I got introduced to this famous apple cake during the pandemic and it's definitely one of the most delicious desserts and comfort foods ever! This was my first time visiting Mystic Muffin and got two slices ($3 each) for me and my friend and they were still hot right out of the oven! Total foodgasm with every bite! And the crust was so uniquely crispy and chewy at same time. I loved the small town family run feeling inside with an old-style hand-written menu covering the back wall. There were some stools to sit by a bright open window where we sat and enjoyed our apple cakes. Very friendly service from Annie and we heard the owner Elias warmly chatting up other customers that sounded like regulars. I loved the neighbourly vibe! On my way out I got a full freshly made apple cake $22 for my brother's upcoming birthday. It was heavy! Highly recommend visiting this Toronto landmark! read more

See all

We stayed at a hotel nearby and this looked like an unassuming breakfast place, but it turns out we found a hidden gem! Bagel with cream cheese was delicious. Nicely toasted, and I loved the sesame seeds. The falafel are also delicious. We got some banana bread fresh out of the oven -- very good. Everything is very cheap. Service was awesome. The owner is so friendly. read more

As soon as my friends and I walked in, we were welcomed with the very old school, family-owned, been in town for forever vibe. We got 2 slices of the infamous apple cake to share and it definitely lives up to the hype! It includes big chunks of baked apples that are soft but not too too mushy, paired with the crispy crumb on top. read more

Mystic Muffin - Apple cake - Sandwiches Near Me - Toronto, Ontario

THE SHOP OWNER WAS SO NICE AND FUNNY!! I actually got an apple cake and it was super good. I think they're known for it here. It wasn't too sweet. I also got to a chickpea salad and veggie samosa. I ate it all and definitely want to come back. Keep up the great work :) read more

Mystic Muffin - Sandwiches Near Me - Toronto, Ontario

I loveee mystic muffin. The owner is lovely and the food is cheap. If you're looking for a sandwich that rivals only that made by your mom for a summer beach day, this is the place for you! read more

Down-to-earth, kind owner. My breakfast bagel was great. Will go back the next time I am in Toronto. read more

I had high expectations for this place and it surpassed all of them!!! I wish I could go here every day. Bring cash!

Feeling ashamed that I did not know about this 29 yr old Toronto small cafe 'til now. Its kitschy & super casual. Wonderful to see the steady flow of obvious regular customers. Happy accident helped me finally find it. Our little group were fortunate to stop here for a snack of: lentil soup, egg wrap sandwich, egg salad, coffee, banana bread and apple cake. They TRULY DO have incredible apple cake! Go visit Mystic Muffin in downtown T.O. Support this family run biz! I'll definitely be back. (Find me on Instagram- @aida.loves ) read more

See all

Very sweet owners and very delicious food! Prices are very reasonable too! I tried their small chickpea salad - which I'd say for the price is a good size, and of corse, the apple cake! Amazing cake. The consistency of it kind of reminds me of an Arab dessert called 'hireesay' but apple flavour and it's literally perfect! read more

Easy walk from our hotel. The apple cake is as everybody says. Amazing. Super nice guy runs the place. read more

I was a little confused by the ordering process (owners get a gauge of how many bagels need to be toasted for everyone in the restaurant, then individuals start ordering what they want on them), but the owners could not be more helpful and pleasant. Inside, the area is mostly open with a few seats and tables, enough for a few people to sit and eat. I imagine the open area gets packed most mornings. I had a bagel with ham and cheese, which was tasty and satisfying -- not particularly large but paired well with the famous apple cake and a coffee for a lovely complete breakfast. The other reviews have it right -- the apple cake is a must-buy. It's absolutely delicious with its crisp edges, sweet and moist cake, and soft apple chunks inside. Save yourself the FOMO and just tack it onto your order! Value: 4/5 Quality: 5/5 Quantity: 4/5 Service: 5/5 Atmosphere: 4/5 read more

love this place. The price is amazingly reasonable and you can see it's loves by the community.

Cute little place not too far from Eaton Centre. Has a wide selection of items. Pastries looked awesome. Went with the apple fritter and got a FRESH slice. Corner slice is the best! Owner is super friendly and cracks a lot of jokes. One of the best slices of apple pie you can get in Toronto. 4.3/5. read more

Mystic Muffin - a piece of bread in a paper bag - Sandwiches Near Me - Toronto, Ontario

See all

Pros: + Apple Cake is delicious! + Price is fair + Serving size is good + Friendly staff, clean establishment, good sense of humour, and cool retro interior Cons: - Can't personally give it a 5/5 as I'm not a big apple guy! Not a fan of apple pie or apple crisp, so this isn't something I'd get again, but if you're into that stuff, then this is a must-try! After walking and driving past the extravagantly quirky entrance for years, I finally stopped in to try Mystic Muffin after a friend recommended their world-famous Apple Cake! It almost has the appearance and consistency of banana bread, but instead of being dry and crispy on the bottom, it's moist and gooey. The middle layer is equally as moist with a nice fluffy texture. There are also nice chunks of fresh apple throughout. The top of the cake is crunchy and sweet which really rounds things out and makes a nice bite. I can't personally give it a 5/5 as I'm not a big apple guy! Not a fan of apple pie or apple crisp, so this isn't something I'd get again, but if you're into that stuff, then this is a must-try! The weirdo trippy signage out front is awesome. "781 Billion Served!" is my favourite sign. The gentleman who served me was very friendly, funny, and laidback. The inside is old-school, but nice and clean with a handful of seats in front of the window. read more

See all

Mystic Muffin is an absolute staple of Downtown Toronto. Whenever I have friends from abroad come visit and we're just a little bit hungover, I make sure to work Mystic Muffin into the conversation. A friend of mine recently moved into the Queen/Sherbourne area and I made sure to take her directly to Elias. The owner of MM, Elias, couldn't be more friendly. He works diligently and efficiently, but makes sure that you're well taken care of during your visit. Aside from the traditional breakfast fare, I'd definitely try the apple cake. Think of it as the Baked Apple Pie from McDonald's... but way better. It's usually hot and fresh, and has just the right combination of sweet, savoury, and tart. For $4, it can't be beat. Mystic Muffin is one of the best known places for breakfast in Toronto and for good reason. Great selection, great food, and most of all, great service. You can't go wrong paying Elias a visit next time you're in the Queen/Jarvis area! read more

We were walking in downtown and looking for a quick snack spot to continue going from Distillery District to Nathan Philips Square. Mystic Muffin came to rescue with its moistest and delectable apple cake. While I am a savoury person and took red lentil soup, my husband grabbed a hot chocolate. I'll highly recommend soup and cake (of course not as a combo). This place is in business for 30 years now and the owner is probably the jolliest person I have met. The pricing is extremely economical for a place in downtown. Marked as one of my favourites now. For more such reviews/explorations, follow me on insta at @mygourmetaffair. read more

Mystic Muffin - Hot Chocolate, Apple Cake and Lentil Soup - Sandwiches Near Me - Toronto, Ontario

See all

The world famous Apple Cake I remember trying this almost a decade ago and I couldn't believe how delicious it was. It's still as good today, moist on the inside with some hints of crispy edges. So friggin good. Do yourself a favour and just buy a full or half slab of it because one slice won't be enough! read more

Mystic Muffin - Instagram @fatnam_eats, Apple Cake - Sandwiches Near Me - Toronto, Ontario

See all

Not much to say here except you must get the apple bread. I don't know what they put in here, but it's addicting and crazy good. I haven't worked in this area in years and still dream about this bread. read more

This place an absolute must stop. I was staying nearby for 4 nights and ended up here 3 days in a row. The food is delicious, the owners are awesome, and the prices are "cheap." Whenever I find myself back in Toronto, I will absolutely be visiting Mystic Muffin again. Probably multiple times. read more

A must visit - the people are awesome, kind, and humble. The food is alright but great for the price and way better with the vibes in there. Go check it out and have a sandwich and a slice of apple cake. read more

Flavourful and filling food served with warm smiles at reasonable prices. Not a fancy frou frou place but they've been around for 24 years so that tells you something. RECOMMENDATIONS: - Apple cake - moist cake flavoured with aromatic spices filled with chunks of sweet apple and topped with a scrumptious crumble topping. - Chicken salad sandwich (served on bread or pita) - Chicken and Potato sandwich - Lentil soup - made with 11 different kinds of veggies. It's chunky, thick, savoury and filling. - Hummus - smooth, a little plain but went really well with their falafel. - Falafel - delicious, lightly crisp on the outside. - Cookies (1 chocolate chip and 1 oatmeal raisin) are soft with a nice chew and not too sweet. read more

See all

Place is closed until August 16th. Owners are away for family time- just a heads up! Was really hoping to try this place while we were in town. Until next time! read more

Mystic Muffin - Closed notice - Sandwiches Near Me - Toronto, Ontario

See all

They make the best apple bread I've ever tasted. The apple cake is moist, flavourful and perfectly textured. The cake is not too sweet . Beware that they sell out very quickly so good luck. Best to pre-order if you don't want to be disappointed. read more

Mystic Muffin - Apple cake - Sandwiches Near Me - Toronto, Ontario

"73 Billion Served" - a sign above the establishment reads. I can't fathom that number considering it has (only) been open for 27 years. Maybe it's a joke? A misreading of the numbers? Do I misinterpret? Approx. 3 billion served a year? Absolutely no way - it should've been way more than that. This place states it has served our entire population 10 times over but considering the quality, price and lovability - it should've been 20x. This place has got me full with quality, handmade food for a price no one can really match. Go try anything. except the cookies. I didn't really like the cookies. But try anything else. read more

Great vibe s soon as you walk in. Couple of guys ahead ordering and picking up. I came to try the appetizer cake and it was great. Moist on the inside and crispy edges and best part it was still warm ! We got a couple of muffins too. They were tasty too. I strongly recommend trying at least the apple cake and we were tempted to pick up a couple of pound cake. They were warm too. There are Ali's bagels and sandwiches options. read more

Mystic Muffin - a display case with a variety of food items - Sandwiches Near Me - Toronto, Ontario

See all

What can I say, I have a soft spot for mom and pop shops that provide good food at a fair price and Mystic Muffin is definitely it. Their platter, while possibly to carb heavy for some, is so flavourful, especially the potatoes and portions are very generous. I particularly recommend their eggplant, which, though it costs extra, is worth every penny. Though not pictured, I also indulged in Mystic's famous apple cake---a delicious treat that's got a bit of crunch up top but is perfectly moist everywhere else. So delicious I got half a pan of it ($11) to share at work and nobody could stop at just having a slice. I look forward to trying more menu items and knowing where I can go for delicious and fairly priced cakes for potlucks and gatherings! read more

See all

SO HAPPY I FINALLY TRIED THIS TORONTO STAPLE. Their signature apple cake is a MUST. So moist but still had a caramelized crust. Their croissant was surprisingly very fresh and their muffins wasn't too sweet at all, just the right touch (infinitely better than your local Tim's muffins)! read more

I looked online for nearby restaurants and Mystic Muffin showed up. It had a bunch of 5-star reviews and photos. Especially of their apple cake. So, I got ready and walked in the beautiful 70° weather for the 1.4 miles. The owner, his wife, and little son were so hospitable. I wound up having the falafel wrap, Mt. Dew, and a piece of that apple cake. I am here to tell you, it would have been worth the walk at 5 miles. (For me, that's saying something). By the way, I ordered two pieces of apple cake to go as well. read more

See all

After reading all the reviews and articles, I had envisioned Elias and I having a grand conversation, but he only asked if I wanted onion on my chicken salad pita. He did ask twice since he forgot my answer the first time. Maybe he didn't get enough sleep with the new baby. There was a baby girl behind the counter and a beautiful woman (whom I'm going to assume is his wife) feeding her. My first time here and I didn't a free slice of apple cake. I had to buy my own but it was well worth the $2.50. It was dense, cinnamony, moist, not too sweet, with chucks of apples and very delicious. I came around lunch time and there was 1 person ahead of me in line. After that, there was a constant stream of customers coming in, most sounded like regulars. My $5 chicken salad pita was good (came with lettuce, tomato, onion and spices). Quick, easy and fresh. I was eyeing the samosa and beef roll, but wasn't sure if they would be good for a late afternoon snack. There were plenty of room to sit and I ate my lunch at the counter overlooking Jarvis Street. Update: My 2nd visit, I've made progress with Elias in terms of conversation. I asked him about his favorite pita and he said he likes to make a chicken with eggplant but no onion. I never had a falafel pita before, so I ordered one here. AMAZING! Very tasty and I highly recommend. CASH ONLY read more

See all

Well honestly I can't add anything that hasn't been already said. I'm just happy to give them another rave review. The amount that you get for that price is something that will have me going back. And the flavours will keep my taste buds very grateful for that decision. I'm not usually a big fan of Mediterranean food but of course, with the excellent ratings on numerous review sites, I knew I had to give this place a try. It was one of those unassuming places I would have never gone to unless I knew about it. But am I glad I found out about its existence. I got the Better Life Combo, and upon finding out that it was my first time there, Elias offered me a piece of that crazy famous Apple Cake (instead of the cookie/pita that usually comes with the combo). Yes, listen to everything that's been said before. This cake is very delicious. That little caramelized crust from the top of the cake. I can eat that all day every day. My takeout box was PILED with food and it was so very very good. $8 and I was completely stuffed. What a great lunch idea. Definitely coming back. Definitely going to try and convince my coworkers to go with me. Another satisfied customer for the Mystic Muffin. read more

Mystic Muffin - So much food - Sandwiches Near Me - Toronto, Ontario

Sometimes when you are in a so so mood... and you hate when people asking you too many personal questions.. especially if it is someone you never met before about where do you live? what you do for a living? (I feel like saying live in yelp world, yelping full time for a living) I guess I am in one of my bitchy mood?! Dropped by Mystic Muffin during my Indie Coffee Passport Run, just a sense of "been here! ate that!". Toasted Pumpernickel Bagel with Butter and Med Coffee ($2.49) - Great price! - The bagel itself was lightly toasted.. crispy outside and nice chewy inside.. and how I like it was not overloaded with butter... Services was nice and quick. I would have order more but it was a 3 pm post lunch snack... :) I know it is not fair to rate Mystic Muffin based on one visit...but sometimes it is the first impression that counts? Maybe I should come back when I am in a better mood, maybe I will enjoy the jokes and humor better! read more

See all

Was excited to try this place after seeing so many yelp reviews. I got the falafel plate and spicy beef patty. The falafels were good but nothing spectacular, the fries were good too with the mystery spice he added on top. The salads were T E R R I B L E. I don't think I've had such terrible salads in my life! There was no dressing on the salads and it was basically just leafs. Also I know the owner is trying to be funny but I really did not enjoy how he just started pointing at people and telling them where to go. Seemed a bit disrespectful although I guess that was his humour. He also said it was going to be family day soon and said something about how I should have it on my will??? Bruh wtf?? Was not in the mood for a joke like that when I'm in my mid twenties and was just trying to grab some breakfast. Over hyped and very pushy/disrespectful sense of humour. He should take it down a notch. read more

The apple cake is a must order. The owners are so friendly and encouraged us to get the apple cake which was outstanding. The best I have ever had! read more

This place is the absolute best. From the owner's life story written on the wall, to the funny signs all over, to every item on the menu having "love" listed as a topping, to the funny and friendly service from said owner, to the absolutely BOMB apple cake, you cannot go wrong with this place. I'm in Toronto in that area about twice a year for photoshoots, and I ALWAYS make sure to stop at Mystic Muffin. I like the egg bagel sandwich with a coffee and a slice of the apple cake, but I hear great things about the chicken and potato sandwich, so maybe I'll give that a try next time. Nothing fancy, just deliciousness and heartwarming vibes. CHECK IT OUT! read more

Mystic Muffin has been on many top Toronto best cheap eats list as far as I can remember. You always read the words of "plentiful, healthy, and awesome flavours" that goes on each list. What some list fail to capture is the amazing and incredibly charismatic gentleman behind the counter. He will make you smile if not laugh the entire time you're there. Mystic Muffin names doesn't convey the true nature of this place ... don't expect a bakery. You get to experience the most honest and fun conversation with a complete stranger (unless you're a regular) while enjoying some of the best and most affordable Mediterranean food in Toronto. The lady in front of us was getting the full treatment of learning what Mediterranean hospitality is all about and how she's got to bring one of the banana bread loafs (only $5 for the entire thing and freshly made! That's his hustle) to her friends cottage if she ever wants a return invite. He definitely knows how to work everyone into the conversation so even if there's a line, you never feel it once. As for me, I wanted a piece of the famed apple cake and for $3, I got a good sized helping to bring back. I could have eaten it there and then as there is a few tables available but his super clean but fairly spartan place is meant more as a take out spot. Apple Cake - I get why there's much love for this. It's like the best homestyle baked good you can find in Toronto. Tight crumbed and yet will quite light and moist, the cake is just the right sweetness that still gives the tender apple chunks the starring role. I loved how the sugar created a light crisp top that shatters and crumbles while you take a bite. It's very simple and homey but sometimes simple is the best. 4/5 The cake is a solid 4 star rave but the gentleman is a star in itself so 5 star from me. Next time, I'm here for lunch! read more

See all

I LOVEEEEE THIS PLACE!! Not just for the food but the owner as well! He's such a sweet guy, very chatty, loves to talk to customers and is just the nicest person ever. He works there with his wife and son and the whole family is just the best. If you're reading this now during the coronavirus - please go visit him and help him keep the business alive!! He's open because he genuinely wants to help people - he gets a lot of healthcare providers from the nearby hospital coming through, tired and hungry because nothing else is open, and he just wants to be able to provide for them! Their apple cake is the moist-est cake I've ever had and their breakfast bagels are top notch. Love this place, love the owner, highly highly recommend!!! :) read more

Cannot recommend Mystic Muffin highly enough. The food is always fresh and delicious - the apple cake is amazing but the muffins are unsung heroes. The owners are friendly and kind. This place is a real hub and pillar of the community. read more

I haven't lived in Toronto for 10 years but I still think about their apple cake. They were always so kind and warm when you went in. My first time visiting I was 18 and new to the city. I ordered a slice of apple cake and a tea without realizing (at that time, it's probably changed) that they didn't take cards. The kind girl behind the counter insisted that I still take my order and pop back in when I could to cover it. I went back the next day and thus began a years-long addiction to apple cake. Eventually I had to stop eating gluten for a stomach issue and had to give up the cake but I still think about it and occasionally try a copy cat recipe with GF flour. Nothing has ever compared. read more

I was moseying around for my morning walks and figured I'd go see if Mystic Muffin was open. Not only are they open but they are ready to serve! There is a lot more room to wait inside as they cleared away the tables and chairs to the corner. The store is still homey with lots of pastries, patties, and ready-to-make wraps at your service. The food is literally always, always fresh. The owner is the sweetest man ever. He's always ready to joke around and have a conversation with you. I bought half an apple cake today for $11 (full one is $20) and these things are massive! Definitely drop by if you're in the area. read more

I was hungry and looking for something cheap, asked what the guy working would recommend and he gave me the chicken and potato sandwich, said he'd guarantee I'd be full. He was right, delicious, filling and a great price. Not only that but he was super friendly (even introduced himself by name, turns out he started the business) and made great conversation. Best eating experience in Toronto so far! read more