Nancy's Pizza O'Fallon

293

8 years ago

Was a little hesitant to try because every other "Chicago" style pizza offerings in this area have not even come close to we know as "True" Chicago pizza. We finally tried it, had a Greek Salad to with the Garlic dressing. It was great. Pizza was really good. Very very close to what we know and love. The only real issue I had was that the sausage was not spicy enough nor was there enough of it. We are used to a solid patty of meat so there is some in every bite. However, we still enjoyed it and will keep going back. read more

Helpful 1

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Lisa K.

3 years ago

Good pizza, but it's impossible sometimes to get them to pick up the phone to take a to-go order. My husband and I both have been trying to get them on the phone for 15 minutes straight and the phone just rings and rings. read more

Helpful 2

Thanks 0

Love this 1

Oh no 0

Eric G.

7 years ago

Nancy's Disappoints....Again! We ordered two large deep dish pies. We were told 45 minutes. Knowing that they typically run late, we waited 55 minutes. When we arrived they could not find our order; they had the ticket, but had not made the pizza. If this had been the first time I could understand. But no, this was our third time we have had this same issue (apparently I am a slow learner). If you are lucky enough to actually get your order its usually pretty good, that does assume you get the right order. Check your oder throughly before you leave the store. If you are going to order I wish you "good luck!" read more

Helpful 5

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Bridget W.

186

7 years ago

Tried a new place tonight for dinner and it was a total win!! If you're looking for a different type of pizza that's delicious, try Nancy's pizza in O'Fallon! We had the stuffed deep dish pizza with pepperoni. Which was so delicious!! We also got wings but we weren't a fan of them. We ordered buffalo but either we got a different kind or their buffalo doesn't taste like buffalo but rather a light sauce with pepper. read more

See all

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Steve G.

4 years ago

Much better than my first visit. The deep dish is not Chicago quality but really good for St Louis. I will return! Good deep dish when you can't get the real stuff. read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Bill S.

Elite 24

1684

860

9415

9 years ago

If you grew up in St. Louis area, you might think not much good comes out of Chicago.Let's start with the Cubs! Ha! Yes, our cities have a long fun and good spirited rivalry. One positive culinary delight out of the Windy City is deep dish pizza. The aroma inside a Chicago pizzeria creates a distinct, mouthwatering, crave. Stepping inside Nancy's carry out only location on Highway K, reminded me instantly of that scent. Yes this is very similar to a traditional deep dish you would wait in line an hour for in Charge. Tasty pizza! Try it, you'll like it....but GO CARDS! read more

Nancy's Pizza O'Fallon - Veggie Deep Pan - Pizza Near Me - O'fallon, Missouri

See all

Helpful 1

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Sarah E.

4 years ago

Pizza was amazing! It tastes authentic like what we are used to getting in Chicago. We'll be back!

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Ann S.

9 years ago

This just might be the BEST pizza I've ever had! We ordered the Chicago style with sausage. I picked up the pizza and was utterly amazed at how heavy it was. So, so good! So much gooey, flavorful cheese and toppings. Yum! I literally can't wait to order again. An added bonus...they offer gluten free crust (not for the Chicago style). read more

Nancy's Pizza O'Fallon - Passed the cheese test with flying colors. - Pizza Near Me - O'fallon, Missouri

Helpful 1

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Diane G.

4 years ago

Excellent pizza. We ordered both deep dish and thin crust. Quality ingredients! Dough is spot on.

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Jaclyn B.

Elite 19

120

191

7 years ago

We've had Chicago style pizza several times... Giordano's has always been our fav! After spending 2 weeks in Chicago this week for work I got the chance to have Giordano's, D'Agostinos, Lou Malnatti's... I came home today and was craving... more pizza. The man partner wanted pizza tonight for dinner. We were informed of this place months ago by a friend of ours who ran Francesco's in St. Peter's. (RIP Greg, you're missed!). I'm happy to report that Nancy's definitely lived up to the hype! We'll be back read more

Helpful 1

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Michelle L.

249

2579

5452

9 years ago

Is deep dish Chicago pizza my very favorite? No, but I'll certainly order it and enjoy it from time to time. I was out in O'Fallon for some errands and I called in and ordered a small deep dish stuffed crust pepperoni. They said it would be ready in 30 minutes. Deep dish takes a long time to cook! I pulled in exactly 30 minutes after my order and the pizza was ready and I was on my way. Tallest pizza box ever! So if you're not familiar with Chicago pizza it goes crust, pizza topping, cheese, and chunky tomato sauce on the top. This was pretty good. My only complaint was not much pepperoni. Did I feel like I was sitting on Wabash Ave people watching with my deep dish? No. For St. Louis though I think this was almost as good as it gets. I love love love thin St. Louis pizza with provel cheese but you know what? This was a nice trip outside my (pizza) box and I'd absolutely visit again. read more

Nancy's Pizza O'Fallon - Small Pepperoni - Pizza Near Me - O'fallon, Missouri

Nancy's Pizza O'Fallon - Tallest Pizza Box - Pizza Near Me - O'fallon, Missouri

See all

Helpful 1

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Melinda P.

286

441

7 years ago

Greek salad was good. Stuffed deep dish & rustic crust Italians were ok. Plenty of toppings.

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Chris L.

Elite 24

197

128

5 years ago

Finding authentic Chicago Style "Pizza" in St Louis is a great find and Nancy's fits the bill. 2-21/2 inches thick sauce on top, two layers of crust and cheese underneath, it was what I was looking for. I had the A lot of Meat, and it was. Loaded with canadian bacon, italian sausage, pepperoni, and bacon. This was one heavy pie. Admittedly I remain a Nee York Slice kind of guy, and it's hard to compare Chicago style vs New York, but if your in the mood for a Chicago Pie - give Nancy's a try. Definitely where I'll go next time I'm craving it! read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Allison B.

Elite 22

268

111

5 years ago

Pizza was good, but a little pricey. Staff up front had mask on and there was plexiglass by the register.

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Bree J.

4 years ago

Some of the staff was outside smoking cigarettes when I pulled up. They walked in with me and immediately began preparing food without washing their hands. I cancelled my order after explaining to one of the employees (who was outside smoking) that I witnessed them not washing their hands after they came in. He just looked at me with a blank stare and nonchalantly said, "Ok." That was my family's first time attempting to eat here...I can't say that we will be back any time soon. read more

Helpful 3

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Michael S.

6 years ago

Amazing Pie! Some of the best pizza I've had in O'Fallon or surrounding area. Ordered one pizza on delivery, was here within 30 minutes, fresh and delicious. I couldn't eat more than half by myself, and I only got the 9". read more

Nancy's Pizza O'Fallon - All meat 9 inch Deep dish - Pizza Near Me - O'fallon, Missouri

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Pamela S.

3 years ago

Got the Chicago style. Lots of sauce. Plain sauce. It needed some seasoning. Crust tastes like flour and water.

Helpful 1

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Teri M.

8 years ago

Nancy's Pizza is very good. Based on other reviews, we decided to try it. It did not disappoint. From the order placement over the phone to the delivery person, everyone was a delight to work with. The food was delicious and I'm pretty sure it's one of the best Chicago style deep dish pizza you can get in the St. Louis area. A medium deep dish pizza definitely feeds up to four people. There is a lot of cheese and sauce and is enjoyably filling. We will return! read more

Business owner information

David H.

Thanks for the review, we appreciate the feedback on the service. We…

Helpful 2

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Paula B.

154

6 years ago

Tried to order online unsuccessfully. Received message that I had to phone. Was told 1 hour until pickup. Agreed and adjusted our schedule accordingly. Ordered half of stuffed pizza with spinach and artichoke (advertised on their website). I was told, "We don't have artichokes. " Instead ordered entire pizza pepperoni and mushrooms. Picked up at exact time told. Pizza already done and sitting in warmer (emphasis on WARM). Had to microwave before we could eat. Lots of cheese and pepperoni but only a few minuscule pieces of canned mushroom stems. The 4 of us only ate half and our friends asked us to take it with us or they would throw away. I miss Chicago style pizza and the flavor was good but the rest of my party will never return there. I probably wouldn't go alone. read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Jacquelyn T.

232

159

8 years ago

I love Chicago style Pizza! My favorite pizza place doesn't have any locations outside of Illinois, so I thought we would give Nancys a try. We got the "Uncle Tony". The pizza was good. Not great, but good. But you CANNOT dine in, you must take it to go. And on the 20 minute drive back, it lost some appeal. read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

PJ J.

193

5 years ago

The best pizza in The Ofallon Area, this is what real pizza is ! None of that fake cheese crap like most around here have , this is true mozzarella, not to mention the deep dish weighs around 7-8 lbs ! read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Angie V.

6 years ago

We ordered delivery so you should know that they will provide you with a delivery time. I ordered ours at 5:30 pm and our delivery time was 7:30. We LOVED our pizza and salad. We got the Chicago style deep dish with sausage and pepperoni. My husband thought it was a bit too saucy on top, but I thought it was perfect. We will definitely order again! read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Kelly M.

Elite 20

274

158

110

9 years ago

Definitely a solid meal. A medium deep dish could feed 4-5 people easy. We got the Lots of Meats. We didn't really dig the ham, but my 3 year old loved it so win win. Fettuccine Alfredo was also pretty darn good. We will be regulars! read more

Helpful 3

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Veronica G.

6 years ago

We just ordered an extra large meat pizza , wings and salad . Pizza was the best I've had in 18 yrs living in OFallon. Salad was huge and fresh . My son loved the wings. Thanks for a wonderful meal during uneasy times. read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Mike Q.

6 years ago

Love the pizza....but the customer service is bad. I have NEVER had a pizza ready on time. Most recently order online 1 1/2 hours ahead of time to be ready at 5:30...wasn't done until 5:45. read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Dan S.

177

6 years ago

Probably the worst deep dish I've ever tried. Undercooked crust thst was soggy, veggies didnt seem all that fresh and they forgot one of the toppings. Top it off with a 90 minute pickup time , an inept employee that had to ask me 3 times if I paid for it (purchased online) leads to a solid 2 star review. Guess I'm gonna have to wait till I'm in Chi town for a proper pie. read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Pete B.

112

9 years ago

Called. No answer. Tried back. No answer. 3rd time, guy answers in a rushed manner. I placed my order. A 10" stuffed pepperoni. Doesn't get simpler than that. Go pick it up- cashier was friendly. Take it home , 3 bites in , realize their is sausage on my pizza. Look at the receipt, sausage. Not pepperoni . Fine. I'll eat it. But why is the crust, bottom and edge , so damn chewy and rubbery? Sauce is ok, Very sweet. Just very disappointed. 20 bucks for medium , wrong ordered, rubbery crust pizza. I guess I'll stick with places actually in Chicago for my pizza fix. read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Jessica M.

158

8 years ago

Nancy's Pizza is the perfect pizza place! First of all, when they began to open for lunch on Fridays, they came into my work & dropped off menus and coupons. I have been ordering almost every Friday since then. They alway deliver to my office & they are quick and the food is AMAZING! I am obsessed with deep dish pizza, I am used to Burt's Pizza (featured on the food network) in Illinois but Nancy's Pizza hits the spot! They have amazing bread sticks too! I highly recommend ordering here verses any other pizza delivery place. Plus all of their employees are super nice whenever they come in with the delivery. They have the best pizza & other food as well as the best customer service! Highly recommend this place! read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Amanda B.

8 years ago

Grabbed a pizza and pasta to go for dinner. My husband is such a fan of deep dish and this did not disappoint. We thought it was an eat in place but it's just carry out and delivery. Pretty nice having Chicago style pizza out this way though. read more

Nancy's Pizza O'Fallon - Pepperoni Deep Dish! - Pizza Near Me - O'fallon, Missouri

Business owner information

David H.

We are thrilled that your husband is a fan of our deep dish pizza.We…

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Erin F.

6 years ago

I ordered online for pick up. The process was quick and easy although the wait time was about an hour and a half. But I cannot even describe how worth it it was. The service was fantastic and the food was phenomenal! They were very clean and following all safety precautions. The gentleman working was very nice and personable he didn't even want to accept a tip. But good service and food should not go unappreciated! If I could afford it I would definitely go there a lot more! :) read more

Nancy's Pizza O'Fallon - Tuscan rigatoni - Pizza Near Me - O'fallon, Missouri

Nancy's Pizza O'Fallon - Uncle Tony's Stuffed Deep Dish Cheese Pizza - Pizza Near Me - O'fallon, Missouri

See all

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Brad H.

6 years ago

I am a frequent visitor of Nancy's. I really like their deep dish pizza, which is tough to find in St Louis. However, I actually like the leftover reheated pizza more, as the crust is crisper than when it is first cooked. The pizza is a bit pricey, but when you consider multiple meals you can have from leftovers, it isn't that bad. read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Michael H.

Elite 21

136

7 years ago

I was trying to save my dear friends in O'Fallon from eating nasty chain pizza, and I stumbled upon Nancy's. Let me start by saying I consider myself somewhat of a deep dish snob, and all deep dish is NOT created equal. Having said that, Nancy's is PHENOMENAL. I have always held Giordano's as the gold standard for deep dish, and Louie's on Hampton was previously the only halfway decent Chicago-style I could find in the STL area. That has changed, my friends. Nancy's is possibly the best deep dish I've ever had. If you find yourself in this area, don't miss an opportunity to grab a pie. You will be so, so, so happy you did. read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Timothy H.

Don’t See Your Question? Ask Away!

195

283

9 years ago

Love this place. Pricey but if you think about it, no more than taking the family out to eat. A great change from the usual chains. I really hope they stay open. Great Pizza. read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 1

Oh no 0

Back

Page 2 of 4

2007 State Hwy K
O'fallon, MO 63366
Directions
(636) 272-2223
Call Now
Order Takeout or Delivery
Start Order
Visit Website
http://www.nancyspizza.com

Full menu

Hours

What time does Nancy's Pizza O'Fallon open?

Nancy's Pizza O'Fallon opens at 4:00 PM on Monday, Tuesday, Wednesday and Thursday.Nancy's Pizza O'Fallon opens at 11:00 AM on Friday, Saturday and Sunday.

What time does Nancy's Pizza O'Fallon close?

Nancy's Pizza O'Fallon closes at 9:00 PM on Monday, Tuesday, Wednesday, Thursday, Friday, Saturday and Sunday.

Mon-Thu 4:00 PM - 9:00 PMFri-Sun 11:00 AM - 9:00 PM

Payment methods

Does Nancy's Pizza O'Fallon take credit cards?

Yes, Nancy's Pizza O'Fallon takes credit cards.

Food & Alcohol

Does Nancy's Pizza O'Fallon have catering options?

Yes, Nancy's Pizza O'Fallon does have catering options.

Does Nancy's Pizza O'Fallon serve alcohol?

No, Nancy's Pizza O'Fallon does not serve alcohol.

Indoor Amenities

Does Nancy's Pizza O'Fallon allow dogs?

Yes, Nancy's Pizza O'Fallon allows dogs.

Does Nancy's Pizza O'Fallon have TVs?

Yes, Nancy's Pizza O'Fallon has TVs.

Outdoor Amenities

Does Nancy's Pizza O'Fallon have outdoor seating?

No, Nancy's Pizza O'Fallon does not have outdoor seating options.

Does Nancy's Pizza O'Fallon have parking?

Yes, Nancy's Pizza O'Fallon has parking options. Validated Parking

Other Amenities

Does Nancy's Pizza O'Fallon have free WiFi?

No, Nancy's Pizza O'Fallon does not have free WiFi.

From the Business

Specialties

Nancy's Pizza in O'Fallon, MO is the home of the Original Stuffed Pizza, a Chicago staple invented by our founders in 1971. We continue the tradition of serving our famous 2 1/2-inch thick stuffed pizzas, alongside award-winning tavern-style thin crust, rustic crust, and gluten-free options. Our menu features authentic Italian-American favorites including pastas like Fettuccine Alfredo, hearty sandwiches like the signature Godfather, fresh salads, and jumbo wings. We specialize in fast pizza delivery to O'Fallon, St. Peters, Wentzville, and Cottleville, as well as convenient carryout and professional catering for local events, parties, and corporate meetings. Join Nancy's Rewards to earn points on every order. Taste the history of the pizza that started it all!

More Info

Health Score

Ask the Community - Nancy's Pizza O'Fallon

East Coast Pizza

2.1(16 reviews)

4.5 mi

Asked for a slice of sausage and was brought pepperoni, could've moved past that if it was warm but…read morethe pizza was cold. Spaghetti tasted odd, wings were half sauced. Soft drink was flat. Ranch is still top notch. Just drive the extra 10 min and go to the Chesterfield location.

Ordering in the restaurant was ok, except I was greeted with "it's too late in the day for any…read moreslices except pepperoni and cheese" and it was about 5pm. The pizza was good. The garlic knots could have been good, except they were hard as bricks. Not cold. Warm and hard. Too long in the oven or warmed. The toasted ravioli were the same way. So much for ordering it fresh to take home instead of having it delivered. We had it at work, in Chesterfield, and the food difference between the two locations is drastic. Not sure I will try this one again.

See all

Liliana's Cottleville

4.0(190 reviews)

3.8 mi

food! amazing fucking amazing…read more service - great ambiance - just fine but go for the food - so good

My daughter and I had dinner there last night and something has changed. We have dined here before…read moreand enjoyed our meals. Last night was different. We ordered the cannellini bites and they were good. But then we ordered the chicken spedini, which is one of my favorite Italian entrees. It tasted like the chicken was made from frozen already cooked breaded chicken(like a bad chicken nugget), the pasta was bland and there were only 2 asparagus spears. We also ordered the Timmy's pizza(meatball pizza) it was also very bland, unfortunately I ordered the larger size for the leftovers not knowing how bad it was going to be. I read through some of the other reviews before I decided to write one and it seems I'm not the only one that has noticed a change in the food quality and taste. I will not be back and I will stop recommending this restaurant. So sad.

Interior' Decor

Large meat lovers pizza w/hamburger, crispy bacon, sausage, and pepperoni.

See all

XL Meat Lovers Pizza Pepperoni, crispy bacon, and sausage with a mozzarella/provel blend

Stefanina's Pizzeria

3.8(210 reviews)

1.3 mi

Stefanina's in O'Fallon is easily one of the best pizza spots around. Their pizza has that perfect…read morebalance--crispy, flavorful crust, generous toppings, and cheese that melts beautifully without being overly heavy. Every bite tastes fresh and made with care, and it's the kind of pizza you crave again the moment you finish it. The rest of the menu is great too, but for us the pizza is truly the star. Whether you dine in or take it to go, the quality is consistently excellent. The staff is always friendly, quick, and welcoming, which makes the whole experience even better. If you're in the O'Fallon area and want some of the best pizza you'll find locally, Stefanina's should be at the top of your list. Highly recommend! Oh....and don't forget - on Tuesday's- you can get a large pizza for the price of a small! What a deal!

Always awesome service, food and staff. Never disappointed…read morewith any choice on the menu. Support our local restaurants. This one has been here since 1981.

Italian Sausage and Canadian Bacon Pizza

See all

Pirrone's Pizzeria

3.4(175 reviews)

2.7 mi•St Peters

My absolute favorite STL style pizza. The sausage is impeccable and the carry out deal is perfect !read more

One of my favorite pizza spots in the St. Louis area, as a person who loves full meat, lovers…read morepizza, Pirrone's pizza is an excellent place for lunch or dinner, we ordered a pepperoni pizza and the Jerry's special, both came out hot and with full flavor, the service was friendly and our waitress gave my friends a good rundown of the menu as it was their first time. We also ordered toasted ravioli as an appetizer, and it was excellent as always.

Bacon Pizza

See all

Noto

4.5(343 reviews)

4.7 mi

•$$$

Excellent cocktails! Perfect Neapolitan pizza!…read moreInteresting house made pasta offerings. Great desserts. All with perfect service! The small but mighty dinning room is nicely appointed. If you like "the Hill" you will hate Noto. Noto is more in line with real Italian- Italian food in this St Charles county outpost.

I thought I left a review the first time I tried this place early last year or late 2024 but I…read moreguess I didn't. I have since been back at least four times. The first time was a great impression. My fiancé at the time ordered a margarita pizza which was delicious. I ordered a garganelli pasta with some sort of red sauce and beef. It left a lasting impression that made us want to come back for more! The impression was so lasting that I made a reservation for my bachelorette dinner to be here but the pizza I ordered fell very short. I think I ate once slice and left everyone else eat it. We got about 3 different other pizzas and they were just okay. The arancini was good and the blue crab pasta was really good and I was like okay I'll order that next time. It was also to celebrate my birthday and they brought out this dessert and the clove flavoring was so bold I spit it out. It was actually not good at all. I felt bad because they gave it to me for free so I just said I was way too full to finish. (First two visits food pics were on my previous phone so I do not have those any longer!) The third visit, I ordered the blue crab pasta and for the price there was barely anything in the bowl for one, but there were also these small chunks of lemon in it and I could not see it so I bit into it with the peel and it was so sour that it just ruined it for me. Ordered the arancini again but there wasn't enough sauce. The burrata was good though. I feel like I can't catch a break lol The last time I went (last night) we rock paper scissored between the shrimp toast and burrata. Shrimp toast won and I had really great shrimp toast from Indo so this fell flat and then I ordered the garganelli with kale and sunflower seeds and it really wasn't anything great and I've come to realize that this place is overrated and I really think it's psychological because there only open certain days of the week and they're so booked out so it MUST be fantastic, but it's just.. good. That's probably the last time I'll go. I feel a lot better spending my money at Katie's. It's more of a 2.5 star rating but I can't do halves and 2 seems like I hated the place but I didn't. It just really fell short the last 3 visits when other places are just so consistent with quality, Noto has been consistent with disappointment. Hot take, I know from other reviews, so take what you will. Other notes * it's pretty loud so prepare to speak up * very small waiting area - more like an aisle really and an outdoor four person space deck with a door leading to a ramp * even if you make a reservation, the exact time isn't guaranteed until the party before you leaves and they don't rush customers (good if you're the one dining, not so good if you're waiting -- had to wait the night of my bachelorette * no tiramisu a tragedy really * dim lighting so very romantic / love the aesthetic * though it's listed as classy, I've seen men wearing cargo shorts, people wear sweats... disrespectful in my opinion but no strict dress code

1000 degree pizza oven

Arancini

See all

Gemelli alla gricia

Woodgrain Pizzeria

3.8(19 reviews)

0.3 mi

MOD Pizza is my favorite "fast-food" pizza restaurant and I wasn't close to one so I thought I…read morewould give Woodgrain a try. I arrived at 7pm on a Sunday evening and there was no one sitting on the pizza side; there were two tables with people on the Oberweis side. The restaurant was clean, but it should be since it was not busy at all. I stared at the menu and was disappointed. This place charges for every topping that you want on your pizza. I was used to MOD where I could build my own pizza with unlimited toppings and the price doesn't increase. I wasn't about to pay over $20 for a pizza so I just ordered a one topping, pepperoni pizza. $10.24 with tax. ($7.49 and then $2 extra for each meat topping) The temperature of the pizza was great. Hot, but it should be since it was "made to order". The crust was subpar. It lacked crispness and was very doughy. The sauce was probably the best ingredient on the pizza. The cheese was plentiful and the pepperoni lacked flavor. I am a pizza connoisseur and this is one I will not be eating again. I give it a 3/10 (5/10 if there was unlimited toppings).

Love that they have gluten and dairy free options. Food was good. Super hot inside during summer.read more

Underside of flimsy crust

See all

Expensive menu board.

Pantera's Pizza O'Fallon

4.2(200 reviews)

1.3 mi

Locally owned & operated

Established in 1981

We essentially drive 45 minutes to enjoy this delicious & classic pizza place!…read more Even though there are just two of us, we get a large sized "The HUNK" and savor the leftovers for lunch and dinners the next days following our trip! Just yummy!

I went with my boyfriend for the all-you-can-eat lunch buffet---you definitely won't be leaving…read morehungry. I wanted to shamelessly gorge and this very casual neighborhood pizza spot fit the bill! For less than $10, you have access to a plethora of pizza, salad, and soda (from 11:30-1 on weekdays). The staff was extremely efficient in keeping everything full and clean. I started at the salad bar, which offered most basic salad toppings, including different veggies, hard boiled egg, etc., as well as several dressing options, and even cottage cheese. They give you a glove to use when using the salad bar, which I appreciated. Moving onto pizza--I loved it! It was a thicker doughy consistency, with some crunch at the crust. There were lots of different options for toppings, which changed throughout the hour we were there. There's even dessert pizza--albeit a little on the sweet side, I'm sure lots of people are fans. Overall an excellent value for lunch--be prepared for a post-meal nap if you can swing it.

Combo Platter

See all

The Cowboy Luau BBQ Sauce Base | Chicken | Bacon | Mozzarella & Cheddar Cheese | PIneapple

Monical's Pizza

3.2(137 reviews)

0.9 mi

We came here for the Pizza Passport and honestly left a little disappointed. The pizza was decent,…read morebut it needed more sauce. It was just okay. Our waitress was super nice, but the manager was kind of rude when we pulled out the Pizza Passport, which made things a little awkward. Because of that, we probably wouldn't come back again.

We had heard good things about Monical's, so we headed out to O'Fallon to try it out. From the time…read morewe walked in, we felt very welcome. We told them it was our first time there, and we got a nice lay of the land, and some great history. The pizza was very good and the atmosphere was really nice. The place was very clean and we would definitely go back.

See all

Great pizza, salad and breadsticks! Our replacement pizza for our shuttered Ponticellos!

Godfather's Pizza

5.0(1 review)

5.1 mi

We ate at Godfather's Pizza in Bozeman, Montana, and thoroughly enjoyed the pizzas. One of my…read morefavorites was the Hawaiian pizza.

See all

Racanellis New York Pizzeria

3.4(118 reviews)

3.7 mi

I grew up in Brooklyn, New York. So I can say without a doubt that Racanelli pizza is the closest…read moreto NY style that you can find in the St Louis region. Perfect chew with a slightly browned bottom. Cooked in real 1000 degree pizzeria style ovens. Excellent Italian marinara sauce (sweet, not acidic) olive oil and top quality mozzarella cheese that stretches the length of your arm. None of that 'provel' crap here! Their calzones are great also. Although they don't fill them with as much cheese as it should be. If you're looking for a slice of pizza reminiscent of Gino's or Lenny's on 13th avenue Brooklyn in the 1960's and 70's, this is the place to go.

This location is off Mid Rivers Mall Drive in a small plaza with plenty of parking. There's several…read morespots right in front of the restaurant. I stopped by on a weekday to pick up 2 lunch specials that I had ordered. This is a good value for the amount of food that you get. It's around $12. I ordered a slice of New York style pizza with one topping, a small house salad with dressing and a brewed iced tea. My dining companion got the sandwich combo, which was a buffalo chicken sandwich (huge portion), a small Caesar salad with Caesar dressing and a fountain soda. They stated it was all very good. The ambience is very casual and family friendly. My food was ready on time, and the service was adequate. Overall, I'd probably give it 3.5 stars. It's better than average but not memorable for me. I want to try a calzone or Stromboli on a future visit.