Cancel

    Open app

    Search

    The Dinner Detective

    4.0 (4 reviews)
    Open 11:00 am - 6:00 pm

    The Dinner Detective Dinner Theater Restaurant Photos

    THE DINNER DETECTIVE ATMOSPHERE

    What's the vibe?

    You might also consider

    Recommended Reviews - The Dinner Detective

    Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
    Yelp app icon
    Browse more easily on the app
    Review Feed Illustration

    5 months ago

    Helpful 4
    Thanks 2
    Love this 5
    Oh no 0

    9 months ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0
    Photo of Mark O.
    49
    15
    1

    7 years ago

    Business owner information

    Photo of Ian B.

    Ian B.

    Helpful 1
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    7 years ago

    I loved this show the cast was amazing and it was a blast trying to figure it out how was the killer

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    Ask the Community - The Dinner Detective

    You might also consider

    Gayle's Broadway Rose

    Gayle's Broadway Rose

    4.3(215 reviews)
    3.3 miTheater District, Midtown West
    $$

    I'll be back! So…read morethis was my second time at Friedman's, different location than the previous night. Got the Elphaba and Galinda lemonade matcha drink. FABULOUS. The burger was immaculate. Unfortunately they don't have regular barbecue sauce or deli mustard so I opted for the garlic aioli. That was it! Get the garlic aioli. At the other location, I got the honey mustard and the herb aioli. Wasn't doing the job. I needed the garlic aioli! Big shoutout to them for taking allergies seriously. I didn't not react the next day. I rarely eat fries in the wild because of cross contamination in fryers so this was nice. Love love love the singing wait staff.

    What a fun evening at Gayle's! The servers take turns singing songs, and also do some group numbers…read more-- and they've got CHOPS. I definitely felt we were seeing and hearing a number of future Broadway stars! The place was PACKED -- and although some folks got in without reservations, a reservation is highly recommended, and a must if you're in a group. The food was really good -- I had a burger; my partner got the chicken sandwich; and our friend, who wasn't as hungry, had the matzoh ball soup. I had sweet potato fries, which were delicious -- as were the regular fries, which my partner got. We were too full for dessert, but what we had we really liked -- and our server couldn't have been nicer or more attentive. A heads up that it's LOUD there -- so this is a place you go to have a good time, not deep, meaningful conversations! I'm excited to go back and hear more -- if you visit their website, you can read about the servers. Lots of talented folks working there!

    Photos
    Gayle's Broadway Rose - EMPTY RESTAURANT on a Thursday night at 7 pm in the theater district. There's a reason why.

    EMPTY RESTAURANT on a Thursday night at 7 pm in the theater district. There's a reason why.

    Gayle's Broadway Rose
    Gayle's Broadway Rose - Galinda and Alphaba mocktail

    See all

    Galinda and Alphaba mocktail

    Truffles Mystery : Immersive - A whodunnit like never before....come immersive yourself in character for Truffles Mystery!

    Truffles Mystery : Immersive

    4.0(70 reviews)
    2.7 miMidtown West
    $$$$

    I hosted my 40th birthday party with Truffles Mystery at their Cranford, NJ venue and it was by far…read moreone of my best birthday parties ever! The storyline was awesome and everyone got to play a role: some friendships, some backstabbing. It was hilarious to see everyone get into their characters. The production crew made sure everything ran smoothly and that we didn't run astray but still allowed the story to manifest according to what each character was saying. Having a private venue with small bites being passed around and a bartender elevated the party to the next level. It's been almost a week and everyone is still talking about it. I am so so grateful I found Truffles Mystery Immersive and Sonia!

    We were a party of eight...a great time!! It was so much fun, the characters were fun AND funny…read moreand the musicians top notch. Piano player was killer! It wasn't interactive so much that you felt uncomfortable but you definitely felt like you were a part of this zany comedy. The food was delicious (oh so good truffles!) and the actors and all the staff were welcoming and sweet. Everyone did an amazing job -- even the waitstaff. Overall, a great night out!! Would highly recommend Truffles!

    Photos
    Truffles Mystery : Immersive - Ahhh, the glory, the magic, the "truffle" in full display @ Truffles Mystery Immersive- Now playing @ Secret Room NYC! Get your tickets now!

    Ahhh, the glory, the magic, the "truffle" in full display @ Truffles Mystery Immersive- Now playing @ Secret Room NYC! Get your tickets now!

    Truffles Mystery : Immersive - View from our seats

    View from our seats

    Truffles Mystery : Immersive - That's my "shy" boo on stage with the cast.

    See all

    That's my "shy" boo on stage with the cast.

    Paradise Club

    Paradise Club

    4.3(113 reviews)
    3.3 miTheater District, Midtown West

    NYC's Wildest Multi-Course Dinner Party right now!…read more Born at EDC in Las Vegas, Salvage City Supper Cclub brings its chaotic multi-sensory dining experience to Paradise Club -- blending Michelin-level dining with acrobatics, live performances, music, art and ritual-driven storytelling. The entire night felt raw, immersive and completely unpredictable -- felt like stepping into another reality for a few hours. Definitely one of NYC's most unique nights out right now. Dates till August only! Don't miss out! Check out their website for details. Follow me @foodie.elite on IG and Tiktok for more great finds.

    Came here for the Moonrise show. You line up in the lobby along the left side and once they're…read moreready to let you up, they scan your tickets once you get to the elevator bank. Upon exiting the elevator they make you feel like you enter "paradise", do some tarot card reading by asking for your birthdate, and then get some beads with perfume dropped on them depending on which card you got. After all of that, none of those stuff mattered. We were served a three course meal before the actual aerobics show happened, but they still had performers perform while we had our meals or a few drinks. I enjoyed their Crescent Dip, which is a hummus dip with whipped feta and comes with a massive chip. The Full Moon Rice I wasn't really a fan of. After those two, they came out with the entree, which they called Fire, Water, Earth; essentially beet, halibut, and short rib. These were alright, not amazing. The third and final course came during the intermission of the show, which was a bunch of dessert treats and they were delicious. The show itself was fantastic. It was more than just aerobics, has there are also singing, dancing, and violinist. You may get wet in the front so FYI. There's also some fire involved. Overall, a well put together show. I'd probably skip the food, but the drinks were great.

    Photos
    Paradise Club
    Paradise Club
    Paradise Club

    See all

    Fondudes

    Fondudes

    4.9(12 reviews)
    2.9 miMidtown West

    Okay, so I really wasn't too sure what to expect from Fondudes. All I knew was that none of the…read moreladies in the bachelorette were down for seeing full on strippers, we're not into clubbing.. we do like shows (theater, comedy) but then we would have to be quiet during most of it. We were looking for a fun and unique experience that we wouldn't get elsewhere. I won't give away the exact details of what happens from start to finish, but we all had a blast!! It was a lot of improv, and their main goal is to make sure that the group has a good time. So yes, they will try to be outrageous and push the boundaries - but not in a bad way. They are good at reading the room and working with that. If you have a crazy insane group, or a tame one, they will try to make sure there's a good energy flowing. Our bride is pretty straight-laced / conservative, but she had such a great time!! Just a tip - if you're doing it in a hotel room, or somewhere where they quiet time by a certain time, make sure you book them to come well before quiet time. We had security knocking on the door to tell us to shut up right at 11pm, so just make sure you get the guys in by 9pm or however long the show is meant to go on for.

    Just went to a fondudes party last week, and it was SO. MUCH. FUN. We booked fondudes for my…read morefriend's bachelorette party, and we all had a GREAT time! Our friend especially loved it, because it's definitely not your typical bachelorette party. The performance was HILARIOUS, the actors were FUNNY, SWEET, and SEXY, and (a personal favorite of mine) the whole concept was SO WITTY! For example, two of the (delicious, by the way) fondues were named "Chai Me to the Bed" and "Pound me like a S'more." On the practical side, booking the party was really easy too - they were super professional and helpful in working with us to choose the fondues & type of performance. I'd highly recommend it to anyone looking for a silly, fun party idea!

    Photos
    Fondudes
    Fondudes
    Fondudes

    See all

    IPIC New York City

    IPIC New York City

    3.4(814 reviews)
    0.6 miSouth Street Seaport

    I am writing to share the wonderful experience I had during a recent visit to see "The Devil Wears…read morePrada." The service was impeccable, particularly thanks to Travis. When he checked our tickets, he surprised us with an upgrade that truly enhanced our evening. After the movie, we expressed our gratitude and were deeply impressed by his professional and humble demeanor. Travis also took the time to tell us about special events at the Speakeasy and even allowed us to take some photos. His exceptional service made our visit memorable, and we will certainly make IPIC our primary theater moving forward.

    I went to iPic with my cousin to see The Devil Wears Prada 2. I usually go to Alamo Drafthouse, but…read morewe decided to try something new--and unfortunately, it was a pretty disappointing experience. The staff came across as nonchalant and not very engaged, which set the tone right away. The food didn't help either--the spicy tuna was completely flavorless, not crispy and the drinks were underwhelming. We also weren't told ahead of time that you have to pick up your food and drinks yourself, which was surprising since we're used to full service at your seat. On the positive side, the popcorn and truffle fries were decent, but everything else fell short. The seats were just okay--not particularly comfortable. The bathroom situation was also frustrating--it's located upstairs near the restaurant and wasn't well maintained. There were no paper towels, and overall cleanliness was lacking. Overall, this felt like a subpar experience, and I won't be returning. My cousin mentioned the New Jersey location is much better, so maybe it's just this one--but based on this visit, I wouldn't recommend it.

    Photos
    IPIC New York City
    IPIC New York City
    IPIC New York City - IPIC Theater Exterior at Fulton Market New York

    See all

    IPIC Theater Exterior at Fulton Market New York

    Murdered by the Mob Dinner Theater

    Murdered by the Mob Dinner Theater

    3.0(93 reviews)
    3.2 miMidtown West, Theater District, Hell's Kitchen
    $$

    Twenty-five of my family descended upon the Murdered by the Mob family last week and they could not…read morehave handled it any better than they did. It was really perfect. They managed to include almost everyone of us in some capacity, and had us all laughing from the time we arrived to the minute we left. the wait staff at the club were friendly and professional and while it is a pre-fixe menu of chicken parmigiana, pasta with vodka sauce and salad with mini cannolis for dessert , they were very happy to accommodate special dietary needs, in our case it was a severe gluten allergy and a strict vegetarian. The group of actors were so kind to take pictures with us at the end and kept us all laughing even after the show ended. We spent the whole night laughing with the actors, at the actors, at each other, at ourselves and with each other. Truly what fond memories are made of. if You are looking for a unique fun filled interactive experience you should definitely check out Murdered by the Mob.

    Great silly fun! I heard it's been running for years and had never seen it so my posse and I had a…read morenight out. We dressed up and had so much fun being incorporated into the show. There was a group celebrating bachelorette night, anniversaries, birthdays and some tourists and it looks like we all had a ball. Great atmosphere in The Secret Room and a fun cast that knew how to mingle in character.

    Photos
    Murdered by the Mob Dinner Theater
    Murdered by the Mob Dinner Theater - Entrance to show...

    Entrance to show...

    Murdered by the Mob Dinner Theater

    See all

    Medieval Times Dinner & Tournament - Chocolate Eclair (Dessert)

    Medieval Times Dinner & Tournament

    4.0(954 reviews)
    8.3 mi
    $$$

    My family and I was so surprised coming to Medieval Times. We had no idea! We were told to be ready…read moreand we had to head out to NJ. We are all excited but still had no idea where until I saw the castle and I froze. Like, wow! I have been wanting to come here since I was young and that wish came true. The ambiance inside the castle and the staff were so welcoming and very into their characters. It was so cool to see and experience. The concession stands had really nice items to buy and great photo ops. As we were waiting to go inside, my boys were knighted and that was so cool to see as they were having the time of their lives! As we were walking towards our section to sit down, we saw a royal falcon, which was pretty cool. As time is getting closer, we are now waiting to be seated. My family and I and everyone around us was so excited to finally go inside, sit down, and enjoy the show. We are finally in our seats excited for this moment. Our server Isaac was awesome!!!! (FOR ANYONE READ THIS OR TAKES A TRIP OUT THERE, TIP YOUR SERVERS) For anyone who hasn't been there I just don't want to spoil the moment but what I can say is I 1000% recommend this!!!!!!!

    We visited Medieval Times Dinner & Tournament recently and while the kids had a great time, the…read moreoverall experience felt extremely overwhelming from start to finish. The line to get inside, the line for pictures, and even trying to find our seating created a very chaotic atmosphere. We made a reservation for 9 people but were seated for 8, which resulted in two children having to share a chair. That was disappointing and felt unfair, especially considering the cost of the experience. The show itself was entertaining and the host was very kind, but the food was just mediocre. The potato was dry, and the chicken was unevenly seasoned -- one section had an overwhelming amount of seasoning while other parts had very little. For the amount of money spent, everything felt just "okay" rather than worth the price. Leaving the venue was also stressful. Guests for the next show were entering while our crowd was trying to exit, causing everyone to crash into each other and making the experience feel even more chaotic. Overall, the kids enjoyed themselves, but as an adult, the entire experience was overstimulating and not something I would personally rush to do again.

    Photos
    Medieval Times Dinner & Tournament
    Medieval Times Dinner & Tournament - Roast Chicken

    Roast Chicken

    Medieval Times Dinner & Tournament

    See all

    The Dinner Detective - dinnertheater - Updated May 2026

    Loading...
    Loading...
    Loading...