Stefanina's pizza has been my favorite since 2001 and they've been around since 1981! But even…read morethough their pizza is my favorite I always end up getting the Tour of Italy! They are usually fast service but there can sometimes be a wait however not today! They have a bar and options of tables and booths depending on what your preference is for seating. Family friendly and has room for larger parties in certain areas.

Tortellini Alfredo was tasteless and cold and inedible. Lasagna was not good either. Salad had…read moreslimy rotten lettuce. Service was ok. But made excuses such as that is a popular item. I don't know why. I've had Steph's Pizza which is good This restaurant has seen better days and is pretty run down.

Upon first going I do need to be honest. This place has little to no vibe. We were the only people…read moreeating in on a Thursday evening but they did keep busy doing carry out and delivery orders. The toasted ravs were average but the NY style pizza hit! It was hot, fresh and loaded. We had meatball, sausage and pepperoni on ours! Delicious! This is DEFINATELY a grab your pizza and take it home place but it was gooood!

This location is off Mid Rivers Mall Drive in a small plaza with plenty of parking. There's several…read morespots right in front of the restaurant. I stopped by on a weekday to pick up 2 lunch specials that I had ordered. This is a good value for the amount of food that you get. It's around $12. I ordered a slice of New York style pizza with one topping, a small house salad with dressing and a brewed iced tea. My dining companion got the sandwich combo, which was a buffalo chicken sandwich (huge portion), a small Caesar salad with Caesar dressing and a fountain soda. They stated it was all very good. The ambience is very casual and family friendly. My food was ready on time, and the service was adequate. Overall, I'd probably give it 3.5 stars. It's better than average but not memorable for me. I want to try a calzone or Stromboli on a future visit.

So Glad We Stopped In!…read more We decided to get the Medium Unlimited and dine in -- there was only one table, but this was our first visit and we wanted to try the pizza straight out of the oven. Wow, was it worth it! The crust was perfectly crisp, the toppings were generous, and the flavor was amazing. The staff was super friendly and welcoming, and you could tell they really take pride in what they do. Even though it's mostly a carryout spot, it was such a great experience to enjoy it fresh and hot. If you haven't tried Alfano's yet, definitely stop by -- it's easily one of Wentzville's best!

Ordered a 14" pepperoni and sausage pizza and shared it with one other person and still had 3…read moreslices left to take home. At the time of the order, the pizza was amazing!!! The dough was made fresh as I watched the gentleman toss it. The thickness of the crust is not too thin or too thick it's right in the middle with a crispy bottom and stuff on the top. You could tell the sausage was homemade and not store bought. It had a slight char to the crust similar to brick oven pizza and the sauce had great flavor. My only complaint was that my oven at home did not properly reheat the 3 slices I took home the same way as their oven it gave it a "burnt like" taste so I had to toss it out. I reheated it at a very low temp but it just didn't taste the same as in the restaurant. I'll be back for sure, but I'll make sure to eat it all there. lol

Great pizza and wings. Worth the trip! Great value too. We also used them for a rehearsal dinner.read more

Stopped in at Phily's pizza for the first time on a Wednesday evening after a quick drop-in at our…read moredaughter's cabin. We were initially the only customers there and were immediately greeted and seated. The service and staff were absolutely the kindest they could be! The restaurant had filled to about 50% by the time we left (which was unexpected for a VERY cold early January Wednesday) and call-in orders just kept coming. The pizza and salad were absolutely delicious though I would say the house vinaigrette dressing could use a little "punch." That would be the only tiny negative that I can say and we WILL be back as soon as we can get out there! The pizza sauce was the right amount of sweet, the hand-tossed crust was perfect and puffy and doughy and crisp! Excellent choice for a weeknight or weekend!

I picked up a hot pizza last weekend, and we loved it! I also bought some frozen Alfredo sauce to…read moremake chicken Alfredo the following day and it was good also. I was told while I was there that they sell frozen pizzas at Wright City Meats so I went there and bought a frozen pizza today. Haven't tried it yet but it looks yummy.

If you like St. Louis style pizza, fresh made thin crust, proven cheese, & supporting small…read morebusinesses, Cusumano's in Warrenton is a must try. There are certain time windows that this place is open; currently they're open Tuesday-Saturday 4-8 according to Google. They have been open for lunch before, would love to see them do lunch again in the Springtime or when the warm season hits! The space is a smaller and narrow, yet does offer seating to customers who wish to dine in. This gives the place itself a unique, true "hole in the wall" character that fits right in downtown Warrenton. If you don't like provel cheese, there is substitution such as mozzerrella. Or scrap the idea of pizza all together and try other options on the menu such as salad, cheese bread, toasted ravs, or chicken wings. They even have cannolis! I have tried Cusumano's only a handful of times, but it's still not enough. I'm happy with each order. The price is more reasonable, surprisingly, than Imo's. Each pizza has been different depending on what I get, but my favorite is The Alexander. We are lucky to have a treasure of St Louis History come join our small town of Warrenton.

Dukes BBQ already has a great BBQ. They've now added a pizza oven and are kicking out some nice…read morepizzas, similar to the Mod Pizza that used to be around the corner. Pricing is a little steeper but nothing alarming. The service is just like Dukes, and you can eat in the same dining areas with the cool retro vibe. Minor issues... it's just mozzarella. Good mozzarella, but that leaves it a little one dimensional. Small burnt areas on the crust are expected, but their flour left them really bitter. Nothing really bad, but it just missed a little.

Ordered the Duke. Description says brisket, candied jalepenos and red onion. The brisket was…read moreextremely sparse and was more like brisket jerky. Hard, dry and chewy. One red onion per slice. First and last time ordering a pizza here. Garbage.

Please be aware that Guffey's Pizza in Washington is not associated with the Guffey's Pizza in the…read morePacific region. However, having tried both, I must say that the Pacific Guffey's Pizza is truly exceptional. If you enjoy Imo's pizza, you will absolutely love this one; it far surpasses Imo's in quality. Guffey's Pizza also offers wonderful sandwiches, particularly their phenomenal burgers, especially the Hawaiian burger. Their salads are enormous and delicious. I cannot speak highly enough of this establishment; everything is excellent.

Just went to get a salad. It had pepperoni and salami along with generous olives, fresh lettuce…read more it's all carry out so no ambiance but the help was very friendly. I seldom tip on carry out but they got on from me

Friendly staff, recommended the thin crust which was good. This is St. Louis style pizza so…read moreproceed with caution if you're not a fan. Cheese and toppings were plentiful and this pizza was baked to a nice crispy perfection! This is takeaway only so try it on a night when you aren't excited to cook but still want to be at home. Enjoyed supporting this small business!

This place is awesome! First time trying it - got a small buff chicken pizza and side salad. Side…read moresalad was larger than I anticipated and it was realllyyy good. Pizza - top notch / it is thin crust but snot cracker thin. Really good tho. Order was made fast / picked it up quick and now I have dinner also! Thanks DanOs I'll be back- for appetizers and take out pizzas - on and also - their dressings were really great!