I really don't understand the hype with this deli. I've now ordered from here three times and every time my order has been horrible. One time the sandwich had grilled chicken that was completely inedible because it was tonight and horrible tasting and now I had a bland sandwich that was completely cut wrong leaving a top of bread with a tiny little piece of bread as the bottom. I do not recommend this deli. read more

Millburn Deli - Delis Near Me - Millburn, New Jersey

Best deli in NJ, hands down. I grew up in the area and would get the Gobbler (thanksgiving sandwich) and I would ask for it grilled in the panini. I get the god father as well. Lots to choose from. read more

Been going to this deli since I was a child. I live for the way now, but every so often I gotta go down there and get My ham Joe. And the quality. Has always been good. It's got more expensive, which is understandable during the years. And I love the iced tea. Matter of fact I might have talked myself into going up there this weekend. read more

This place will not disappoint.. Weather you want a Sloppy Joe, Italian Sub, or anything & everything in between. I have been eating here for over 10 years and am yet to be disappointed. Be prepared to circle the block looking for parking..I promise its worth it.. read more

The best deli I've had in NJ. Simple as that. Always go with the Pastrami Joe!!! Parking sucks but oh well. These folks are quick!!!

Millburn deli is a solid local eatery. Good price, good service, consistent quality. Recommended!

Everything is amazing! We have been going here for years. Large delicious sandwiches! You have got to get the God fadda!!!

The best sandwiches ever. No question or doubt about it. Their ready-made specials are amazing, and the Joes are wonderful, along with everything else they have to offer. Try the iced tea as well!! read more

Really disappointing - picked up food to go and both my sandwiches were completely wrong. I ordered a grilled chicken mozzarella tomato sandwich and got chicken cold cuts instead. I don't even eat cold cuts!!! My husband ordered a bacon turkey sandwich and there was no bacon on his sandwich at all! I repeated the order literally three times when I was there. My husband was frustrated and called, they told us to come back. My husband explained we have a newborn at home and can't come back. They did not even offer a credit or anything for next time. Really disappointed after all the hype! read more

Without a doubt one of the best delis in Jersey. Being from central Jersey, I still regularly make the hour drive up here sometimes just for Millburn Deli. My go to is the godfadda, but the soprano is a close second. Their in house ice tea is also great and goes really well with their sandwiches- you can't get just one or the other. At peak hours it gets REALLY packed in here because everyone wants a sandwich, but service is still reliable and the sandwiches always come out great. This deli is located next to a small park that my friends and I like to enjoy our food in, and there are other small places and eateries around town to enjoy. read more

Never disappointing. Love the Mediterranean salad. Very clean and many options to choose from

The best sloppy joes in the area. We swing over every so often and I send their sandwiches via Goldbelly to my mother who grew up with them.

A staple in the community! I've been going here since Highschool and even though I've moved away after college, I still bring people here to try their sandwiches! In recent years the deli has expanded and made room for more customers, phone and online orders too! read more

Absolutely best sandwich I've had in a very long time! I ordered the chicken cutlet gyro with lettuce, tomato, and bacon. SO yum! You do have to order online and pickup but they were pretty fast and it was ready on time. read more

My whole family loves the Millburn Deli. Husband and stepson either get the Gobbler sandwich or The Godfather. On the lighter side, the Charlie wrap is a yummy tuna salad with pickles. They're chopped salads are surprisingly tasty as well. Try the Fiesta or the Cobb! read more

Always consistent. Great food and good service. They've done a nice job with serving food during covid

The best deli around town, hands down!! So many varieties of sandwiches, salads, and more. My favorite is "The Mutz", mozzarella, pepper, and pesto, it's so good. Everyone should go to Millburn deli if they are in the area. read more

I am not so happy with the Millburn Deli. My dad grew up in Millburn and we have been coming here since I was a young child. Their customer service is where they lack. I have written them twice about a story of meeting a fellow fan out in California and they read my post and did not even like or respond to it. That left a sour taste. Then, my dad went to order sandwiches for a childhood Millburn reunion. People flew in from different states and countries to attend and when he called to place his order they basically laughed in his face and told him he was too late to place it. Fine if that was the case but no need for the extremely rude response. We ended up ordering from the Avenue Deli in New Providence which ended up being a much better choice and we will continue there. read more

Millburn deli is a staple for all locals. From the make your own salad station to the sandwich area, there really is something for everyone in your party. They are famous for the gobbler sandwich which is basically thanksgiving on bread - delicious? But they also have other amazing sandwiches- from the pastrami and turkey to the subs! If you plan to come here just prepare for a crazy line and an ordering system not for the faint of heart read more

Food is awesome, the wait in line is not, but it's worth calling ahead bc it's delightfully fresh and delicious- half the staff is lovely (ladies at check out) and other half is like the Seinfeld "soup nazi" - many good options- suggest to look online and avoid being kicked out bc you know ahead what you'd like read more

The sandwiches are a meal and a half. Delicious. It's really just a matter of what you're in the mood for, as they're all good. Excellent chicken breast in sandwich yesterday (Chicken Fresca, I think). The Godfather is amazing! Getting hungry writing about it. Enjoy. read more

Great deli! If you like paying overpriced YUPPY prices! Why are sandwiches over $10+? Because the housing market in Millburn is insanely overpriced and the rich control the market. If your looking for a nice lunch sandwich, look elsewhere. $16 for a sandwich, soda, and chips is ridiculous. As a passerby Millburn this town is disgustingly inflated and overpriced! read more

Love coming here for lunch! You can never go wrong with any sandwich you choose. So many options it's a hard decision. Always fresh and very tasty. read more

Don't order from here over the phone if you want any kind of customer service. Not sure if they think they don't have to be nice because it's busy, or something else, but I won't go there. Good luck. read more

Heard so much about this place and had to swing by on my way to the mountains for a hike! Went in at around 2 and the place was PACKED. Make sure you grab a ticket number because that's how they call you to order. I didn't know and ended up grabbing a number 4 people later. I was 20 numbers behind the current one they were serving but I had my order taken in less than 10 minutes. To top ittl off, I was out the door with my sandwich in less than 30 minutes. Can not help but be impressed with that husseling. I even got a panini griller! Got the soprano griller with pesto and the capi. Both were delicious but the capi definitely had more of a kick. The banana peppers really tied the sandwich together. Must go back for another visit. Heard griller #8 was amazing. Definitely worth a visit if you're in the area! Word on the street is it's a milburn classic. 6/2018 - they now have GF bread! read more

Tasty sammies. Moved here from Los Angeles and so happy to have found a great East Coast sandwich shop!

Paid $20.00 for chips, soda and a predominately cole slaw sand Russian dressing sloppy joe with a small taste of corned beef and pastrami. Had to use twenty napkins to eat it. Really please call it what it is which is a cole slaw and Russian dressing sandwich with a smidgen of meat . Charge less than $7 for what it's worth . And that generous .... Very surprised because they have a huge operation . Disappointing . read more

Millburn Deli has been here for 75 years, and once you try it for yourself you'll understand why. They make tons of ingredients in house, and all of them are fresh and delicious. I love anything with their house roasted turkey, and you can't go wrong with garlic mayo or a garlic roasted tomato, but they have literally dozens of options so you're sure to find something that hits the spot. read more

Great selection of sandwiches. Only tired once so far but will go back! Only negative is higher prices generally.

I have been obsessed with Millburn Deli since last year (I am relatively new to the area). My husband and I pick up sandwiches up all the time. His favorite is the Soprano and he sticks to it while I try some thing new all the time and they are all good. read more

My husband was dying to try this place due to great reviews from friends. While their Mediterranean salad was tasty, the ingredients were standard. I loved the dressing. My husband said his turkey sandwich was good, but was not completely wowed either. The ingredients of his sandwich were typical. It would have been nice if this deli offered above what is expected, however it is what it is. The service was adequate, so we will be back. This is a solid 3. read more

I always get the sante fe. The food is delicious but a sandwich and a side is $20+. Honestly, it is cost prohibitive.

Was craving a Sloppy, ordered it up through Goldbelly. Every bite was awesome, great Sloppy Joes. The Godfadda is no slouch either, best chicken cutlet sandwich I have had in twenty years. I have already ordered a second time, as the first time was so good. Second round just as good as the first. You want to taste great NJ deli sandwiches, here is the place. Enjoy! Only comment, why can't I order the Super through GB? read more

I ordered a Chicken Parm for lunch today and it was undercooked. Worst part is that I can't go back to complain because the parking there is horrible. Basically paid $10 for uncooked chicken :( Wish I got the wild bull instead. read more

Best deli in town and among the surrounding towns!!! Friends come in from Maplewood and Livingston to get a sandwich here. They have a wide selection of sandwiches as well as salads and warm meals, and so there is always something for everyone. I like both their sandwiches and salads, my favorites are the gossip girl and The Godfather with pesto (not Russian). However it is quite salty and heavy. People also love their iced tea. There is usually a long queue and the space gets quite crowded, but it moves. read more

Thanks again food is fresh help is nice very orgainized,. My husband loves their roast beef.

The best deli around! The sloppy joes, specialty sandwiches and salads are all fantastic! I'm am never disappointed. In addition the service is fast and efficient. What more can you ask for!? read more

Best sandwiches around. But there is one thing that has always bothered me about their menu. Their "GODFADDA" sandwich is made with Russian dressing? Sorry, but anything called the "GODFADDA" has to be 100% Italian. read more

We've been coming here for years and it's never a disappointment! I usually rotate between The Godfather, #9 grilled, and roast beef sloppy joe!! Everything here is amazing and definitely a great place to bring visitors!! read more

Millburn Deli - Roast beef sloppy joe!! So beautiful... - Delis Near Me - Millburn, New Jersey

Overall. 5 star. Terrific and delicious. The fried chicken is so sexy. If ur in short hills go there or you suck. Haha read more

Millburn Deli - Delis Near Me - Millburn, New Jersey