This was our first time ordering here, new to the area. We had to order online, my wife accidentally ordered the wrong pizza which we discovered upon arriving to pick up our order. I asked if they could work out a deal with me so I could get the pizza we thought we ordered. The manager said "NO, because it was ordered online". Great customer service would have cut me a deal in order to make a new customer satisfied. Will never order from this company again. read more

Food was amazing came in around 11:34 on a Tuesday. Love how nice they are and brought out multiple different types of pizza and it even surprised me they brought out some potato wedges. Amazing love it fresh and warm not cold pizza read more

Mountain Mike's Pizza - Pizza buffet - Pizza Near Me - Atwater, California

best pizza in Atwater ordered last night good as always will order again never dissappointed pick it piping hot got home still hot

Great pizza but prices are kinda high. I gave special instructions and they were followed.

100% recommend! Great pizza and excellent customer service. Try the lunch buffet with the family!

Too expensive. Ordered a large pizza with 3 toppings, pepperoni, sausage and black olives. All toppings including cheese and sauce were on the light side. Our total was 30.44 that was after tax and after they gave us $3 off. We won't be going back. read more

This place deserves no stars !!! Do not eat here trust me this specific location skimps on the cheese and sauce .. I can compare this garbage pizza to 711 pizza .. honestly I got a pizza from here ""the mountain""" ya more like a mountain of waste, my money .. I'm disappointed and upset I don't work hard for my money to waste it and this place is not good .. I hope no one else waste there money I honestly feel like I got robbed it's that bad!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! $45 after tax down the drain I won't even give the left overs to my dog ... dry pizza no sauce and barely any cheese read more

Look if your going to be in customer service you should have to be nice I went here after church yesterday and they were so rude even with a coupon it was 55 dollars for two pizzas that price is crazy for quality of food they serve be honest it's not the best pizza around but to be treated so poorly on top of that come on people the first person behind the register is your first impression of that establishment, alll it does is make ur business not feel great and definitely won't be returning back there ever again and will contact better business bureau about this business staying in business I feel like for what I paid the pizza was old it wasn't even hot poor service and I paid 55 dollars for this??? I should have went home and made something for us to eat then to waste my hard earn money on this!!!! Absolutely disgusting service and food read more

They won't even give you enough cheese and peppers for your pizza-2 per pizza-we got a mountain size and a large. I'd say that's quite unreasonable! I will not be giving them my business anymore! Rico's and Round Table it is baby! read more

Pizza was bad! Very little sauce and toppings were not cooked. Charging extra for cheese and plates but no peppers.

This place used to be awesome ever since Ricardo left the quality of the pizza and customer service has declined drastically so sad

I ordered two pizzas, both with extra sauce and received two bone dry pizzas. To make things worse the man preparing the food had a very large beard and no beard net. I was disgusted and went home and made myself a sandwich for dinner instead. read more

Mountain Mike's Pizza - a pizza in a box - Pizza Near Me - Atwater, California

We haven't been here in quite some time but we used to get pizza here every week. This most recent visit, our pizza was phenomenal, we were so impressed. It was very hot and tasted great. read more

Mountain Mike's Pizza - Snowy Alps Pizza and Pepperoni Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Atwater, California

Best gluten free pizza by far. I have tried everyone's in town and this one has a nice crispy crust and I love the pepperoni here. Pizza was nice and hot and I love that it is close and easy to get in and out of. People are always nice when I go in. We are regulars here read more

This is the pizza that was delivered to my parents house. I ordered the pizza for my parents. They are deaf and didn't realize the delivery driver was at the door. The delivery driver called and I did my best to inform my parents that they were at the door. I came back to the house to see the pizza destroyed! I have no words at this time. If you are reading this review, please do not go to this establishment. read more

Mountain Mike's Pizza - This is the pizza that was delivered to my parents house. - Pizza Near Me - Atwater, California

I absolutely love this restaurant found a way to offer buffet style during a pandemic. The buffet included the salad pictured below, that they made and brought to you with dressings on the side. As well as fresh pizza, in which they asked us what we would like when we first arrived and made within 10 minutes of us arriving. The manager came and spoke to us and was very friendly. Masks are still required to enter, but can be removed after sitting. read more

Mountain Mike's Pizza - Salad Bar - Pizza Near Me - Atwater, California

The customer service is horrible over the years even before this thing happened . I came over and pick up my pizza. Scanned my card and my bank approved it. Receipt printed. After two hours they called me and they stated I didn't pay. How in the world , that man gave me the pizza if I ddnt pay right?! This got me so upset. WF stated it was the merchant's end that the reverse my payment. When u called to pay although upset, The woman arguing that it wasn't their mistake. What a waste of my time. The pizza quality has even gone bad.The chicken laua have only 4 small pieces on it. Cost cutting i guess read more

We ordered this pizza from Mountain Mikes in Atwater and decided to call to inquire on the how it was made/looked. As you may see, it's burned around most corners and oddly shaped. I've been their customer for 10 years and never have I seen a pizza delivered this bad! I asked to speak to the store manager and a guy gets on the phone saying he was the manager. I told him what the pizza looked like explained that it looks like two smaller slices were added from a medium or small pizza on to the large. He said that it might not be so round since they have new people training but he can guarantee the pizza didn't go out that way. He then proudly said he has been making pizza for 14 years and admitted he wasn't the store manager but the chef manager or so he said. I insisted to speak to the store manager but He then refused to take my number down and said I will have to call back on Wednesday at 9am to speak to her. Apparently, this employee after 14 years of making pizza or at least trying to can't relate a message either. read more

Mountain Mike's Pizza - Bad Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Atwater, California

Amazing as always! Place is always clean! And employees were very attentive PIZZA is always so so good here! It's the best pizza around town that's cake pizza! I love the Everst pizza, it's so loaded and it's just so satisfying! Can't go wrong with pepperoni either is so delish! They have games and stuff to keep the kids busy! Awesome pizza joint! read more

See all

The pizza is delicious and I enjoyed the salad bar which includes a variety of pasta salads as well. Delicious food with a wholesome family environment. I love it! Also, has sports tv for all the sports fans. read more

After emailing Mt. Mike's, I received a pleasant email from the corporate office saying someone from the Atwater one would be contacting me. Got that call last night. A lady on the other end gave me a half hearted, if even that, apology and instructed me that if I come in they would give me the buffet at half price and not charge me for another one at full price. Then came the BS excuse that the printers messed up on the sign. Well I drove by there this morning and low and behold the exact same sign is still hanging in the same place. When our conversation was almost over it was revealed to me what this call was really about. She asked me to contact Corporate and YELP to retract my original bad reviews. Felt like I was being bribed with a half off buffet. I promised her I would contact both places. Prior to writing this I sent a similar email to corporate. Promise kept!!!!! read more

Make sure to hound the staff because they won't call your name or check the orders horrible service also add 10 mins to your older as well never have I had something not go wrong read more

The service was friendly. The pizza I ordered was not up to par. It was an expensive pizza in my opinion. We got a $20 large one topping pizza, which was a special. The pizza had almost no sauce and the crust was burnt. Not made well. read more

Ordered a XL pizza and the dough was undercooked and the cheese tasted expired. Never again will I order from this place

I would give a 5/10 for the Pizza and a -10/10 for the service. No beer, salad bar is inaccessible, no water, no plates unless you ask. The tv works for 10 seconds and goes off for 5 seconds. Don't wAtch a football game here read more

This place is great for family size parties. We had a party of 15! Pizza was out quick and taste great. We ordered pepperoni, barbecue chicken, sausage and cheese. All fantastic choices. So what's the point? If you like a delicious, oily pizza this place is the spot. Why not grab a beer too. read more

Mountain Mike's Pizza - Chicken wings! - Pizza Near Me - Atwater, California

See all

After spending $75 on 2 pizzas and some wings, Can I have some cheese on my pizza next time? Also, it would probably be a good idea if you didn't stick flimsy plastic containers of ranch in the same bag as a 2 liter soda. read more

Mountain Mike's Pizza - Busted open container of ranch that was in the same bag as a 2 Liter Soda - Pizza Near Me - Atwater, California

See all

Ok, so it's probably not the best picture. But the customer service here is always great. I always have ordered from here, and couldn't wait for their buffet to open back up. Although it's no longer self serve, the older woman who served my salad put really good amounts of everything I asked for!! There was only Hawaiian and mushroom out when we arrived, but the manager kindly asked if there was any pizza he wanted his cook to make. Which is very generous, considering I had gotten there at 11:20, (20 mins into the buffet) and there was only one other customer there for the buffet. Really awesome customer service. If I could say one thing about them, I'd say they could add more cheese to their pizzas! Other than that. They truly are golden in my eyes. My go-to pizza place, I feel I rambled on about the buffet, but they've always been my #1!!! Pizza place in ATWATER. read more

Mountain Mike's Pizza - SALAD! CHEESE Garlic Bread with Cheese - Pizza Near Me - Atwater, California

Mountain Mike's used to be great! Then they turned to garbage over the course of the last year. COVID must have hit this place hard. Their prices have been going up and up. The employees are cool, but the manager is a bit of a doofus. Try a different place unless you have large amounts of money to spend on subpar pizza. My real review is 0/5, however, 1/5 is the lowest Yelp will allow :( read more

We usually order delivery...decided to eat in. We had a coupon but it accidentally blew away on the wind...bad weather. They wouldnt attempt to offer or honor it in any way even though we knew all the details on the coupon . Then...the menu clearly states beer and wine. I dont drink beer ..ordered wine. Oh we dont have any wine ..double annoyance. If you dont carry it take it off the menu. Never have these types of problems at the Merced store. Highly annoyed..when you end up spending close to 100.00 you expect more. read more

Poor service! The employees were arguing in front of me, employees interupting sales flow to chat with one another, and not paying attention to customer/customer service ie. smile, courtesy, greet, timeliness. Bread/crust was stale (i think its not fresgly baked), cheese was VERY minimal (i think theyre trying to save money by putting less cheese), and overall flavor was disappointing. Shame because ive had good mountain mikes before so id expect some sort of consistency in flavor but i guess not. read more

The best mountain mikes in all 209 ! Very clean and organize and have the best pizza hand down

Mountain mikes is our favorite pizza spot in town. Yes, the pizza could be cheaper however with their coupon from their website, it definitely isn't too bad, considering that it's delicious. We like to order the pineapple chicken luau pizza and add jalapeños... super duper yummy. As our second pizza we add a pepperoni. Great pizza! read more

Horrible phone service. Couldn't understand the person on the phone. She even mumbled under her breathe "this is taking forever". Rude. Will never order from the Atwater store again. read more

Me and my friends meet at the Atwater Mountain Mikes every two weeks on pay days before work. Pros: The food is good and not priced to bad. The service is generally good. It can get kind of busy in there sometimes when large groups of people are there but there is enough room so that you don't feel crowded. Cons: Sometimes it can take them a while to get the pizza out and keep em coming. It would be nice also if they cut the slices of pizza bigger. I feel rather greedy when i have to take four slices of pizza. lol Overall the Mountain mikes is a fun, clean, and relaxing place to eat before work. read more

Two weeks ago I ordered a pizza 3 mediums one Hawaiian one MeatLovers one Combo wings and bread sticks.. The medium combo pizza was not cooked all the way - very doughy - I called in spoke to one of managers - she told me she would be able to send another combo pizza on the next order... Called today and was told that they never noted the conbo pizza - I like mountain mikes but I will no longer order from this placd - VERY POOR CUSTOMER service ! They need real Managers - need to learn how to deal with customers better ! read more

Young daughter put $.50 into a machine not seeing it costs $2.00. Management wouldn't reimburse her. Entire pizza buffet tasted like the dessert pizza with cinnamon. They also don't have knives and charge $.50 for ranch. Won't be back read more

I really like their pizza because they pile on the toppings, especially on the specialty pizzas. We only do takeout and they are always ready fast. We'd love it if Mountain Mike's expanded to SoCal, where we live! In the meantime, we consider it a treat when we're in Atwater. read more

Great service, pretty good pizza, but the salad bar is small, and prices are pretty steep. Lunch buffet is very well worth the money. The service is OK, not real good, but not too bad. When placing an order they could have pretended a little better that my business was appreciated. It was like, "What do you want?, give me your money, sit down and wait till we bring it to ya." They really didn't say it quote that way, but her attitude exuded that feeling. read more

Here for the buffet and it is whack!!!! My friend also said the beer is flat!! Very disappointed in the buffet experience here at atwater mountain mikes. I been here for over 20 minutes and it's still the same Pizza as when I walked in being served. They have not brought nothing fresh out and the pizza that's been sitting for almost a half hour is cold. read more

See all