The new location and updated menu are both great. There are still some old favorites but there are some new items that are great. Fried chicken with mashed potatoes and brussel sprouts. The chicken was boneless but not dry. Brussel sprouts were cooked perfectly. Solid dish. Troddy coddy is always a solid choice. Fish is done really well and the fries are great. Inside is cozy and they have done work to help with the sound. Booths are nice. Staff is great. We have never had to wait, but we plan our trips so we are not there at busy times. Great addition to downtown Centerville. read more

See all

Wow! What a glow up! We liked Mudlick when they were downtown but the Centerville location is a lot more upscale. The hostess greeted us warmly and seated us right away. Our server was friendly but we found it a bit odd when the first thing she said to us was "we have everything on the menu" like that was not the ordinary and they were typically out of items? I ordered the Chicken Avo (grilled chicken sandwich with pepper jack cheese, jalapeño jam, fried leeks, and avocado) and our meals came out very quickly. The sandwich was delicious but spicy so be prepared for that. Their fries were great too! My husband really liked his lunch as well. We're happy to have another independent restaurant in the Centerville area! We will be back. read more

Mudlick Tap House - Chicken Avo and fries - Gastropubs Near Me - Centerville, Ohio

Tonight attended the soft opening of Mudlick Tap House in downtown Centerville. The new location is beautiful & tonight was a wonderful night to sit outside for dinner. Our waitress was friendly took our drink orders right away & allowed us to review the menu. We finally decided on the Trotty Coddy fish, fried & side of slaw and I enjoyed the Chicken Avo sandwich with grilled chicken I asked for it to be blackened & was, it was juicy, flavorful with a generous portion of fries. With it being new, they're still working out of variety of items. They will definitely need to have some sound panels put in cause it is very loud inside. Will be back to try again as there were a variety of items on the menu to try on a future visit. read more

See all

First time at the new location. Very nice upscale feel. We sat inside but the patio looks great and we will try it next time. The amount of parking was a pleasant surprise in downtown Centerville. This has been a rate limiting step to development I was impressed they had 24 taps with the beer menu displayed on TVs above the bar. We were seated at a nice sized table and the staff was very friendly and did a good job. I had the mussels and frites which were great, the addition of andouille sausage was an interesting twist making the broth very smokey and satisfying. Overall a very solid lunch and I look forward to returning and trying the desserts, they looked very tempting read more

Mudlick Tap House - Inside shot from our table looking towards the bar area - Gastropubs Near Me - Centerville, Ohio

See all

Walked out after 45 minutes Made a reservation for 7pm. Arrived about 5 minutes early. We were seated immediately. Waitress took our order and brought our drinks. We walked out at 7:45. When I asked the waitress if our order got lost since other people were being served, she said it was because they ordered before us. I then asked if that included the couple at a nearby table who were seated after us, were served their meal, and were paying their check. That left her speechless. Never again. After my first review, I figured they deserved a second chance. There will not be a third chance. We left and went to a good restaurant. read more

I feel like when it first opened food was great, but last month or so it has kind of went down hill. Has just been as good. Not a favorable and seems rushed. read more

I really REALLY wanted to be able to justify spending $20 on a sandwich and fries....and another $25 on two drinks but I cannot. We came in on a Sunday around noon and the place was empty. The guy who "greeted" me was pretty rude. I was looking for my friend and didn't see her right away. He literally said "this is it" and pointed to the empty restaurant. She happened to be hidden in a booth. The attitude from the greeter set a bad tone. The waiter was friendly but not very good. A third person arrived and we had to ask him for another water cup and a set of utensils...when the price for anything and everything here is astronomical I expect top notch service. The Chicken Avo was ok. I split it with my friend...the waiter knew we were splitting it and didn't have it cut in half nor did they bring another plate / tray. I'd rather go to Arby's next time. Their fresh cut fries were good but nothing special. My friend got the salmon sandwich and the bread bun looked raw. I'm very underwhelmed by this place. Won't be a regular here. Can't afford the price and for a special occasion I'll go somewhere special. read more

I've been to the Mudlick in Dayton but this was my first time visiting the new Centerville location. We sat at the bar which is elegant and nicely decorated. I ordered the Mudlick mule which was very tasty! They have a full cocktail bar and limited craft beers on tap. (That's actually my only complaint- no domestic beer, but I understand it's a tap house.) I ordered the creole grouper. It was cooked perfectly and the creole tomato sauce was amazing! My husband got the hanger steak and fries. He said it was good. They have sandwiches and salads on the menu, but also more upscale cuisine. Our bartender did a good job. The price was a little steep, but we would definitely go back. read more

Service was good. Family had a variety of sandwiches and salads, all were good. I had the shrimp and grits, the worst shrimp and grits I've ever had! 4 shrimp. The sauce states a white wine tomato sauce. What I got was something with so much old bay or other seasoning you couldn't taste anything else. Cheddar grits??? No cheese could be seen or tasted. If McDonald's ever does shrimp and grits, it would be better than this. I ate the shrimp and a couple bites, the rest wast really edible. read more

This was our second visit to Mudlick and won't be our last! The patio is one of my favorite things, but I also love that you can make a reservation. The menu is unique and varied, it was so hard to choose! I ordered the Chicken Avo sandwich and my husband had the Reuben. My chicken was cooked perfectly and I love the combo of the jalapeño jam with the smashed avocado - so yummy! The fries were cooked perfectly, crispy like we like them. My husband's Reuben was OUTSTANDING; one of the best I've tasted. Our server was Amanda and she was fantastic. When they didn't have the beer I wanted, she recommended a couple of alternatives and offered samples. We will absolutely be back - can't wait. You hear that Reuben? I'm coming for you! read more

My Burger was really good! Had glazed onions and arugula. Service was good as well. Love the interior design.

From the moment we walked in, Mudlick Tap House was fantastic--cool, inviting vibe with tons of space inside and a great patio. Maire (our hostess) was so sweet, and Sabrina (our server) was knowledgeable, attentive, and spot-on with her recommendations. We shared the Cajun Parmesan Fries and the Buttermilk golden-fried chicken with Boursin potatoes and maple bacon Brussels sprouts--absolutely amazing. My wife especially loved the cold brew martini Sabrina suggested. What stood out most was the teamwork. The manager checked on us, and other servers pitched in to help Sabrina--something you don't always see. Great ambience, stellar service, and unbelievable food & drinks--Mudlick Tap House is a must-visit! read more

Nick is awesome!!! Try the mussels . They have a great ambiance! You will not be disappointed!

Great burger and Brussel sprouts were awesome too. Very new and clean. A little sterile. Service good. Beer great!

We had a reservation for dinner with several of our friends on New Year's Eve. We got seated right away. Took about ten minutes for our waitress to even acknowledge us. My husband had the Creole Grouper. The size of the piece of grouper was so small, not even enough to fill you up, the temperature of the fish was barely lukewarm and not accommodating enough for the menu price of $25. I had the Fried Chicken, the chicken was dry, the mashed potatoes were barely warm, but the side of maple bacon brussel sprouts it was served with, were delicious, menu price of $24. We don't have any plans to go back, very disappointed! read more

I stopped in with my girlfriends as part of our girls night out. We made reservations two days a head of time online which was quick and easy BUT seems to fill up fast. When we got there they seated us right away and it was clear why they do reservations--most the tables and the bar was full. Our server was attentive and nice--we needed some extra time to go over the menu and she came to check on us an appropriate amount. I had an Old Fashioned which was pretty good--smaller portion than I would like at $11. Then I tried the Sazarac which was brought out "neat" and $13. For dinner I decided to just get myself the Calamari and Peppers. It's from the appetizers but was a great portion. The calamari was okay. Not something I feel the need to ever order again. One of my girls got the Buffalo chicken egg rolls and they were yummy!! The deviled eggs looked amazing too as I watched two of my friends fight over them. One got the large market salad with salmon and the salmon looked meh and dry. I definitely feel like Mudlick really comes through for their drinks and appetizers. read more

Too Loud. Average 80 db, went as high as 90 db. Members of our party had extreme difficulty speaking with each other when sitting next to on another. Service was slow. Food was average. We won't be back read more

Excellent food choices and unique recipes. Many GF options as well. Delicious and the service was almost perfect. (Who is really perfect?) read more

First time there. Loved it! Beautiful decor, comfortable booths and seating, beautiful lighting. Service was great and the meals were delicious!! Im visiting from Arizona. Would love to go back to this restaurant. read more

We sat at the bar on a Saturday night and apparently just beat the rush. Had a burger and the fish. Tomato soup was cream, delicious and hot. We will be back. read more

Mudlick Tap House - From their November drinks menu this was a fun twist on an old fashioned. - Gastropubs Near Me - Centerville, Ohio

See all

First visit with our friends. Easy to reserve a table, host was friendly and our waitress was excellent. This recently opened restaurant was clean and spacious. The menu has a wide variety of dishes to choose from. All four if us tried something different and we all enjoyed each entree. The only downside was the high level of noise echoing through the inside dining area, which made it difficult to have conversation. Management should consider adding sound deadening features to the current hard ceilings and walls. Overall we enjoyed our visit and plan to return. read more

We were here for the soft opening weeks and really enjoyed it. The new restaurant is beautiful inside and out and Nicolaus was a great waiter. I had The chicken avo sandwich and my husband ordered fried chicken. I love their food and drinks so much! read more

See all

Went to their new location in Centerville. We received an email inviting us to attend their "soft opening". We made a reservation - very easy to do online. Building and patio are great (although outdoor seating is very close to a busy road so it's a bit noisy). Inside tables were nicely spaced. Service was fantastic. Food was good. Part of our order arrived cold, but that was quickly rectified. Nice beer selection. They seem to be working on all the kinks associated with a new restaurant opening. I wish they would have discounted the total bill. I've never attended a soft opening and had to pay full menu price!! ‍ We will definitely go back after they get settled in. read more

The burgers aren't very tasty. The service was good and attentive, but frustrating unable to use our accumulating Toast loyalty policy.

Food is very good, had the Shrimp.'n Grits this evening, competes with anything in New Orleans. Service was very good, friendly staff.

Really good food, drinks and service. Only thing missing was some college football. TVs on the patio please!! read more

See all

very expensive and very small servings. I ordered brisket taco's for $18. not enough brisket to even taste. I guess I expected they would be stuffed full. read more

Food was delicious and cooked perfectly with fun items to choose from, the waiter was polite and kind, and the decor was warm and inviting. High quality without being pretentious. Can hardly wait to go back! read more

Visited the new location for the first time after enjoying the previous location for years. We decided to share the poutine and fried chicken. Poutine was good, very fresh and tasty. The fried chicken was dry and overcooked. The mashed potatoes were very good and Brussels sprouts were excellent. Service was ok - bottle of wine took some time to arrive and water carafe was never filled. Ambiance was ok - not great not horrible. We may try brunch here but not overly impressed with dinner. read more

Very nice ambience. Nice staff. Ordered lamb medium rare. Came out well done. Second time it came out raw. Opted after that for a dinner salad, which was very good. The key lime tart was excellent. They took off the lamb on my bill, but billed me twice, then took off the second charge on my credit card. I would go back again to see what the other menu options are like, since the menu looks very appealing. My friend's dinner, the salmon sandwich looked very good. I was hoping they would comp my dessert charge since I was never able to eat with my friend. read more

Overpriced. Their "side of potato chips" was an actual small bag of chips that was put on my plate next to my sandwich. I thought it was a joke, initially. read more

Service was great. Went there for their soft open and wasn't really blown away with the food. Chalked it up to them still learning the menu but along with the subpar food, should have came a discount. I don't mind paying full price but since your staff was still getting the hang of things, the whole experience took longer and the food was just ok. Pretty cool place to hang out and have a beer or two. Maybe small eats would suit this place better. read more

They're still figuring out some kinks. Went for an early dinner and were seated quickly and our orders were taken in a timely manner too. My husband ordered the lamb chops and needed to send one piece back due to it being undercooked. Not a huge deal due to there being a large bone in the chop, but we did wait quite a while for it to come back out. We asked for a to-go box for my daughter's meal and were literally ghosted. We were also never asked about drink refills. Overall food was good but service still needs to be worked out. read more

The good: atmosphere, servers, drink choice, outdoor seating. The bad: the food, the prices and charges. Everyone there was friendly - hostesses, bartenders and servers. But my BBQ brisket sandwich was small, dry and priced too high for what I got. I asked for BBQ sauce because it was so dry, then got a charge for it on my bill. My wife's grouper was ok, but was small and the "vegetables" ending up being just a salsa... The drinks were good with a good selection. Overall, disappointed with the value for what we paid. read more

Very bad food. The gravy was cold and lumpy and the steak was overdone. Also the wait was long

Overpriced and food was mediocre at best. The beer choices are superior to the quality of the food.

Terrible service. Half empty hsd to ask server three times for things. Over priced pretzel with terrible tasting cheese. Asked for a honey mustard and was charged 1.25 for a very very small cup. Will not last if dont step up service. read more

I ordered the fired chicken served with mashed potatoes and Brussels sprouts. Probably one of the best Brussels sprouts I've ever had, I love Brussels sprouts and I order them a lot! The chicken was good but a little dry. My wife had the burger and she was okay with it, nothing exceptional. However, she also got the spinach salad which was missing the cranberries! The subpar service was the issue, the server had way too many tables. A couple of firsts (we've eaten out a lot for many years), when taking our order the server abruptly stopped and informed us that she had an order up for another table and she would be back to take our order. The other issue was the table had water all over it when we were seated. I used my cloth napkins to wipe the table off, when greated by the server we informed her that we needed another napkin since we had to wipe the table off and she said no problem. When we placed our order we reminded her again that we needed a napkin. When my wife's salad came, I had to go to the men's room to get some paper towels. Finally after our dinner was served by the kitchen staff the server checked on us a few minutes later and after another request she got us a napkin. She also made a comment when we asked a third time for another napkin "what a poor guy", I don't think it was intended to be anything mean but how many times do you have to ask for a napkin? We also waited a long time in-between being checked on and had a fairly long delay in getting our check. We also noticed the couple next to us that appeared to have the same frustrations. We also noticed a family that took our seats at the bar when we were seated leave the restaurant long before us after being seated and having dinner, of course with a different server. We eat out a lot and probably would frequent this restaurant more often because the food is better than average and the prices are reasonable. However, the service has been an issue both times we visited the restaurant. By the way, the Rueben was not available both times we visited the restaurant. Not sure if we'll try gain. :/ read more

Absolutely amazing experience! Food was fantastic, staff was amazing ! We will definitely be back!