Great sandwiches and all different styles of sandwiches which make it impossible to try all their sandwiches. The Godfather is my favorite so far have not try all their sandwiches yet. read more

Cant say enough good things about this place. I have been here so many times, and have never been let down once. I guess if there is anything negative to say its that the parking situation might be a little tough because it gets busy in that part of town (which isn't even their fault) also if you are going around lunch time, expect to wait a little because they get Busy! (Because their food is so damn good!) definitely worth checking out, cant think of a better sandwich place in the area! read more

You have no idea what you are missing here. Best deli ever in NJ, every sandwich has an amazing touch my favorite : #10 read more

Clearly said I wanted a smoked turkey sandwich sloppy Jo and a corn beef sloppy jo. They gave me avocado and bacon on a turkey sub. No cole saw- nothing . Same with the corned beef. 20+ dollars down the drain. Already en route back home b4 we notice. They were nice but def NOT efficient read more

Millburn Deli - One of the sandwiches. Nothing exciting. Was hoping it to be "sloppy" - Delis Near Me - Millburn, New Jersey

13.00 for a sandwich and a drink. Good sandwich but obnoxiously high prices. They itemize lettuce and tomato on an already high price. A sandwich includes bread and meat only. Expensive area so rich people go there read more

We love the South West Chicken on Plain Flatbread housemade Iced Tea and small Greek Salad

One my ABSOLUTE favorite sandwich spots! They are quick, fast & Delicious! Their meats are always fresh & tasty! They never disappoint!

Love all of their griller sandwiches. Been coming here for years and never had a complaint. The place gets super packed around lunch time so get here early to avoid the lines. There is a park behind the deli which you can go and enjoy your delicious sandwich on a nice summer day. If you want tasty high quality gourmet sandwiches and tired of the old Subway, Mike's and other franchises, I would highly recommend this place. read more

This is a great place! Happen to be in the area and Pete Genovese from NJCOM has this place mentioned a lot. Gave it a try and nothing but great food and staff! Had a grilled chicken on a roll with mozzarella and bacon. YUM! My friend had the Rueben which looked great as well. When I'm back in that area, it will be the "go to!" Easy parking. read more

I've been eating here for decades. One of the few businesses where the quality hasn't gone down over the years. The sandwiches are fresh and delicious! read more

Service is always above and beyond! Quality and price of the menu is reasonable. Millburn Deli added the order ahead option and it's very convenient. Always satisfied after grabbing a sandwich from here! read more

Very sad. Ordered late at montclar location but there was no message warning me that they close early. I got there after they closed. So no food but they did charge my card. People at the location were very nice but didn't refund my money. I'm now having to chase them through my credit card. It's a new location and their systems aren't working. Very sad. Probably won't try them again. read more

Best deli I have ever been to in my life. The selection is tremendous. The food is fresh and delicious, and the decor of the deli is so interesting and colorful. If you are ever near this town, it is an absolute must that you get food here. read more

They have gluten free options which made it easy for me. I would recommend placing your order online ahead of time so that you can pick it up. Ordering online was super easy and quick. My custom sandwich was great and my GF bread was really good. The only negative is that this place is so busy, you will wait if you go directly and place your order. read more

Best deli EVER! I love all of the different sandwiches they have to offer! Everything is always fresh & delicious. My go to sandwich place

Great sandwiches. Had a sloppy joe Turkey and Roastbeef today. Both were delish. Also got a side of potato salad and that was also tasty.

All kinds of good solid sandwiches... rice pudding is yummy, when it's not sold out that is :(

The sandwiches here are absolutely delicious! I personally recommend the Godfadda as it's my favorite but you can't go wrong with anything e

*Updated review* The owner contacted me after reading my last review, and was sincerely apologetic. He offered me a gift card so that I would have he ability to try the sandwiches. I will say the customer service here is top notch! The owner knows he has an excellent product here. I ordered three sandwiches-turkey sloppy joe, #8, and corned beef (no, I didn't eat them all myself lol!). All were delicious!! The meats were fresh, bread was soft, and although the sloppy joe has a lot of wet toppings it wasn't soggy. That speaks volumes in and of itself. I can't say more than that, besides you must try it...I guarantee you won't be disappointed. My review is not based on the food, because I never got a chance to taste it, but on the lack of communication from the business. I had heard great things about this deli, and decided to give it a try. It's almost a 20 minute drive from my home, but thought all the hype would make it worth it. However, as I drove up and parked I noticed a closed sign on the door. When I walked up to the establishment one of the workers came out saying it was closed. Mind you on their website it said they were opened from 8-6pm. When I asked why they were closed, they said they close early the day before a holiday. If that is their policy I have absolutely no qualms with it, but it is best to state that on their site before customers travel to their establishment. There were several other people that walked up to the door expecting to be able to order food, and were turned around as well. These all seemed like frequent customers, so if they weren't aware of the business closing early the day before a holiday, how could a new customer know? read more

See all

Got rid of their baguettes. At least they're real ones. Don't even call out "gobbler" or ring bells anymore when you order one. Damn shame.

They know their business! Overstuffed and delicious sandwiches make up for not so great parking.

Fast-paced, always packed, difficult to find parking but the sandwiches are solid and pretty great! If you're looking for a great hot sandwich, delicious iced tea and just a quick bite to eat, this place is a solid choice. read more

Hometown Deli... The staff is attentive and makes sure your being helped. I only got breakfast... TAYLOR HAM EGG AND CHEESE ON A ROLL. The roll was soft and the Taylor ham was cut thick... one of the better deli breakfast sandwiches I have had in the area. I will certainly go back for lunch when in the mood for a sandwich! read more

Giuseppe. Joe Cool. Cup o' Joe. GI Joe. Josephus. Joey. JoJo. SLOPPY JOE! What's in a name? That which we call a sandwich, by any other name would taste as delicious. Much like the feuding Montague and Capulet families, the war over the Sloppy Joe sandwich rages on and the history runs deep in these parts of Jersey. As the story allegedly goes, a former elected official from Maplewood discovered this magical creation while in Cuba and solicited the Town Hall Deli in South Orange to recreate it for him. He said, she said, not really sure who to believe here, but I do know that the Millburn Deli makes one hell of a Sloppy Joe, among other things. In case you've never heard of this (which I hadn't before moving out here), this is not the Chef Boyardee-esque Sloppy Joe of your childhood, with BBQ ground beef on a hamburger roll. This is a double decker club sandwich on rye with varying combinations of meats (popular versions include pastrami, ham, turkey, corned beef, etc.), Swiss cheese, cole slaw and Russian dressing. At first, I didn't really like the sound of it, but GOT DAYUM. One of the best sandwiches I've ever had. This thing has a story and people fight over it, that alone should intrigue you enough to try it. What's more, Millburn Deli has a ton of other amazing sandwiches like The Godfodda, Cubano, Chipotle Chicken, various Italian subs, and essentially any other combination you can dream up. Basically, if you're preparing for a sandwich orgy, these guys should be your suppliers. The dudes behind the counter are no BS, but they work quickly like a well-oiled machine, and they also do catering. I have ordered platters a couple times for parties and they're always a hit. I freakin love this place and although I have had to forego a visit during peak hours more than once (it can be a complete mob scene here), I return again and again. Bottom line, this deli rocks and if you haven't checked them out, you need to get on that. Yours truly, Just some average Joe read more

I order from Millburn deli at least once a week. I LOVE their homemade iced tea. Salads and sandwiches are great! The brownies are good too! Awesome local place! read more

Very solid. Order was ready quickly even though it was busy. Will definitely come again

I grew up in Millburn and always loved this place, but success sometimes breeds arrogance and I'm afraid this is what has happened. I went there today and tried to order half a sloppy joe. They refused saying only full joes. Not everyone can afford to consume 1,000 calories at lunch or save half for later on. Do they think that providing a half joe will threaten their business model? I'm sorry, but the place has turned into a factory and I will never go there again. read more

In addition to the Pastrami Joe's & Pastrami Rueben, I've also started getting the Charlie Melt (tuna melt on rye w/ cheese & tomato). Next time I think I'm going to try the urban cowboy. read more

We went to Millburn Deli for the first time this Saturday... normally my husband leaves the Yelping to me, but even he wanted his two cents added. It was a beautiful day, a lot of people were sitting outside the Millburn Deli, there's plenty of seating with umbrellas and also additional seating next door. We walked inside and it was jammed, be sure to grab a number!! Once your number is called, also be ready with your order. The guys behind the counter were joking with each other and seemed to have a system down pat for the sandwich ordering and assembly, but as a first timer, was paying more attention to their back and forth than the lengthy chalkboard menu -- a whole board dedicated to sloppy joes (which I didn't understand at first because I was thinking about the sloppy joe I grew up with), a board for salads, prepared foods, and two boards for hot and cold sandwiches. I didn't make it past the grilled menu, so keep in mind their are plenty of options regardless of what you are craving. My husband, an Essex County native, knew his order immediately, a turkey sloppy joe... I, on the other hand, was overwhelmed so didn't thoroughly go through all the menu options, I landed on a Black Forest, which I ordered with turkey... turkey, cheese, apple, special sauce, grilled sandwich...amazing and gooey and delicious. Meanwhile, not being from Jersey, my husband informed me that this was not the sloppy joe that I had grown up with, but indeed something better. Three slices of rye with meat of your choice, coleslaw and thousand island dressing. He did want me to add that it was one of the top five sandwiches he's ever had... and that he would be dreaming of this sandwich (I guess instead of me). Our sandwiches were generous in size and cut in threes, which I loved and made it easier to eat. The bread was so fresh, as was the turkey. Look forward to going back and trying something new -- or potentially the dream-worthy sloppy joe of NJ. The deli was pristine, very clean, while there were a lot of people, there was an organized line and ordering process. I also ordered a black and white cookie... the flavors were there, but I prefer a harder frosting. Definitely recommend. read more

*2.5 Stars* I am torn about this place. The sandwiches are decent but the chaotic scene during lunch is enough for me to pass it up in the future. Parking on the side is a cluster. It's tight, it's limited and most people don't know how to navigate a narrow parking lot. When you finally walk into the place, it's mayhem. Deli workers screaming out numbers, kids unsure what the heck to order, no one is in the order of their numbers and I had the luxury of going with an angry, hungry coworker. Picture the snickers commercial that once their appetite is satisfied, they calm down. Yeah that was him. They have a lot of pre-made sandwiches, mostly with chicken. Their menu took up the entire wall behind the counter. You are rushed through and I advise if you go, have a slight idea of what you want to order. I have never witnessed such chaos yet quickness, quite humorous. After I had ordered my sandwich, I felt under the gun so I went with one of the premades (breaded chicken with bacon, chipolte sauce, BBQ sauce and it was hot pressed like a panini). Now this is where the disappointment sets in. I grabbed a bag of chips and a seltzer and brought my sandwich to the counter to pay: "That will be $13.25" "Come again?" "$13.25" "Did I break a window?" --sympathy chuckle from the young lady-- "Wow..." Millburn is a bit hoity toity but to pay over $13 for an average sandwich, chips and a drink is absurd! Thank goodness it was a nice day out because all they have is outside seating. A lot of it...which gives them an extra star. So if your looking to pay a lot for an average sandwich, fight for parking, feel pressured into ordering something because you are being rushed...this is your place. read more

This deli is the main reason why I would live in Jersey. I grew up in this town and after the hundredth visit to the deli, i still love it as much as i did when i first tried it. It's always busy, especially around meal times. High school seniors flock here every day during their lunch break. But you'll never have to wait long to order or be served. They are well-prepared for the masses of people. The prices may seem a bit steep for normal sandwiches and I've watched the prices steadily climb over my years there, but these arent normal sandwiches. They run around $7 a sandwich, which is a very good deal for the amount of delicious satisfaction you'll get. I'd pay a day's wage for one of these sandwiches. My parents love this place too. Definitely try the roast beef sloppy joe and the Godfather. The turkey gobbler is also good. The house-brewed and bottled ice tea is also a good grab. Even though I don't live in the area anymore, my parents still do. And whenever I visit my parents, I stop by the deli. read more

Crazy selection of foods and specifically sandwiches. Something for everyone's pallet. Highly recommended. Bring your appetite and good luck choosing just one item. read more

First off, delicious sandwiches. I had the Soprano (I think). Grilled chicken, pepperoni, mozzarella, peppers. Very tasty. Little light on the grilled chicken though, it was only a few thin slices which was a little disappointing, and if the taste wasn't there I don't think I would have been as impressed. They have two parts to their deli, the come to order, and the pre order. I did the former, but I recommend the latter. If you're new to the area the whole experience can be a little confusing if it's busy inside (which it was). Come in and grab a number. When your number is called, the. You place your sandwich order. There's a lot of sandwiches to choose from, so make sure you know what you want when your number is called or they get a little testy. Then you gotta make sure you're paying attention when they call your sandwich out. All of this can be bypassed if you order online or by phone and pick it up in the other half of their store. Also, they close kind of early, so make sure you grab something before dinner time or you'll be out of luck. read more

This place blew me away. Just when you thought a sandwich could not be more delicious, here comes Millburn Deli! Great quality bread, a variety of sandwich selections and fresh ingredients. Great service also. read more

This past weekend was my first time in Millburn and to be honest, there wasn't much to see. I've been to Edgewater and Fort Lee and while they're more alluring, Millburn has one thing to offer (besides my boyfriend) - THIS DELI. As soon as I woke up on Sunday morning, I sought out this deli and the infamous "Gobbler" sandwich. It totally lives up to the hype. How could it not?? It's literally thanksgiving on an enormous sandwich. If you love thanksgiving and wish it were thanksgiving everyday like moi, I highly recommend you try it. I also got chicken noodle soup on the side and you could tell it was freshly made that morning. My boyfriend is going back home for the weekend and I've already asked him to bring back a gobbler sandwich to Boston. I'm patiently waiting for Monday to come along. That's a first. read more

Millburn Deli - The gobbler - Delis Near Me - Millburn, New Jersey

I could go on for days about my favorite place in the world, but I will keep it short. Millburn Deli is literally heaven on earth. Everything they make is touched by an angel, and I look forward to coming back from school just to hit up the deli. Make sure to try any joe on the board, and for something crazy...get it grilled, worth it. Gobbler is great, godfather, and griller #8. Get everything,go with alot of friends and be in paradise. my only con for the place is that the iced tea is not as good as everyone else says...go for the snapple read more

Amazing every time been coming here for years and there is no sandwich spot like it. If you haven't tried it you aren't living

I'm from Jersey City, so going to Millburn is a bit of a journey for me. That being said, there are 2 main reasons why I come to Millburn: South Mountain Reservation: the park & trail that's conveniently located across the train station And ... Millburn Deli. I lie to myself and say I go to Millburn for the hike but the during the whole trip, I'm thinking about the sandwiches I'm going to order from the deli. Honestly, the hike is just a precursor/warmup for chow time. I know what you're thinking. They're just sandwiches. How good can they possibly be? I was wrong.. We all are ... Anyway ... you can't go wrong with the Godfather or the Cuban sandwich if you have a hard time choosing from their big menu. I can't wait to come back and try their much-advertised Gobbler - their ode to Thanksgiving sandwich. I do admit, its a bit pricy for sandwiches but the portions are generous and I know I sure as hell can't make one this good at home so I think it's more than worth it. read more

The worst sandwich I ever had!!! I ordered a chicken parm to go and it was absolutely terrible. The Bread was crunchy outside and soggy on the inside. The chicken was dry with no flavor whatsoever and the cheese wasn't melted. It looks like they make the sandwich on a panini press not an authentic chicken parm. Also. When placing the order the lady hung up the call on me, very rude!!! read more

Millburn Deli - Delis Near Me - Millburn, New Jersey

See all

Growing up in Short Hills, you just have had to spent some good time and money at the Millburn Deli. When they changed hands (what must be 20 years ago by now), everyone thought they would go down hill - new owners ruining a good thing, but the food got better, the service got better. They have added a ton of what looks like great things to me, but when I go i'm getting either a Sloppy Joe or Sub. Have to have their iced tea. read more