Honest to god one of the best slices of pizza Ive had in San Francisco / Oakland. Very unique too. The crust had an almost sweet flair to it and a great after taste. We were just on our way through the area and stopped for a slice and Im so glad we did. Id go out of my way to have it again! read more

Mustafio's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - San Francisco, California

Why no 5 stars?!?! This area, late night drunks and crackers. And PIZZA COMPETITION like at 3am, I YELP! for what food I can possibly run out of the hotel and drive 5-10 mins to pick up, and it's showing nothing but a long row of pizzerias. "Damn!!!" I shout inside my disappointed head. The usual pizza only, (or convenience store styrofoam cup trash ramen.) Last thing I need is a gut full of greasy colon clogger food this late while I'm traveling and oh.. here in town for gastrointestinal care. So I see there's a dinner. One NOT pizza option. I go get a slice of peach pie with a micro side of ice cream, for $20, pick up. Inhaled it in the car. Wasn't enough. So I decide to maybe just get one slice of pizza at the other option. But WHICH ONE?! Out of 100 joints to choose from maybe? Obviously NOT Pizza Hut, for I am a foodie SNOB. My eye kept wandering to this spot, I don't know what drew me to it repeatedly with only scanning the surface. I click on it. Hmmm looks like it'll work, it's got slices. WINNER! (So was the amazing $20 total pie slice at the cute dinner. Lucky night). The crust, the options, the good vibes; dude is very friendly and generous as well. Good person. You know it's made with love and passion and total confidence. This is definitely one of the best in the US. if you're a pizza connoisseur or snob, add this spot on your pizza wish list. read more

Pizza pizza happy times ..different one mustafios..more pizza...offers square pizza with pepperoni ..funny ..with a soda

Halloween weekend was probably one of the more chaotic times to visit Mustafio's Pizza, but I enjoyed it! The pizza shop was busy, but luckily there was no wait to order. The owner kept rushing us though, which led to an unnecessarily stressful ordering experience. It was also unclear whether or not they accepted credit cards, because he kept shouting "cash is better!". We placed our order, grabbed a high-top table, and our slices came out almost immediately. I really loved my Chicken Pesto slice - great flavors, generous amounts of chicken! It was also very filling and ended up being the perfect lunch/snack for an afternoon of bar hopping. Would return! read more

See all

He even cut my pizza into pieces for my drunk ass!!! It was soooooo good!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! read more

Mustafio's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - San Francisco, California

Great pizza! Amazing after bar hopping on Polk streeet and the owner is super nice. Juicy and heated up quick and they close at 4am read more

Mustafio's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - San Francisco, California

I come here late at night, and I don't know what he puts in the pizza, but it's the best tasting pizza I ever had (I only get the pepperoni) Always have a fun little chat, everyone is really nice, and it has some nice seating! read more

Genuinely the pizza was so good. We came in not expecting much but as soon as we took a bite we looked at each other and laughed because it was so good. The perfect late night bite while bar hopping on Polk. I'll be obsessively dreaming about this one for a while! read more

This was the worst food delivery I have had in a VERY long time. They are on UberEats, Doordash, Seamless, Grubhub and Postmates under the name "THE FARMERS SALAD" but it is the same restaurant, same address, and same pizza boxes as this place, so they are operating under a different name on the food apps. Salad: The salad was described as "Fresh romaine lettuce with your choice of toppings" and I added cucumber, chicken, spinach, carrots. See the attached picture of what it looked like. Barely any toppings. The chicken was rubbery and it looked like that pre-cooked chicken that had been sitting in a refrigerator for days or the kind you buy frozen and just let thaw. Not worth the extra $5 for the chicken. My salad was also warm so I wondered how long it sat out for. The Meatballs: They sent me meatballs for delivery in TIN FOIL. I have never seen a restaurant deliver meatballs like this. Why would they not put them in a safe container with a lid? They just put meatballs in tin foil, and used the tinfoil as a bowl and poured sauce and cheese on top and wrapped it up. The cheese and sauce stuck to the tinfoil when I opened it and I couldn't even eat it. Pieces of tin foil were also stick in my food, rendering this unable to eat. The meatballs thus arrived cold and I wondered how long they sat out for too. My house is not that far from the restaurant so my food should have been at a proper temperature. I called the restaurant and they said this was all normal (yes, including the tin foil. I had thought they ran out of take out dishes). The staff told me they do not use to-go containers for the meatball dishes. Poor quality, unappealing presentation, and terrible packaging. Dear restaurant owner, please invest some money in some to-go containers. read more

Mustafio's Pizza - a plate of meat and a salad - Pizza Near Me - San Francisco, California

See all

Walking by, it's hard not to stare at the pizza in the window and honestly it's what drew me into this place. It was a busy night on Polk st. and the pizzas were looking hot n fresh. However, I decided against it at the time but made my way back a couple days later and what I learned is that when coming here, I think time makes a difference. The first time I came here was on a random weekday night (sober) looking for a quick bite, and the pizza tasted as if it had been sitting there for a while. I decided to give the pepperoni a shot and they reheated the slice and I ate it there. The dough was overly crispy and the cheese and sauce lacked flavor. It's a pretty big slice for under $5, so if you are looking to get full, one of these would do the trick. The next visit, I was out with some friends at the bars, and this was the closest slice so I gave em the ol college try again. This time I went with the chicken pesto and plain cheese. Chicken pesto was definitely my favorite of the two. The trick that made it better for me was not asking them to reheat it and I did it myself at home. If you wanna know the trick to reheating pizza correctly, it's through the air-fryer, which is basically a convection oven. This made the pizza taste way better and wasn't dried out like the first time. I think the best time to come is after the bars, when the lines are long and they are pumping out pizzas constantly. It's not my favorite pizza, but after a night out, it serves its purpose. If you can get it hot n fresh, go for it. If you have to reheat it, take it home and use that air-fryer, you'll thank me later. read more

Best place to go when you're out on Polk Street for the late night much! Clean bathrooms, cheap pizza, quality everything

Mmm mmm mmm delicious pizza. Nuff said. Great price too. Thank you Stepped out for a midnight snack and found this place. Very satisfying read more

Mustafio's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - San Francisco, California

See all

Great pizza! Grabbed a slice to go and was pleasantly surprised! Might be the best pizza on polk.

Very disappointing! I really expected a restaurant on such a busy street to be so much better! I came in and was super friendly to the man at the door, Zeke, who I later learned was the owner. I politely ordered then asked about the restroom. Once in the restroom there was not a shred of toilet paper nor paper towels. Once I left the horrible situation I let zeke know that there was nothing to utilize in the restroom and he said yes we do not keep any type of toilet paper or paper towel in there because the homeless steal. And I said I definitely understand that but as a paying customer I would've appreciated a notice or you could only reserve the toilet paper for those who are genuinely customers at your restaurant. The owner did not care and proceeded to say that even customers steal from him so there is no point. It was pretty sad as I try to support small businesses as much as possible but it's clear this city has tainted this owners perspective on humanity. I will not be returning! Hopefully there can be a change in this attitude moving forward! read more

Mustafio's Pizza - This is the Chicken Pesto Pizza. Served very cold and with no customer service :( - Pizza Near Me - San Francisco, California

Ain't bad, ain't amazing. Filling slice. Staff was super friendly and it was a quick purchase. Not much else to say. Check out the photograph. read more

Mustafio's Pizza - Pepperoni Pizza Slice - Pizza Near Me - San Francisco, California

Best slice of pizza I had for the price they charge. Just ran into this shop while walking on the street, never heard of it before (I was visiting SFO from SEA), was presently surprised with the first bite and devoured it till the end. read more

Pizza and mustafio is amazing ! Amazing customer service! Great pizza! Great customer service!

The Bachelor Party Finale...for some of us at least...it was almost 1:00AM when the bachelor party I was with arrived at Mustafio's. If you're drunk, or high, or both this pizza might be seem absolutely delicious. Probably the best pizza you've ever had in your life, and it'll help prevent a hangover, or at least lessen the pain...5 Stars. If you're sober, I'm pretty sure this is just really average pizza. Maybe worse. At least these $4.50 slices are huge...3 Stars. So I'll just do the math and say its 4 Stars. Tourist Tip: Last call in San Francisco is 1:45am...plan accordingly. read more

See all

Calzone was a piece of art ' with spinach, ham, and olives, all in perfect harmony, the flavor sang like an angel. read more

Mustafio's Pizza - he mastered dough across five or six decades, not really sure, but easily on par (or exceeding) the finest calzones in Italy - Pizza Near Me - San Francisco, California

Great service, first time coming here- deff coming back again. Guy was working alone, very attentive, great service and worked fast. Now food wise, the chicken wings were great. The pizza was very tasty ! read more

Mustafio's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - San Francisco, California

See all

amazing spot! The owner is very nice please come here. The food is very good. I saw this owner give free pizza to a homeless man, this owner is a real one. Suppprt your small business yall!!!! helll yeaa read more

This place is one of my favorite. Great pizza and staff! Nice place to enjoy a late night snack!

Amazing pizza. Way too good for it to be open till 3am but thankfully it is. Also in a great location, highly recommend

A great option for a late night bite. Shakh was very helpful when I picked my pizza!!! Pizza is the best on Polk St!

Went in there late last weekend. Should have known better after the couple before me walked in and walked right back out. I order a slice and guy behind counter tells me he will include a second slice for free since he is closing. He then proceeds to charge me $10. I tell him I thought you were going to give me the second slice for free and I don't even want a second slice. He says sorry and removes the second slice from the box and says it will just be $6. He then goes ahead and rings me up for $7.28 Beyond that the place was dirty. The guy making the pizza and trying to cheat me also didn't look too clean himself. There are many pizza places in the area, go elsewhere, anything would be better read more

This is a nice pizza place. The pizza slices are square. The toppings are generous. Overall, their pizzas are good. I also like their Tiramisu cake. The place is clean. Customer service is good. They are open late. Since there are so many pizza places in San Francisco, it is hard to give it more than 3 stars. Other than the shape of the pizza, there is nothing really unique or special about their pizza. read more

See all

Overview: Very greasy - yet flavorful - pepperoni pizza by the slice. A box will cost an extra .35 and well worth it to absorb all the grease. When I first opened my pizza box and saw all the grease absorbed into the cardboard I had a knee jerk reaction -- and the reaction wasn't a positive one. Ambiance: Cool vibe inside. Great seating. Friendly workers create a warm and welcoming space. My advice to you: Order plain cheese. I have suspicion the grease was mostly from pepperoni.... Right as you get it place a few napkins on top and bottom - a real pizza eating sin according to my Italian friend... something I've never done before because of growing up with my Italian friend. About me: I was perfectly sober like a Mormon when eating this pizza. Also, I've had the best pizza in the city - Tonys, Mozzeria, Firetrail, & Golden Boy. I've easly become a pizza snob as a result. Also if anything is really good I become price insensitive. Conclusion: Perhaps if i was really drunk - lets face it... this place caters to the late night bar crowds.... I would have loved it. Will do my best to come back and re order and try a more plain pizza slice... and update this review... If I had ordered a plain cheese I would guess I would have rated this much higher - keep that in mind in consideration of my review. read more

See all

Went to order a sandwich on Uber eats the prices were ridiculous so I went to check reviews couldn't find the place in question.. Come to find out this place has a fake Uber eats shop called "olivias sandwich's" where they have made it look as if it's a completely separate location and they're charging almost double for the same things on their menu. Skeevy. read more

See all

This place had a very delicious cheese slice. All I tried and my review is based on the cheese slice. There was lots seating inside. I found this place refreshing especially with all the pizza offerings in the area. The best part of this place was the painting of Al Pacino Scarface. Will have to try the other pizza toppings. read more

See all

Cute and nostalgic pizza for sure. Hits the spot, great service. Pizza doesnt have to be fancy, thin, or triangular! Just look at that takeout box. read more

See all

This is a GREAT pizza spot. They deliver by the slice as well, and the pizza is Halal, which is why they've earner extra brownie points from me. I ordered the chicken pesto and pepperoni, both were scrumptious! Would definitely recommend! read more

Mustafio's Pizza - Cheese Pepperoni Pizza Slice Chicken Pesto Pizza - Pizza Near Me - San Francisco, California

You are better off ordering dominoes. At least they won't be rude, and at least dominoes will add red sauce

The best pizza place to come when on polk st!!! Great service and great pizza!! 10/10 would recommend!

Very friendly guy , good spot to get a late night slice very good pizza small hidden spot but very clean space

Great pizza! One of the best cheese slices in the City! Just discovered this place and will definitely go back.

Immensely incredible Pizza, immensely nice owner. Definitely will come back if around.

I had this when I was drunk, I thought it was good. I tried it when I was sober, I thought it was good. So I think it's good. Recommendation still: pesto chicken pizza with a side of ranch. GIT IT. read more

Pizza is tasteless and overpriced for no good reason. Owner is rude. I asked for a specific piece and he acted like he couldn't hear me. He barely warmed it up for me. I am such a pizza lover and was starving yet this was absolutely disappointing. And why is it 4 dollars for a tiny piece of cheese pizza? An ALARMING note. Server came by with whatever dirty water, owner touch it and did NoT wash his hands before taking my box and placing my pizza in it. Disgusting and against ALL FOOD HANDLING BASICS. Seriously if you want a good, reasonably priced and tasty pizza go to either Golden Boy Pizza or Pizza Milan. They are both superlative, kind and clean at service and definitely under 4 dollars pour slice! read more

Came here via the Yelp Elite event and was quite happy to find a decent pizza place since I've moved out here! Came back afterwards to see how they did without the special Yelp event treatment and still was happy! Pizza slices range from $3.25 to $4.50. Before you jump the gun and be all "I can get a $1 slice pizza", this isn't your typical super thin triangle pizza. When I say these slices are big, I mean they are HUGE for the price you are paying. I could have easily been full with just one slice of cheese pizza, but I got two as part of the Yelp event. I base my pizza reviews mainly off of the simplest pizza - the cheese pizza - b/c there's no point in eating something with tons of condiments if you can't even get the most basic pizza down. I must say that I was pretty satisfied with it- crust was thick enough that you can pick it up without it flopping over (if it's not too hot out of the oven), and not too much cheese that you would enter a food coma. Thankfully not too much grease either- sometimes I find myself dabbing my slices with a napkin but this time I didn't really need to do it. I also had a slice of their Hawaiian pizza- I liked how the pineapple chunks were small/ plentiful enough that you didn't have to tear through a piece/ awkwardly drag it off the slice when you bit into it but there was enough to give it a sweetness to cut the saltiness from the bacon and ham. One thing to note- the pizza slices are thick so if you are a fork and knife person (like me), it might be a bit thick to cut. Luckily, the waitress offered to cut my slice into smaller parts, but otherwise I recommend just waiting for it to cool before using your hands (since as I said before, the slices don't get too soggy / become limp). If you are out on Polk, craving pizza, and want a bang-for-your-buck, I'd recommend Mustafio's! Added bonus- if you check in on Yelp, free garlic bread when you order a pie of pizza (need to check this out eventually). read more

Mustafio's Pizza - Cheese and Hawaiian pizza slices- they are huge... - Pizza Near Me - San Francisco, California

Meh it does its job. The gyro is different but ok. The pizza I need to try again fresh. Not that great after it has been sitting around. For the area and if you need something quick it will do the trick. read more

Mustafio's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - San Francisco, California