I always order the cheese pizza and the caramelized onion and mushroom pizza. Both are fantastic and if you like thin crust , this is the place to go to! The winner is the balboa cheesesteak. It's served on a toasted sesame hoagie roll imported from Philly! read more

Their pizza was on point last night! Got delivered fast! And of course the ambiance was amazing at home. It was perfect! And much needed.

Very nice place. The owner/manager was very nice and helpful. It is very clean too. Lots of salads and special pizzas. I had a gluten free Mediterranean and my husband had a large sausage. Both were excellent. Excellent quality, nice and fresh. We'll be here again. There are great lunch specials too! read more

See all

Get the chicky chicky parm parm. Funny name, great taste. We ordered that with a cheese pizza and a pepperoni pizza and all three were very tasty. Take out was easy and the service was nice. read more

Tried Manhattan Pizza for the first time yesterday and had a great experience. I ordered the Alfredo and wings. Both were pretty good. I used a Go, Play, Save coupon and they knew how to apply it at checkout (something that doesn't happen often), which made the already reasonable prices even better. Service was friendly and quick. Definitely a solid local spot I'd go back to. read more

Food and service here are always great. Staff is super friendly and they offer excellent rewards. Highly recommend!

Love these guys! Pizza is great, staff is great and the Owner is VERY supportive or our local Highschools! Go Mustangs!!! I eat at both of his locations and love that I can get their pizza at Middle Creek Football and Soccer games! read more

We really enjoyed this family friendly Italian restaurant. The pizza was fantastic, especially the truffle porcini mushroom pizza. The whole family was impressed with the light and delicious flavor of that pizza. There was a large menu that included pizza, pasta, wings, subs, and more. Gelato is served here as well if you're in the mood for dessert or just want to come in for a cool treat. You can take gelato home in pints as well. The restaurant is spacious, clean, and comfortable. We would definitely return. read more

Craving pizza and found this spot! The cashier person was super friendly and welcoming. We mentioned this was our first time and he offered recommendations. We decided to check out their sandwiches. Started off by ordering pizza rolls which were sooooo tasty. After eating a few I was so full. The make their own gelato which I will try next time. Make sure to sign up for their coupons for a free gelato next time. read more

See all

This review is specifically for your mobile app. My biggest complaint that it does not remember your user credentials like any other app. In order to log into the app, I need to go into my chrome browser and track down my password, then go back into the app to copy and paste my credentials. This is a really poor user experience. Your customers deserve better. Also, when I check out, the system does not remember my card on file, despite me checking the box asking the app to keep it on file. There are other pizza establishments in Holly Springs with a much smoother mobile ordering experience on their mobile apps. I have a newish iPhone, so this is not a device issue. Until you guys can make some upgrades, we will be taking our Friday night pizza orders elsewhere. read more

Ordered last night In a hurry. Pizza arrived perfect, delivery driver polite, phone order easy as pie. We are never disappointed here.

Went for lunch and had a couple of slices which were very good! A week later ordered a large pie to go. Was there 10 minutes later and the pizza was ready. Awful pizza. Was almost like they had made the pizza earlier in the day, put it in a box and sold it. Might give this place another chance in hopes that it was an isolated incident. read more

I'm from the Philly area and the pizza there is super, for the most part. Manhattan Pizza in our new state of NC was like an oasis in the desert. Great pizza, salads, etc., consistent and reliable. read more

Just a great go to place for lunch or dinner. Love their subs. Also like their spaghetti for a quick meal. It's not a high-end Italian joint but everything tastes good anyway. Service is excellent. The atmosphere is just fine. read more

Haven't eaten in the restaurant but have had the pleasure of ordering Manhattan Pizza for delivery twice and have enjoyed it each time!! Yummy! read more

Place was clean, hand washing station from the front was a sign they take cleanliness serious. Bathroom and overall place was clean and AC was nice and cool! The lady was really sweet and patient with my orders and my kids couldn't make up their mind. The gyro meal was phenomenal-came with all the sauces and ketchup for my fries. Salad with my meal was fresh and had everything a Greek salad is to have. Kids loved the thin slice pizza and my wings were cooked to perfection. I'm very picky with wings as some place have unnatural large wings that are can't cook evenly but this place knocked the wings out of the park-they sell beer and wine so extra kudos. 1st timer but won't be my last time. I will drive the 20'ish something minutes to support them. A+ food and service! read more

Manhattan Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Holly Springs, North Carolina

Fifth time getting delivery from DoorDash and favorite pizza in NC thus far, and as everyone says "I'm picky." Well I am growing up in NY! The right amount of extra cheese very little sauce and the crust is perfect. Wish there garlic knots had been drenched in butter, very little in my opinion. The place looks cozy and they deliver faster than quoted. read more

Pretty good for a pizza joint in NC. Since I'm from NJ I've had a lot of NY Pizza in my lifetime and this was actually pretty decent. read more

Manhattan Pizza - Pepperoni slice - Pizza Near Me - Holly Springs, North Carolina

See all

Takeout was quick (less than 20 minutes) and the order was ready and made correctly when arrived. BBQ pizza was surprisingly better than expected - not too much BBQ sauce and even had red peppers which were a perfect touch to the pizza. We ordered the buffalo chicken pizza too, but this pizza wasn't the most thrilling. The buffalo chicken pizza matched the description on the website - just felt it lacked here (maybe needs a veggie or sauce drizzle). Would def recommend BBQ pizza :) read more

I ordered a Gyro salad and a couple of other items. The salad was soooo generously filled with the best gyro meat - enough for two or three people! So I had leftovers and it was every bit as good the day after!!! I also ordered a side of meatballs for my grandkids (amazing!) and received a small cheese pizza from the rewards plan that they offer (also fabulous!). Everything was unbelievable! Also the staff were so upbeat and gracious; all in all, a great experience! I cannot get over the portions! Thank you so much! read more

Great pizza, easy to order online and if you sign up for their rewards program they will send you a bunch of coupons.

I don't love the pizza here, but the sandwiches have always been great. Today, I was in the mood for a good salad and tried to grab some veggies for the kids to snack on. Unfortunately, Manhattan severely let me down. Their "superfood" salad is very basic and had a small amount of wilted kale. This biggest disappointment is the veggies and hummus for $5.99! We got super old looking carrots, some celery, and a small thing of hummus. The hummus itself is good, but we had no more than 2 pieces of celery that was capable of being dipped. read more

Manhattan Pizza - Hummus and Veggies - Pizza Near Me - Holly Springs, North Carolina

We have always had great service and enjoyed our food. Recommend highly. Katen Bender-Manahan read more

We have ordered online delivery and dine in. Both fantastic. . Great ownership. Owner John is extremely involved and great.

I'm not impressed with the pizza. Upon opening the box, my first impression was that it was small and flat, not at all what I like to see pizza as. Granted, this was delivery and it had been delivered about 45 minutes after I ordered (not too bad), but there was no cripiness to the crust at all and it was dense and gummy. The cheese was kind of congealed, but the flavor was on the better side. Honestly, it reminded me of one of the bad versions of grocery store freezer pizza. With so many other choices around, I recommend some place else. Maybe it's better in house, this was a let down. read more

Ordering catering for event was effortless, food was great and packaged for easy transport. John and Tonya were so friendly and the location was immaculate. Definitely ordering again! We got lasagna, garlic knots, pepperoni rolls. read more

Great food and great service! We love the pizza and we are from NJ , so we are very picky with our pizza! Great service too! We had an especially good experience last Saturday with Patty at the counter. What a nice kid! read more

Can't say enough good things about Manhattan Pizza in Holly Springs. We probably average an order a week for the past few years and they never disappoint. We have sampled pretty much the entire menu and have never found an issue with anything. The delivery drivers are always courteous and pleasant too. read more

Wish I had taken a picture before I demolished the pizza defreakinlicious. Pepperoni does its job but the Buffalo Chicken pizza has me in a choke hold read more

Wow. Super good. Crust was crispy and on point. Cheese was thick and just the right amount. Will be back. Will also try delivery read more

Manhattan Pizza - Mac N Cheesy - Pizza Near Me - Holly Springs, North Carolina

See all

We are not New Yorkers but we liked the thin crust pizza. The ingredients seemed really fresh and I thought there was a good balance of sauce. It was hot and fresh - the wait for our order wasn't long. We will order again. read more

The reg. Slice was just ok,,but the Grdma pie Was to die for! Very delicious in my opinion.. read more

Pizzas ok, salads are very good compared to other pizza places. However quality is inconsistent and the pizzas are tiny compared to Johnnys, Randy's, Pasta di Pizza, even Dominos. Look how small the mediums are! Next time I will check the size rather than assuming a medium is a normal medium. read more

Manhattan Pizza - a pizza in a box with a measuring tape - Pizza Near Me - Holly Springs, North Carolina

See all

Great flavor, fresh ingredients. Helpful staff. We very much enjoyed the varied menu. Pizzas salads sandwiches and entrees We will be back!!! read more

Love this place! The Food is great and the owners are so nice! I love when an owner makes the time to come out and ask how everything was! Fantastic! If you haven't tried it.....let's go. read more

The worst pizza place ever Is a waste of money time Terrible I ordered a large cheese pizza is suppose to be barely had cheese all burn dark black color sandy taste, not flavor it all. Bad service too. Actually some one came when we were leaving the place and told us how bad the food is there. We are not coming here anymore read more

Manhattan Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Holly Springs, North Carolina

See all

It pains me to write this review especially during these times but we did not have a good experience. I ordered online at 4PM for a 7PM delivery time, we did not get our food until 8:16PM. I understand that they got backed up but I had to call for an update and was told it would be here by 8PM. We ordered a house salad with blue cheese dressing, small manhattan supreme pizza, medium margherita pizza, a side of marinara sauce and a slice of tiramisu (because they were out of the creme brulee cheesecake). It was a little on the expensive side. The supreme pizza was our favorite out of everything but we didn't like the crust. The marinara sauce was too garlicky and the tiramisu was too marscarpone heavy. I think that there are better pizza restaurants around the area. read more

Do not eat here. We requested meat on only half the pizza and the pizza had meat all over it. Not to mention, there was hair all over the pizza. Absolutely disgusting. read more

Somehow we ended up with a Flyer/Menu for Manhattan Pizza so it ended up on our radar. We ordered an app which has French fries smothered in mozzarella cheese and was loaded in bacon bits. It was probably the highlight of the entire meal for me. If you go order these fries! My son and husband both love Calzones and they both loved this one. My husband also ordered a Greek Salad which he said was really good. We had a coupon for a free cheese pizza with a $39 online order. It didn't blow my socks off but it was good and everyone seemed to enjoy it. My daughter and I shared a Caesar Salad with Grilled Chicken, not bad, and both ordered Chicken Alfredo. The Alfredo is why I cannot rate this restaurant higher than a 3. I can make scratch-homemade pasta. I can make scratch-homemade Alfredo sauce. Sometimes you don't want to have to cook. It's been a long day...running around, work, carpool, after school activities, homework, laundry, etc... when I make my homemade Alfredo it's probably not the most traditional. I use shallots, garlic, Italian spices (not a lot bc it's mostly about the cheese) and then I blend fresh shaved pecorino, Romano and Parmesan. All this tasted like was steamed/warmed heavy cream. No garlic, no flavor, no spices. Not even salt. It was bland to the point of gross! Maybe the chef was having an off day but this was by far the worst Alfredo I have ever been served. I am a creature of habit. I order this almost every time we go to an Italian restaurant and this was not good. Thankfully MP prices and portions are not out of control so I didn't waste a lot of money and didn't feel too badly when I threw it away. Unfortunately, I ordered two...so two went in the trash. read more

The food is very good. Good service! Friendly, clean and fast. I love the fast service anywhere