Good atmosphere, small store, fresh dough, good pies. Get it and go. I would. Also fun arcade games for a wait.

Amazing pie Best in Dallas IMO Owner is nice and very friendly along with having it ready right on time read more

SOOOO GOOOD!!! Truly the BESTTTTT pizza in Plano, and like up there as some of the best I've ever had in life truly. Today I was busy chatting with the super sweet cashier and distracted so when I went to pay I accidentally hit the 15% tip went I meant to give way more and now I'm panicked LOL oops next time. Love it here so much, love the crew and their energy, will keep on telling people how great Heriloom is and I'll get you with the proper tip you deserve next time :D!! read more

Heirloom Pizza - 1/2 The Author 1/2 Pepperoni - Pizza Near Me - Plano, Texas

Delicious. I went to pick up dinner for friends. We got a caprese and the Author pizza. We could not stop eating it. They are so nice and quick. Just a store front with fantastic video games. Will order again soon. read more

I tried Heirloom last night. I got the Author pizza and I thought it was pretty good. I also got their caprese salad and I liked that as well. Customer service was great. I wish they had the Parmesan cheese packets though. But I'll definitely be back to try other items on the menu! Forgot to take pics because I was pretty hungry and dove right in! read more

Best pizza I've ever had. Large slices but hold the shape when held up. Alittle oily but so worth it. A bit pricey but they give you codes to get a percent off when u join rewards read more

I was surprised to learn this is take-out only. Although I really don't mind eating it at home, but I think it might have lost a bot of its crispiness on the drive home- which is about 15 minutes. We ordered the Aurthur, and it was delicious. I wasn't sure how much to order so I got a large to be safe. Well, its huge at 16". Probably more than we needed for two people as we each ate two large slices, leaving 4 slices left over. I love leftover pizza, so no problem there. I think its a better value at $23.50 versus $16 for a small? I liked the greek salad as well, although It could probably use a larger lettuce to all-other-ingredients ratio. it seemed like all the ingredients were about equal in portion. Delicious, but I want a bit more lettuce. I will for sure try some of the other pizzas here. And I liked the friendly staff. They seem genuinely "all-in", which is a great thing. read more

Heirloom Pizza - The Arthur- 16" Large - Pizza Near Me - Plano, Texas

Very good pizza. Definitely just focusing on making quality pizza based on the spot alone. I got the detroit thick crust with pepperoni and also just a ny cheese. Both were very good and definitely would recommend a ny pie to anyone who likes simple pizza. Good service not too long at all. read more

Heirloom Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Plano, Texas

Delicious pizza. Kind and personable staff and cook. A small and honest front shop to pick up the delicious pizza. There are two arcade game machines in the front that really add some positivity to this pizza shop. Great crust and sauce. The pepperoni had a great chew and flavor. The generous amount of jalapeño added an amazing spice. read more

See all

This pizza is absolutely amazing. Justin is probably one of the most giving people I've met. He works so hard to make good pizza and you can really tell how passionate he is in what he does. He makes some amazing specialty pizzas and also does a Detroit style which oh my gosh is good. This is not an eat-in establishment but an order, pickup and go. There is a video game to play if you're waiting. If you want something special, let him know, he will do his best to make it for you. If you love pizza, Heirloom is not to be missed. You can thank me later!! read more

Pics look great, but the taste and texture not so much. I've lived in Plano for about 8 years and have yet to find anything close to NY/NJ quality pizza. Staff is friendly and my pizza was close to on time for pickup, but as others have said the texture is mostly floppy and the only crisp I got was by heating more in the air fryer after I got home. Also pricey, but typical for most places here outside of the national chains(Dominos, Pizza Hut, etc). No seating, just went in for pickup. Have Arcade One Up's to pass the time until your pizza is ready. read more

Heirloom Pizza - Inside - Pizza Near Me - Plano, Texas

See all

The pizza itself is ok, but the value for the money is awful. I placed an order online and was thinking the default was for a medium ($18.95), but showed up get my carry out and found out they were for smalls! And not very good ones at that. Outer crust and first 3rd are cooked well, remaining 2/3rds is a soggy floppy mess. I get NY style pizza is supposed to be floppy, but not raw pizza dough floppy. First time I came here (albeit a few years ago) they were loaded with toppings and the owner and pizza were great. Times have changed and I won't be going back for this ridiculously sized pizza for the price. read more

Heirloom Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Plano, Texas

See all

We loved their pizza! It is a little on the expensive side, but we believe worth it. The only sad thing is that we tried to buy pizza yesterday, Friday April 24th and today, April 25th, and they are closed! I hope they are still in business. No sign on the door to explain why they are closed and when calling no special message explaining why they are closed either. I hope they open soon again! read more

Best pizza in the Dallas area. Would put it up against the best in the Bronx, NY. Pepperoni is wonderful. Sauce is brilliant. Just the right amount of sharpness. The supreme is great tasting and a visual delight. read more

What a great place for takeout pizza! Family owned, quality ingredients and great customer service. They have gluten free and vegan options! read more

This is by far one of the best pizza spots in the area. it's in a hole of the wall 90s style shopping center, but don't let the looks of this place fool you. Pizza is to go only, which is a shame because you want to eat this on the spot. Seriously I found myself eating the whole damn pizza in my vehicle lol read more

Heirloom Pizza - Pepperoni pizza - Pizza Near Me - Plano, Texas

See all

Omgoodness! This is the BEST pizza I've ever had anywhere. The fact that the owner makes everything from scratch, dough, cheeses, sauces, etc. I guarantee once you've tried this, you'll never eat another pizza anywhere else! It's a little expensive but SO worth every penny. We had the garlicky cheese which is better than any garlic cheese breadstick anywhere. That thin crispy dough and delicious cheese! Oh my! Also had a large pepperoni cup with homemade red sauce. Family loved it. My husband and I had a large veggie of our choice, with Italian sausage and homemade red sauce and added homemade ricotta too. Incredibly delicious! I wish he would add a couple of dessert pizzas too. Yummy! Please give them a try, you won't regret it and you'll fall in love too. read more

Gluten Free pizza is some of the best we have ever had!!! Crust was crispy and toppings were fresh!!! A little pricy but very worth it!!! Try them read more

Saw the owner post on Facebook about free slices for lunch so had to check it out. (I did tip as well so review is my own and not because the slices were free.) The owner recently took over the place earlier this year (2024) and is trying to make a name for himself here in Plano. It's not a place you can really sit down in but is great for to-go. The owner was super friendly and made the experience enjoyable. For the slices I had the Meat Master, Fred's Steakhouse Special, and Detroit style one. The meat master was very well done with your basic all meats topping in a thin crispy crust that was perfection. The flavors shone through and it was not over sauced which I thought it was perfect. However, if you like sauce be sure to order extra. The Fred's Steakhouse Special was phenomenal and I will order it on another day. The owner gets his steak from Fred's next door and then tops the pizza with Alfredo sauce, banana peppers, red onions, and cheese. With that crispy thin crust again it was truly unique and something I never had here before. The last slice was the Detroit style one. It's a deep dish style pizza and the crust was amazing on the edge that I got. Overall I highly recommend checking them out. He seems like a good guy and will quickly become a local staple. So get in early while you can and help support a local pizzeria here in Plano! read more

See all

As a New Yorker who's chased great pizza in Texas for 30+ years (and even lived in Italy and Detroit), I can say Heirloom Pizza in Plano is the best I've had in Texas, period. The regular pizza is my favorite--thin, crisp, perfectly balanced. The Detroit-style is excellent too, with its caramelized crust and surprisingly light dough. What makes Heirloom even more special is the owner's story. Justin saved for years, taught himself pizza-making from scratch, and built something incredible with passion and heart. Takeout only, but worth every minute of the wait. In a world of chains, this is a true gem. Don't miss it. read more

Excellent pizza, got Pizza of the Gods adding spicy capicola! Love the crust, nice and chewy.

Michelangelo carefully crafted the David, a true masterpiece. Just like that renowned statue, each pie at Heirloom is a masterpiece of pizza perfection. Justin is an artist that dances the fine line of divine inspiration, passion and attention to detail. We tried a Detroit, the Author, plain cheese, a Supremely Superior, ham & bacon and last but not least, a White Gold. All of them were as delicious as they were unique. Crispy, chewy crust, top of the line toppings, and all the love Justin clearly has for his craft. Run, don't walk to this pizzeria! read more

Heirloom Pizza - Large Supremely Superior - Pizza Near Me - Plano, Texas

I work for Instacart and Justin, the owner of the place, just gave me the best tip I have ever received after completing a delivery. I got a full large cheese pizza! It was amazing; the crust of the dough, the freshnes of the tomatoes and the gooeyness of the cheese were absolutely perfection. It doesn't matter where you are, you will not, I repeat, you will not regret the trip!!! Kudos to Justin for being a one man band and I hope he finds the success those pizzas deserve!!! As Arnold very well said it; I'll be back!!! read more

Heirloom Pizza - Simply Cheese Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Plano, Texas

I met Justin and Gabriel this evening. Both were very personable and extremely generous with their time as they were preparing my order. I placed my order in person because I wanted to see how his operation had changed from the previous owner. Justin has created something very special in Heirloom Pizza! We had his Detroit deep dish pizza and also enjoyed his New York thin crust pizza and the cannoli. My wife and I will be ordering lunch and/or dinner from him again very soon. Keep up the great work, Justin! read more

See all

Large, half pepperoni mushroom onion and bell pepper, half ham pineapple onion and jalapeño. read more

Heirloom Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Plano, Texas

The quality of this pizza is very good. I appreciate that they offer white sauce. One of my favorite pizza places in Plano!

amazing pizza stumbled upon this place by accident and kicking myself for not finding it sooner this diamond of a place has stolen my business for life. Justin the owner makes you feel welcomed from the second you walk in till the moment you leave with your amazing pie. if you think you know good pizza try this place and youll finally understand what AMAZING pizza really is. Also they have a pac man game inside to kill some time while taking in the smells of your amazing order read more

Heirloom Pizza - Pepperoni ny style - Pizza Near Me - Plano, Texas

Absolutely delicious! Best NY style around this area that I've been to so far. Caesar Salad was also delicious. Loved the dressing. Definitely a new favorite pizza place for us! read more

Heirloom Pizza is amazing!!! We've been a couple of times and tried different pizzas each time. I have never been disappointed with our pizza choices. Fair warning, they are not playing around with the garlic here. There are definitely no vampires hanging out at Heirloom's. We ordered a BYO Brick Oven NY Pizza with fresh garlic as one of the toppings and wowza, it was a masterpiece. The garlic was well placed, flavorful but not overpowering. The garlic complemented the meat and sauce so well. We've also tried the White and Pesto specialty pizzas. Both were fantastic. The eggplant on the Pesto pizza is seasoned and cooked so well you almost think it's sausage. The White pizza is rich and decedent. if you are looking to enjoy a non traditional (no red sauce) pizza, I highly recommend either of these options. Their pizza also gets bonus points for reheatability. The pies are generous so of course there's leftovers for days and they are still delicious 2-3 days later. read more

See all

Would give more than 5 stars if I could. 10/10. Amazing pizza every...single...time. Justin is the absolute nicest guy and has nailed it with his recipes, sauce, the crust. My wife and I look at each other with every pizza and say "holy crap this is so good I can't stop eating it". You've got to try this place. What's more, it's a local family owned business. What's not to love? Support local! read more

See all

Wow !!!! What a great place. It took me back in time for a for a restaurant. Owner Justin is fabulous. Everyone is so polite and wonderful. It's like the good old days. We need more local restaurants like this. . read more

Christine greeted us with a BEAUTIFUL, warm smile when we walked through the door. She's the mother of the owner Justin. She took us through the menu and we decided to create our own. The pizza is made to order, in a small grab and go type of establishment. You can eat there but it's only like one table for two inside, I believe. The pizza was phenomenal. Extremely fresh with all our favorite fixings. Christine was even so nice to give us a dessert on the house, which was so gracious of her. Hands down the BEST Pizza in Dallas!!! read more

Heirloom Pizza - Pepperoni, Sausage, Pineapple, mushroom, jalapeños - Pizza Near Me - Plano, Texas

Very tasty pizza. The crust was nice and thin. The cheese and sauce were good. The pepperoni were small and when cooked formed a little'bowl' shape. My husband loved it. It was very oily from the pepperoni to me. That's what he liked best. The service was excellent. Very quick and on time as promised. I called it in, then picked it up. The family owned business was obvious- father checked me out, son cooked, brought out my pizza and even introduced himself. Very nice family. The ambiance was what was to be expected for a pizza place. It was nice and clean and welcoming read more

Heirloom Pizza - New York style pepperoni pizza - Pizza Near Me - Plano, Texas

Pizza dough was really good as well as the chicken and pesto sauce. The pepperoni pizza however was disappointingly swimming with grease- normally pepperoni pizza is greasy hut considering the amount of pepperoni on the pizza this seemed like an excessive amount and made the pizza less enjoyable. We would certainly return and have this pizza again if the pepperoni pizza was less greasy. The wait times provided when you order online are also not accurate. The chicken was cooked well, the shredded Parmesan is a nice touch and I love places that offer pesto sauce - it's hard to find a place with good NY pizza and pesto sauce! read more

Heirloom Pizza - NY style pizza with pesto and chicken - Pizza Near Me - Plano, Texas

See all

We ordered 13 pizzas for a party of 50 people at Nerfies down the street and EVERYONE kept coming up to ask us the name of the pizza place we ordered from. Even the party host said in all the parties she's hosted that this was the best pizza. We ordered the maui, the author, pepperoni, cheese, the alfredo bliss and the margherita. I tried each of them except for the alfredo (it was all eaten up) and they were all delicious. My favorite was the margherita and the author. My husband said the staff was super friendly and even helped carry all the boxes out to the car. Will come back again when in the area and will recommend! read more

The ingredients were so tasty and fresh on both our pizzas. The sauces were delicious, rich cheese, and great crusts (both the regular and the cauliflower/gf option). Definitely a new favorite! Great customer service when I called to ask about gluten free option, online and delivery options, etc. Justin helped me with my questions and it felt like a real neighborhood business! read more

We just tried Heirloom Pizza for the first time and it was incredible! Our order was ready at exactly the designated time. The staff were very welcoming and friendly. We got The Author and it exceeded all expectations. The pizza was cooked perfectly and we could tell all the ingredients were high quality. It was also great value for the style and size of pizza. We just found our new go-to pizza joint! read more

FANTASTIC family owned pizzeria. Make amazing deep dish Detroit style pies, and even modded for us as we are vegan (yes, they have great vegan cheese and a decent selection of vegs - no v. meats however). Super friendly, accommodating and reasonably priced. We love this place. SUPPORT SMALL! read more

Best pizza in Collin County, hands down. The Author and the Supreme are our go tos - with a generous amount of toppings in both. In addition the pizzas being delicious and the toppings being incredible quality (also, my fiance who is NOT a foodie talks about the crust, constantly), the staff are so incredibly kind. We thought they closed at 10pm on the weekends (they close at 9) and called in one night at 8:45, only to find out they closed in 15 minutes and we were 25 min away. The guy who answered the phone said he'd be happy to get us a pie. Can't recommend Heirloom enough. read more

There might be a wait (they're popular). There might be an order switch up (they're busy). There might be a confused and impatient Uber driver (nothing new here). There might be some boisterous pizza slingers yelling out orders (love the energy). It will be beautiful. It will be delicious. It will make you happy. If you want pizza a HUGE step above all the nasty Texas "pizza" within a 15 mile radius, check out these local guys doing it right. Coming from a CT native that grew up on New Haven a'pizza (iykyk). This place's only DFW rival for a north east style pie is Fortunate Son in Garland. read more