They have the absolute best steak you can get anywhere in Lima! I order mine well done and I swear it still melts in my mouth! The service is always great! I highly recommend this restaurant! read more

I left feeling disappointed. The food was meh, about on par with Olive Garden. The worst part was the service. We sat waiting for our food for about an hour. We were only asked if we wanted more bread after we had boxed our food, and when they said they'd give us some to go, they never did. read more

See all

The cheese bread was delicious. The owner is cool. and the pasta sauce was good. meatballs are massive, like the low taper fade.

Good menu, food and kind staff. The restaurant is clean and well maintained. I like the Thanksgiving take home meals.

Ever since coming to live in the area, I have been told by several people how delicious Milano Cafe is. They would rave about the food. After hearing it for a few years, my family and I came by one weekend to try it out. Sadly to say we were disappointed. Driving to it, the outside is actually quite nice. It looks like a quaint and rustic Italian mom and pop restaurant. When you go inside, well it looks like a rather old basic bar. The atmosphere, in other words, ends at the door. There was no wait and we were immediately sat down. My brother and I ordered beer, my mother wine and we also ordered some apps. My brother got a caesar salad and we all got the mozzarella marinara. These were some thick and hearty mozzarella sticks. They did not taste or look store bought and were the highlight of the meal. I ordered for main course the Pork Chop Augustino, while my mom and brother each had their own pasta dish. All the dishes are hearty it seems but the taste is the part that needs work. The Pork Chop Augustino was ok... it was a bit bland actually. My family disliked the pasta dishes. We left most of the food and left feeling dissatisfied. Maybe it was an off day, we are not sure. But we are unlikely to return. read more

See all

I'm Italian so perhaps I'm A bit picky . I ordered the chicken Marsala dish. It was ok. The waitress was lovely but we sat for An hour waiting for our food after we ordered and it arrived cold. The quality was ok but absolutely not worth the 20/plate average cost! I won't go back . read more

Ive been comin to Lima for years and Ive never thought about gettin pizza from this place until this weekend so here it is.........Not bad but not good. Ya ever tasted somethin and said "This doesn't taste like anything" well that's the pizza. I asked for extra sauces of course and it had no flavor at all. They make their own Italian sausage and it was jus ok. It had a bunch of cheese which didn't taste like anything either and the crust was too chewy and flavorless. We got meatball too. They were cooked right and from scratch so that's the good news. They added the flavorless sauce to them and it didn't do the meatballs any favors. I will give this joint another try but I will get somethin without their red sauce. read more

Milano Cafe - Meatballs - Italian Near Me - Lima, Ohio

See all

Had my mother's surprise birthday party here and the staff at Milano's did a great job taking care of the 30 people in attendance. The appetizers that were bought for the party were delicious and the server taking care of the party did an outstanding job. I apologize for not taking pictures of the food. But the stuffed mushrooms were excellent. A very nice Italian restaurant even for a romantic dinner read more

Today was our first time here and we really liked it. We got the Tour of Italy appetizer which included portables mushrooms, calamari and mozzarella sticks or should I say logs because those things were huge and everything was good. My wife got the Walleye and I got Chicken Nunzio. Both were really good. Staff was all super friendly and our waitress Kathy was the best. read more

5 star rating. I can't remember the last time I finished a full meal not caring if I was full. We went here for a team lunch and, for the love of God, the food was phenomenal. I had the pesto pasta dish and added a side salad. The bread was brought out, complimentary, to start and it was delish. The melted garlic butter and cheese was epic. We asked for a box to take it home. It was plentiful, even for our table of 4. The house salad was fine - unusual for a house salad which I actually really appreciate. Kalamata, chickpea, bell peppers, lettuce, tomato, onion - the works. But that pasta..... perfectly cooked - fresh flavors and the best size. Not too much but enough that as I started to get full, I didn't care. It's 8:00. I ate at 11:30a. I'm still not hungry.... read more

Milano Cafe - The best bread on the planet with garlic butter and melted cheese - Italian Near Me - Lima, Ohio

See all

The wait staff was very nice, but when they were told my pork chop tasted old like it was freezer burnt and I only ate two bites she said she'd tell "Frank". It didn't do any good. The cheese cake was very tasty. The environment was very nice. Just wish that my entree was eatable. read more

We had come from out of town and the pictures of the place looked cute. When we walked in the building had a weird sewage smell to it. Staff wasn't very friendly from the get go. They gave us attitude when we were unaware that you sit yourself and you can only sit in specific tables. The whole atmosphere just felt unpleasant and off. The staff seemed annoyed. When our food came out it was cold. My friend got the fettuccine and when I tasted it, it had absolutely no flavor. It literally tasted like milk and noodles, parmesan couldn't even save the dish. Mine was just very mediocre. The pasta wasn't fully cooked and the sauce tasted like a bottled marinara. The only thing pleasant was the meatball as well as our bread. The Caesar salad had a weird fishy smell and taste unlike any other we've had. Another customer complained of waiting long and receiving cold food while we were eating. Our waitress yelled back at him and told him "this isn't fazolis"....unfortunately I think I would have rather went there. The whole experience was just so disappointing. It left us with upset stomachs and still hungry. We were very nice even though we had a feeling we should've left from the start. I unfortunately don't recommend unless you want an awkward and flavorless experience. read more

Wonderful staff delicious food and drinks... we went in for valentines to have dinner and where just so impressed with how friendly and efficient the staff was. The place is clean and inviting. I ordered a chicken dish I'm not sure the name and my husband ordered raviolis and they were just amazing. They have house made garlic cheese bread just we just loved it. I also had a salty caramel martini that was delicious The price was not too much definitely worth the great service and food read more

See all

We just love this place! Love their house salad and excellent quality food and good service! Highly recommend!

We just went here for the first time and it was great! Friendly staff, nice atmosphere, delicious food and excellent prices and portions! Looking forward to going back and trying more of the menu! read more

I wouldn't describe it as good fresh made from scratch Italian food. It is way overpriced for what the food is, which was just OK. My wife and I travel quite frequently and always prefer to eat at local establishments rather than commercial chain restaurants, but after eating here we should have gone to Olive Garden instead. The bread was still doughy and tasted like the frozen loafs one buys at the grocery store. It was not fresh bread, which was disappointing for an Italian restaurant. The salads were fresh and nicely chilled, but we requested no onions on them and when we received them... they had onions. Which I know.. isn't that big of an issue, but it does indicate that they were pre-made and they couldn't be bothered to remove the onions. As for our entrees, I ordered the Chicken Nunzia which was fairly decent, but the sauce tasted like it came out of a package with some fresh mushrooms added. It was heavy with sodium and had a presertative like taste to it. It was definitely not made from scratch. My wife ordered veal piccata and it was so bad she sent it back. It was not only cold, but tasteless and swimming in oil and not good olive oil, which doesn't make a difference, too much oil is not good, but it does indicate the type of Italian kitchen it is-subpar. They did replace her meal, but the waitress copped an attitude. My wife rarely returns her food, but for the price (23.00) she thought the piccata should be hot, good, and at the least taste like piccata. She also lived in New Orleans for 20 years and knows what fresh, good Italian food tastes like and sadly to say, this is not it. To top it off the proprietor couldn't even be bothered to make an inquiry about the sent back meal or offer an apology for the inconvenience. Which indicated to me he really doesn't care about the quality of the food or the guests' experience at his establishment. My guess for the poor quality of the food is the kitchen is ran by a line cook and not a chef. A real chef would be embarrassed by the food served at Cafe Milano, as should the proprietor be, but apparently he is satisfied serving subpar over priced food. As for the snippy waitress, she should remember she is working for tips. read more

The best Italian in the area. Everything is family recipes. I prefer the chicken parmesan, however the lasagna is great too.

Had a great time, atmosphere, service and meal were absolutely spot on! Had the special (prime rib) cooked PERFECTLY!

Very good food & service! I'm picky about Italian food & this is the best around. You won't be disappointed!

Googled "salads near me" they came up so I stopped in to see what their salads were like. I gotta say the "Tuscan" was great. super fresh looking (no wilty or bad lettuce all super green), and TONS of fresh fruit of different types (strawberries, thin apple slices, melon, and grapes). It had some fresh grated cheese (not a lot) and came with some type of sweet vinaigrette. I added a grilled chicken breast. Only wish I had taken a pic for this, as I ate it back at the hotel so fast I was half way thru.. oops too late. Staff was friendly. Wish I had gotten an ice cream I saw go out while I was waiting, or the Tiramisu Gelato I overheard someone ordering, but I have to stick to just the salads. Lol I would definitely go back. read more

Had my mother's 75th Birthday dinner there and had the back room which was very nice! Good food and service was good.

Superb Italian cuisine. The food never fails to be anything less than a gift from the Gods. When initially see the price you might question if the food will live up to the expectations. We'll rest assured, it will most likely surpass! If you are able to really take time and enjoy 5 star dining is available at Milano's! read more

Had a reservation with 5 people for my friends birthday. Took over an hour to get our food. Ambiance is decent, nice lighting and tables. Staff is friendly. food was decent, nothing special. read more

Milano Cafe - Alfredo with chicken - Italian Near Me - Lima, Ohio

First time trying this restaurant. My husband and I were away from home and wanted to try a new Italian restaurant. Based on reviews/rating we thought this would be a good place to try. Unfortunately we likely won't be returning. I ordered the wild mushroom fettuccine and asked to substitute broccoli for the house salad. I was informed that I could do a cup of soup but the broccoli would be an up charge. However on the menu the side of broccoli was $3.50 and the cup of soup was $3.99. Even after bringing to their attention they still said they would have to up charge at least $1.75 for the broccoli. The breadsticks were good but our waitress did not ask if we wanted seconds and was sure to bring seconds to another table. My main entree was disappointing, it was so salty I could hardly stomach it. Not only was it super salty but it had way too much butter! See picture. read more

Milano Cafe - Wild Mushroom Fettucine - Italian Near Me - Lima, Ohio

This place was pretty good! I needed vegetarian food, and they had a couple of options for me. I tried a summer fruit salad plate with sorbet for a light lunch, and it was very yummy. Service was very good, and the atmosphere was peaceful. Ok, 6 months later I'm dropping down to 3 stars. There are two vegetarian things -- pasta with red sauce or pasta with white sauce -- and the server never refilled my water. I'd go back, but I'm not wanting to endorse the place. read more

So far the service is sub-par the ambiance is lacking, the decor is dated... The garlic/cheese bread you get for free felt rubbery at best, a little time on toast would have helped the freshness. I ordered one of the house specialties, the Asiago Sirloin, with crispy portabello and Asiago whipped potatoes, medium rare. The steak came well done, and sure didn't look like a sirloin... anyway, the mushroom were good but slightly over seasoned. The mashed potatoes were tasteless on the other hand, and lacked seasoning... I didn't care for the dish and didn't even eat half of it, when asked I did tell them the steak was overcooked, they offered to replace it, but I wasn't interested... they did not remove anything from my check and charged me the full $19.99 for the entree... Probably won't be back. read more

Milano Cafe - Italian Near Me - Lima, Ohio

See all

We were here for a late Christmas gathering on Dec. 26, 2021. There were 6 of us. All the food was swimming in olive oil and no seasoning. Even the shrimp was oily. I ordered the Pita Gyro but with chicken. Something they called chicken was gross. I actually ask the waitress if this was real chicken. Waitress was "Jessica". Friendly but not attentive. She never ask us how our meals were, We had to look for her when we needed drink refills and even to pay the bill. Terrible Terrible Terrible. GO ELSEWHERE. read more

The food was excellent today! The meatballs were HUGE and amazing. The side salads were exceptionally good... the shaved cheese was a perfect topping! I had classic spaghetti and meatballs and it was delicious. My son had a fish bruschetta that he thought was good but that he would never get again due to the saturated roasted tomatoes. Our waitress was the downfall. She seemed to be the only one on the floor, although it wasn't busy at the time we went. She kept complaining of being hot. She rarely came back to the table with the exception of bringing the check that is. Probably I would've given it a five had we not had such a poor server. read more

Milano Cafe - Italian Near Me - Lima, Ohio

See all

Excellent food and service. Nice little jem in Lima. Tortellini Cab was excellent reminded of the excellent food I can get back home. Our waitress was wonderful and helpful. read more

Milano Cafe - Italian Near Me - Lima, Ohio

Food was good besides the fact my cousin found a piece of tin foil in her food service was slow

Food is great and the drinks are delicious. The staff is always so pleasant and warm. Appreciate having the restaurant in the Lima area!

Stopped in to try because it received decent Yelp reviews. An atmosphere for the older crowd. Not very trendy for the younger crowd. That was very apparent. The food was average. It wasn't bad. But I wouldn't justify the price for the product. I think they could adjust that. Overall I would say it was an average experience. Nothing spectacular where I would return again but nothing horrible that I would tell others not to visit. read more

The last thing one wants is to provide a negative review for a local restaurant, especially when the staff greeting you seems friendly. But my gawd what I got was much worse than what an elementary school serves on their "Italian day". In 20+ years of eating Italian at establishments big and small across the US, Rome, Milan, Venice, Florence, Palermo and so on; I have never seen anything like it - I'm not holding it to Italian-food-in-Italy standards, I'm saying Olive Garden seems like something from the heavens compared to this. I ordered food to go. The calamari was cheap, small, stringy and heavily breaded. The portabella sticks had an insane amount of moisture. The bread was just undercooked, seemed like frozen bread that was done in a microwave instead of an oven. The star of the show was my seafood pasta. I'd asked for fettuccini which they obliged - I wasn't expecting house-made pasta, but I have never had such stringy, overcooked pasta since I boiled Barilla to death in college. There was no seasoning in the pasta - none, even no salt. No basil. And the seafood was something I have never seen, ever. Think of the tiniest scallops you have seen, then think of something a fifth of that size. Diced shrimp pieces, perhaps a total of 2 salad shrimp. I could go on but you get the picture. I'm sorry dear owner - you seemed friendly and interested in your patrons. I just wish there was - forget a chef - even just a basic cook in the kitchen who had ever seen an Italian cooking show. read more

Over priced and mediocre at best. A place that makes you feel like their doing you a favor to be there. Meatballs not seasoned at all. read more

Good Italian food all around. The wait staff is friendly and attentive. The restaurant isn't always the cleanest and their draft beers need to be a little colder, but it's a great dinner out. read more

I am a 3 strikes your out kind of girl. My first experience here was not so good. The apps were great, the wine was delicious but my main course was disgusting. I order chicken piccata and took one bite and was done. It was soaked in butter, it smelled awful to the point my husband even commented. Maybe they were having an off night I don't know but I would be willing to come here one more time to see if their performance improves. read more

Great food for a great price. Waitress very attentive although we are in another room. Breadsticks are lit

We would like to thank the Milano Cafe for providing a funeral luncheon for our family. We had made previous arrangements with another establishment for the luncheon and due to 3 inches of snow the previous night before the day of the funeral the restaurant failed to notify us that they were not going to open. Our family arrived at the restaurant only to find a sign posted "closed due to weather". We quickly made a call to Milano's to see if they could provide a buffet for 40 people and they were able to accommodate our family with less than a 15 minute notice of our family arriving. They provided a lovely buffet with lemon chicken, pasta, green beans, salad and bread in less than a 30 minute wait. The food was delicious!!! We cannot thank the owner and staff enough for the excellent service we received!!!!! read more

Great appetizers, decent service and nice atmosphere but the pasta dishes have decreased in quality since my last visit. Of the party of four we had, my angel hair dish was too spicy, the Alfredo was bland and the tortillini cabanaro dishes were salty. Everyone in our party was happy but no one was impressed with the pasta at an Italian restraunt. Hope that turns around because the brachetta is still the best in town and I love the good house Italian salad dressing. read more

No wait close to 5pm, fast and friendly service, hot and tasty food, personal thank you from the owner. You can tell there is history and heritage in this place. read more