Really great lobster rolls, have been here before and will come again in the future! Best lobster rolls in the whole area, nice little spot in the middle of a nice relaxing Plaza, with employees that are all friendly and helpful (as well as knowledgeable about the menu!). Recommend to anyone that likes lobster! read more

See all

I like my lobster rolls stacked with lobster ! Very flavorful and fresh! I would definitely go back! The only downfall I would say is I wish they served fries but they did offer getting some next door and bringing it over. Still very good ! read more

Mystic Lobster Roll - Sandwiches Near Me - Naples, Florida

New Owner...New Name....Now called Magic Lobster Roll. Be careful ! The prices have gone up.....the quality has gone down ! The new owner is rude. I ordered on line and was charged twice for the same order. One through Mystic and the other through Magic. The new owner said it was "impossible" since they don't send emails. I will no longer frequent this place.....terrible rolls.....terrible management. It's sad since Mystic was so good ! read more

Very impressed and it just goes to show that you can't judge a book by its cover. This place is small and kind of nestled a little hidden in a big shopping plaza. I had the clam chowder and a New England style lobster roll. After living in Boston, it's so hard to find a good lobster roll outside of there, but this is pretty close! read more

Mystic Lobster Roll - Sandwiches Near Me - Naples, Florida

See all

Pleasantly surprised with this lobster roll option in Naples. Hailing from the northeast, I was intrigued but prepared to be disappointed. But they delivered on a great lobstah roll! Use the app to get a discount. Order ahead. Unassuming little place in a strip mall. Not much to write home about for sit down. Staff was friendly but seemed a little overwhelmed. I went with the New England, and it's worth doing the Mighty upgrade for extra meat. read more

See all

Here's everything we tried Connecticut Roll -- fresh, tender lobster + melted butter -- 9.3/10 Lobster Bisque -- creamy, rich, more juicy lobster -- 9.0/10 Italian Roll -- pesto aioli + mozzarella = unreal -- 9.5/10 Clam Chowder -- insane flavor + warm potatoes -- 9.7/10 Deep South Roll -- spicy, flavorful with jalapeños -- 9.7/10 Key Lime Pie -- soft, citrusy perfection -- 9.3/10 Want to see the full video ? Check us out on Instagram. J.D_Ovalle And TikTok: J.Dovalle1 read more

See all

We found some INCREDIBLE lobster rolls at Mystic Lobster Roll Co!! Not only did they have classic rolls, they also had rolls with such a fun variety of toppings! Here's what we got: ~Lobster bisque- It was so full of flavor! ~New England Clam Chowder ~Connecticut Lobster Roll served warm with butter in the Mighty Size. This is a classic way to enjoy lobster and it has SO MUCH MEAT ON IT!! ~King Louis XIII specialty roll in regular size-fresh Maine lobster, fresh mozzarella, crispy prosciutto, and truffle aioli. I've never had a lobster roll with prosciutto on it before, but it really worked! I also loved the truffle aioli! ~Deep South Roll in regular size- lobster, Chipotle mayo, jalapeño aioli, candied jalapeños. My husband loved this roll and its unique flavors!! ~Lobster Mac and cheese-It was so cheesy and had a really generous portion of lobster on it! Mystic Lobster Roll Co has EXCELLENT lobster rolls with some incredibly fresh lobster. They also serve beer and wine and have a variety of beers on draft. The restaurant is such a vibe with nautical decor and they play music videos. We can't wait to eat these delicious lobster rolls again!! read more

Mystic Lobster Roll - Lobster Mac and cheese - Sandwiches Near Me - Naples, Florida

Definitely one of the best lobster rolls I ever have had. Everything's made fresh to order and you can taste it. Small unassuming place in a strip mall but you won't be disappointed. Service was quick and attentive. Their menu has a wide range of traditional lobster rolls and special ones. I tried the LBI specialty roll that included huge portions of lobster with giant chunks of avocado and tomatoes with avocado mayo. Was very delicious and I got the middle size and I could barely finish it. Can't imagine how big the largest one is. read more

Mystic Lobster Roll - LBI specialty lobster roll - Sandwiches Near Me - Naples, Florida

Wonderful lobster on a fresh toasted roll! Mac and cheese was excellent too! Coming back to try clam chowder! read more

Mystic Lobster Roll - Lobster roll - Sandwiches Near Me - Naples, Florida

Mystic Lobster Roll Co. - Naples, FL Food was amazing! The lobster rolls are huge and absolutely stuffed with fresh, flavorful lobster, so you really feel like you're getting your money's worth. The lobster soup is loaded with meat and has a rich, comforting flavor that stands out from other places we've tried. Staff was friendly, and the overall experience made this a new favorite for us. We will definitely be back! read more

Mystic Lobster Roll - Lobster roll - Sandwiches Near Me - Naples, Florida

If you're a lobster fan, Mystic Lobster Roll is a must-visit. We tried the lobster bisque, the Maine roll, the Hawaiian Roll, and the Monster Connecticut Roll, and every dish delivered. The portions were generous, the staff was friendly, and the food lived up to the hype. Looking forward to coming back and trying more of the menu. read more

See all

I can see why this place continues to win Best Lobster Roll in Naples! They get daily deliveries of fresh Maine lobster and they do not skimp on the pieces and portions of meat either. I had the giant classic Connecticut roll and lobster Mac and Cheese that was so creamy. Their soups are not to be missed either especially the Lobster Bisque read more

Mystic Lobster Roll - Lobster roll with butter - Sandwiches Near Me - Naples, Florida

See all

Can't go wrong with either warm or chilled - so fresh, juicy, and absolutely delicious!!!! I'm still thinking about it! Hands down one of the best I've had. Will definitely be back!​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​ read more

Mystic Lobster Roll - Sandwiches Near Me - Naples, Florida

I got the Connecticut Roll with mayo added on top and Garlic Butter, which came with a pickle and a side of cole slaw. We also got the New England Roll with Mac and Cheese (make sure to add some lobster!). It was TO DIE FOR, I'm still thinking about it. It's all delivered fresh daily and you can really tell in the quality of the lobster. I'm in my 20's and dressed in sweatpants and a jacket to go, and the servers and (who I believe is the owner) all treated me with the same respect and pure kindness they treated the big families, the fisher men getting beers, and the older folk. That is hard to find around here! Walk-in to-go, picking up to-go, sit-down casual restaurant, bar-seating, they've got it. The space is clean, the food was 5 stars, the bill wasn't high, the workers made me smile, and I left full and happy. Definitely making the drive to come back. read more

See all

Excellent Connecticut Lobster roll. Manager/owner is super friendly. Definitely making this one of our lunch spots. read more

Great value meal and delicious food! Friendly service as well :) Unique flavors of lobster rolls and lobster bisque was a must have!

Great service & good was made fast! We ordered like 5 plates. The Hawaiian roll was amazing & the Connecticut roll tooo :) read more

Mystic Lobster Roll - 3 rolls - Sandwiches Near Me - Naples, Florida

Service was very friendly! However, with only one person working (both taking orders and cooking) it was very slow. Also our warm Connecticut style rolls weren't very warm, and they needed more butter, salt and lemon, I wish they served them with a side of lemon. What was a total bummer was the weird, free crab gimmick. More than half the roll was crab meat, with lobster on top. So strange that they threw it in "for free" but in all actuality it was the majority of the roll. We drove over an hour and a half for dinner and sadly it was a miss. read more

Mystic Lobster Roll - Sandwiches Near Me - Naples, Florida

See all

Can't ask for a better lobster roll! Dine in, eat them fresh, service is great when eating restaurant. Been here a few times, it's pricy but you know you're eating good seafood. Have a verity of sodas, wines and beers; and great key lime pie. Lobster is best dine not take out! read more

If you've got the money to spend, this is definitely the premium lobster roll experience! Located in a bustling location, this little spot had so many items to pick from to fulfill any lobster lover's heart. I got the classic Maine roll with the mighty size upgrade! It came with two small sides of pickles and coleslaw, which paired so well with the roll. I also ordered an extra side of Yukon Gold potatoes. Everything was absolutely delicious. The lobster meat was fresh and juicy, mixing well with the mayo on a warm buttery roll. The potato side was hot and steamy with butter and rosemary seasoning. As someone who LOVES lobster rolls, I highly recommend this place! It is quite pricey, but definitely worth every penny. read more

Mystic Lobster Roll - Maine Lobster Roll - Sandwiches Near Me - Naples, Florida

Started Bad, but the food saved the day. Food = 5 Service=2 Total= 3 Well, another road trip stop. I happen to search seafood, and my partner loves lobster rolls. We pulled off the Naples 107 exit, headed to Sanibel for 4pm checkin. Well, this place of empty at 3pm. It was strange to see him asking peoole to sit down and order. Very poor process! You are one person at front of house, I dont think there was any erson in back, as I heard no voices. So he was preparing the food, after ringing order, and trying to wait on a family of 4. Disater was unfolding before my eyes. He disappeared in back, we smelled food bring heated. So I started this in anticipation of a a hot mess. He stares down to nevr catch my unhappy stare, why are two lobster rolls with chips taking so long? Are they killing thr lobster. This isnt a cheap stop! So hurry up... We have been here almost 30 min wainting for 2 lobster rolls and a side of soup to go. If I knew my way around I would leave. We started reading the Naples papers. Very empty for 240pm, sadly. But I couldnt imagine at all if this place was packed. You could see the store at the left was trying to pull eyes with a clothing rack out. Finally, the food.THIS WAS THE ONLY SAVING GRACE FOR THIS $75 PITSTOP. My BLT LOBSTER for $25 was 6 inch, $33 is 8 inch. Was a delight. Moist, not skimpy on amount. Bread was fresh. Lettuce was fresh, bacon crisp. Hands down best I ever had. Its not cheap but was good. Expect to spent $35 to $40 per person with drinks. He asked for tap. This uppercrust crowd had bottled, so at $5 per bottle, do the math. The table of four, two women went shopping next door. An uber order came, slowed him down more. So my parnter had the basic Maine, the first one. Cold. Excellent. Meaty, sweet. Both came with chips or slaw. Always cautious of slaw due to fridg tems, can get sick. So we kept safe, chips. Overall, a solid 3. The servee was kind, just put in a bad spot by the owner. Its a bad look to take orders, cook, se4ve, ot makes me question the cleanliness. You cant drop off water, ring up orders, then go cook. Hm?! Hope the owner sees this: install a SELF SERVICE POS. Let customers order at POS, two stations. Having this poor guy who appeared slkind but stressed. Stop this silly table serice to drive tips. Just add a tip to everything. Most businesses are there already and Naples can withstand. We went to lunch ner Ft Laud, automatic tip. So establish, dine in 15% added, then you can give great service without saying dont order at counter, go sit. Seema an odd service setup! Stop by visit, enjog, expect to wait! read more

Recommended by a friend so decided to try it out. Lobster was good. Strangely the sandwiches are open, so you can't really eat it like a sandwich, knife and fork are required. Great selection of classic and new lobster dishes put on an open sandwich. My suggestion would be to make it real sandwiches so one can eat it like a sandwich. read more

Mystic Lobster Roll - Exterior - Sandwiches Near Me - Naples, Florida

See all

If you're in Naples and love seafood, Mystic Lobster Rolls is an absolute must. Everything tastes incredibly fresh, and you can tell the lobster is high quality and delivered daily. We tried a few different rolls, and each one had its own personality. The classic is simple and perfectly done, the New England roll is light and refreshing, and the surf and turf is just next level, packed with flavor and super satisfying. The portions are generous, the bread is perfectly toasted, and everything is served warm and buttery in the best way. The atmosphere is casual and beachy, making it a great spot to relax and enjoy a really good meal. The staff was friendly and the whole experience felt easy and welcoming. It's honestly not surprising they won the Naples Community Choice Awards in 2022 and 2023. Highly recommend, we'll definitely be back. read more

The absolute best Lobsta roll when I'm visiting Naples Florida. Takes about 20 minutes so plan ahead. He boils the lobster fresh, crab fresh - the salad has mozzarella bacon and a pickle! Probably the best one I've had in Florida. The owner is the sweetest man, just honest and sets expectations- it's going to take a minute ! Fast food is not this place, the love is in the food:. Also if you hate mayo which I do, he does no mayo at all and it's delightful. I come out of my way just to get the lobster salad. read more

Mystic Lobster Roll - Lobster salad- no mayo and balsamic dressing f - Sandwiches Near Me - Naples, Florida

This place is one of the cleanest and lively places I've been to. The food is phenomenal and the service is amazing read more

See all

These lobster rolls were amazing. Highly recommend you try them out. And very reasonably priced. Service was awesome! read more

Good, but definitely not great. Expensive; small roll and drink....$32.81 before tip. Not much flavor or tender lobster. I ordered the Connecticut Roll.... Hot with butter. Couldn't taste the butter. Tiny cup of slaw. Ok, but I won't go back. read more

Mystic Lobster Roll - Connecticut Roll. - Sandwiches Near Me - Naples, Florida

Absolutely phenomenal experience! These lobster rolls are next level. The meat was incredibly fresh, juicy, and buttery -- perfectly cooked and generously piled into the toasted buns. Every bite was full of rich lobster flavor, and you could tell they use high-quality ingredients. We tried several versions, from the classic warm buttered roll to the chilled lobster salad, and even a spicy one with jalapeños -- each one was absolutely delicious in its own way. It's rare to find lobster this tender and flavorful outside of New England! Friendly service, clean setup, and fast prep time made the whole visit even better. If you're a seafood lover, this place is a must-try. We'll definitely be coming back for more! Shout out to Lalit for amazing service read more

Mystic Lobster Roll - Maine roll, Connecticut roll, Surf and turf , and Deep South - Sandwiches Near Me - Naples, Florida

Insane lobster roll!! Thank you guys. Rolled in here on a whim bc my daughter was hunting for Jelly Cats, and I know my kids are starting to crave lobster rolls. Got their first one in the Keys. This one was better. Tons of lobster! Perfectly cooked. We got both a Maine and a Connecticut. Both were great! read more

Best lobster roll ever! We had a lobster roll and the lobster mac and cheese. Both were delicious! read more

Mystic Lobster Roll - Lobster roll - Sandwiches Near Me - Naples, Florida

See all

Best different lobster rolls ever. Fresh, the prices are competitive and the counterperson was friendly.

The counter person Austin went over and above to ensure that we enjoyed our food. We had a cold Maine roll with mayo and warm Connecticut roll with drawn butter. Both delicious. Lobster bisque was also good but not epic. We weren't wild about the coleslaw but we went for the lobster. We will go again. read more

Great lobster rolls. Had all 3 kinds - service was good. Took a bit so they threw in a Crab Roll because of the inconvenience. It was also delicious. Highly recommended. read more

Mystic Lobster Roll - All 3 rolls and crab roll. - Sandwiches Near Me - Naples, Florida

Tremendous food and great service!! Go go go get a lobster roll there!!! Gluten free options also!!

Best tasting lobster roll in the Naples region. There is a fair amount of lobster in the lobster roll(anyone giving lesser reviews for the amount of lobster on the sandwich are just being gluttons). But if you want something excessive, you can choose the larger size. It is very very fresh tasting. We tried both Connecticut & Maine style, and were pleased. I feel like simple is best for something that is made well, but if you want something different, they do have a nice variety of other sandwich add ons. read more

Yes it is on the pricer side for a casual dining establishment but anyone who is a lobster roll fanatic like I am knows that the prices are on par for lobster rolls that you would get anywhere. I also feel like they gave a good portion of meet for the price and service was great. The roll came out hot and was yummy even though I got it to go. It also came with added crab meat as well for no extra charge which I thought was a nice touch. Overall, the only grief would be the shredded meat verses crab and lobster both being chunks. Which is how I would have preferred the dish but it still has good flavor. Will definitely check out the place again. read more

Mystic Lobster Roll - Connecticut Lobster - Sandwiches Near Me - Naples, Florida

The food was fabulous. We are from New England and the lobster roll, chowder and bisque were fresh, authentic and yummy!

The service and the food is really great. This is a highly recommend place. The lobster roll are outstanding.

What can I say except amazing!!! A definite must have for anyone who appreciates fresh and flavorful food!

I'm not a lobster roll aficionado but I went with some Boston natives. I loved the rolls as did my friends from Boston. Very friendly people that made us a great lunch. No lobster scamming here. Real lobster that was really good. I will be back. read more