Cancel

Open app

Search

Murder Mystery Manhattan

5.0 (7 reviews)
Open • Open 24 hours

Murder Mystery Manhattan Photos

You might also consider

Recommended Reviews - Murder Mystery Manhattan

Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
Yelp app icon
Browse more easily on the app
Review Feed Illustration

2 years ago

Business owner information

Photo of Keith D.

Keith D.

Helpful 1
Thanks 1
Love this 1
Oh no 0

2 years ago

Business owner information

Photo of Keith D.

Keith D.

Helpful 1
Thanks 1
Love this 1
Oh no 1

2 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

2 years ago

Business owner information

Photo of Keith D.

Keith D.

Thank you, Marie. Hope to see you at a show soon!

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

2 years ago

Business owner information

Photo of Keith D.

Keith D.

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

2 years ago

Business owner information

Photo of Keith D.

Keith D.

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

2 years ago

Business owner information

Photo of Keith D.

Keith D.

Helpful 0
Thanks 1
Love this 1
Oh no 0

Ask the Community - Murder Mystery Manhattan

Verify this business for free

Get access to customer & competitor insights.

Verify this business

The Dinner Detective - Early into the evening one of my kids had a 'starring role' for a minute...

The Dinner Detective

4.0(4 reviews)
57.3 mi•Civic Center, TriBeCa

My kids turned 17 and we wanted to celebrate with something unique and... this delivered…read more The food: four courses (kinda-sorta), small portions, better than what we expected. (I'm assuming the grub came from the trattoria above us.) Lots of flavor, a few entrée options to pick from (made ahead of time) to appease any preferences or dietary restrictions. My only issue was whoever was working the salad station was entirely too heavy-handed with the sliced radishes. Ease up on those next time, partner. The show: exactly what you probably expect/fear/need/want - equal parts goofy and interesting, ridiculous and intriguing. It's well thought out, constructed and paced. (We were 'warned' from the start - how much 'we' put into it is what we'd be getting back out and that's legit... some people were completely "in it" and you could tell they loved every second of the adventure, whereas my in-laws started to fade after about 90 minutes.) I should fess up I was positive my "thinking outside of the box" was going to snag me the win but I completely flubbed and it's safe to assume my final guess was the WORST one of the night. (Some advice: pay attention to ALL the clues. Don't try to be too damn clever or it'll bite you in the rump!) The three hours went by smoothly... lots of laughs, lots of interacting with the other diners (suspects!) as well as the actors and before you knew it - crimes were being solved, tabs were being closed and it was time to head back into the cruel streets of the city that never sleeps. Biggest issue (aside from the radishes!) - parking, of course. (A few blocks away was the only option and that added another $50+ to an already expensive night.) We were a party of seven (which is how many were seated per table) and I think we would've had an even better time had we been split up or went as a smaller group (so we could mix-and-match with other people, including the performers). Most definitely worth checking out if you're out for some fun that can appease (older) teens to their grandparents.

On the Saturday July 26th NYC show, one of your male actors and later 'victims' was noticeably…read moregetting high during the show. Given how expensive the tickets are, this is not what I was expecting from a Manhattan production and extremely unfair to the audience. Please use actors who respect their jobs - he was a taller white male with brown hair who kept sneaking off to the bathroom and coming back smelling of weed.

Photos
The Dinner Detective - My final guess was a 'grave mistake'...

My final guess was a 'grave mistake'...

The Dinner Detective - Join us and find out if you are a suspect!

Join us and find out if you are a suspect!

The Dinner Detective - Something happened here......

See all

Something happened here......

Pines Dinner Theatre - made from scratch french onion soup

Pines Dinner Theatre

4.4(18 reviews)
93.4 mi
•$$

The tables are so close that I had no room to move my chair in order to view the stage better…read more Seating is very cramped with no leg room. The play (School of Rock) was boring and most of the instruments were little better than toys - sound was obviously controlled from backstage. Even soda and water were overpriced. Needed to have another employee get our waitress so we could pay our bill. No credits, no refunds, so if you can't make the show, you are royally screwed. Would never return here again.

Pines Dinner Theatre is such a fun spot and perfect for a date night or special celebration. I love…read morethe setup -- dinner first, then the first half of the show, dessert, and then the rest of the show. It keeps the night flowing and makes it feel like a full experience. The theatre itself is nice and simple, and I like that you pick your table ahead of time. From the moment we sat down, every staff member greeted us, which was such a nice touch. They walked us through how the night would go, and everything felt super organized. For appetizers, we had mac and cheese and bruschetta -- both solid choices. The mac and cheese was simple but tasty, and the bruschetta was fresh and flavorful. For entrées, we went with the salmon (roasted potatoes & string beans) and the filet mignon (same sides). The salmon was a little overcooked, and I do wish we could have picked our own sides, but it wasn't a dealbreaker. Everything was still good. Dessert was hands down the highlight. The apple crisp and brownie sundae were amazing. And then the show... wow. The acting, the singing, the dancing; all fantastic. They absolutely crushed Footloose! Definitely recommend this place if you want dinner and a show all in one. I'd go again in a heartbeat. 1000000000/10 recommend.

Photos
Pines Dinner Theatre
Pines Dinner Theatre - Fresh baked baguette with melted garlic herb butter

Fresh baked baguette with melted garlic herb butter

Pines Dinner Theatre

See all

Alamo Drafthouse Cinema Yonkers

Alamo Drafthouse Cinema Yonkers

3.5(823 reviews)
43.1 mi
•$$

The staff is very nice; tickets are easy to purchase online. My favorite feature of Alamo…read moreDrafthouse theaters is the QUIET in the theater during the film. Patrons are respectful of others here. The QR-menu ordering system was problematic, awkward, and time consuming. I imagine if you're an Alamo Drafthouse regular who is locked-in on what to order and memorized the process already, nbd. But it was a hassle for me. Plus, I used to enjoy the brief but pleasant interactions with the staff during the ordering process. Also, at this particular location the bathrooms could be a bit cleaner.

On 9/13/2026, I went to Alamo to see practical magic 2 the 2:40PM showing in theater 1 and the food…read moreand drinks were fine and so was the staff. However, towards the middle of the movie we heard squeaking pretty loudly behind us and the people behind us heard it too. It just made us cringe and it was hard to focus on the movie after hearing all that squeaking. We had to every now and then bang on our seats in hopes it will stop or they don't come near us. After hearing that it made us feel uneasy of what we just consumed during the movie. We were liking this theater and the experience but after hearing the squeaks , doubt we'll come back unless they fix this issue asap. Based on the comments in Google it seems it has been happening for a few months now and nothing has been made to fix this rodent problem.

Photos
Alamo Drafthouse Cinema Yonkers - Screening room one, third row, center seats. Notice the tables? No separate trays.  Menu under the table with a dim light to see it.

Screening room one, third row, center seats. Notice the tables? No separate trays. Menu under the table with a dim light to see it.

Alamo Drafthouse Cinema Yonkers - Truffle parm popcorn

Truffle parm popcorn

Alamo Drafthouse Cinema Yonkers - Key lime pie

See all

Key lime pie

Murder Mystery Manhattan - dinnertheater - Updated October 2026

Loading...
Loading...
Loading...