Cancel

Open app

Search

Mikey's Pizzeria

4.8 (17 reviews)

Order Mikey's Pizzeria Takeout or Delivery

Mikey's Pizzeria Photos

MIKEY'S PIZZERIA ATMOSPHERE

What's the vibe?
Casual
Dogs allowed

You might also consider

Recommended Reviews - Mikey's Pizzeria

Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
Yelp app icon
Browse more easily on the app
Review Feed Illustration

Reviews With Photos

Menu
Maia H.

Honestly winning me over with the sweet tea. I got sausage pizza and hot honey wings. Wasn't a big fan of the hot honey wings bc it was just mikes hot honey sauce :/ they food was nice and hot and she brought it directly to me which was nice. Very clean and open space. Its giving classic pizzeria with arcade games and prize crane! Even the pizza boxes stacked up I really see the vision they're going for. I can see this being a very good place to come with children or even after an event.

The White Pizza add Prosciutto
Jaime S.

My daughter and I had dinner on a lovely Monday night at Mikey's. There's plenty of parking in the parking lot out front. It's super cute inside with plenty of seating. They even have a couple of arcade games. We were greeted as soon as we walked in. We took some time to order since this was our first time visiting. We ordered the side of meatballs and The White Pizza, and added Prosciutto. The meatballs were so good and they came with breadsticks, they were good too!! The White Pizza was absolutely delicious. They have the best crust!! We then had a cannoli, which was good. They have daily specials. The menu is plentiful, appetizers, pizza, pasta, subs & salads. They even have a kids menu with crayons and a coloring page. I can't wait to go back!

Gabrielle B.

I had a slice of pizza and a lemonade. The pizza was good. Nice and spacious. There is inside and outside seating. They have a few arcade games and there was even a birthday party when I was there. Very family friendly restaurant. They sell THC seltzers. The cashier was super nice and helpful.

Margarita 12in
Kristal R.

Seriously one of the BEST bruschettas I've EVER had!! I always love to test out bruschetta whenever I see it on a menu and honestly this alone is worth coming back for A LOT!! The pepperoni was very classic and delicious. The Margarita was very classic and great too. The line works quickly and they do come by and help move plates out of your way which was so nice. I will absolutely be back!!

Samantha R.

The pizza is some of the best NY style I've tasted in Raleigh. Not too saucy and a plenty of toppings. The side of meatballs is a bit high in price, almost $13 for three large meatballs, topped with ricotta and it does come with garlic breadsticks. The place is super clean, service was quick and made to order. And there's a cute little arcade so kid friendly!

Cheese Pizza with Fresh Basil
Victoria R.

Delicious NY style pizza in Raleigh! I'm from NJ so I am very picky with my pizza - this passed my test. Sauce is garlicky, crust is thin & crisp, & the cheese pulled nicely. They also had fresh basil as a topping which is my favorite! Service was great and ambiance is that of a classic NJ/NY pizzeria. Will definitely be back soon!!

Pepperoni  and mushroom ‍
Lola W.

Went to check out Mikey's pizzeria because who doesn't love a great pizza joint. The crew was friendly and the place is inviting. They sell pizza by the slice, whole pie, and have deserts. They have a beautiful red wood fire oven to make this great pizza. I love a good pizza, especially a New York style pizza. The most important thing for me is the fold, hold, and crunch of a pizza. This one has it! When I folded the slice in half it did not droop like most pizzas! The taste was great and the size was just right! Go check them out! The parking lot around there gets really busy so bring your patience and your awareness.

Half Rustiche, Half White Pie
Emily G.

Decent experience here! We visited and dined in on a Friday evening. Very quiet. We ordered an 18 inch half Rustiche and half white pie. It came out hot and tasty. It was around $30 which is steep for pizza, but fed 3 people.

Mushroom slice
Rebecca F.

Great addition to the pizza scene! From the family of Vic's Pizza, this spot will scratch that itch for sure. The restaurant is very clean and employees are all super friendly. Food: fantastic! Fresh ingredients, lots of toppings even for a 1 topping. Desserts very refreshing too! The chicken wings keep a little of their crunch and are very flavorful. A few claw machines inside and pinball too! Everything is also very clean. Highly recommend!! Heads up! There will be a grand opening celebration on July 11th and a raffle to win free pizza for a year! Also, lots of family friendly activities planned that day.

Perfect cheese to sauce ratio with thin crust. Delish!

I'm originally from the northeast, so I'm always looking for good pizza, and Mikey's Pizzeria lives up to that standard. The staff are super friendly and eager to help, and the food is top notch. You can tell they use quality ingredients. The sauce to cheese ratio is perfect and the crust is thin and crispy. Mikey is really passionate about what he does and it shows. Highly recommend.

Meatball and onion pizza

See all

3 hours ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

23 hours ago

Helpful 1
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0
Photo of MK W.
23
194
2139

3 days ago

Helpful 1
Thanks 1
Love this 2
Oh no 0

3 days ago

Helpful 1
Thanks 1
Love this 1
Oh no 0

6 days ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

2 days ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

2 days ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

2 days ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

5 days ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

5 days ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

3 months ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

4 months ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 1
Oh no 0

2 months ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

26 days ago

Helpful 1
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

1 month ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0
Photo of Jay F.
309
3
2

3 months ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

3 months ago

Outstanding pizza and great ownership. This is a welcome addition to the neighborhood! This will be my go to in the future.

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

Ask the Community - Mikey's Pizzeria

Review Highlights - Mikey's Pizzeria

“I've been to Mikey's Pizzeria a couple of times, and the pizza has been consistently great--crispy crust, good sauce, and fresh toppings.”

Mentioned in 2 reviews

Read more highlights

You might also consider

Verify this business for free

People searched for Pizza 10,228 times last month within 15 miles of this business.

Verify this business

Oakwood Pizza Box - White pizza w/pepperoni

Oakwood Pizza Box

4.5(338 reviews)
1.7 mi•Oakwood
•$$

Oakwood pizza box is five stars for me for their simplistic approach. Take good ingredients and…read moremake the best possible pizza. This, to me, what makes a great pizza. You can taste the tang of the sauce. The cheese has some pull but not too much. It makes a perfect crease when you fold it. The pizza has a bit of grease, but not such that you have to blot it with a napkin. It has a thin crust. It's simple, it's authentic, and it's delicious. The salads are huge, the wine is inexpensive, it's just perfect. Wait staff were great. You sign in via a QR code and get added to a waitlist. There's a bench to wait, bar seating, and a tv.

Stopped by Oakwood Pizza Box a little while back and wow we weren't disappointed. When you arrive…read moreparking can be a little difficult in this area. If you can't find parking on Person street I recommended parking on a side street and walking. Walking in the pizza shop has a cool, laid back, neighborhood vibe. To be seated you'll want to ask for an open table from the staff. Once seated we ordered a pitcher of Narragansett Pilsner and a small Caesar Salad (housemade dressing, lemon garlic breadcrumb, pecorino). The pils was excellent and wanted to order a little extra beer since it was the weekend. The Caesar was excellent and the portion was plenty of food for two people. For pizza we ordered a pizza with half sausage and half pepperoni. The pizza was huge and we definitely had to take 3/4s of it to go. The pizza itself was good and was a little heavier than I was expecting. If you are in the person street area and looking for pizza, I definitely would check out the Oakwood Pizza box.

Photos
Oakwood Pizza Box - Bar area

Bar area

Oakwood Pizza Box - Large ceasar salad

Large ceasar salad

Oakwood Pizza Box - Narragansett Pilsner

See all

Narragansett Pilsner

Anthony's La Piazza Prime

Anthony's La Piazza Prime

4.4(171 reviews)
2.4 mi•Glenwood South

The pizza was delicious with a perfectly crispy crust. We also had the rigatoni Alla vodka with a…read moredelicious cream sauce. The food came out hot and fresh. Our waitress Nunzia was so friendly and attentive. She didn't blink twice when our daughter spilled her drink, and took amazing care of us. We would definitely come back again to try additional dishes! If you come here definitely sit in Nunzia's section!

Stopped by Anthony's La Piazza Prime while spending the evening down in Glenwood South. When you…read morearrive there is parking available in the hotel garage or parallel on the street. Walking into the restaurant it has a lively, upscale, and New York influenced vibe. When you enter the restaurant you'll check in with the host to be seated and then be shown to your table. Once seated we were greeted by our server Brittney who made sure the dining experience was excellent. It also happened to be her birthday, happy birthday once again Brittney!! For drinks I ordered the Long Island Iced tea (vodka, rum, tequila, gin, triple sec, sour mix, and a splash of cola) and my partner ordered the Appletini (vodka, sour apple pucker, fresh lemon juice, simple syrup). Both drinks were excellent and were nice and smooth. For our entree we split the Chicken Parmigiana with spaghetti. We also ordered a side of spaghetti and it was the perfect amount of food for two people. The chicken parm was seasoned perfectly and may be one of the best I've ever tried. Overall this was a great experience and I look forward to our next trip to Anthony's La Piazza Prime. I'll have to try the Lobster Ravioli on this next trip with the vodka sauce.

Photos
Anthony's La Piazza Prime - Interior

Interior

Anthony's La Piazza Prime
Anthony's La Piazza Prime

See all

Timber Pizza Co. Raleigh - Pretty in Pepperoni

Timber Pizza Co. Raleigh

4.5(97 reviews)
0.4 mi
Free parking
Sports on TV

Timber is AMAZING! Easily the best pizza I've had in Raleigh and it's not even close. Granted, I am…read morea sucker for anything that is (or is close to) Neapolitan style pizza. It was just so, so good. The menu offers a wide variety of pizzas depending on your mood for the day. It was a difficult choice, but we wound up going for The Bambino. Absolutely no regrets, and it was an amazing combination of flavors. They also have a great variety of drink options at an incredible price (cocktails for $10.50 or less, and wine/beer for $8 or less - hello??). Such a great experience and we will be back!

Wow, I've been looking for a Neapolitan-ish style pizza (as it was almost like a Neapolitan style…read morewith the smoky crust and thin/crunchy similar to a ny style pizza). When you arrive there is parking available out front or on the street. Walking into Timber Pizza it feels like a 90s summer camp vibe with a beautiful pizza oven in the middle of the restaurant and the overall pizza shop felt small/welcoming. We ended up sitting up at the bar and ordered a couple drinks to start. I ordered a pint of the Utica Club Lager which was excellent and very easy to drink. My partner ordered a glass of the Spellbound Pinot Noir which also was great and had a nice finish. For food we ordered the Bambino pizza (spicy honey marinara, mozzarella and provolone blend, fresh mozzarella, all beef meatballs, pesto, garlic oil) which was excellent. The crust was perfectly cooked, along with all of the flavors from the meatballs, garlic oil, pesto, etc. which made this pizza a hit and something we couldn't stop eating. Highly recommend checking out Timber Pizza over in the Five Points area!

Photos
Timber Pizza Co. Raleigh - The Jules is a cheese-less pizza that packs a punch

The Jules is a cheese-less pizza that packs a punch

Timber Pizza Co. Raleigh - Green Monster

Green Monster

Timber Pizza Co. Raleigh - The Ward 4 - brisket on pizza?!?! with bread and butter jalapenos and a housemade spicy cranberry jam - so good

See all

The Ward 4 - brisket on pizza?!?! with bread and butter jalapenos and a housemade spicy cranberry jam - so good

Ponysaurus Brewing Co - Cheese, pep, sausage and peppers!

Ponysaurus Brewing Co

4.1(114 reviews)
0.5 mi
•$$

I love this spot! TBH my review is all for the food and service (the only drink I've had here was…read moretheir special 4th of July "rocket pop" lol). Anyway - Pizzas are consistently good, come out quick, and new pizza toppings/flavors pop up every once in a while. I especially love their Wednesday night dinner specials - sometimes I'm not as much in the mood for pizza but they do things like chicken parm and pasta just as good. Service is like a mix of waitstaff and self serve but whenever we interact with anyone working there they're always super friendly and helpful. Like I said, just love this spot! Parking at Raleigh Iron Works is never an issue - I just park in the back gravel lot

We were at Raleigh Iron Works for the Oktoberfest Weiner Dog race. They had it set up real nice…read more It was a little crowded. There was a line at Ponysaurus for beer outside. They had a little tap on the patio. So we hopped in line. My friend went inside to see if we could get beer faster. You know divide and conquer. She won, however the line outside was still long so we stayed in line so we could get another. Sure enough by the time we reached the front of the line we were out. So we grabbed a couple more put them on the open tab from inside and walked around. We came back after walking around and decided after seeing everyone walking around with pizza boxes and Togo bags that we would eat here. We knew from being there earlier that they had outside first come seating seat yourself, but it was full so we went inside, turns out that is also first come first serve seat yourself. There was a table getting up as we walked in so we sat down and they were quick to come clean it. The waitress came and too our drink order and we saw her 1 more time after that. Even though they have a scan menu on the table for you to place your order I think they should still check on you. She came at the end to see if we needed her to close out our tab at the bar, we had already taken care of that. We could have used her during our meal. The wedge Cesar was ok, the lettuce was nice and crisp. The Cesar was good. I always get my dressing on the side sometimes when you get a salad it can be overdressed and I don't like that so I don't take chances. The Chicken schnitzel was ok not outstanding. It could use some seasoning. The salad "on top" of it was good. The dressing was really good. Now this roasted broccoli was the star of the table. It was so yumm. I only wish the dressing was on the side. It was so much of it in the top I had to rub some off. Otherwise it was so good. We would have ordered more but having to use the San to order and pay each time I didn't like that so we just ate that and moved on. Maybe we will try the pizza next time.

Photos
Ponysaurus Brewing Co - Ponysaurus in Raleigh

Ponysaurus in Raleigh

Ponysaurus Brewing Co - Wings!

Wings!

Ponysaurus Brewing Co - Ponysaurus in Raleigh

See all

Ponysaurus in Raleigh

Mikey's Pizzeria - pizza - Updated October 2026

Loading...
Loading...
Loading...