Love this place. While I mostly come here for the calzones, the pizza is good as well! Great staff, very chill place. Again, 10/10 would give the calzones a go. They know their pizza read more

Terrible experience, we have ordered from Molinara's several times and has always been good. Tonight however our cheese and pepperoni was rancid, the smell was sickening. My husband called the manager and he stated "don't call here anymore, I have made 300 of these today ". REALLY! We were not looking for anything, they could have it back, we didn't, couldn't eat it. Don't order it's not worth the health risk. read more

Tried out this place for the first time, ordered the NY style pizza and LOVED it! The only other place in Tonawanda that has a great NY style is Olisi's and Molinaros has them beat!! We also ordered wings and for once ordered extra crispy and actually got extra crispy with this pizzeria unlike so many other places. Our food was excellent. This is definitely going to be our new go to pizza place! I wish I would have known a long time ago about this little best kept secret read more

The pizza was really solid, thinner NY style crust which I prefer to the real doughy Buffalo style. Sauce, cheese, and spices were delish. I like how they have a few different red sauces to choose from. Wings left something to be desired however, and the blue cheese was straight up terrible and tiny portions to boot. I'd definitely get pizza from here again but their wings are not very good. read more

Lived in Buff for about 4 Years now form NYC. Looks like I found a piece of home. Great Pizza. read more

I got the Steak and cheese sub. It was delicious. My favorite steak and cheese in Buffalo. Definitely recommend this spot!

Best pizza in buffalo, hands down. I'm just sad that it took me 6 years as a buffalo resident to find this place.. so much wasted time eating Franco's and bocce. This pizza is where it's at! Sweet sauce is 10/10 and tastes just like the pizza sauce my great grandma who immigrated here from Italy used to make. read more

In an area over-saturated with pizza spots, Molinara's has something unique that keeps me coming back. A delicious sweet sauce. They do thin crust, NY style pies that are good, but the sweet and semi-sweet sauced pizzas are downright craveable. They definitely stay in our pizza rotation for this reason and if you are looking to try something besides the standard Buffalo style pie you should give them a try. Also worth trying is the stuffed hot pepper roll. It is a gluttonous treat. Sausage stuffed banana peppers inside pizza dough then deep fried or baked. Good homemade desserts as well. read more

Don't do business here. People not friendly. Won't take multiple prepaid gift cards. Pizza was overly greasy. Anchovies tasted like rubber. Over priced for crap food. Sauce had no taste. Boss ended up paying cash with the whole gift card fiasco. Again, don't go here, but I am recommend going to Olisi's for food. Much better and friendlier there. read more

First time visiting. Live less than a mile away and really wanted an Italian dinner I didn't have to cook. The stuffed shells were fantastic. Would go back in a heartbeat for them. The breadsticks were also a big hit. While my son didn't mind, the bacon on the blt was super over cooked in my opinion. But like I said he ate it. The fettuccini Alfredo was the big let down. It looked amazing but not so much on the taste. It tasted funny honestly and ended up in the garbage. They seem to be known for their pizza. By the looks of the 3 choices for slices that were out on the counter I wouldn't have ordered it. Appeared to have been sitting a while. All that said, they will get one more chance from us. If only for the shells from time to time. read more

First time with the family here. We got a small white veggie pizza and a chicken finger sub. Everything was good as expected based on the reviews. The pizza dough tasted very fresh, and everything was bursting in color and flavor. The only thing that pissed me off was that we were the only customers when we got there. I can't understand why this little Italian pizzeria isn't hoppin! The staff was excellent and actually gave a crap about what they were doing. They are probably all family because they treated it like it was their own place. Check it out for your self. :) -a family of pleased customers. Thank You read more

Molinara's - Menu - Italian Near Me - Tonawanda, New York

Hole in the wall. We love their thin crust pizza with sweet sauce, pepperoni and mushrooms. We always our pizza with honey garlic and garlic parmesan wings. Wings are hit and miss. When they're a hit, they are exceptional! read more

Had good food before ,but today no,chicken finger sub with lettuce onion,well got lettuce tomato instead cold sub,slab cheese on it and this side salad should be ashamed,other household food was ehh,maybe checking around read more

They have other things and we've had their catering which was great, but we ordered the pizza and wings. Sauce is your choice sweet semi sweet and traditional. That's pretty cool. It's my style so pretty thin but well made, nice crust. Tastes made from scratch and made fresh.. cheese is his quality, plenty and more than one type. Wings are perfect, fresh not over cooked. Salad is big, enough for side. Man said on phone that it was for 1-2 people, but pretty big. Nice family run feel. read more

Pizza is terrible. Cheese is greasy. Also pricey for a cheese pie. Not NY style. I went here for NY pizza and got soggy greasy nasty pizza. Had one slice and threw the rest away. Ingredients are low end. read more

Absolutely my favorite close to home place to get pizza! The semi sweet sauce is an absolute must try and I'm sure, like us, will become your favorite way to get it!! Every time we go in the staff is always friendly and quick to get your order taken care of. If you haven't had this pizza, you're missing out!! read more

Very small place on the outside but once you get in there and order it is amazing it is the best pizza I have ever had they make it very fast very polite people in side they made me feel very welcome. read more

I think this is the best pizzeria in the area, and they have good prices. All their pizzas are great and delicious. You can dine or leave. The dining room is quiet and nice. The staff are great people and I would make sure to tell you if you were in town to go to Molinara's for pizza! read more

They got great slice pies up starting about 11am. Good selection and really great tasting pizza. The stuffed hot pepper pizza is amazing. I also like the pepperoni with sweet sauce. I wish I still worked over in that area. I miss the food. read more

Finally ordered from Molinara's earlier this week. Thin crust NYC-style, and they deliver! Actually, they offer several styles of crust, and several styles of red sauce (traditional, sweet, semi-sweet). I don't do white pizza. read more

Close your eyes and you would think your in NYC..Others claim to make a NY style thin crust pizza, this is the only place that actually does..Bada Bing read more

This is my FAVORITE spot for pizza, I have yet to find a better one anywhere else. New York style, sweet sauce, with cup & char pepperoni....the crust is soft but crunchy, there's a marvelous garlic flavor that makes this pizza!!! read more

I've tried Molinara's three times in the past year and a half. I haven't enjoyed it very much each time, but *want* to like this place because it is close to my house, the guys who work here (and possibly own it) are very nice, and because I have a friend who enjoys it. But each time the pizza has consistently disappointed me, being a little tasteless and a little too salty for my preference. I must say - I don't dislike their pizza. It isn't bad, and so many others might like Molinara's just fine. I believe they sell themselves as Brooklyn or New York City style pizza, and indeed their slices are large and flat. I enjoy a good Brooklyn-style slice, and enjoy Molinara's crust which was tasty. But the rest of the pizza, of which I've tried cheese as well as cheese and pepperoni, didn't impress me much at all. I enjoy Olisi's a tab bit more, which is just down the road and serves up the large, flat slice, when I'm in the mood for something other than deep dish or Western-New York style slice. Relatedly, Molinara's does indeed serve a very tasty fried pepper, stuffed with cheese and breaded to wonderful goodness. If i was a fried pepper fanatic, I'd definitely come here more often. Perhaps other dishes (other than the pizza) are equally as good? read more

This is my favorite pizza joint around they have different sauces and we usual go with the semi sweet! I cannot get enough I would recommend this place over any of the competition around. Their wings are pretty good too! read more

Bad day at molinaras Wings over cooked pizza crust unchewable you know it's bad when Mom says worst pizza ever and she's 90 my fault for trying something different read more

The first time I ordered from them, the guy baked my sub; WITH the lettuce on it, which just ruined it. If he hadn't, it would have been great. Stopped in there recently for a slice of pizza, which was overpriced & lousy. I've had better at John's Pizza & Subs read more

My girlfriend loves NYC style pizza so we tried this place. We arrived about an hour and a half before they close and there were some slices sitting on the counter to choose from. We were informed that We could not get anything fresh made because all of the cooks had left for the day which I found a little strange. I got a buffalo chicken slice and a spinach and onion slice and they were both pretty good. In my opinion they could have been heated up in the oven for longer. I also was not a fan of the crust at the end. To me it left a weird taste on my tongue so I let me girlfriend eat the rest of it because she was enjoying it. read more

A decent pie- but almost no sauce. Literally just cheese on dough. Called and ordered a second week in a row after our initial experience with no sauce...we ordered extra sauce and still...basically no sauce. An employee told us the owner told them to cut down on the amount of sauce used. We won't be back. read more

We've been going here for years, the service is always wonderful. We get delivery and they're always fast and they stand behind their food. 1 time, in the tons of times we've ordered, they made a mistake, and they fixed it immediately and re-delivered the food right away. Food is always delicious. It's a good place run by good people. read more

Have driven by this place to and from work for years thinking I needed to give it a try and now that I have I am really unhappy that it took so long. Perfect Buffalo pizza. Crust is awesome - a little crisp but tender and a little chewy. I go for the traditional sauce - less sweet and it is really good. Curl and burn (or as they say cup and char) pepperoni of course. I want to try other menu items but can't not have the pizza. Always friendly service but really with pizza this good I wouldn't care. If you are anywhere nearby you really need to try this pizza. read more

Wow, what a fantastic meal. We tried Sicilian style pizza (mamma Mia!), wings, a grilled chicken sub, and fried stuffed hot pepper roll. Hot, fresh and delicious one and all. You could tell everything was prepared with care and with quality ingredients. Thanks Molinara's we are all delightfully sated!! We will definitely be back soon. read more

Love everything that comes out of this pizza place. The traditional sauce is fantastic.

This is my favorite pizza place in buffalo! If you like sweet sauce pizza this is your place to go! The crust is buttery and amazing! There has been times that the crust was a little overcooked but it's usually cooked perfectly! A must try in Tonawanda/buffalo if you like NY style pizza. read more

My favorite pizza place in town. It is the most unique to me as you can order their sweet sauce. I'm not crazy about their traditional sauce but the sweet sauce compliments the oil and herbs they use so well. The new york style is great, but if you like a nice thick crust, the sicilian style is amazing. Give the place a try! read more

Delicious pizza I have been a loyal weekly customer for over a year - very disappointed in my recent visit to pick up my order.. the pizza was incorrect due to poor employee handwriting and I had to 'run an errand' for 15 minutes to kill time while they made me a new one. Ultimately not a big deal, but they didn't offer to discount the order or give me a coupon for my next trip or anything for the inconvenience!!! And they know I'm in there every week, it's the same staff all the time. From now on I'll go up the street for pizza that tastes the same but is $4 cheaper - no customer service will lose your loyal customers molinara's!! read more

i used to work down the road from Molinara's and would order once a week from them! they have great food, if you want the best taco salad ever get it from there! read more

Only thing I've ever tried and get from here is a large NY style cheese pizza with sweet sauce. It's my addiction still. A bit expensive, but so worth it based off of taste versus other pizza places in the area. read more