I visited this Mick's All-American location for an evening mixer with a large group and came away impressed, especially compared to the location near Progress Avenue and Linglestown Road. This one is laid out better for a crowd, and it handled a standing-room-only event surprisingly well. Because I was with a big group, the usual service details didn't really apply, but the bar staff kept things moving. I didn't hear anyone complaining about drink waits beyond what you'd expect with a packed mixer where people are constantly circulating and the bar area is full of conversations. The staff stayed friendly and didn't seem bothered by the volume. What stood out most was how consistently the team was cleaning and clearing. Glasses and empties never piled up. Even in spots that weren't obvious from the bar, staff were coming through regularly and picking things up quickly. With that many people in the space, that level of attention was noticeable. The place stayed clean the whole time. It was loud, but that was the group, not the venue. Parking was easy since it's in a shopping center, and getting in and out was straightforward. I didn't try the food, but it's a chain, so I assume it's consistent with other locations. Overall, I wouldn't dissuade anyone from going, and I'd go back if I were in the area and in the mood for a drink or a casual sports-bar type meal. read more

We are fans of the Mick's on Linglestown Rd and frequently stop by, so we decided to take my mom out for lunch to the Mick's near Mt Joy since it's close to her. While they are the same chain of restaurants, the one in Mt. Joy definitely was not the same as the one on Linglestown. We tried the Thanksgiving egg roll, which was very good and served with a side of gravy. It should also come with a side of cranberry sauce for that holiday "twang". One of us ordered the Cottage Pie, which was served hot. I ordered the build your own burger, which is a favorite of mine at the other location. I was vastly disappointed by this burger, which did not resemble the juicy mouth watering version I was used to. The atmosphere was fine and service friendly, but I don't see us returning to this location. read more

Was excited to try it ... VERY disappointing. Sunday noon , wait staff was fine , almost an hour for food(appetizers) after ordering. The Nachos were sparsely topped and the beef was unseasoned. Chicken quesadilla had good chicken chunks but too was unseasoned. Others had chicken cheese steak they enjoyed , but it was visibly short on cheese steak. Felt sorry for the server , but it was among the worst meals I've had in a long time. Presentation was fine , but tasteless. Ambiance was fine , a little load , read more

They easily acomoda-te a 20 people party for a volleyball team, place is clean and service was fast. Drinks were good, food was ok, what's expected from this types of American bar/restaurant read more

We were hesitant to come here because of some reviews but we were staying across the street so it was convenient. We sat at the bar, service was friendly and quick. We ordered wings and they were great, even got a pizza to go which was delicious. Prices were pretty good. Don't listen to the other reviews, this is a local gem! read more

The patty melt was excellent (because I got it with NO thousand island dressing, which, IMO does NOT belong on a Patty Melt!) and the service was great too. My husband had the French dip, which is served with French onion soup, and said it was really good. Even the chips were good! If you want a nice meal with a casual atmosphere, go to Mick's! You won't regret it! read more

We had a person in our group in a wheel chair. Asked for a table that was wheel chair accessible was out in a back corner with no room for the chair so we had to move the adjoining tables out of the way. Our server was not happy and the food took 45 minutes to come out of the kitchen from time of placing the order. It was not busy at all so not sure why it took so long. Not impressed at all. read more

Food - 2 stars, but the excellent service bumped it to 3 stars for me. Food is like something you'd get from the frozen section of SAM's Club or Walmart. Not terrible... but very much lends more to TV dinner quality than high quality pub food... I ordered the Diablo boneless wings - frozen heavily breaded glorified nuggets in a spicy mash/sauce - breading was so thick & hard on most pieces that I couldn't stab them with a fork. Others ordered chicken fingers that were similar low-quality frozen tenders... fish n chips had much too thick breading & was either very overcooked or the fryer oil was in need of a change... their salads are pretty decent & surprisingly are made with fresh mixed greens & not iceberg lettuce. I wouldn't go back, but if I had to - I'd order a salad. Our server was great and pushed this to a 3 star review. read more

Mick's All American Pub - 1 lb Diablo boneless wings - meh - Pubs Near Me - Manheim, Pennsylvania

My fiance and I finished our date day here. They had no draft beer available, and they can't make a cocktail if you need the soda gun for it. Not a deal breaker, however having to pay for a bottled beer at full price sure is. If your CO2 is down and customers choose to stay, discount the bottled beer you have available to serve. Mick has a reputation of being a greedy, money hungry business owner. I wasn't sure I believed it until today. read more

Very good experience nice waiter wings were extra crispy and fries were good. The atmosphere was great too.

Popped in for a quick drink and some appetizers. The place was busy! Sat at the bar and was greeted immediately. Received our drink order in appropriate amount of time. Food came out shortly thereafter and was tasty! Any reviewers leaving less than 5 stars should try this place again! read more

Went back after not trying for a while. After the food came out, we quickly remembered why we haven't been back in a while. We won't be back any time soon. The food we got was so bad that we wouldn't even give it to the dog as we didn't want to get her sick. read more

First time at this location. I normally eat at the Columbia Ave restaurant. We chose this one because of the outdoor patio area. I was not impressed with the taco salad. The beef fell flat on flavor, they don't offer guacamole, the salsa was bland and even lacked lettuce. read more

Mick's All American Pub - Taco Salad - Pubs Near Me - Manheim, Pennsylvania

Food was ok - had the Caesar Salad with Chicken and 6 traditional wings. Sat at the bar - place was slow. I'm traveling and staying at the hotel across the street - this place is very convenient. However, I feel like I'm an inconvenience to the staff. Not a great feeling and will not be coming back. No attempt to strike up a conversation- staff hides in the back. Sucks. read more

Have been here a few times while on business trips. It shares the parking lot with teh Hampton Inn. So it is very convenient. Food is always good, never had a problem. Has a very good rotating beer selection. Service has always been top notch and very helpful. Will be back. read more

Good wings and cold beer. Service can be a bit of a waiting game but. Gets the job done. Last time we chose fuddruckers next door because we couldn't get seated but overall will try it again. Takeout at micks was good too. read more

To Mick's owners of Manheim Location: You should be ashamed to serve the food you gave us tonight. The onion soup tasted like water with a wee tinge of beef broth. Onion? Could see some but not taste it. We then received our BONELESS wings that came as BONE-IN instead. When we FINALLY received what we ordered--boneless--the outside was so hard my wife could not bite into them. The server announced the wings were adjusted from our order. The only adjustment made was that we were charged for boneless instead of bone-in wings. No adjustment to what we actually ordered. Final take on Mick's: Two drinks (1 wine, 1old-fashioned), 2 soups (1 onion crock, 1 crab bisque), and one dozen boneless chicken wings at Happy Hour came to $56.50. We came to eat, not be insulted and robbed. Goodbye, Mick's. read more

Our last time there we were seated inside near the door to the patio.The flys were so bad, that was gross,but what really bothered me was Fox News was on the TV. read more

I only had a Caesar salad. It was good. The service was great. It's a huge place so didn't feel touching elbow with the next table.

Always good! Lots of variety on their menu for everyone in your group. Oversized booths for larger groups. Friendly staff Several locations around our area. read more

Excellent food, the service at the bar was well staffed and attentive. Very nice atmosphere to enjoy sports or just a casual conversation.

We were greeted and seated very quickly. We had a party of 9. the lunch crowd was leaving and other families were arriving from a local sports complex. We were attempting to get lunch before heading to the sports complex. we arrived at around 12:30 which was many of time to be at our 2-15 game..... or so we thought. our waitress took our order, then several other tables of four people arrived. they were waited on by another waitress. we sat for about 20 minutes and finally got drinks. another five for straws. people who came in after us started getting their food. our never arrived...... we waited 1 hour before I spoke up. another 15 minutes my husband spoke up. finally our food arrived with 5 minutes to slam it down before leaving for our game. it was cold and obviously forgotten. We were really offered no explanation and not offered any discount and were given our bill to pay and left. I have worked in customer service all of my life and am so extremely disappointed in how this situation was handled. if you have any hopes of eating, do not go here. Do not be fooled by quick seating. do not be fooled by the nice atmosphere. the place is poorly run and mismanaged. read more

Had lunch here today for a first time experience. They have a nice list of lunch specials. I had the crab bisque and Caesar salad. Both were very good. My daughter enjoyed her tomato soup and grilled cheese. 22.00! Great pricing, imo. Our server was attentive and pleasant. read more

Ordered a club sandwich and nachos. The nachos were soggy with all of the toppings clumped in the middle. There was barely any meat on the club sandwich that cost $13.99. Ridiculous. We will not be back. read more

The food was just ok. I ordered a burger medium well. The burger came out very bloody. I had to send it back to be cooked more.

Service was good, dink was made well (Long Island), Cesar Salad was warm and brownish and soggy (couldn't eat it). Steak was a 10oz ribeye, and was rubbery and about 3/8 thick, I would say 7oz. Didn't finish that either. I actually left and went across the parking lot and ordered a personal pan pizza from Dominos as soon as I left. Too bad. I did leave the server a good tip, and to be fair they took the Ribeye dinner off. $29.00 steak dinner. No where near worth that. read more

I've been going to Mick's for several years and always leave satisfied with the food and service.

Cold beer Good Burgers and Sandwiches, Wings are decent too. Prices are reasonable and there is always a special on the board when I'm in town. Thanks Mick for keeping my hotel stumble short and always having a game on TV and crazy barmaid pouring ice cold beer. read more

This place is mediocre at best. Came here around 1 pm on a Saturday to check it out. Sports bar grub it was not. And wow, the prices for what you get? Wow. The prices in general? It's hard to find much under 15.00. I ordered the Stephanie which was basically a Rachel with a small side of chips. It was alright, but basically diner quality food. 13.00 Bucks? Not worth it. I ended up with an upset stomach afterwards. My fiancée got the chicken bacon wrap that was also 13.00 with chips. Ummm, small meal. For these prices, it should come with fries. Service was fine, nothing to complain about there. This is the only reason it gets two stars and not one. Also, blaring country music is not everyone's cup of tea. Good pickles though! read more

I love this place! I have never had a bad experience at any of their locations. Service is always prompt and friendly, and I have loved all of my meals there! My favorites are the crab dip, crab pretzel, wings and chicken quesadilla. My fiancé loves the wings and sandwiches as well. They also have a great selection of bottled and draft beers. There's plenty of seating at the bar, which is nice. I will continue to frequent Mick's! read more

I don't see how people can give a bad review over one incident??? I've known Mick for a long time, and his establishments are run with great respect for his clientele. My wife and I eat at the Mount Joy restaurant frequently and are always treated well and never a complaint. I highly recommend eating here to anyone local or in town for the weekend. All his restaurants are top notch to say the least. We will be there again tonight. C. Stoppard read more

Yesterday, the Retired Guys started off the year with a visit to the Mick's in Manheim (Mount Joy). Check it out at - http://beerafternoon.blogspot.com/2018/01/micks-all-american-pub-manheim-bar-130.html read more

Mick's All American Pub - Mick's Front Entrance - Pubs Near Me - Manheim, Pennsylvania

See all

Parmesan crusted chicken primavera consisted of dry chicken and a dish with no flavor. Our other two dishes were overloaded with fries to mask the dry chicken fingers and poor bread to crab cake ratio sliders. Inexperienced server who left dirty dishes on the table. read more

Food nasty and lady at bar tried to tell on nothing really instead of asking me can I put my cigar up I wasn't even smoking just had it it my hand but then the supervisor come over and tell me that I can't have it in my hand and that I have to leave over all if I'm not smoking I don't think she should have bothering me bullshit as folk over there be careful I wish I could give no stars read more

Ordered carry out. Was ready when I picked up, no wait. Ordered two orders of fish and chips and got home to eat. The picture attached is the amount of breading (no fish) that was in the 2 orders. It was so greasy and mushy. And it ruined the chips below it. Coleslaw had no flavor. House dressing on salad was good. Just a very disappointing experience. read more

Mick's All American Pub - Breading from 2 orders of fish. Gross. - Pubs Near Me - Manheim, Pennsylvania

After a long hiatus and not so pleasant experience with an appetizer we decided to check out their new location and cash in on our (now) few year old appetizer comp. The new location is not only much closer to us but easy to find parking and convenient. The shopping center where it is located is not yet completely full of retail establishments but once it's completed will be very useful to those in the area. Upon entry the new space was very large and consisted of a large open space and a smaller room off to the side which is where we dined. It felt like new construction, but lacked any warmth or identity and I felt very "exposed" in such a massive space. A little décor, plants, booths or half walls or columns would benefit this space greatly. I requested a window seat as it was just beginning to get dark and the place was (in my opinion) too dark to be comforting. The waitress explained that the owner likes it dark to create "ambience" but I felt it was too dark - and would have appreciated it the lights hung over the tables in lower proximity so it was would be easier to read the menu. In addition to our comped appetizer - the spinach/artichoke dip, I ordered the meatloaf meal and the hubby a Stromboli. The appetizer was a huge improvement over our last visit; generous in size and had a nice presentation. However it was lukewarm and smothered in a tomato garnish which I could have done without. My meatloaf meal was also a good serving size but was dense and slightly overcooked. The mashed potatoes were real and tasted like the kind grandma used make. The veggie of the day - a sautéed sliced Brussel spout medley was the star of the plate. Unique, flavorful and my favorite! While I believe the gravy was pork or poultry - I craved a rich, dark beef version and felt it would have complimented the meal better. Hubby was neither under or over impressed with his Stromboli but he rarely gets excited about food. Service however was so-so. We had three people waiting on us yet still had to ask for napkins, water refills, as well as the check. The appetizer was not comped and this needed corrected on our bill which caused us to wait some more. Overall an additional 20 minutes was wasted on the check alone - flagging down someone to present it to us, flagging them down to correct it, flagging them down to take it, plus the wait for our card to be returned. Considering they weren't that busy and we had service from three different wait staff personnel throughout our meal I think the payment process should have gone quicker. With that being said we would and will go back. It's convenient location and no wait to be seated is a bonus however due to the lack of lighting and our difficultly reading the menu will only patronize during daylight hours. read more

Average food. Friendly place. Service was good and food was brought out promptly. Didn't have to wait for drinks. Nice open bar area.

Was here tonight for the very first time. And it will be my last. Food was good but some portions are real small and some are nice and large. If you get the meatloaf over mashed potatoes you get a small amount of gravy over meatloaf none on the potatoes. I ask for a side and was charged for this to. Limited selection. Just not my cup of tea. read more

Sports bar that charges extra for celery and blue cheese when you order buffalo wings... makes no sense!!!!! Drinks are weak Service sucks Waiter forgot our order, drinks, and messed up our food read more

The food was good. We ordered the Brussels sprouts that were in honey mustard and they were soaked in it, couldn't even taste the sprouts really. The service was great! The ambiance is a sports bar, nothing above and beyond. read more