This place has been raved about by folks that I know, and with good reason. This time I got the steak sub....it deserves its reputation. The onions and peppers and mushrooms were all perfectly caramelized and paired so well with the thinly sliced steak. All this piled on crusty fluffy bread....mmm mmm mmm Great place to stop after a hike to re fuel and warm up. read more

My Father's Pizza - Steak sub - Pizza Near Me - Black Mountain, North Carolina

Very tasty and fresh tasting pizza. We had friendly staff taking our orders. Very cute spot to grab pizza at. read more

My Father's Pizza - White Garlic Pizza with Salami and Spinach Topping - Pizza Near Me - Black Mountain, North Carolina

The atmosphere is very comfortable (like an old-school pizza parlor), our server was friendly, and we enjoyed everything we ordered. OUR ORDER - cheese pizza. Good crisp crust and nicely seasoned sauce. 4/5 - Cheesy breadsticks. We would probably not order them with cheese again -- the breadsticks were delicious but the cheese overwhelmed them a bit. 3.5/5 - Meatballs - nicely seasoned and abundant. 4/5 - Chicken Parmesan sub - good crunch to outside of the bread. It was good, but I was surprised that it was grilled chicken rather than fried and there was less cheese than expected. The pickle was excellent. 4/5 read more

See all

I should say that were kind of stumbled into this place after a rude experience at another place across the street. Black Mountain is a very nice little, walkable town where we were staying in a hotel while visiting Asheville. My Father's Pizza is a very nice place with an upstairs bar and both an inside and outside eating area. Our watress, Lettie, was very nice and treated us like family and when she figured out we would be intown a few days she made suggestions on other places to eat- More on that later. Bruschetta was what we picked for an appetiser and it arrived fast and was very good and enough that we took some of it back to the hotel for later. We followed that up with a My Father's Supreme Pizza which was was terrific. All this time the waitress mad sure everything was fine and mentioned some places we might like to visit while in the area. He left full and happy. The next night we looked around for another place to eat in town and we mutually decided that we would just go back to where we new was perfect. Out waitress, Lettie saw us come in and got the hostess to usher here to her table so she could find out how our day went, We ordered the whipped Ricotta dip which came out quickly and we followed that up with a steak sub and lasagna. The portions were large and the quality was as excellent as the night before and I am sure when we are in the area again whe will be back. read more

My father's pizza never fails to deliver a delicious pizza. They even have gluten and dairy free options, which does not hinder the taste or quality at all. Definitely recommend if your in the mood for Italian food. The place is pretty big inside, when you walk in it's initially just a bar area. But as you walk further in the dining area is there and an outdoor patio. Super nice for a beautiful day outside to have a great view of the mountains. read more

Service and ambiance lasted about 20 minutes, but was worth the wait. I got a Monza on a GF crust and with vegan cheese, which is basically a Philly cheesesteak pizza with onions and mushrooms. The crust had a good crunch to it, and the whole thing tasted like a Philly cheesesteak with tomatoes due to the sauce. Overall, this was twice as good as I expected. read more

My Father's Pizza - Monza (GF crust, vegan cheese) - Pizza Near Me - Black Mountain, North Carolina

I visited here once ~25 years ago and kept trying to come back, but the parking situation around downtown Black Mountain is intense. Today, I drove around for 15 minutes before finally spotting someone backing out of a spot within walking distance of My Father's Pizza. With that being said, this is a gem of a restaurant. The food was exactly what we needed-- fast, creative, fresh, and flavorful. The prices were totally reasonable as well. The indoors has almost a dive bar type feel, so don't worry about dressing up to visit. Our server was very friendly and got everything to us as it was ready. All in all, My Father's Pizza is as good as it was 25 years ago, so they must be doing something right! read more

My Father's Pizza - Menu - Pizza Near Me - Black Mountain, North Carolina

See all

The service was second to none! Everyone very polite and joyful! The pizza was delicious as well. Will surely be back to try other dishes. read more

See all

My family and I came here for dinner on a Saturday night. It was pretty busy but we were seated right away. It was very loud inside the restaurant. The waitress was friendly, however the food took a while to come out. I ordered a sub without cheese and onions and it was really good. It tasted fresh and the bread was soft. My family tried the margarita pizza and two salads which they also enjoyed. Overall I'd say that is a nice spot for pizza, just be aware that it can be pretty loud and the food might take a while to come out. read more

My Father's Pizza - Roasted chicken sub - no cheese no onions - Pizza Near Me - Black Mountain, North Carolina

Went on a Wednesday night in October. Good atmosphere. The bar service was good. The spinach lasagna arrived in 10 minutes and was very good! read more

Worst lasagna I have ever had. So greasy and disgusting. I only ate a few bites but I had heartburn for 2 days.

Amazing steak sandwich! I honestly enjoyed this and had a great time eating it. It was satisfying to eat because it was easy to eat read more

My Father's Pizza - Steak Sandwich - Pizza Near Me - Black Mountain, North Carolina

I used to give my father's a lot of business. I ordered 7 orders of garlic bread to go, which I had done many many times, and when I got home they messed up the order and sent me with bread sticks. I left a handsome tip for takeout and when I called to get it corrected, they refused to make it right. It blew me away as I had spent thousands over the years. They have gone way downhill. If your visiting my great little town, avoid this place like the plague. There is a great place next door called the trail head. Wayyyyyy better. Mike L read more

I have been visiting My Father's Pizza for years and always try to eat here when in the area. The food is always fresh and yummy! The steak and cheese sandwich, salads and of course pizza are favorites! I want to try the chicken salad bites next time! The bruschetta was delicious! Service is usually fast and friendly. You can sit inside or out depending on the weather. We always prefer the patio if the weather is nice! read more

My Father's Pizza - Bruschetta - Pizza Near Me - Black Mountain, North Carolina

See all

Food was more than phenomenal and outside seating and inside seating are both accessible . Service was more than fantastic and the overall atmosphere was enchanting. Lots of options for food and picky eaters. read more

My Father's Pizza - Margherita pizza. Outside seating. - Pizza Near Me - Black Mountain, North Carolina

I have been coming to My Fathers Pizza since I was a little boy, and it is still the best pizza in Black Mountain.

Came here for dinner this past Friday on our way into Asheville. We had a party of 9 & sat outside. Unfortunately, they weren't able to put the tables together, so we had to sit separately. That was the only downside. The pizza was decent, but the prices were great. It also would have been nice if there was music that played outside, but that wasn't a deal breaker. read more

See all

Hairy Food! Well... it hurts me to have to leave this review. March 7th of 2025, my wife, brother in law, and his wife went out for our birthday celebration. I have visited My Father's regularly over the years. We grew up in the valley and live close by now. My pizza was good but had a hair in my first piece. I politely asked my waitress for another plate. I didn't make a big deal of it, thinking , ok, she'll make it right with me. Nope, she didn't even offer. Is hair in your pizza just acceptable now? I've known the owner for years. I have to say, I'm disappointed . We may not be back for a while. I really hope they read these reviews. It's important to their reputation. read more

Was in the area for a ladies retreat and our group decided to kick off the weekend with lunch at My Father's Pizza. Based on other Yelpers' recommendations, our table chose to share a large Skinny Pig pizza and an antipasto salad. Everything was fresh tasting and delicious! Whenever I find myself in the Black Mountain area, this is a definitely go back. The staff was friendly and the restaurant was roomy enough for our large group to be seated comfortably at two adjacent tables. read more

My Father's Pizza - Skinny Pig Pizza Large - Pizza Near Me - Black Mountain, North Carolina

See all

Amazing place -- ambiance is ok. But food great! Staff friendly and attentive. Love the location. Hope the flood hasn't ruined them.

Not great. Nice servers but the crust is yeastless and ver hard and tasteless. Its very dense and dry, minimal sauce as well.

My Father's Pizza was a 5 all around!! The food was amazing, there was a large enough menu from GF to specialty pizzas. We had gotten the Manzo, the steak was beautifully cooked and juicy, onions were caramelized to perfection, and overall was good. The crust was crispy and a good thickness to support the toppings, but not too thin where the pizza would collapse from the weight of the steak. The lasagna was a hearty portion and delicious. The eggplant Parm was seasoned well too. Our waitress and staff were accommodating since we brought our dogs and said we could sit out on the patio and gave us amazing service. We accidentally dropped the eggplant parm and they quickly cleaned it and ordered us a new one with no problems. The patio has umbrellas and tables to seat slightly larger parties. The restaurant themselves do not take reservations, it is first come, first serve. Order: Manzo Pizza Lasagna Eggplant Parm Catawba White Zombie Bold Rock Cider read more

This is our go to when we visit Grandpa. We always get the sausage and pepperoni pizza. We like how they cut their slices a bit smaller, which helps to regulate- ha! We also like to start with the Greek salad and it is the perfect salad. Highly recommend My Father's Pizza if you are looking for good pizza in the area. read more

This place was great! They seated nine of us in less than half an hour on a Friday night. Nice local draft list reasonably priced. I ordered the large spinach salad and added the smaller size portion of grilled chicken. Salad was huge and delicious and the small portion was plenty of chicken. Everyone in our party loved their food, from pizza to ravioli to calzones. Waitress was friendly and efficient. We'll definitely be back when we're in town. read more

My Father's Pizza - Pisgah Pale Ale - Pizza Near Me - Black Mountain, North Carolina

Best cheesesteak I've had in NC. Went to school in Philly, so am familiar with cheesesteaks. But skipped the mayo and asked for provolone. Lots of mushrooms! read more

The pizza is good but if you order over the phone (on 3/18/25 at 6:15Pm to be specific) the female that answers the phone is super rude it is ridiculous. Might want to try cosmetology school as another professional option. read more

My fathers pizza is a nice family style restaurant that's all about family. I was recommended this place by my brother who is local and said they had the best pizza in the area. So I had to try it. We were seated within 15min of arriving and waited only seconds to be greeted by our server. Everyone who works here is so friendly and attentive to all customers whether it's their table zone or not. This is they type of service you only receive with family owned restaurants like this one. My family and I ordered the garlic rolls , cheese breadsticks, margarita pizza, traditional pizza, the spinach lasagna, the mushroom ravioli, and White Garlic Pizza. Yes this sounds like a lot butttttt it's all worth it. When on vacation you have to try as much as you can and I'm glad I did. Next time in town I'm definitely coming back. And if you haven't tried this place, you better make it a point to. read more

They were SLAMMED. Just blindsided with summer rush on a Wednesday at 5. The staff was young--but they all did a great job. Managing long food order times and huge groups of people waiting for food. They stayed calm and kind and didn't give up. Our food took a little longer than expected but everything was cooked perfectly. Good work guys. read more

We arrived with a Service Dog and the Girl was visibly mad at us! I had all the paperwork but she didn't bother to ask. She stormed by twice and finally agreed to let us sit inside. The service after that was great and the food was great. We will never go back read more

My husband and I ate at My Father's about a month ago, and we ordered "My Father's Supreme" pizza. It took quite a long time to get our pizza -- they were not terribly busy. When the pizza did come, it was very overcooked. The crust was inedible -- it was dry, burnt in places, hard as a rock. I thought it was just a one time thing. Today we got the same type of pizza as a takeout order. Their online ordering was not working and it took 4 calls to get someone to answer the phone. The crust again was inedible. We have other pizza restaurant options, and we will be sticking to those from now on. read more

Excellent service with yummy pizza. The Stromboli was the best! My white pizza with mushrooms was perfect. Our boys had the children's pizza and it didn't disappoint with pepperoni and while pieces of bacon. We highly recommend for pizza and such in the area. read more

My Father's Pizza - White pizza with mushrooms - Pizza Near Me - Black Mountain, North Carolina

See all

Their pizza is so great! Can't believe I'd never been here. Their location is a bit hidden off the road behind the trailhead. We were actually waiting on a table at the trailhead and wandered around to My Father's Pizza. We decided to go here instead and we're so glad we did! Great service, great pizza! We will be back for sure! read more

My Father's Pizza - Yum yum - Pizza Near Me - Black Mountain, North Carolina

See all

Really great pizza!! My husband and I are foodies so we were skeptical but were pleasantly surprised. You can tell the dough is homemade and the sauce was super good. You can't beat the price and the location is great! We sat outdoors on the covered patio and enjoyed our pizza and beers! read more

My Father's Pizza - Great patio! Plenty of shade for the pooches! - Pizza Near Me - Black Mountain, North Carolina

See all

Always delicious and a fun atmosphere! Whenever I am in the area this is a go-to stop! Staff is always kind and attentive. Make this a priority on your next journey! read more

We could smell the delicious pizza outside while plundering in Black Mountain. The taste was just as good as the smell. Quaint pizzeria with a variety of items on the menu. Our waitress very attentive. Would absolutely love to come back! read more

See all

We showed up with a decent sized group and went early for dinner knowing they don't take reservations. We were easily accommodated and food arrived quickly. We had several tasty appetizers- the bruschetta was overdone for my preference (crunchy) but the breadsticks and cheese bread disappeared fast at our table! We ordered several pizzas for our group and thought we'd have leftovers but ate almost all of it- so tasty! It's also not super thick crust so it isn't as filling per slice as you might think. I enjoyed the white pizza especially with garlic, olive oil and cheese- yum! It got really busy as the evening went on so timing is important if you don't want a long wait to sit down! read more

Great food! Amazing service! And cute location with indoor or outdoor seating. I ordered the Meatballs and all my friends ordered pizza. read more

See all

This place has amazing pizza! We have gone here for years and not much has changed, but the food is to die for! The atmosphere is causal. When you walk into the building, a delicious aroma greets you. They have a foosball table in the back which is great for kids or if you have a wait for your table. The garlic breadsticks are heavenly! The inside is so fluffy and they are seasoned to perfection. We also got a gluten-free garlic white pizza and an Italian sub. Everything was amazing! The gluten-free crust is one of the best I have ever had. read more

See all

Too crowded. Very long wait but good food and service once you get in the place. The ambience is loud and hectic. Very much a family place. Large groups and little kids. So if you're looking for a quiet spot- this is not it. Again, that's not bad necessarily, just know what to expect. read more

My stomach does best with gluten free so I had a gluten free with bacon and black olives. Excellent, I had a few pieces left over and the regular pizza eaters ate them with no complaints. I'll be ordering more where that came from. read more