Cancel

    Open app

    Search

    The Dinner Detective

    4.0 (4 reviews)
    Closed Closed

    The Dinner Detective Photos

    THE DINNER DETECTIVE ATMOSPHERE

    What's the vibe?

    You might also consider

    Recommended Reviews - The Dinner Detective

    Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
    Yelp app icon
    Browse more easily on the app
    Review Feed Illustration

    8 months ago

    Helpful 4
    Thanks 2
    Love this 5
    Oh no 0

    1 year ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0
    Photo of Mark O.
    49
    15
    1

    7 years ago

    Business owner information

    Photo of Ian B.

    Ian B.

    Helpful 1
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    7 years ago

    I loved this show the cast was amazing and it was a blast trying to figure it out how was the killer

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    Ask the Community - The Dinner Detective

    You might also consider

    Gayle's Broadway Rose

    Gayle's Broadway Rose

    4.3
    (225 reviews)
    3.3 mi
    $$

    I'll be back! So…read morethis was my second time at Friedman's, different location than the previous night. Got the Elphaba and Galinda lemonade matcha drink. FABULOUS. The burger was immaculate. Unfortunately they don't have regular barbecue sauce or deli mustard so I opted for the garlic aioli. That was it! Get the garlic aioli. At the other location, I got the honey mustard and the herb aioli. Wasn't doing the job. I needed the garlic aioli! Big shoutout to them for taking allergies seriously. I didn't not react the next day. I rarely eat fries in the wild because of cross contamination in fryers so this was nice. Love love love the singing wait staff.

    We truly enjoyed Gayle's Broadway Rose. First of all, the food was very good: I had a fear that the…read moreentrees would be mediocre and you were paying just for the experience, but that wasn't the case. The service was friendly, quite efficient (perfect for a reservation before a Broadway show, because they're going to make sure that you get out in time!), and the food was all fresh and really well made. My salmon entrée was great, and my daughter loved her BLT. I ordered an espresso martini, and it took a while for the bar to make it (they were pretty backed up), but then the server comped it after it came, which I hadn't even asked for and I really appreciate it. It was so much fun to have our friendly server then take the mic and offer a wonderful performance. The servers they really are stars! My only complaint: while they say that you can see the performances at every table, we were sitting in the bar area, and there were definitely a couple performances where the people did not walk over to our side of the restaurant at all. I would hope that they are reminded to move about the restaurant so that everyone gets a performance experience, because we felt a little short changed with that element.

    Photos
    Applauding the excellent performances
    Applauding the excellent performances
    Gayle's Broadway Rose
    Galinda and Alphaba mocktail

    See all

    Galinda and Alphaba mocktail
    Paradise Club

    Paradise Club

    4.3
    (114 reviews)
    3.3 mi

    NYC's Wildest Multi-Course Dinner Party right now!…read more Born at EDC in Las Vegas, Salvage City Supper Cclub brings its chaotic multi-sensory dining experience to Paradise Club -- blending Michelin-level dining with acrobatics, live performances, music, art and ritual-driven storytelling. The entire night felt raw, immersive and completely unpredictable -- felt like stepping into another reality for a few hours. Definitely one of NYC's most unique nights out right now. Dates till August only! Don't miss out! Check out their website for details. Follow me @foodie.elite on IG and Tiktok for more great finds.

    Came here for the Moonrise show. You line up in the lobby along the left side and once they're…read moreready to let you up, they scan your tickets once you get to the elevator bank. Upon exiting the elevator they make you feel like you enter "paradise", do some tarot card reading by asking for your birthdate, and then get some beads with perfume dropped on them depending on which card you got. After all of that, none of those stuff mattered. We were served a three course meal before the actual aerobics show happened, but they still had performers perform while we had our meals or a few drinks. I enjoyed their Crescent Dip, which is a hummus dip with whipped feta and comes with a massive chip. The Full Moon Rice I wasn't really a fan of. After those two, they came out with the entree, which they called Fire, Water, Earth; essentially beet, halibut, and short rib. These were alright, not amazing. The third and final course came during the intermission of the show, which was a bunch of dessert treats and they were delicious. The show itself was fantastic. It was more than just aerobics, has there are also singing, dancing, and violinist. You may get wet in the front so FYI. There's also some fire involved. Overall, a well put together show. I'd probably skip the food, but the drinks were great.

    Photos
    Paradise Club
    Paradise Club
    Dessert heaven

    See all

    Dessert heaven
    54 Below

    54 Below

    4.1
    (253 reviews)
    3.7 mi
    $$$

    I went one time last night. It was a bit cramped. I did not sit by the rail and went to the bar…read more The food I had was great. Talent was very good. It was cozy. I must have passed it many times. A Greek church and a Greek diner are nearby, as is Alvin Ailey where I have taken lessons and performed, and of course the SAG Foundation is across the street. I will update this when I visit again. The man on the telephone should not hurry customers if they have not made up their minds to come.

    Was here for a special night and left a bit underwhelmed…read more So much of this place works - classic NYC theater vibes, and the musical talent, food and drink were all great. The show I saw had incredible performers and felt really happy to be attending. But this is where it fell apart. I have a great deal of empathy for waitstaff especially during this kind of cabaret show. I had gotten a last minute VIP ticket and ordered a drink - and was informed at the time I placed a drink that there was a $25 mimimumx which I knew about when I bought the ticket. The waitress who served us was unnecessarily rude sbout it: I went to order food but stopped at spending more because at that point, the fewer interactions with her the better. I don't know what to think - someone willing to spend more money and feeling reluctant to because of a rude waitress is a problem to the venue to fix.

    Photos
    54 Below
    View from the bar.
    View from the bar.
    Zero-Proof Hot Buttered Rum, Zero-Proof Strawberry Margarita, zero Vinada Airen Gold Zero-Proof Sparkling Wine

    See all

    Zero-Proof Hot Buttered Rum, Zero-Proof Strawberry Margarita, zero Vinada Airen Gold Zero-Proof Sparkling Wine
    Fondudes

    Fondudes

    4.9
    (12 reviews)
    2.9 mi

    Okay, so I really wasn't too sure what to expect from Fondudes. All I knew was that none of the…read moreladies in the bachelorette were down for seeing full on strippers, we're not into clubbing.. we do like shows (theater, comedy) but then we would have to be quiet during most of it. We were looking for a fun and unique experience that we wouldn't get elsewhere. I won't give away the exact details of what happens from start to finish, but we all had a blast!! It was a lot of improv, and their main goal is to make sure that the group has a good time. So yes, they will try to be outrageous and push the boundaries - but not in a bad way. They are good at reading the room and working with that. If you have a crazy insane group, or a tame one, they will try to make sure there's a good energy flowing. Our bride is pretty straight-laced / conservative, but she had such a great time!! Just a tip - if you're doing it in a hotel room, or somewhere where they quiet time by a certain time, make sure you book them to come well before quiet time. We had security knocking on the door to tell us to shut up right at 11pm, so just make sure you get the guys in by 9pm or however long the show is meant to go on for.

    Just went to a fondudes party last week, and it was SO. MUCH. FUN. We booked fondudes for my…read morefriend's bachelorette party, and we all had a GREAT time! Our friend especially loved it, because it's definitely not your typical bachelorette party. The performance was HILARIOUS, the actors were FUNNY, SWEET, and SEXY, and (a personal favorite of mine) the whole concept was SO WITTY! For example, two of the (delicious, by the way) fondues were named "Chai Me to the Bed" and "Pound me like a S'more." On the practical side, booking the party was really easy too - they were super professional and helpful in working with us to choose the fondues & type of performance. I'd highly recommend it to anyone looking for a silly, fun party idea!

    Photos
    Fondudes
    Fondudes
    Fondudes

    See all

    IPIC New York City

    IPIC New York City

    3.4
    (816 reviews)
    0.6 mi

    I went to iPic with my cousin to see The Devil Wears Prada 2. I usually go to Alamo Drafthouse, but…read morewe decided to try something new--and unfortunately, it was a pretty disappointing experience. The staff came across as nonchalant and not very engaged, which set the tone right away. The food didn't help either--the spicy tuna was completely flavorless, not crispy and the drinks were underwhelming. We also weren't told ahead of time that you have to pick up your food and drinks yourself, which was surprising since we're used to full service at your seat. On the positive side, the popcorn and truffle fries were decent, but everything else fell short. The seats were just okay--not particularly comfortable. The bathroom situation was also frustrating--it's located upstairs near the restaurant and wasn't well maintained. There were no paper towels, and overall cleanliness was lacking. Overall, this felt like a subpar experience, and I won't be returning. My cousin mentioned the New Jersey location is much better, so maybe it's just this one--but based on this visit, I wouldn't recommend it.

    I went to iPic this past Monday to see the Michael movie. I was mostly there for the "dinner" part…read moreof the "dinner and a movie" promise. The setup was exciting - having my own private booth made me feel like i was experiencing something luxurious. Then, the menu arrived. ​Our waitress hit us with the news that most of the menu was unavailable because they had run out of... well, almost everything. It's hard to stay excited about a premium experience when you're basically forced into a "leftovers" draft pick of things you wouldn't normally order. ​Guava Fresca: Actually pretty good! It's zero-proof and gave off a solid spritzer vibe. If only the food kept that same energy. ​The "Shareables": We went with the buffalo wings and the coconut shrimp. The shrimp were surprisingly large, but they showed up without any sauce. Both were fine, I guess? Very generic food court vibes and unmemorable unmemorable. ​Fish & Chips: The chips (fries) were the best part of the meal, which is saying something. The fish had a weird sweetness to it, and the cocktail sauce was aggressively heavy on the cilantro. I'm usually a fan of cilantro, but here it just felt like it was lost and out of place. Also the fish was covered in bread crumbs and not a traditional batter. ​Lobster Roll: This was the biggest heartbreaker. It was generic, bland, and lacked any real flavor. If you're going to charge theater-premium prices for lobster, it should probably taste like something. ​It's disheartening to pay for a "luxury" experience only to be told you can't have 70% of what's on the menu. I would've had a much better time if I could've actually eaten what I came for. Sadly, I don't think I'll be back unfortunately

    Photos
    Storefront
    Storefront
    Lobby
    Lobby
    Concession

    See all

    Concession
    Murdered by the Mob Dinner Theater

    Murdered by the Mob Dinner Theater

    3.1
    (95 reviews)
    3.2 mi
    $$

    Twenty-five of my family descended upon the Murdered by the Mob family last week and they could not…read morehave handled it any better than they did. It was really perfect. They managed to include almost everyone of us in some capacity, and had us all laughing from the time we arrived to the minute we left. the wait staff at the club were friendly and professional and while it is a pre-fixe menu of chicken parmigiana, pasta with vodka sauce and salad with mini cannolis for dessert , they were very happy to accommodate special dietary needs, in our case it was a severe gluten allergy and a strict vegetarian. The group of actors were so kind to take pictures with us at the end and kept us all laughing even after the show ended. We spent the whole night laughing with the actors, at the actors, at each other, at ourselves and with each other. Truly what fond memories are made of. if You are looking for a unique fun filled interactive experience you should definitely check out Murdered by the Mob.

    If you haven't been to a murder mystery dinner, and particularly to "Murdered by the Mob", please…read morego! We were laughing all night- there is dancing, audience participation, good food, exceptional acting, and great service here. We had so much fun and recommend anyone who hasn't already done so to check this place out. Tip: the food is penne pasta and chicken parm. If you want something else (like a vegetarian selection), you have to coordinate that with them ahead of time. We stuck with the classics and were not disappointed.

    Photos
    Murdered by the Mob Dinner Theater
    Entrance to show...
    Entrance to show...
    Murdered by the Mob Dinner Theater

    See all

    Medieval Times Dinner & Tournament

    Medieval Times Dinner & Tournament

    4.0
    (962 reviews)
    8.3 mi
    $$$

    After many (many - MANY) years of passing by on the highway, we finally got to experience it for…read morethe first time. Bought tickets for a Friday night show on a holiday weekend. Went early and there was a line waiting to get it. Not crazy. The show actors came out to greet us. After the wait we got let in and assigned a color. Took a picture and then we waited in the lobby for the show to start. Bought some trinkets and other items. Got called to go to a door. The arena was cold, so bring a light sweater. Walked to our seats and the server introduced herself. She told us what to expect and when. The show and food started. The food was good, no memorable. Show was also entertaining. Server was efficient. Overall, a well managed location, good, clean and friendly service, fun show you end up cheering for your color. Make sure to tip your server well if you think they did a good job. Had fun and won't wait again for many years to go back.

    The beginning felt a little slow with the falconry and horse demonstrations, and I started…read morewondering if the advertising was overselling it. Thankfully, once the knight tournament started, the entire atmosphere changed. The jousting matches, exploding lances, sword fights, and audience interaction made the second half incredibly entertaining. I thought the last hour alone was worth the ticket price. The food was definitely the weakest part of the experience. Since dinner is included, I wasn't expecting anything amazing, but it was still below average. Even the fountain soda had almost no carbonation, which was a little disappointing. One tip: arrive at least 30 minutes before the show starts. The earlier you're seated, the closer you'll be to the arena, and it's absolutely worth it. I'd happily come back for the performance, but not for the meal.

    Photos
    Medieval Times Dinner & Tournament
    Roast Chicken
    Roast Chicken
    Medieval Times Dinner & Tournament

    See all

    The Dinner Detective - dinnertheater - Updated August 2026

    Loading...
    Loading...
    Loading...