked and burnt. Plus there fries were old and there was barely enough meat sauce in the pasta. That was the first time trying this restaurant and the last. read more

Lots of cheese and sausage. Too much bread on the deep dish .Will try the thin next time.

It's been yearsssss since I've ordered Nancy's, and honestly it'll probably be another few years if I order from them again. The pizza is just very average - there are definitely other Chicago style pizza places nearby that are way better. I ordered the roccos party original stuffed pizza. It honestly just felt like I ordered a cheese pizza - there was barely any meat or veggies in it. Also, their pizzas here are quite small. I ordered a medium & it came out more as a small. For the size, the pizzas in my opinion are a little bit on the pricey side. We ordered the Parmesan pesto fries too, and those were just average as well. I liked that the fries weren't completely drenched in sauce tho. read more

We used to order from the old owners in Tinley of Nancy Pizza. This is the 2nd and last time I will order from this New Nancy's. Pizza was both times as close to being burnt that is humanly possible! Plus $42 for a 16" pizza is insane! Wish the quality would have been worth it!! read more

Great pizza but you need to take a loan out to get one. Also their large stuffed is a 12 inch while most places are 14 inches.

Good pizza. We tried Nancy's because we had coupons...we usually don't end up at that end of town because it is a bit of a drive. In the end, it was worth the drive. We had the deep dish and it was lush. Lot's of cheese and the tomato sauce had a nice tang. Filled with sausage and pepperoni, we had no complaints with the meat fixings, although there could have been more of the mushrooms. Nancy's is strictly a take-out place, as there really isn't much seating to eat your pizza there. A couple of stools in the window is all you'll find. The bottom on our takeout deep dish was a bit soggy when we got home, but I think that is just a problem with carryout...the pizza was still very good. All around good pizza...we will go back. read more

Great customer service ! First time ordering and my husband and I fell in love with the rustic crust! The Deep dish was good but there wasn't any pepperoni on it we called to inform them of our concern and their manager was amazing ! Very friendly and you could tell he really cares about his customers, he insisted on making us a new one and the new one was GORGEOUS! I even took pics of how amazed I was with the night and day difference definitely will become a nancys regular ! The delivery guy was also such a nice guy ! read more

Nancy's Pizza - a deep dish pizza - Pizza Near Me - Tinley Park, Illinois

Driving through Chicago and had to try a deep dish pizza. This Did not disappoint. Pleasantly surprised at how tasty it was. We will be back next time we visit the area. read more

Nancy's Pizza - Steamy and delicious! - Pizza Near Me - Tinley Park, Illinois

My favorite pizza ever! I am very picky about pizza and this is my absolute favorite place. They are very generous with the toppings, have a very nice sauce that isn't sweet or too salty, and the crust is always perfect. read more

I don't know if this place replaced every friendly employee with bots, but the staff and service has taken a total 180. The pizza is still good, hence the three stars. We're shopping around for a regular pizza place. Hopefully, we won't get any blonde hair in our pizza and practically be told that we're lying, even AFTER said hair was shown. The only blonde in our family was our dog, and he's gone. Get it together! read more

Excelled stuffed pizza spinach and mushroom. Nicely complemented with Caesar salad. Delivered on time and hot at least for the pizza.

Lately the hubs and I have been trying new pizzas in our area. We received a coupon for Nancys and decided to try it. And we were NOT disappointed! The pizza was amazing! I called and made our order and the person who answered the phone was friendly and super helpful as this was our first time ordering. I said we also wanted garlic bread. She suggested the cheesy garlic bread with the tomato on top. It was AMAZING!! I wanted more! We also ordered a large pizza. Half veggie for me and half sausage for the hubs. The crust was crispy and thin, which we love. There were a ton of ingredients. All delicious. We ordered for delivery. They quoted an hour and made it in 45 minutes. The delivery man was nice and polite. I can't wait to order Nancy's again soon. You won't be disappointed. read more

I thought I would have some type of Ephiny based on the previous reviews. Needless to say, I am extremely disappointed and I feel like I was cheated of what should have been a great meal. The pizza was subpar --nothing was spectacular about it. The wings were oversized and rubbery to eat. I've wasted a significant amount of money trying this pizza for the first time. I really wish I could get a refund! read more

Super nice staff. Pizza is excellent and affordable. No complaints whatsoever. Delivery is pretty accurate and so is pick up time

Poorly run place. No management. Shouldn't take an hour and a half for a pickup when the place isn't even busy. Last pizza was pretty bad but we decided to give them another try since we used to like them, but when we got there to pick up our pie an hour after ordering it, it looked like they hadn't even started it. You could see they weren't all that busy in the kitchen. If you can't properly run the place, shut it down. We won't be wasting our time here again. read more

Perfect pizza. Extremely expensive. Still worth it. If you have an extra $50 and want good pizza? Look no further; you want to come here. Also they are perfect with allergies! We have never had a reaction but if your dairy free make sure you tell them so they make it specifically since there is dairy I believe they said the crust or sauce if you don't specify. Whenever we have company in town this is what we always order. Just go here, it's worth it read more

New to the state and been trying to find a good pizza places and Nancy's is the first great place we found. Their original crust Lots of meat is awesome. And their 2 1/2 in. Stuff crust pizza is delicious, not too hearty the crust is fluffy and light. Their large salads come in a bread bowl and is really good to munch on along with the salad. read more

They claim to have created Chicago deep dish pizza so I had to give it a try. The brochure in my hotel room said their 2-1/2" deep dish was unique and everybody else simply copied their 1-1/2" pie. Turns out the 2-1/2" basically had more bread, as opposed to toppings. Definitely good pizza but Aurelio's and Geno's East still has them beat. read more

I ordered an original crust pizza with roasted garlic and basil for takeout. The pizza was done on time and delicious as usual! Nancys is a childhood favorite of mine and I would definitely return! read more

Nancy's Pizza - Roasted garlic and basil pizza - Pizza Near Me - Tinley Park, Illinois

AMAZING Stuffed Pizza. They have coupons that make the pizza a really great deal. I got a large 2.5" thick stuffed pizza with 3 toppings for $23 out the door. Really clean flavors. Nice and hot. Great service all around. read more

I've been ordering from Nancy's since 2013.I use to order from the lemont location, this is my third time from Tinley. Food comes within an hour. I've had the bbq pizza, italian beef, and peperoni pizza. All the pizzas i have ordered are thin crust. I have no complaints at all!!!! Great food! read more

Best Chicago style pizza in the area! We've had the stuffed, deep dish and thin crust; all fabulous!

Ordered only twice from them .....1st messed up the order, 2nd lost the order when I went to pick up.no more done with them.also both times never offered to compensate,good luck to anyone ordering I'm done.To bad I had to give them 1 star they don't deserve even one. read more

One of my three favorites in the area. Never had a bad pizza ever!!! They always have coupons and deals that help offset a Friday Night dinner for 5 - saved over $8 bucks on two great thin crust pies. Keep up the great work Nancy's read more

Nancy's is known primarily for pizza, not sandwiches. If you want a beef sandwich, go to Al's Beef which has the best beef sandwich. Nancy has the best stuffed pizza, especially the Rocco's Party Pizza which has sausage, green peppers, mushrooms, and onions. read more

I ordered the deep dish pizza. The pizza was done on time and absolutely delicious!

HORRIBLE! They screwed up my pizza 2 weeks ago, the girl on the phone told me I would receive a $10.00 credit on my next order. I call in to place my order and they tell me I only get $5.00 for getting a pizza that stuck to their crappy tin foil which made it almost inedible. The pizza was an x-large and cost me $17.00. The owner/manager then tells the girl after my arguing that it was for $10.00 says they won't deliver to me as I am out of the area now - hahaha - I am 5 minutes from them. This is how you want to run a business Nancy's in Tinley? Nancy's has different owners so I won't punish other locations just the ones that these cheap, ignorant lying owners run. Go to Beggars Pizza if you want to be treated right and get the best pie in town. 0 stars if I could. Losers. read more

Not the cheapest, but the thick stuffed pizza is seriously amazing (great crust, great sauce, tons of cheese...) and once you order from them once, they tend to supply good coupons on a regular basis. read more