Best pizza and so close to home! Staff is very friendly and the restaurant is spotless! The new owners made me and my husband a fan and the burgers are amazing too! Good job!! See you soon! Angelina and Robin read more

The atmosphere inside Middlefield Pizza is very upbeat, relaxing whether youre picking up food to go or is youre eating in. The staff are congenial, right on top of things......"do you need this or do you need that". It's a good spirit there. Oh yeah, and the food is great..... Come to big downtown Middlefield and enjoy. Then visit Lyman's Orchard Apple Barrel or go visit Powder Ridge. Carpe Diem read more

We had never been to Middlefield pizza under the old owners, but there is quite the buzz going on in the area about the new owners. So one night when we didn't feel like cooking, we gave it a try. Called ahead to ask about beer and wine, and found out it was BYOB, yippee!! We had read some great reviews on a local Facebook page, so decided to order all the things others were raving about. We ordered the cheesy garlic bread, which was fantastic and the sauce was good. We also got 6 garlic parm wings, extra crispy. Be sure to tell them how you like your wings cooked because they will cook to your preferences. These were exactly how we like them!! We also got a 12" meatball grinder and a medium house special pizza with bacon substituted in place of the hamburger. We only had half the grinder and one slice each of the pizza, because well, we just ordered too much food lol. Both were extremely tasty. The grinder has a perfect ratio of bread to fillings, and reminded me of the old school grinders that I used to get from my small town pizza shop. You don't find them like that anymore. Even though I'm not usually a Greek pizza kind of person (I generally prefer New Haven style), this pizza was great. Plentiful toppings, cooked perfectly, nice crispy bacon!! A big pet peeve of mine is when onions are cut too thick, or are raw and crunchy on a cooked pizza. They cut their onions nice and thin here, so they were able to cook - perfection achieved. The pizza is great cold too, or reheated at 450 for 8-10 minutes. Our server Erica was super friendly and gave us lots of info since it was our first time. They've been taking feedback from customers, and have switched suppliers on some of their ingredients to ensure they get the best quality items. The owner, George, came over and introduced himself and told us a little about his journey in the restaurant industry. He's so nice and kind and just really wants to be a part of the community. There are several booths if you want to dine in like we did, they also did a ton of take out orders when we were there. Expect paper plates and plastic cups (at least for now), but guys, did I mention it's BYOB!! There is a package store right next door, in case you forget to grab something from home. I don't mind a no frills establishment as long as the food is good, which it was! I already have a list of items to try on our next visit! Get down there and check it out for yourself!! read more

See all

Come here with my girlfriend for the first time, we didn't expect them to have like a dining area it was really nice. And the pizza we ordered had a good wait time. The service was great too. read more

Middlefield Pizza and Restaurant - Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Middlefield, Connecticut

Dined in at Middlefield pizza today. They offer several booths to sit in, with nice bright lights. The new owner is so pleasant and the wait staff friendly. Today we had wings with bbq sauce and garlic bread with mozzarella cheese. The bread was delicious with a nice garlic butter and topped with mozzarella cheese. The wings were crispy and moist with just the right amount sauce. All reviews prior to February 2024 should be disregarded as this place has a new owner. read more

See all

Great food especially the grinder rolls. Small place with great service. Working my way thru the menu and everything has been delicious.

Since it's reopening, the pizza has been outstanding. The restaurant is clean and inviting, but was slow. This is the best Greek style pizza around. read more

The owner was so kind and helpful when we showed up with 5 kids after seeing the Chinese Lanterns down the road. The food and promptness were solid. Ambiance was fine, pizza boxes stacked in the corner. I think they do mostly take out. Only soda or water to drink. But really just fine for what we needed and a kind group working there. read more

I was so excited to try their pizza after the new ownership opened it. Got a bacon pizza is was greasy (perhaps to be expected), and the crust and sauce were just o.k. Will try another type of pizza next time and update. Glad the dining room is open read more

One of the best pizzas with a lot of toppings no skimping here. Still maintaining their quality product, did not disappoint, keep it up !

The BEST pizza, not a bad thing on the menu. The service is great! Very friendly and accommodating! Always a joy to come home to Middlefield Pizza. See you soon read more

Middlefield pizza is now under new ownership. The new owners are very friendly and very conscious of their new reopening, the pizza parlor great pizza I enjoyed eating there inside and I have also taken out orders free delicious food group menu, and very friendly you eat in read more

Highly recommend!! Had a delicious Greek salad with grilled chicken and stuffed grape leaves- the house dressing is amazing. The salad is huge! I ate about 1/4 of it! Chicken was very tender. Hubby had a lamb gyro with French fries and his meal was awesome too! Will definitely be ordering again! Service was great too! read more

Middlefield Pizza and Restaurant - Greek salad - Pizza Near Me - Middlefield, Connecticut

See all

Great pizza! We had the Tony's special. Really fresh ingredients in the right combinations. Traditional crust but cooked perfectly!

The Greek salad was one of the best I've had. I wish I could have that house dressing on every salad I'll ever eat. I like the crust on the pizza. It could be a little more crispy on the bottom...But it was still good. I like a thick crunchy greek style crust. The sauce was perfect texture and taste. Pepperoni slices were distributed very evenly across the top of the pie. We'll be back! read more

New owner , same food quality, only funny thing is it's another Greek Family and if you have ever seen my big fat Greek wedding movie, they fit the stereotype. Very clean place, nice interior, plenty of seating. Nice service, leave demetri alone and let him learn the register ! Lol read more

Excellent Greek Pizza! Loaded with toppings and cooked perfectly! Will be adding this to the rotation!

Good Greek Pizza new owners are way better highly recommended if you are in the area and looking for quick bite.

Disregard older reviews, Opened 2/15/24 two weeks now, Order early , busy, pizza was good, antipasto salad, alot of meat, pasta ask for extra sauce, over all new owners are doing a good job read more

Probably my favorite family pizza joint around..I drive 20 minutes to get dinner here, even passing 3 other pizza places. They've been here forever and nothing has changed. The owners (husband and wife) are always friendly and appreciate of your business too, something that's hard to come by now a Days. Their Greek style pizza is baked in probably decades old pans, adding a unique taste to their pies. Top hits: -Toasted salami grinder w/lettuce tomato mayo. Classic but amazing. -Crispy chicken Caesar salad. Their cutlets are bomb. -Chicken Parm pizza. Just get it, so tasty. read more

Placed an order for 6 large pizzas. Was told 30 minutes. Got a call back 12 minutes later from Middlefield Pizza saying they needed another 30 minutes. I explained we needed the order for noon and the woman said "I am canceling the order" and slammed the phone down to hang up on me. We were a 36-40 pizza per year person from them and now they are dead to us. read more

I had low Expectations for the food here. But was Pleasantly surprised when the come out. The chicken cutlet was really great and I could eat one ever week. The Buffalo chicken pizza was Super surprising I like how they cut up chicken cutlet for the chicken on the buffalo pizza. read more

Middlefield Pizza and Restaurant - Buffalo chicken pizza small - Pizza Near Me - Middlefield, Connecticut

See all

I grew up in Middlefield and have been going here forever. Love it. Small hole in the wall with good pizza and a friendly staff and vibe. Totally recommend :-) read more

Have been going here for years. Tony and Tammy work hard to please everyone. I have never had a bad meal from there restaurant yet. Ellen W. read more

My youngest daughter loves pizza. If you ask her where she wants pizza from it's always "Middlefield Pizza!" It's a Greek style pizza, but not sliced in squares. The crust is the best. We order from here at least once a week. They have awesome grinders as well. The staff is friendly and our order is always prepared correctly! read more

LISTEN PEOPLE! A friend and I tried this place on a whim out of proximity and hunger. IF I COULD COULD GIVE MORE STARS I WOULD. THEIR FOOD GREAT. We ordered stuffed shells and ravioli, the meals come with the most delicious garlic bread I have ever had the pleasure of devouring, and salad that is a REAL salad! Peppers, onions, tomatoes, olives, cucumbers, and of course lettuce; and great dressings! The pasta is fresh and superb. The service was great, these folks didn't miss a beat. And very reasonable prices, besides! I can't believe how lucky we were to find this place, it's a diamond in the rough. HIGHLY recommend. HIGHLY. read more

I am a fan! I grew up having new haven style pizza and pastas and they can compete! I highly recommend getting any salad with the "house" dressing. It. Is. THE BEST! Dip your garlic bread in it also, you won't be disappointed. read more

Great pizza, consistently happy with the food here. Owner seems nice. Small hole in the wall type place, you can eat in at a cozy both or do take out. Been there forever too!! Definitely one of my first choices for pizza around the Durham/middlefield area. read more

I grew up in Middlefield and I have to say that I soooooo miss the way Middlefield Pizza used to be. The owner in the 1980s was a Greek guy (forgot his name) and the pizza had oozing cheese and it was oily from it. It was unique and delicious. He used to cut it into squares and if you had a middle piece, you had to use a fork to eat it. Yummy! Now, with new owners (not sure how many ownership changes since he sold it), but it is just ok. Nothing bad, Nothing great. Just a "play-it-safe" little pizza place where locals and package store patrons can bump into each other. As far as aestetics, nothing has been changed since the 1970's including the booths and floors. That could be bad or good, depending on how you look at it. That's about it. read more

Tasty, quality pies...Classic American pizza, not wood fired thin crust, no californianess- just decent tasty pizzas. Somehow Middlefield pizza small pizzas generate a kind of flavor their other sizes can't replicate... My advice and secret tip is to order a small for maximum flavor, it's worth two smalls of different flavor than risk it on a large. The crust is really good too it's an average not too thin not to thick really good slice. Top pies are small cheese. Small Hawaiian small olive and mushrooms. read more

It is very unfortunate that the owner was rude, accusatory, and abusive to me when I returned an uneaten salad with ham and cheese instead of the turkey and cheese that I ordered as take out. His pleasant assistant apologized saying that she believes another customer might have received the turkey and cheese instead. The owner accused me of lying and having eaten some of the salad and wanting another in return. Really? Sad. read more

I love Middlefield Pizza! I have been coming here for my entire life and it never gets old! This pizza is thicker, Greek style pizza. I am not typically a fan of thick crust pizza but this is some of the best crust I have ever had! read more