Stefanina's in O'Fallon is easily one of the best pizza spots around. Their pizza has that perfect balance--crispy, flavorful crust, generous toppings, and cheese that melts beautifully without being overly heavy. Every bite tastes fresh and made with care, and it's the kind of pizza you crave again the moment you finish it. The rest of the menu is great too, but for us the pizza is truly the star. Whether you dine in or take it to go, the quality is consistently excellent. The staff is always friendly, quick, and welcoming, which makes the whole experience even better. If you're in the O'Fallon area and want some of the best pizza you'll find locally, Stefanina's should be at the top of your list. Highly recommend! Oh....and don't forget - on Tuesday's- you can get a large pizza for the price of a small! What a deal! read more

Always awesome service, food and staff. Never disappointed with any choice on the menu. Support our local restaurants. This one has been here since 1981. read more

I came here for lunch with a large group and was (with others in agreement) really not impressed, The one positive was our server who was very pleasant and efficient. The food, however was a different story. The dinner rolls were cold and the butter containers were watery. The side salads had too much yellow and white lettuce and not enough dressing to hide the sour taste. I had a lunch pizza that featured tasteless crust, little to no sauce and toppings that had bland flavor with no trace of cheese. One person's pizza was under cooked with semi raw crust. Two people had bland marinara sauce on their small serving of pasta and said the sausage served with it was lukewarm. One had manicotti and one had pasta con broccoli. Neither could finish their small serving due to the taste. I am at a loss as to how this place stays in business. read more

1 star is too generous for what we just went through, the old lady server needs to revisit restaurant manners. You don't let out a huge sigh and roll your eyes when your taking someone's order lol. Sorry we were "inconvenient" to this establishment. read more

Been in business 44 years - I don't know how based on the Italian dishes we had. And the only reason I give it 2 stars, is because the pizza may be good. May be good. One dining with us tonight...said it was her new favorite pizza. I take that opinion with grain of salt....as she thinks store bought frozen pizza is good or loves McDonalds all the time. The baked mostaccioli or baked spaghetti - uhm.....horrible. The sauce tasted like like watered down tomato paste - no other flavor. Yuck! Yuck Yuck! You in St Louis and want Italian? Go to Charlie Gitto's if you want a nice place at night. It's phenomenal. Or during the day and want the best deli sandwiches or certain pasta dishes - go to Eovaldi's. Another place that will rock your taste buds. Both on the Hill in St Louis....fantastic places! read more

See all

We ordered past and house salad To go By the time we hit only 10 Minutes to home The salad was wilted They should not have put the dressing on prior to me picking it up. AdrianBrock28@gmail.com read more

One of Saint Louis' top family owned and operated pizza establishments.... If you are in or around Saint Charles area, then check it out!

Great pizza. Stefaninas is a great supporter of non-profits. They have provided pizza at great discount for our organization multiple times still with great service - and pizza. read more

Food wasn't very good. Figured it would be hard to mess up pizza... The waitress we had seemed nice. I don't recommend this place overall though based on the food read more

After swimming at friends pool. On way back home. I craved for pizza and so Stefania's sounds interesting. So many young servers like 10 young servers running around. Busy lobby. I ordered pineapple and pepperoni pizza large. It was very good and I didn't eat all of it since I was full. Took some home. I like their hospitality. Thank you read more

See all

Haven't had the pizza in probably 15 years and went back while in town. Same amazing staff and will be making the trip back for pizza soon! read more

See all

Went there Saturday 12/13. Really cold outside. Front door recoil was broken causing heat to get sucked out of restaurant. Really cold inside. Ate with our coats on and couldn't wait to leave. Food was great by the way. read more

We were greeted as we walked in the door. Our waitress was very attentive. We ate their lunch special with a side salad and personal size pizza. Both were delicious! I love their thin crust and flavorful meat toppings. They have awesome prices for their lunch and daily specials! I highly recommend Stefanina's! read more

I came here on a Tuesday in the middle of the day for lunch. The place wasn't very busy and we had a large group. At the beginning our waitress came by a lot to get drinks and take our food orders but once we got our food we didn't see her really at all. For food I got one of the lunch specials. I got a salad and pizza. I decided to go with the BBQ chicken pizza and I had hot sauce drizzled on top. The salad was very good and the pizza was delicious! Everyone's food looked good and my group all said it tasted good. I will come back and have to try some more times. read more

Stefanina's Pizzeria - BBQ pizza with buffalo sauce drizzled on top - Pizza Near Me - O'Fallon, Missouri

Our go-to takeout pizza spot. Tried: toasted raviolis, bosco sticks, mozzerella sticks, meat lovers pizza Loved: their extra large pizza is a really great deal - it's massive and lasts a few meals for us. Everything is good value while also being great St Louis style pizza. Ordering ahead for takeout is the way to go - they always are quick to help but it gets very busy in their restaurant overall so just plan ahead! read more

The service is awesome and the pizza is amazing! We enjoy the food and we have to drive over 35 to 40 minutes to get there!

I have ordered Pizza, Wings and mushrooms from Stefanina's Pizzeria several times and the food is always good. The restaurant is pretty basic. The staff is very friendly and helpful. I do think that the price of the food is a little high and we have had a problem when we place an order online that it goes to a different location that where we thought we placed the order. We thought that the order went to the Zumbehl, St. Charles location but were told that it went to the Jungermann, St. Peters location and we had to drive to St. Peters to get our food. They would not make it in the St. Charles location, even though we were standing right there. read more

We were driving through St. Louis on the return from a big camping trip out west, and I HAD to have some St. Louis style pizza- something you just can't get anywhere else. So, I looked to yelp, found a place near the highway, google map checked it to make sure the camper would fit in their parking lot (it's a big lot- fit just fine :) ). I used their online ordering to place our order when we were about 15 minutes away, and it was hot and ready to go when we got there. EXCELLENT pizza! Great toppings and plenty of gooey provel cheese. St. Louis style pizza at its finest. We'll keep this place on our list in case we're ever passing through again! read more

Stefanina's Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - O'Fallon, Missouri

Great St. Louis style pizza. This is our go to place when I am out visiting my parents. Always a good pizza and delicious toppings. The cheese is creamy and perfect and the crust is nice and thin. We usually just get this to go to enjoy their house with a few beers. read more

Stefanina's Pizzeria - Sausage pizza - Pizza Near Me - O'Fallon, Missouri

See all

Any St.Louisan knows you are ether team Stef's or team Imo's, and for me Stefs wins every time. The Stefs special is my go to. Consistently chock full of toppings and flavors for the perfect pizza. The house salad always hits the spot with creamy Italian dressing, olives and artichoke hearts. Sit down or carry out you can't go wrong. read more

Our favorite pizza and salad place! Wait times for delivery can be long on weekends, but the pick up times aren't too bad

Wait 10 min to pick-up, 3 minutes home it was cold, burnt, and the cheeses has changed - looks like cheddar cheese.

Pizza is fantastic! We ordered delivery and it's our first time eating it and we heard great things so we had to try! Driver was friendly. And their estimated time for delivery was very close so we appreciate that. We ordered Stefs specialty pizza and a pepperoni for the kids. Also the bosco sticks. Don't skip on the bosco sticks! We can't wait to go into the restaurant next time. read more

Stefanina's Pizzeria - Stef's Special Pizza - Pizza Near Me - O'Fallon, Missouri

See all

This place is just okay. We hadn't visited in awhile, and we used to order carryout frequently, so we decided to go in for dinner one night recently. I don't know if it's gone downhill or if it was never that great, but the last time we were there, it was disappointing. They seem to do a good business and are frequently crowded, so somebody must like it, but I was underwhelmed. The food is okay, but nothing special. It's honestly kind of flavorless and bland. We just haven't been impressed and probably won't be back. read more

We are locals and Stefs is always my first choice. They are busy, but their pizza is consistently delicious and they don't skimp on toppings. We will always recommend and return to Stefs (we have been here 17+ years, so they are consistent!!) read more

I'm new to the St. Louis area, and also St. Louis pizza. I'm still trying to decide if it's for me or not. Having said that, of the 3 different St. Louis style pizzas I've tried, this is far and away the best. I will probably try it again, but I really wish they made NY style here read more

Delicious food and with good portions for our visit. Recommend the Steph special pizza or the Taste of Italy.

The food is delicious. The taco pizza is amazing. All the way around; an awesome place to eat and dine. Employees are receptive and polite. The environment is pleasant and clean. I highly recommend. You won't be disappointed. read more

The cheese fresh out of the oven is extremely thick and glorious! The pizza was $15 and the service was quick read more

See all

Great food and great service. Be ready to take a doggie bag home, very large portions.

Many years ago I was very fortunate to have some Stefanina's pizza at a friends house. I thought that this is the best pizza ever! I loved it so much. Today, I was back in the area and saw we were near Stefanina's Pizzeria and needed to grab some lunch. My sister's family joined mine on this delicious journey. From the pastas to the pizza, everyone loved their lunch! My picky eater son was happy that they had Kraft Mac and cheese. Their pizza is the thin crust St. Louis pizza which is the BEST! I love everything about their pizza . The cheese, sauce, and crust is so good! I should ordered a larger size because I wanted more after I polished off my pizza. The beautiful restaurant has many of the owner's family photos throughout. It makes me feel at home. The service was top notch! Our waitress was spectacular! She was very friendly and attentive! I look forward to returning in the near future for the best pizza! read more

See all

I have become a bit of a snob when it comes to eating any place on this side of the river (IYKYK ‍). I've lived out this way for almost 7 years, and had pizza from this place completely by accident. My neighbor ordered pizza for a birthday party, and I was completely blown away by 1. That we have pizza this good in Saint Charles county and 2. That we have pizza this good in Saint Charles county. We decided to stop in for dinner recently. The service was great! Hard working high school students who were professional and very friendly. We have a vegetarian in our group, and went with a veggie pizza and the big dinner salad. I'm not sure what they put in the salad, but man it just works. The house dressing is lick the bowl delicious! The veggie pizza was heaping with veggies and cheese. The crust is the square homemade variety I grew up with as a kid and still love today. I'm hosting friends for dinner tonight from South City and have decided to order pizza for dinner tonight. Hopefully, they love it as much as I do! read more

This is the place to go while in Ofallon MO for pizza the Ofallon way. They have been making pizza here forever and they know what they are doing. So delicious and get there early or get takeout bc it gets busy on the weekends. Their other dishes are good but we usually get the pizza since it is so dang good. Stephs special is the way to go (basically a supreme pizza). Service is always great and try to go to the original location off Hwy K if you can. Full bar makes this a fun time for all! read more

----- Concise Review - Great wings and pizza, with our friend ----- Longer Review We had just picked up some items a Gateway Powder Coating, in O'Fallon, and wanted to meet a friend for lunch. Wings and pizza sounded good, and Stefanina's the place for both. I hadn't dined there for many years, and this was the first visit for our daughter; I can attest they are still as consistently good as they were back then... great salad wings and pizza... we had enough for our friend and for us to take some home. The staff is friendly and the atmosphere welcoming. We'll be back. ----- ----- read more

Ordered delivery from here. I usually get their pizza but decided to mix it up and I was not super impressed... toasted ravioli lacked texture, but were decent. Side salads had way too much cheese and not enough dressing. I do like the creamy Italian dressing a lot, but I would have liked some more to cover the entire salad. Asked if my baked spaghetti could be made with proved instead of mozzarella and they said only if the provel is on the side?? Makes me question if the meal is premade. I ended up just getting it with the mozzarella to avoid having the cheese on the side. Overall it was meh, didn't have much flavor, wouldn't recommend it. My boyfriends cannelloni was good, but was a small portion. Probably won't come here again (unless it's for their pizza, which I wish I had ordered instead) read more

See all

Amazing service at the bar. I've taken clients and friends there, Saturday nights both times. Bartender was Matthew. He made everyone feel comfortable and welcomed and he remembered all names! Will definitely continue to return on Saturday evenings!! read more

Pizza has a strange creamy cheese sauce on it. Ravioli was great. Service was speedy. Restaurant was clean

Good pizza. Great toasted ravioli! Old school pizza joint with good vibes. Will be back.

Just not too good. I would not recommend. The pizza was a mess and the meatball sandwiches were soggy and were supposed to have cheese. Bummer. read more

Great service, amazing people, love their food!!! Must try the stefs special or cheeseburger pizza!!