I saw this pizza place on Yelp. The pics of the pizzas looked fabulous. We were looking for a new experience, so we went to Monterey Jack's. I could not have been more disappointed. The pizza crust was burnt. Nothing like biting into a slice and tasting charcoal. I thought this has to be an aberration, no, the party at the table next to us also had burnt crust. We did not complain. Just ate the charcoal flavored slices and vowed never to return. read more

Monterey Jack's - Burnt Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Kimberly, Idaho

Stopped at this cute little pizzeria on Christmas Eve on our way back from the mountain, we were super hungry and we had such a lovely experience at Monterey Jack's! The food was all delicious (super fresh, cooked perfectly and very flavorful), the service and staff were welcoming and very accommodating of our large group. The pricing was very fair. They were very kind and we couldn't have picked a better place to dine! Highly recommend! read more

Need to make specials so more family's can afford to eat here !! Too expensive!!! We like to support our local businesses but you need to work with us !! Check other shops and learn about prices and specials. read more

expensive and terrible. I literally ate one piece and threw it away. I'm sorry to write this review, but I ordered it based on the previous reviews. $17/small & it still was frozen crust. The sauce was very spicy. Ps. I also didn't appreciate being prompted on my carryout with a suggestion of leaving a four dollar tip... read more

best pizza i had in a minute no lie i would recommend it here if you're ever craving pizza. read more

Monterey Jack's - so good - Pizza Near Me - Kimberly, Idaho

The service was good but the pizza was great. Best pizza I've had in a long time! Ambiance was laid back and casual. read more

Monterey Jack's - Lunch - Pizza Near Me - Kimberly, Idaho

See all

I just don't know ... we ordered a pizza to go .. they said 20 minutes ... drove there after 25 minutes. wasn't even in the oven ... it was ok pizza .. but not mind blowing by any means. 35 bucks for family size Idiot pizza and 4 pieces of cheesy bread. The cashier had her mind one where else and folks that were eating in had to come back up and ask for their drinks ... then had to ask for the salad they had ordered ... I don't get it .... 3 people in the kitchen ... and one cashier .. two people eating in and regular people coming in to pick up .. yes i have worked the pizza biz before .. yes i understand being on the wait staff ... the pizza was just ok... i had to put the cheesy bread in the air fryer to " bubble " the cheese ... this place could be amazing with the right management to inspire the workers toward excellence! read more

What a great find!!' Excellent pizza. The crust is outstanding. Delicious red sauce and they do not skimp on the toppings. Only a 10 min drive from twin falls. Cozy family style eatery. All homemade. Nice varied menu. Very nice staff. I highly recommend. read more

Ordered a little early today, and Ed made the delivery possible. I have been ordering their pizza for over 30 years and never get tired of it. Tonight's was perfect as usual. Double pepperoni and black olive. We always liked theirs better than Twin Falls's. Thanks Ed. It will always be known as Maxie's to us read more

Monterey Jack's - 2X pepperoni and Black Olive - Pizza Near Me - Kimberly, Idaho

Monterey Jack's pizza is delectable and the the service is delightful. The first time I stopped in was while I was moving to Kimberly, tired, hungry and in need of a quiet place to enjoy dinner. They fortunately had just reopened their dining room after a staffing shortage and our server was friendly, attentive and very welcoming. We had their Mountain of meat, the potato pizza and a smores pizza for dessert. OMG it was all delicious. Even if this wasn't right around the corner we'd be back often- love it! read more

We gladly make the trip to Kimberly for our takeout pizza. They put lots of toppings on the pizza and the veggies are fresh. Hands down the best pizza in the area. read more

This place is where it's at! Pizza is DELICIOUS. We recently branched out and tried their lasagna which was TO DIE for- my 4 year old asks for it twice a week at least! Salad bar is always supreme. Service is every bit of excellence (we especially love Codie). Lighting is dim which we really love on these summer afternoons when we're trying to beat the heat. For as wonderful as this place is, it surprises me that it's not ALWAYS packed. This little treasure of a place should definitely be your next stop when you're shopping around for a place to eat! read more

Not sure how they do it but there really is something special about a Maxie's Pepperoni and Sausage Pizza!!! Also the delivery person was great! read more

After 30 years we finally made it back to Maxie's. We had the family dinner. We had a 12" pizza with pepperoni and sausage, garlic bread, a pasta dish for everybody and a salad. The pizza was great, full of flavor and lots of toppings. We got 3 different pastas spaghetti, fettuccine alfredo, and ravoli. The meat sauce and Alfredo were so good. My other daughter had chicken tenders. They were great, the chicken wad dipped in a homemade batter which was so good and crispy. A great place to go if your looking for great pizza and pasta. We will definitely be back!! read more

Monterey Jack's - Pepperoni and Sausage Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Kimberly, Idaho

Hungry and want Italian food or Great pizza. Easy to order and pick up or get delivered.

The cauliflower crust pizza is amazing. This is our go to for a Saturday lunch. Salad bar is fresh and staff has been very courteous.

The place was empty at lunch time. We found out why. Micro size salad. Tasteless crust. Pizza sauce probably came out of a can. Pepperoni heartburn stayed with me all day. Feel bad for the staff. They were really nice and hard working. read more

If you're driving between Boise and Salt Lake City this is a great place to dine. The establishment is very western-looking and their pizzas top of their class. read more

This place was awesome. They have great customer service. It is definitely affordable. The pizza was super cheesy and everything tasted so fresh. The wait time was not long at all. The employees here were very friendly. read more

Favorite pizza place in twin. They have good quality food and a variety of other things on the menu. My favorite is the create your own pizza. They are very helpful and kind inside the restaurant! read more

What great food. Service is great, and I love that they still have a salad bar. Lots of selections for food no matter what your mood. Can not wait to go back, it is a place I visit every year when we go to see family. Wish I could take the food and whole restaurant back to Oregon with me. read more

The pizza is the only pizzeria type pizza I have found in this area (twin falls included) and it is great! Their burgers are also amazing! The cost per person is kinda high, more than I would normally pay, but it is a great place to go as a family after our kids sports games. The dining room is rather small. The employees have always been very nice. Overall, I love Maxie's, but it's a smige expensive. read more

Been eating Maxies pizza since I was old enough to chew. Best place ever and unlike some places that lose quality and value over time this is not the case here. We have actually made it a weekly tradition in the house to eat from here. read more

Very good custom pizzas. This is an older spot but, waiters are always the same and very nice. Reminds me of the good old days. Very good cheeseburger pizza is what we had last time. read more

We have eaten at Maxies over the 35 years we have lived in Kimberly and always enjoyed the quality of the food. The thin crust pizza is a nice change to many of the chains in Twin Falls. The quality of the food is overshadowed when you are met very aggressive non-customer service driven staff. We had purchased a todays deals through Magicvalley.com which is a gift certificate at a discounted rate. The business agrees to participate in this program. When we arrived to use it, a lady grabbed it from our hand and headed to the phone stating she will call to see if it's valid. I assured her it was as we had not used it. After the call, she walked to us and said "it's not valid". Her tone was very accusing as it we trying to pass along a counterfeit bill. It's certainly not worth it to us for any amount to be treated as a criminal over an advertised/purchased certificate whose participation was initiated by the business. Owners - take note that your rude staff is driving away customers. read more

Maxies has excellent pizza, and the best lasagna around! I am sure they have other choices on their menu, but after you eat their lasagna you won't want to waste your time on anything else! read more

Decent pizza, but nothing special. Small dining room looks and feels more like a diner than an Italian restaurant. It is set up such that you order at the front counter and then go find a table. read more