We're always on the hunt for great cupcakes, so we decided to check this place out since it's so close to home. Unfortunately, it didn't quite live up to our expectations. The staff weren't especially welcoming, but honestly, that was okay. We were there for cupcakes, not a red carpet rollout. The inside was nice and exactly what you'd expect from a cupcakery/ice cream shop. We tried a variety of mini cupcakes along with two regular-sized ones. The icing was definitely the highlight - good, but nothing extraordinary. The real letdown was the cake itself, which was dry across the board. The minis were especially dry, which made the overall experience less enjoyable. On top of that, the flavors just didn't stand out. Nothing really wowed us or left a lasting impression. After seeing so many people leaving with only ice cream, we kind of understood why. read more

Enjoyed some froyo and a mini cupcake (wedding cake flavored). They have several choices of flavors and labeled for dietary needs (dairy, vegan, etc). They had sample cups to try flavors so you don't commit to something you don't like. I went later in the day so several of the mini cupcakes were out. Appreciated the associate and shared a bit about the differences in flavors. The restroom was clean and plenty of parking. There are only a handful of tables inside, but several tables and chairs outside on the patio. read more

See all

What is your weakness? Cake? Cupcakes? Ice cream? Mine is cupcakes and if it's carrot-flavored cupcakes..and ice cream! Or if you're like me then just get the Cake Shake. It's a combo of the two! I'm so in trouble. Frozen and frosted goodies. The owner's love for yogurt and the desire to offer something of a healthier version of it by using only real ingredients. Then there's his love for cupcakes too. So Milk and Cake was born. This is a small nine year-old business by a local. Almost a decade old! Yay! Let's support local small businesses! They can bake custom cakes too. When I opened the door to this shop I fell in love with the cuteness of it! Especially that one little nook with the picture of a cow hanging on the wall above it. It's a romantic oasis. Check out their outdoor area. Worthy notes: *Cupcakes- made fresh daily in house *Soft-serve- 16 flavors *Cake shake-combo of cupcake and ice cream. *FRENCH press coffee, tea, and hot chocolate *Cookies *Gluten-free available every day. *Vegan available for orders. *Local premium frozen yogurt. No corn syrups, no artificial flavors, all natural yogurt, ice cream and sorbets. read more

See all

Got 2 cupcakes: birthday cake, and vanilla/chocolate. They were both good, but imo had way too much frosting; it was half the height. I think it should just be one swirl-layer or whatever. Then it's not too sweet, not too much, and I could physically eat the thing. read more

I was super excited to try these good looking cupcakes and was sadly disappointed. Don't get me wrong, they all looked amazing so 10/10 on that BUT the flavor of the sponge itself was not there. I really wanted it to be there and kept taking more bites but never got it. They crumbled super easily and fell apart after the first bite. I got 5 cupcakes bc I couldn't decide on a flavor and they were maple pecan, French toast, funfetti, almond poppi with lavender frosting and wedding cake. To me, they lacked flavor and in a weird way, they all kinda tasted the same. They are on the pricier side as well-about $20 for 5 cupcakes. The place is pretty big and open, inside seating and I believe they sell ice cream and milkshakes. The staff was super friendly as well. read more

See all

Still a cute little cupcake/frozen yogurt place! I went here with friends for a birthday celebration! We all got some frozen yogurt. We all had just eaten a big pasta dinner so frozen yogurt was perfect :) They have a lot of fun flavors and some were even ice cream! Plenty of toppings to choose from too! read more

Needed gluten free cupcakes for a baby shower and these were a hit! So happy to discover that we have gluten free bakery in Aurora.

I ordered take out from milk & cake (VIA door dash) and was very disappointed. I am not judging the delivery experience since I used a 3rd party service. However the cupcakes I ordered were dried out and tiny. There is no way they should have served them to a customer. For what they cost I expected more. read more

Had a hankering for a chocolate shake and found milk and cake right off of I 25 and Hampden. All I ordered was a simple chocolate shake and boy is it delicious! They have a huge variety to choose from from your standard milkshake to what they call cake and shake. I believe shakes with bits of homemade cake in them. I was looking down the list and there are certainly some options I would like to try and I will be back. The young lady behind the counter that made my shake was very delightful and friendly. Give this place a shot as the summer heats up. read more

Extremely dirty. Floor is sticky, tables had old dried puddles of stickiness. Unpleasant cold atmosphere. Yogurt tastes bad, fixings seem stale. I cannot recommend. read more

We ordered some cupcakes for delivery, and while they hit the spot and satisfied our craving, do not be fooled as these are nothing more that box cake mix and whipped canned frosting. They add some decor and maybe some food coloring, but really we were hoping for a legit, bakery made cupcake. While they hit the spot, these cupcakes definitely weren't good enough for us to want a second try. read more

Milk & Cake - Red Velvet Single Cupcake, Birthday Cake Single Cupcake, berry lemonade cupcake, Wedding Single Cupcake, Caramel Turtle Single Cupcake - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Denver, Colorado

What!?!? I haven't left a review yet? Honey I really hate to tell ya because you'll fall in love too! Just a great lil spot for homemade cupcakes and the have soft serve ice cream and froyo! Stumbled in accidentally and have been back four time since. I could come weekly but it would negate my workouts...! I digress, tasty full size and mini cupcakes! My favorite are the carrot cake and red velvet but they have many more flavors! Four stars because their frozen yogurt selection is small but 5 service and absolute joy felt when in the store! We always leave all smiles! read more

Milk & Cake - Strawberry Lemonade sorbet - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Denver, Colorado

See all

I have been buying cakes and cupcakes here for years. I ordered a cake online with plenty of notice (they require 48hrs) and NOWHERE online does it say you have to call with payment 48hrs ahead or they will cancel. They sent me an email yesterday saying they had everything setup for my order and to give them a call with payment. I called this morning and they said it wasn't in the 48hrs and cancelled my order already. I've heard of other bad experiences here from friends but now I WILL NEVER BUY FROM THEM AGAIN. Terrible customer service and the woman on the phone wasn't even nice and argued with me. You can't run a business this way when you say in an email you have everything setup. read more

I'm obsessed with ice cream and M&C has it all! Hard scoop, soft serve ice cream and yogurt options plus toppings galore. I prefer ice cream over frozen yogurt so I like that they have both options. read more

A MESS. girl working was on her phone even when checking us out, we asked for mini cupcakes and she charged us for large and wanted to replace it with a GF one. Flavors and ice cream were chunky and again a mess, all over. i almost threw out my ice cream because of how dirty the toppings looked. it used to be a lot better of place. NOT WORTH IT. read more

I found this place on Yelp. Needed a little sweet for my sweet tooth for the evening. I decided on the mini to give me variety. I had 6 & my husband had 6. I always like to be positive but I can't be on this one. If were not for the icing I would not rate them. Some were dry. The champagne & lavender/ poppy were better. I will have to say I was not impressed enough to go back. The service was great. read more

Milk & Cake - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Denver, Colorado

See all

Went here to taste test cupcakes for a party. And to see what the mini situation was like. The cupcakes were delicious. The cake was good, nice consistency & flavor-with flavor variations in the cake as well as the frosting. Noting this bc some places only change the frosting but keep the same cake. The frosting was also yummy, true buttercream and they don't skimp. As you can from the pics they are also attractively decorated. They have minis in lots of flavors, ready to buy. And you can order minis in all flavors. The price is better than other places in the area too. And they deliver! Will order here. Fave flavors were snickerdoodle, carrot cake, Reese's.... But none were bad! read more

Milk & Cake - Outside of box - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Denver, Colorado

See all

Store was very clean and well kept upon entry. Staff member was extremely friendly, professional, and accommodating. Kids and wife enjoyed the ice cream and the staff member boxed up some cupcakes for us to take on our way as well since we they were about to close. Would most definitely recommend stopping in for you're in the area. read more

We enjoy this place so much. SWEETEST clerk--very knowledgeable. Cupcakes are wonderful. Liks Ice Cream is a great addition. Much better than what you might find in bigger shop. Support a small business and patronize Milk & Cake. read more

The perfect sweet bite when you want a lot of variety without the commitment of buying 4 separate cakes. Love that they offer delivery w Uber Eats. Great tasting cake, the carrot was some of the best I can remember having. I was secretly hoping for some more pizzazz when it came to the decoration - (Food Network baking marathons have convinced me this is the way) Overall great dessert! read more

Milk & Cake - Small assortment (wedding cake, Oreo, lemon, and carrot) - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Denver, Colorado

Milk & Cake is my LIFE. There are lots of interesting cupcake flavors and they're all amazing! I usually like a more moist, dense cupcake. The cupcakes at Milk & Cake are more light and airy, but don't let that deter you if you're like me and you wish every dessert had the consistency of fudge. Go to Milk & Cake. You won't be disappointed. The French toast cupcake is my favorite. I was worried it would have an overwhelming maple flavor, but it's more like a vanilla or butter cake with just the right hint of maple syrup. I love the powdered sugar on the frosting. Also, can we talk about the frosting for a second? Usually the first thing I do when eating a cupcake is wipe all the frosting off, because most cupcakes have way too much frosting and it's almost never even good. It's almost always just pure sugar with no personality. Well, Milk & Cake cupcakes have just the right amount of frosting, and it's not just bland sugar. The frosting flavors perfectly complement the cake. The frosting at Milk & Cake is, well, it's the icing on the delicious cake! The carrot cupcake and the lemon cupcake surprised me, because I feel like once you've tried one carrot cake or one lemon cake, you've tried them all, but these were above and beyond. My other favorites include banana peanut butter, and caramel turtle, but seriously, they're all amazing. You can't go wrong! read more

Milk & Cake - Caramel Turtle; Lemon; French Toast; Banana Peanut Butter - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Denver, Colorado

First, I witnessed the manager taking care of a homeless guy and I wish I could give this place a better rating. What a good guy! Not sure if he is the owner, but WOW! The cashier on the other hand looked disgusted at the poor guy. Ok, now about the cupcakes. OMG these are so awful. I'm sorry. But they all were one-note. Way over baked and crumbling apart. The frosting is super thick and sweet. Nasty! Don't go to Cupcake wars. You will LOSE. Sadly I won't go back there. Boo! read more

See all

I visited on 3/13 and confirmed multiple times that the cupcakes i was ordering did not have nuts in them. On my significant others first bite there was a walnut inside of the french toast cupcake. Now we get to spend her birthday in the hospital. Unbelievable. read more

Milk & Cake, love the concept, but was disappointed. I ordered a dozen mixed mini cupcakes, they were beautiful, but dry, every single one of them. The icing was decent though...YUM! However, I wanted a moist tasty cupcake and I didn't get it, I was sure hoping for more! I had heard such good things, but this place fell short for me. I did not try their shakes, or full size cupcakes. They also have frozen yogurt and ice cream; you pay by weight for these treats and toppings. I am only judging the mini cupcakes. The staff were all polite, customer service oriented and very helpful! I did see where they make specialty cakes too. I may have to try again, we shall see! read more

See all

6 cupcakes for over $20.... I think the cakes I received must have been sitting out for a while because the frosting was hard. In my opinion the flavors all tasted the same - either like chocolate or vanilla. I wouldn't go back for their cupcakes. I think the bakery section at your local soopers tastes better than these for 1/4 of the price. The service was fine, nothing remarkable. read more

I ordered 3 random staff picked gluten free cupcakes. First off, these cupcakes are really delicious. They are very soft and moist, which is sometimes hard to find with gluten free baked goods. They are totally adorable with their decorations. The only downside is that they are pretty small and a little bit pricey. But alas, I will be back for more and definitely a good find for gluten free peeps read more

Milk & Cake - 3 Gluten-Free Gourmet Cupcake - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Denver, Colorado

Dessert is my favorite food group and Milk & Cake did not disappoint! I was surprised to see that their ice cream and frozen yogurt options were so amazing. It was over 90 degrees out today so I got vanilla ice cream with a bunch of toppings! The price is .58 cents per ounce, I was surprised how fast this added up. I didn't get a very large portion but it came out to over $5. The flavor was worth it but def check yourself before you break the bank with toppings. Their cupcakes are made fresh each day and come in a regular size or minis for $1.50. Worth the bite size! I will def come back here again, it was a nice atmosphere and like I said... dessert is life! read more

See all

The next time I ordered online and they were out of the flavors they called and asked what I would like as a substitute! Great customer service, thank you Milk & Cake! Will be a customer for life read more

We needed a sweet fix while staying in the area, and based on the positive reviews, decided to give Milk & Cake a try and we were glad that we did! My boyfriend selected four mini cupcakes and was pleasantly surprised with all of the options that he selected, and he was even more shocked to find that he liked the salted caramel most of all of the quartet. My weakness is fro-yo and I also opted for a salted caramel flavor, then topped with cookie dough. Service was friendly and we were happy to be able to get in and out without any issue and at a fair price. read more

Went there for cupcakes, got cupcakes, they were delicious. The frosting was flavorful and delicious, and the cake part was good too.

Milk and Cake is a cavity waiting to happen in my mouth but oooohhh do I love this place! It's my sweet escape and a fan favorite when I take any guests staying with me for that sugar rush that never fails to hit the spot! This little spot is tucked behind Starbucks and Panera Bread near I-25 and Hampden. You might have missed it unless you crave sugar like I do and found this gem under desserts on Yelp! It's definitely worth stopping in. They offer ice cream, frozen yogurt, gluten free, and sometimes dairy free options for those looking to satisfy that sweet tooth. They also have a topping bar that has more options than most any other froyo I've ever visited. You can put nuts, candy, cereal, sprinkles, whip cream, Carmel or chocolate sauce (plus it's Godiva!), and most anything else you can think of! They also have little tasting cups for you to try before you buy and ensure you a flavor before loading it up with toppings! They have a rewards program and the price is dependent on the weight. Always seem to have a few dollars off on each visit and they also have two for Tuesday's which is nice! Last but not least they have a selection of cupcakes that look too pretty to eat and are out of this world! They also have shakes that include a cupcake of your choice that is blended in and something I hadn't experienced before. Great spot. Friendly staff. Must try! read more

I highly recommend this bakery. My best friend is gluten free so I did a lot of research to find the best place to get a cake made for her 30th birthday. I called to place the order and the staff were super kind, friendly and accommodating. I went to pick up my cake later in the week to find it to be so festive and beautiful and they even made a 30 out of sugar for the top! That was a nice touch! They followed what I wanted so well. The cake was moist and tasty, the frosting a bit too sugary and with the added sprinkles but overall we were super happy with the cake and had some great photos with it! You would never know it was gluten free. It was also so big and we had leftovers which was nice :) I will definitely return to this bakery for a custom cake. read more

Milk & Cake - Gluten free Birthday cake - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Denver, Colorado

See all

The sweet experience, delicious flavors and a very clean and welcoming environment. Will definitely be back more then I should lol.

I can't speak for the frozen yogurt, though it looked like the usual self-serve froyo machines lining the curved wall. Based on the fun cupcake flavors, I have high hopes for their frozen treat flavors too, so might have to come back in for that one day. I came only for the cupcakes, so that's what I'm here to report. Creative flavors are always appreciated - almond poppy seed with lavender, Girl Scout Samoas, Pink Champagne among others, and their current flavor of the month: chocolate red wine..... I mean, all of the above, please! I managed to keep it together and only got 4 - French toast, banana peanut butter, Oreo, and snickers. Each one of these had fantastic flavor - my faves were definitely the banana peanut butter and French toast. Not too sweet and though I noticed that a couple of the cakes were a touch dry, it was nothing that made me stop eating and the creamy frosting completely made up for it. Great spot right off 25 that I can see myself making excuses to detour into in the near future. read more

I was so excited that they also have Lik's ice cream, delicious and a good variety of flavors, cherry chocolate chip is my fave yummmm.

$57 for a 6" cake that was so dry and flavorless that the 7-year old birthday boy didn't eat more than 2 bites, no one at the party finished their serving, and 3/4 of the cake is still sitting in the box 2 days later. After visiting this location for the cupcakes, I immediately thought of this place when needing a small cake for a birthday. I picked the cake up the night before my event, and as soon as I cut the cake I instantly regretted my decision. The cake was the furthest thing from moist and the "double chocolate" flavor was not there. This cake tasted like a box mix that had been baked the week prior. I feel like I would have had better cake going across the street to King Soopers' bakery, and would have saved myself $40. read more

Had to try the Cake shake. Had the vanilla Birthday cake. That was so good. Will have to try again when I'm in the area.

Great variety of sizes, flavors, and styles. This is a great place four when you get assigned to bring dessert to the family dinner.

I bought 6 cupcakes to share with my family after dinner. We split all 6 flavors: french toast, almond lavender poppyseed, Pina colada, strawberry cream, pink champagne, and snickerdoodle. We really appreciated all the creative flavors and most of them were very good! The Pina colada was the crowd favorite. The strawberry and cream was the only outlier; it tasted weirdly artificial which surprised us considering the quality of flavor of the other cupcakes. I also noticed their cupcakes weren't consistently sized; two of our six seemed like the cupcake tin had been underfilled before baking and we're about half the size of the others. That being said, I'd still go back again to try their other flavors or even their milkshakes! read more

You had me at milkshakes made out of cupcakes along with the lure of a traditional yogurt shop. They have several flavors of yogurt, ice cream and even some sorbet and of course tons of decadent toppings. The cherry on top comes in the form of a milkshake. They take your choice of cupcake, frosting and all, and blend it into your milkshake. Wow! Yummy! Can't wait to come back! read more

Milk & Cake - Yogurt dispensers. - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Denver, Colorado

See all