I recently moved to Plano and was over the moon when I found out there was a Mr. Gatti's Pizza nearby. I grew up in Garland and the South Garland location (closed years ago) was the go-to pizza place for years. I must admit my expectations weren't high because I expected it had been bought out and nothing like it used to be like so many pizza chains. I'm happy to report this is NOT the case with Gatti's. It's still absolutely delicious! They don't skimp on the high quality toppings, they always read my order notes and my pizza is made exactly the way I like it. Don't skip the salads either. For $5.99 you get a salad large enough for an entree for one or a side salad for two topped with tomatoes, olives, cheese, cucumbers and one of their delicious house made dressings. I order from GrubHub and my pizza always arrives piping hot and fresh. read more

Mr Gatti's Pizza - Signature Mr. Gatti's Box - Pizza Near Me - Plano, Texas

See all

I went to this location for the first time today. I got a carry out special -- 1 small 1 topping pizza for $7.99. After paying, I realized that I was charged $1 more for the topping. When I inquired, I was told because I asked for extra sauce. However, the receipt nor the menu board listed a charge for extra sauce. I felt that was wrong. Now the business has lost me as a future customer & got a 1 star Yelp review because they overcharged me $1. I hope it was worth it. Update - After receiving a reply from Mr. Gatti's on this review, I emailed the contact on 8/13. I still have not received a response even though the auto reply said they do their best to resolve all tickets within 72 hours. read more

Always perfect! Quality is worth it. On the lake but will drive for the best Pizza around!

Great service, quick and efficient. Very friendly staff. I lean towards the thin and crispy which is always great! Side of wings is a must! read more

Ordered pepperoni rolls to go since I was in the area, based on previous reviewer comparing them to double Dave's. This is a To-go location only. Aggie here craves them and also has to go to Denton or Keller! Gatti's version was good but nothing like DD. Probably will not order again. That being said, the guys in the pick up location were very nice, greeted me when I came in, asked if I needed anything else. Pleasant pick up, was refreshing. We frequented Gattiland back in the day, nostalgia! May order a pizza to go next time I'm around. Was too hungry to take pics ;) read more

The food is always awesome. They're most of the time on point with everything. Most have great service; wish there were more closer to where I live in Manor Tx. read more

Had my first experience the other day I was pleased with the way my pizza turned out both in looks and taste. I will definitely be a returning customer. read more

Unfortunately, I have to give this a one star today. I have order from this location once a twice a week and I've been satisfied until today. My son went to pick a pizza up and when I got back to my home, it looked old. The sausage the beef looked so old on there. It reminded me of Qt's pizza that's been sitting there all day and not replaced. I called the location. They said they wasn't responsible for any pick up orders and after going back-and-forth, I asked if we could it bring back up there. Can they make a another one and he was like well I guess you can do that. At this point I don't trust the place and I won't be ordering for a while just because of the merr disconcerting for satisfaction of the customers. Matter fact of their loyal customers, because I used to always order from the one on Skillman Road as well. I've been a customer for years. read more

Mr Gatti's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Plano, Texas

See all

First time I've had Gatti's since the literal 80's. FANTASTIC and I do mean FANTASTIC PIZZA. read more

Good stuff. Extra large pizza was slightly thicker than super thin crust. The dough still hasn't chewiness to it as well as being thick enough to support the toppings and sauce. Good toppings. Reminds me of a Detroit style pizza. Pizza layered with cheese and toppings, then half dollar sized circles of sauce all over the pizza. In some cases it could be a southern style. Chicago deep dish. Sauce was very much a great quality for me. I appreciate that. Was not a sweet sauce, but a savory one. It did not take away from the pizza, especially when you got a large bite of mostly sauce. The sauce was sprinkled with parmesan, which probably aided in its saltiness. I know at some point I'm going to have to stop eating all of this pizza otherwise it will be gone. However, my taste buds are screaming for more! Will definitely be back for other flavors. Always want to try to go with a standard to go to pizza for a new place to try. I remember hearing of the name of this place coming up as a kid in Florida. And did not disappoint. Shout out to the chefs working late tonight. Great service as well!! read more

See all

i love mr gatti's pizza and come whenever i'm in the area, but i placed an order and it went through, and the hours are listed as being 10:30-12, but no one was here when i got here at 10:55. this is the second time it's happened and it's incredibly frustrating. read more

I very much like their style of pizza. Their crust/bread is on the thinner side which I like but not Tombstone/frozen pizza thin that it's too hard and cracks. Thinner consistency at the edges too....not rolled up at the crust end. Good amount of sauce and heavier handed on the cheese. It stretched quite a bit when pulling apart the slices yet not too oily. The parmesan packets they have are custom and have herbs and some spices inside mixed with the parmesan. I haven't seen that before. Tasty! They have good bundle deals kinda like Dominos usually promotes (2 medium, 1 topping, etc etc) which saves you a lot of money for family dinners, parties or just downright gluttons. That's a big plus over competitors. The staff inside have been helpful and upbeat. Haven't experienced any stank face from a disgruntled employee who hates his job at all. I think I found my go to pizza spot! I'm not looking any further. All the other stuff like wings and pepperoni rolls I will eventually try. read more

Took time out the drive halfway across town to order Mr Gatti's tonight for my family the manager was very rude when I let him know that the sampler Pizza was not supposed to happen jalapenos on it and he decided to put it on there anyways and when I tried to see if we can resolve this and maybe just do a credit for next time he was even more unprofessional read more

Love Mr. Gattis!!! I've been to Italy and this is the best pizza recipe I've ever had :) read more

Mr Gatti's Pizza - Restaurant - Pizza Near Me - Plano, Texas

Nostalgia purchase. Just okay. I would say it's about a 5.5 on portnoys scale. No more, no less.

The pepperoni rolls are the only reason I come & I cannot get enough of them. I was hooked from Double Dave's & we don't have one here, so I'm glad this is a great substitute when I don't feel like driving to Denton. The place is small, but it does the job. Also, the service is quick, so I couldn't ask for much more. read more

I grew up eating Mr. Gatti's Pizza. I love it. Throughout my years living in Dallas, Mr. Gatti's restaurants have come and gone sadly. There are only 2 that I know of that have been consistent. One is in McKinney and the other is this takeout location in Plano. I order from this location once a week on average. Once in a while I will order a few pizzas and take them to my family in Waxahachie. This location has consistently great service and stays true to the recipe I grew up eating. I don't know what I'll do if this location ever closes. Maybe move to Austin where Gatti's are more common. Support your local business and place an order already! read more

Best pizza got good deals I'd recommend anytime you need a pizza in plano omm best pizza around

It's probably the worst cheese pizza and cheesy garlic bread we have ever had. Pizza had no flavor. Cheesy garlic bread didn't look or taste anything like it. Little Caesar's has better pizza than this place and I avoid Little Caesar's. read more

As an Austinite transplanted to DFW... this is CLASSIC Gattis! There's a "Gattis" in Fort Worth, but it does not taste the same.. This Gattis is straight out of Austin. Same texture and flavor. I live an hour away and my husband and I drove up there because I am pregnant and NEEDED my Gattis fix. Was not disappointed. This is the last good Gattis in North Texas. The rest are fancy places (you can buy wine?) and the pizza tastes different. I see us making several more trips up there in the next few months. read more

Good ,fresh love the sauce and a friendly staff . And if craving pizza early they open at 10:30 am.

I love their pizza. I literally have been driving 50 miles one way to get it. Now that one finally opened in Ft Worth, I no longer have to do that. My husband always went in to order and he has never had any complaints about the service. He says the guy is always really nice. Pretty good carryout specials. Farewell to Mr. Gatti's Plano. You are the best pizza in town; the town is just really far from me. read more

One of THE best pizzas around plus friendly service. I always look forward to eating here.

We ordered 2 medium pizzas and an order of cheese bread sticks last night. We ordered them with only 2 veggie toppings each. We are vegetarians. I even called them to make sure that their sauce did not have any meat in it. I was assured that it did not. Online there is no option for marinara sauce and hence the call to them. Both the pizzas had a meaty smell and flavor and one bite and we threw them in the dumpster. The cheese breadsticks had way too much cheese on them and were pretty gross to the taste. In the 90's we remember taking the kids to Mr. Gatti's and it was really good then. Sadly, we are scratching this place off of our list. TERRIBLE. read more

Definitely recommend trying Gatti's pizza! We got the veggie sicilian pizza, pepperoni pizza and an apple pie pizza. Bonus: their ranch is great too. All amazing! Friendly staff. read more

False advertising there was advertisements saying games parties pizza but it's just a takeout place I looked on the website and it said the same thing but when I went to the restaurant it was just takeout very disappointed read more

Delicious with a reasonable price. I like desert pizza, my friends also the same ... read more

It was fast and the pizza is soooo Hot!! Thank you it taste amazing. Ditto was so good read more

Very good dependable pizza place for years. Fast, hot, yummy, and good service. You can pick it up to save $.

The pizza was awful , customer service even worse. I will not order from here again.

I love this pizza, my only gripe is they charge for extra sauce as if its a topping. I will admit the last time I was there and asked they added it on for free, but still in the future if I want to have extra sauce it will cost. Now this location is not the same as the controversial one from Richardson, but it has since put a bad spotlight on Gattis and the pizza industry as a whole. Still, if I want take out pizza, Gattis would be my choice just this location as I can visably see whats going on for the most part and the service level is far superior at least in my dealings witt them read more

Love me some good gattis pizza and that's exactly what this is! Nothing like gattis baby

Delivery was on time. Driver was very polite. They do offer more than just pizza which is great when you want to order in. I had a calzone and it was pretty decent. I felt it was a little overly salty, but it filled my belly. I also ordered a side salad which was only $3.25 and it was larger than I expected. No complaints there. Overall it's delivery pizza. Good but not mind alerting. Will I order again? Yes! read more

Mr Gatti's Pizza - Calzone - Pizza Near Me - Plano, Texas

See all

Love their cheese!! Delivery is great and usually very quick. Toppings are always fresh. Try them out, you won't be disappointed. Oh yeah, definitely get the stuffed crust! read more

I have loved this place since I was a kid. There's something special here in the sauce, the sausage, and the parmesan cheese that give it its own flavor. I love it! Not to be confused with the giant buffet/theme park version of "Gattiland" you might find elsewhere, this location is all about the pizza as it is a delivery/take out only place. Whenever I can, I get Gatti's. read more

Usually love the food, came by to pick up on a Saturday night to see basically the whole staff not wearing masks including the cooks while they were handling peoples food. They only put their masks up once they saw me walk in, and not even over their noses. You could be very well messing with peoples lives by doing this so I can't recommend anyone risk eating here until this is resolved. read more

This is probably the most underrated pizza place on the planet. Very good prices , the management there are extremely friendly, and the pizza is AMAZING. If you have never tried Gatti's, do yourself a favor and get some NOW! read more

I have had a lot of pizza... I stopped over to place a carry out order on Sunday, and I got home to enjoy the pizza and it was awful. Crust tasted old (couldn't even eat the crust) because it was so hard.... I would rather eat tombstone pizza then here.I've been in the F&B industry for 10 years and this was plain bad. For the $10 bucks I paid I could have paid for 2 people to eat at CICi's and I would have been happy. Very disappointed. read more

Pizza was hot and tasty when delivered. Had the pepperoni pizza and the veggie. Both were excellent. Delivery was a little longer than expected, but the food made up for it! We moved to Dallas 9 months ago and have finally found a great local place! read more

I just moved here from Baton Rouge. And am SO excited I have a Gattis here! Just finished my lunch from here after ordering and picking up. I am extremely satisfied. The guy was very nice. They were one time. Fresh. I can't wait for them to open back up the buffet! read more