Best Beef on Weck I've ever had!!!...and I lived in Buffalo for awhile! Tender roast beef (and a…read morelot of it!)...nice toasted roll...delicious au jus...lots of caraway seeds...and delicious crispy fries! Contributing to the 5 Stars....the beer is COLD and the bartender is CUTE! (Now, you can all argue about which one I'm talking about!)

I never write reviews, but the appalling way my group was treated at Lakeside Pub demands to be…read morecalled out. After a day out on the boat, three friends and I walked in expecting a decent meal. Instead, we were met with pure hostilty from the moment we crossed the threshold--all because one of my buddies, a veteran, had his legitimate service dog with him. The utter lack of respect from the staff, including the manager and bartenders, was unacceptable. They made it blatantly obvious that we were unwelcome, treating us like a hassle rather than paying customers. The staff's tone was nasty, condescending, and completely unprovoked. To disrespect anyone this way is bad enough, but to act with such blatant disdain toward a veteran with a service dog is disgraceful. Do not waste your time or money on an establishment that treats people with such contempt. Take your business anywhere else.

Base my reviews off what you pay:…read more *Place was busy on a Saturday evening. Price - ~$60-$80 (appetizer, entree, drink, tip) Food - 4/5 - tasty and massive portions. Service - 4/5 - great recs, friendly. Ambiance - 3/5 - nicer downstairs. Overall - 4/5 - the spot to go to for Mexican in Skaneateles. Have had better Mexican before but the food us tasty as hell and the portions will leave you stuffed. My girlfriend couldn't even order an entree after appetizers lol. A ton of tequila options. Definitely order the Birria Pizza, but beware of its size. Service was great, Devin was very sweet and gave great recommendations. We did not feel rushed at all. Inside is fine, nothing really crazy. Great place and one of the Skaneateles staples. Best Dish - Birria Pizza, Lalo Tequila Would Return - Absolutely

I am very impressed with this restaurant. My family was visiting from out of town, I brought them…read morehere. It was my first time as well. We were immediately seated for a late lunch on a Saturday. There was a large staircase to the second level so be aware of accessibility. Our service was off to a slow start but everything was too delicious. We shared the triple dipper (salsa, guac and queso) amongst 5 people, it was plenty to share and they offered to bring more chips. We all got tacos (steak, chicken and carnitas) the other 2 guests ordered chimichangas. Everyone thought their food was delicious. The chimichangas were humongous and could probably feed you for a week The restaurant itself was very clean. It had tons of natural lighting and very trendy decor. It photographs well and has a unique look for a Mexican restaurant

We really looked forward to eating here based on the outstanding reviews. Unfortunately, we were…read morevery disappointed with our experience, food quality and the food portions for the extremely high prices. We called to make a reservation, but were told one was not needed for a Thursday night. We were also told to not be discouraged by the number of cars in the parking lot based on a meeting that was going on in another part of the building. When we arrived, there was no hostess, but a sign read, "please seat yourself". As we sat at one of the tables there was only one other four top that was occupied. It took about 10 minutes for our waitress to come to our table. This was a different person than the one assisting the other four top. I would note that she failed to acknowledge us or great us the three or four times she entered the room. We ordered two bowels of the NE clam chowder and an order of onion rings. We ordered the chicken tenders with fries, chicken parm with spaghetti (we were told they had no other type of pasta to choose from) and fish and chips. The soup and onion rings arrived first. The soup was good but not the best. It did taste homemade, but lacked the great flavor you would expect. Our first issue really appeared when we received the rings. It had a total of seven rings, included some rather small ones made from the bottom/top of the onion. This was unacceptable for a price of $14. Likewise, they did not taste homemade but a frozen type you could make at home. When our meals arrived we were again disappointed by the portion of the side of fries for the chicken tenders and fish. They also did not appear or taste handcut and consisted of a small hand full for each entree. The fish and chicken tenders were cooked well, but again lacked seasoning and taste. I was unsure if there is an onion or potato shortage I am unaware of, but the amounts provided as an appetizer and for our sides did not match the price paid. The chicken parm was likewise tasteless and consisted of one piece of chicken and store bought pasta. All-in-all it was a $105 bill, with three waters. We were also presented with a 3% surcharge for using a credit card, which would have been nice to know prior to paying. Although this appears to be common practice for small food businesses, I never had this charge assessed at "higher" end restaurants, as it is becoming more uncommon to carry that much cash anymore. Based on the above, we will not be returning. There are so many other restaurants in the area that are far superior in food quality, portions, and preparation for the price. Moondance is just a few miles down the road, which is one such option and Skaneateles has many others.

Excellent fish dinners....both baked and fried. Best that I've had.....ever…read more Very clean and cozy restaurant. Love it. Shoot out to Nick who took care of us. Will be back...definitely.

Mango salsa top notch Apple cider Margarita very tasty. Stuffed small…read morePeppers with jalapeño needs some seasoning or maybe chop more jalapeno spread it across the cheese. Beautiful view nice deck. Greeted quickly service speedy. Prices fair for most items and a variety on the menu. Nice spot in a sunny day great breeze. Sunday afternoon got busy around 1:30 after we had ordered.

Excellent soup--nice to be offered a brothy soup rather than a creamy one for a change…read more Interesting, fresh and colorful tortilla chips and peach salsa! Good burger with bacon jam. A riper tomato would have been welcome especially since in season. Nice fresh greens in salad with sweet strawberries and blueberries. Wonderful view of Otisco Lake. Spacious deck with shaded areas. Friendly service! Recommend!

The bloody Mary bar here is amazing. So many options, you can choose your liquor, the type of juice…read moreyou want in it and spice level and curate your own skewer. The bloody Mary also comes with a small corona, all for $16. Highly recommend such a fun experience.

Meh. I don't…read moreunderstand the popularity of these two restaurants, one being Blue Water and then this hot mess. We walked in, no hostess. No available employees, dirty tables galore and a bartender who would not make eye contact. We attempted to find a place to sit for several minutes while catching up on the SU football game. Then we left and went across the street to a much more hospitable spot where we were treated nicely and stayed for drinks and food. I don't think I will give this place another try unless I were very desperate.

We had a reservation for 16 today and could not have been happier. Our wait staff was outstanding…read more The food was delicious. Thank you for accommodating us. Your staff did a wonderful job managing 2 large parties simultaneously. My family has enjoyed your restaurant for the past four years as my daughter attended SU. It was only fitting that we celebrated her senior recital at the Sherwood Inn.

Our server was attentive, and I think the prices are reasonable for the location. Food was good,…read morethough I think with a few changes it could go from good to great. For instance the children's menu pasta was just noodles and sauce--no parmesan, no little piece of bread. Five stars for ambiance, assuming you get seated near a window. I'd give 4.5 if I could but will keep it a 5 since they deserve better than 4.

Still a great place to hang with a few friends and have a beer and wings…read more First Timers - Remember there is no wait staff...order at the bar.

Great neighborhood joint! Their wings are always crispy, and their loaded fries are a delicious…read moreindulgence. They're always quick - even on a busy night!

Wow! Our first visit to Stone Creek was absolutely amazing!…read more The food and service were outstanding! Began with the deviled eggs app. The truffles added the perfect touch to an old favorite that you never see. My wife had the lobster carbonara. Simply delicious! I tried the French dip. Tons of beef and the au jus was nicely flavored without being overly salty. Huge portion of coleslaw. Staff was plentiful and very attentive. So many other options on the menu we cannot wait to return. Highly recommend!

Great food, gorgeous restaurant, and incredible service! Absolutely loved my visit to Stone Creek…read more Very unassuming until you walk in. On a whim (and seeing they were booked up that evening) called ahead to ask how the wait was, and were told they were pretty full but had a few bar tables open if we can be there in ten minutes or so. We hustled over there and they promptly sat us. But not only did they seat us, the hostess that spoke with us had popped a reserved tag onto a table after we called- very thoughtful and on top of things considering we didn't ask for that! Server was incredibly helpful with recommendations and extremely personable. Other patrons were also so friendly and it made the entire visit so much more pleasant. Cannot wait to come back and try more of the menu. Food was well made, with familiar favorites turned up a few notches, as well as some beautifully thought out dishes that you would never have expected.

This place... knocked it out of the park! The service was excellent... the ambiance perfect and…read morethe food was Exquisite! A 4 course Prix Fix gastronomic experience! We had the Grouper and the Sea Scallops... we added some oysters on the 1/2 shell... in addition to to the spring rolls & crab cake as apps. The salad course was a perfect complement. We finished up with 2 desserts which were sublime... a lime tort and a poppyseed & raspberry gateaux and a cup of espresso BRAVO!

An historic gem. Always top notch food and drink. From the porch to the bar area and dining room…read more Class but comfortable.

Two of us went here on a sunny Fall day around 10/16/25. The…read moreweather was chill, but Gilda's never disappoints! Warm atmosphere in a small space, Gilda's is always great for a bite. We split a pizza and a salad. Both were delicious, as usual. We sat at the bar, and had a friendly chat with the waitress and the others seated next to us. Altogether a nice place for a quick, delicious bite.

Base my reviews off what you pay:…read more *Place was busy on a Friday lunch. Price - N/A Food - 3/5 - OK, small portions. Service - 4/5 - friendly and quick. Ambiance - 3/5 - fine, boosted by the lake. Overall - 3/5 - may be misremembering but food was better the first time around. Burger is still a classic, best burger in town. Pizza is fine, Italian is fine. Do not get the Zucchini Gnocchi unless you are a diehard goat cheese fan. Service was better, quick, friendly, good service, no complaints. Ambiance is fine but can't go wrong sitting by the lake. Still a solid place but food is not as good as I remember. Best Dish - Burger Would Return - Potentially for burger