Classic. I have been coming - not as a regular - on and off for almost 30 years - and finally came back post-COVID - this afternoon. What's the best thing about Michael's? The first thing I ever came for was the food - it's great - everything - from start to finish. Traditional Italian - Red Sauce - Seafood - Veggies. Then there's the service - your treated like a regular, even if your a irregular - waiters knowledgeable accommodating and personable, bus-help prompt. Lastly - the owners/management - man do they care - professional and sincere - they keep it simple but do it right. In the restaurant world - if you get to the 3rd generation - you have a legacy. Michael's of Brooklyn. Legacy. Classic. read more

I found this place by luck and I must have had a freakin 4 leaf clover on me! You walk in and it's like walking onto the set of Good Fellas. This is one of the most perfect meals I have had in my life. Right off the bat with the olive, pepper and Parmesan plate! The bead was top notch and the butter was the best Ive ever had in my life! The fried calamari was tender and amazing!! We had the rigatoni with vodka sauce and veal parmigiana. Absolutely incredible, and this is coming from an Italian! The brownie desert was 5 star and the service was the best! I am so impressed with this place. Jackie was an outstanding waiter! Thank you guys, CANT wait to come back! read more

I love me some delicious Italian food, Michael's is my favorite Italian restaurant, everyone the menu is finger licking delicious read more

Michael's - The spread before dinner - Italian Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

Went to Michael for the first time food and service were good. But one thing no one mentions is that the restaurant is dated, I never like rugs in a restaurant what is the reason safety there are so many floor options. I don't know when they last renovated but they should. read more

Great stuff !!!! Service is Wonderful Food is delicious I leave stuffed every time This place is a classic !! read more

Amazing, service thank you so much for a fantastic first visit Enzo! Even though covid dining was amazing. Food was very delicious and great ambiance. Food selection was great. Tasty appetizers, main course, and dessert. read more

See all

The people are so nice, the food is absolutely delicious and the prices are absolutely reasonable. I adore this place. perfect for date night or family dinner. read more

First class local Italian restaurant. Excellent food, attentive staff, great choices on the menu, both for main course and dessert. They have a great bakery right across the street from the restaurant. read more

Everything from cup of tea and bread to desert are wonderful! Totally recommend this place! Our waiter Enzo was very professional, helpful, polite and very classy ! We tried few appetizers ( lobster bisque, oysters and buratta ) , couple things for the main dish ( fisherman plate and rabbit ) , coffee, white pear tea and pistachio tortufi for desert . It was lilttle bit too much for two people) , cuz their dishes are pretty big so you can share them! I didn't eat that good for long time ! Will definitely come back! And also I liked the background piano music) read more

Michael's - Pistachio Tortufi !!! AMAZING!!! - Italian Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

Tables too close together. Prices too high. I like the food in Pronto Pizzeria, right across the street from Michaels.

I have passed this place for many years i never even knew what type of place it was thought it was a catering hall for weddings. Boy am i glad i discovered MOB through yelp The food was fresh beyond my expectations. The tomato sauce was light and not oily . I am not italian but it tasted very authentic all fresh ingredients. I ordered the veal smash job it was so tender and huge i couldn't finish it i must say it taste better as left over. I got the side if spinach ing so good made with fresh garlic how i like it. For my appetizer I ordered the eggplant rolatini equally delicious. I have no bad review for this place the waiter was kind and attentive will be returning with my friends soon. read more

Michael's - satisfied my craving for italian #smash job veal primavera side of spinach and angel hair pasta - Italian Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

Michael's is a VERY well known establishment in the Italian job of Brooklyn; and when I mean Italian job, I mean cooking it up - not wacking people....although.... Anyway, my younger sister worked here as the hostess for several years and always enjoyed mingling with the beautiful people and scoring brownie points with the cooks; we never EVER questioned where the free biscotti came from. They are to DIE for....no cement boots here. It's always highly recommended to make reservations when planning on coming here - whether it's an anniversary, communion, birthday, or "just because" affair, it's always best to see what time works for THEM, not just you. They fill up FAST during peak dinner hours and then clear out in the later part of the night; totally depends on the day you go. You might be thinking, "Is this really all worth it?" It is my friend....it IS. Everything you order here at Michael's is guranteed to make your inner Italian come out from the very pits of your stomach and into your hands as you make gestures for "Wow...this is so AMAZING!" to "Whoa whoa whoa! Who said we're sharing this penne pal?!" I've never had a problem here and never left feeling hungry that's for sure. Always ask for the specials if all else fails; tell them the LoBello's sent you. read more

Fabulous food fabulous service, I spoke to the waiters and busboys in Spanish and Italian. The wine was also great. I have been there several times with friends and family. The food was so plentiful that I had to doggie bag it. The atmosphere is also friendly, has good decor with a home feel to it, valet parking makes it easy too. It is expensive but worth it if you want to treat yourself. The menu is very plentiful with many choices of entrees, appetizers, salads, pastas, fish, seafood and meat and chicken dishes. If you want a great night out without the fuss of finding parking in Brooklyn, this is a place worth going to again and again. read more

My name is Michael Ruggiero. 73 years old and 100% Italian. As a result I have a history of great meals through my grandmothers and mother. I have tried other jars when I do not have the time to make my sauce (gravy) from scratch. Then in Publix grocery (Florida) I thought I'd try MOB. You nailed it!!!! Perfect!!! For example I made cappelini and shrimp. My guests and I found the MOB sauce to be awesome. And, no sugar! I also like the fact I can order on line since my stores in Carmel, Indiana are hit and miss on carrying. Keep up the good work. Mike Ruggiero 317.514.7537 read more

Greeting- yes Vibe- 1970 Parking- valet lot Service- excellent Bathroom- Pass. 3 toilets! Yeah Prices - moderate Wine list- well priced many selections in $23 range. Well done Michael Table Brrad- excellent assortment pretzel bread, focaccia, twists, crackers, etc Butter- room temp easy to spread Food Comp - olives cheese sausage plate - fried calamari $14 small portion unique and tasty - linguini with red clam sauce $19. Skip it horrible . Overcooked thin pasta wrong shape for dish and a minimal amount of clams. FU to that blog that just said this is one of the best dishes in NYC. You know who you are! -veal chop t bone $32 nice touch serving it sliced. Veal quality not great - short ribs with fried gnocchi $32 huge portion excellent gnocchi Dessert Comp almond cookies Napoleon $7 very good WIGB? Yes Pleasantly surprised by this Old school class decor and professional service restaurant . Large portions. I love the complimentary dishes. Nice touch . The girl in front hostess needs to smile. They mixed up out leftover take home bags! read more

See all

We had the repast after my brother's funeral yesterday at Michael's of Brooklyn. My brother loved this restaurant and I understand why. Not only is the food delicious, the ambiance and welcoming feeling you get is like a big hug. I want to thank the owners and staff for helping make a extremely difficult day a little brighter. Forever grateful read more

My wife and I love Michael's. The food is always top notch, wait staff have a great attitude and the owners come around and check on you. Overall Michael's is a great place for special occasions or to be with your special someone. read more

When you dine in, the atmosphere is really nice. The food is also very authentic and delicious (though I have only tried a small part of their menu so far). read more

This place is amazing. The food is delicious. I love the fried calamari with the hot peppers. Amazing. Can't get enough of it.

For years when I was growing up in the neighborhood, Michael's was this big, mysterious brick outpost of old-school fine-dining. Most of my experience with Italian food in Brooklyn was pizza-related, and when we did splurge, my family tended to take our money to the Russian dinner-and-a-show event spaces in Sheepshead Bay/Brighton Beach. Recently, we came for my nephew's high school graduation and I finally had a chance to rub shoulders with the neighborhood regulars who have been patronizing this institution for years. Michael's occupies a large floor with the timeless staples of Italian-American fine dining" wall mirrors, round white tablecloth tables, and muted lighting, the kind my grandparents used to create with their dimmer in the living room whenever I visited. The waiters are decked out in formal wear, a veritable team with its captain overseeing proceedings. The food is solid across the board. If you like red sauce, you'll be very happy here, as Michael's makes its own, and ladles it on pretty much everything. Many in our party had pasta, which is a pretty unassailable choice here. Though it was Friday night, I went with something called "Sunday Plate" from the specials menu. It was a lot of everything meat: veal sausage, lamb, pork, and prime rib. A real gut-buster, and I had plenty to spare for the next day. Extensive wine list. Prices are definitely inflated, but it's a nice place to bring your family who appreciate old-time Brooklyn Italian dining. read more

Pre-covid we would usually come here for special occasions and got takeout delivered from here recently. We ordered a bunch of appetizers, Margherita pizza, T-bone steak, veal alla Michael's, and linguine with white clam sauce. The taste and quality of the takeout compared to eating in restaurant was on par and just as delicious. Everything was packed well and still hot when it arrived. I was especially impressed that the T-bone steak was still piping hot and the temperature was exactly what we asked for when it arrived. My favorite was the linguine which was still al dente and the sauce was delicious. Everything was packed neatly and they even gave us the usual bread basket and sauces and olive oil. Would def recommend ordering takeout from here. read more

Excellent old style Italian food .As always owners were present and made sure everything was to our liking

Delicious and great services. Went here on a whim after our flight was cancelled and we were hungry for some good food. Reviews were spot on for this place. read more

Best Italian food in Midwood/Marine park. This restaurant has been around for years, they even sent their biscotti to space! I lived around the corner for years and this was my first time eating here and I should've came earlier. All the food was delicious and the portions were huge!! The staff made me feel like I was part of the family. We ordered the zucchini pizza, baked clams, and fried calamari for appetizers which all turned out amazing. The main courses we had the veal chop parmigiana, chicken parmigiano and fishermans platter, it all tasted so good that we ended up finishing it all regardless of how full we were. For dessert I think we tried them all, the chocolate cake, coconut cake, tiramisu, apple crumb, ice cream in a Bon Bon thing and there wasn't one item that tasted any less then the previous. Now if you haven't been to Michaels, people will tell you you're paying Manhattan prices in a Brooklyn restaurant but I think it's well worth it. I can't wait to come back! read more

See all

My boyfriend surprised me by taking me to Michael's again for the third time. We always come here for a special occasion. Last year, we came here for my 23rd birthday and it was absolutely perfect and came here also for our half year anniversary. Michael's is still as beautiful as I remembered from our visit last summer. Elegant. Classy. Romantic. Classical Music. My boyfriend made early reservations so the wait didn't take long at all. We started off with some bread and bread sticks which was a wide selection. There were also a few light appetizers - olives, cheese, and slices of pepperoni or sausage. I didn't touch too much on these. The Valentine's Day Menu Special had a variety of items to choose from. First, you select your entree which are in the range of $40-$70 and this encompasses the appetizer you order, a signauture salad, after-dinner beverage, and Valentine's Day Dessert platter. My boyfriend ordered a fried calamari with marinara sauce as an appetizer and a linguine with white clam sauce for an entree. For my appetizer, I ordered a mini meatball with ricotta cheese. This was a new appetizer that I haven't really tried before so I decided to order it. I'm battling a horrible cold right now, so I wasn't allowed to eat anything fried and nothing else appealed to me really. The mini meatballs were absolutely delicious and way better than the ones you used to eat in elementary school. They were soft and moist just the way I like it! For my entree, I decided to try something new: Veal marsala. I never really had veal and chicken marsala wasn't on the menu so I tried out the veal marsala. I must admit I wasn't too crazed about this dish after I tried some of the veal. I didn't really like the texture too much cause it was chewy and I'm so used to having chicken marsala cause the chicken is smooth, soft, and easy to chew. The veggie sides were light and I enjoyed them very much. The Valentine's Day dessert platter wasn't what I expected cause I was expecting something nicely plated and like a trio of desserts. Basically it was a velvety and chocolatety cake, chocolate covered strawberries, chocolate candy, biscotti, and some whip cream. The presentation wasn't too elegant, but my favorite part was the chocolate covered strawberries! I love them and they're such a romantic piece of food. All in all, a great dinner shared with the one I love! Although I'm still battling with my cold, we made the best out of the dinner as possible and I loved every moment of it. I highly recommend Michael's if your looking to bring your loved one or family for a nice, sit-down, and formal dinner. This is a great restaurant, with service that's to the point, and top notch food. read more

See all

Michael's doesn't need yelp reviews. It will outlast us all. This Brooklyn landmark lives up to the reputation it has, and delivers every time. The food is great; classic Italian, amazing specials (always check them!!) and a great full bar. Famous for their sauces so be sure to check some out. And I'll say it one more time check out the specials! read more

Michael's - Lobster cocktail - Italian Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

See all

Ok it's the Sunday after Christmas and we are in a mood to try a new place. I've been driving past Michael's for 30 years and never dropped in. I knew the guy who owned this place a long time ago. After checking the Yelp reviews we're finally here. Our waiter Gabriel says the restaurant will be showcased on the Food Network in 2016, as one of the top five Italian restaurants. Ok we're getting psyched. We've started with minestrone soup and baked clams. Clams are fresh and baked just perfectly. The soup is robust with all the ingredients Absolutely wonderful!! Then followed by the Australian rack of lamb and veal alla Michael. The veal is thin tasty topped with scrimp mozzarella and spinach. My son says the lamb is just like grandma would make. It really was deliciously unique! Well this place lives up to it extraordinary reputation. Five STARS!! read more

I cannot adequately explain how welcoming an amazing our experience was at Michael's. Enzo treated us like family. We were coming from the Westchester/CT area. We went to see the lights of Dyker Heights. We were heading to the Belt and it was getting late. We wanted to do a family dinner before we left Brooklyn, but we were torn as some places are too cool to welcome a family of 5...2 adults...3 kids. Not this place...thx God! These were our people! From the moment I called, they were open and willing to have us. Not only that , but they made us feel welcomed. The place is beautiful. It was decorated for Christmas and was warm and welcoming. Our kids were the only children there as we went to dinner around 8:45 (our fault...don't judge) But good people know good people. There was no judgement...just open arms! Not only was Enzo, our waiter, great but the chef came out to us to present dessert (my son's 7th birthday) and gave not one...two...but three teddy bears to each of our children. By the way, we didn't ask for recognition of my son's bday...we just mentioned it to Enzo in passing! Then, as though these individuals were not giving enough, Chef shared his sauce with us. The long and the short is "Go" ! Excellent food...beautiful decor...welcoming atmosphere. Thank you so much. We don't go to Brooklyn often, but when we do it's intentional and planned. Now...seeing you will be part of that plan. It's nice to have a place to feel at home. See you soon! read more

Michael's - Italian Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

See all

Overcharge. Some of their food taste like it has had freezer burn. Makes you wonder how long it had been sitting around in the freezer.

Great food and classy atmosphere the rabbit cacciatore was amazing and the service was great

Fantastic food!! I had filet of sole franchise and it was delicious! Great service! Old school ambiance!

Insanely impressed with their food & delivery! Fresh park cubes, olives & 2 types of bread. So reasonably priced! I will be back

I can't say enough about Michaels and how good it is, this is the rare occasion when a 6th star would be helpful! If you are looking to get a little spendy and enjoy some top of the line Italian cuisine you have to make it to the border of Marine Park and Midwood and give Michael's a shot. You can't miss it when crossing Nostrand and Avenue R, it's an old looking place with a blue awning and from the outside you would think you are heading into an outdated place, but it's farther from the truth. The dimly lit restaurant has stone walls and a bar when you first walk in, along with a stack of sauce jars that you can purchase, and when you try it you will want to bring a jar or two home! It's one big room with tables everywhere, but they are not cramped together, On weekends there may be a wait because it's VERY busy, and they do not accept reservations for parties less than 4. If you have a group larger than 4 you will need a reservation for sure. Now let's get to the fantastic food! Before you even order, you will be greeted with a big basket of bread, focaccia and crackers, along with a dish of mixed olives, artichoke hearts, cheese and sun dried tomatoes, it's all amazing and you could fill up on this pretty fast but you'll want to save some bread for later (see below). There's so much to choose from! I suggest taking a few minutes to look things over because there's a diverse list of items that might catch your eye. They have a list of specials on the menu too, although it doesn't seem to change much. My favorite all time appetizer is their shrimp, crab and avocado salad, it comes lumped together with the avocado and shrimp sitting in the delicious lump crab with a light glaze of oil, Believe me when I say this is my favorite appetizer of any Italian restaurant, it is that good (and not too big, it takes up only half the dish but packs so much flavor that it's worth it). Other appetizers to try are the hot or cold antipasto, the walnut goat cheese salad and the grilled octopus, which is also on the small side but worth a try. Also coming close to my favorite app is the eggplant rollatini, it's a big dish for an app and the ricotta inside is so creamy and dreamy I can taste it as i'm typing! I often times make my wife order it so I can get a taste of two of my favorites! I've had so many main courses at Michael's and loved them all, everything from the swordfish to the salmon to a simple fettuccine alfredo dish, but my favorite is the fisherman's platter. Get ready for this, it's a massive plate that you will never finish in one sitting, and comes with lobster, giant shrimp, mussels, clams and un-breaded calamari over linguine with Michael's signature spicy sauce. They take a little while to make this dish to make sure the flavors from the lobster and clams blend in with the sauce, and it all comes out to a masterpiece! You'll want to save some of the bread or focaccia (or ask for more) because you will be so addicted to the sauce and all you will want to do is dip! You won't finish that dish, so be smart and save some for home and ask for an extra serving of focaccia bread to go with it. For dessert my favorite is the lemon sorbet with fruit, but you can also go with the warm apple crumb with ice cream which is a big dessert dish and would be good for sharing or go for the reliable tartufo. I can't say enough about Michael's to justify how good it is, give it a try one day and you will thank me later! read more

See all

First timer. Although I've lived near this place all my life. The food was good. Highlight: my lychee martini!!!!! I had the penne w. Grilled shrimp my family had the lasagna. We also got a seafood spread. Everything was good. Piano music in the background. A nice and accommodating waiter. I will be back. Just a lovely bday dinner. read more

First time at the famous Michaels! Finally! The bread selection was so good! Definitely a good first impression. The Michaels salad was flavorful but at the bottom of the plate, there was too much balsamic vinegar. The chicken franchese was really flavorful but I expected something more, maybe like a bit of pasta instead of potatoes and vegetables. The chicken rollatina was alright, it was something different to try. The warm blueberry crumble with pistachio ice cream was the ending to a great meal and experience. It was New Year's Eve and they were prepping for a party. The decor was so nice and pretty. The service was impeccable. Definitely will be back to try something new! read more

See all

Their pasta is really good. Their spaghetti is cooked to perfection. The servers were amazing, and the atmosphere is great. It's best to make a reservation, dress well, and come with a big appetite. Their pizza was one of their special of the day and it was delicious! Their calamari like everyone said was yummy and one of the best I've had. I ordered the chicken parmigiana which was yummy. The chicken was tender and perfectly crispy. I came here earlier than the rest of my group. They led me to a table and I was given water before my party arrived. They also left some bread for me to enjoy. They also have a ton of amazing dessert choices! read more

See all

We visited Michael's of Brooklyn on Father's Day (2021) and loved the experience. They offered a special Father's Day menu that included an appetizer (15 different choices), entrée and dessert. Before our appetizers arrived, we were served a lovely antipasto consisting of cheese, salami, olives, two types of bread, bread-sticks, crackers, and butter - all gratis. The mains we selected, braciola with gnocchi and a seafood pasta, were delicious and the portions - as shown in the attached photos - were generous. This old school Italian restaurant is a true gem. read more

See all

Michael's of Brooklyn, Your jarred sauces that you sell in select grocery stores across the US are the best thing that's ever happened to me. My rigatone will never be the same. I will be seeing you in person soon. Don't change. I love you and take care, A crazed Guido read more

Best Italian Food in NYC. One of the few family owned and operated restaurants that's been around for years. Outstanding food, beautiful decor, excellent staff and again superior food. Looking forward to my next visit. read more

When you step foot into this restaurant you feel like you stepped back in time into an old school Italian restaurant. The staff and management really make sure that you are happy about your experience here. The portions are large and the food is delicious. They do not overcompensate with their quantity over their quality. Everything is amazing. They make smooth drinks to go with your food. Their wine list is something to write home about. The quality and freshness of their food is excellent. Try the fra diavolo seafood mix which can be easily ordered for two. Basically, anything you order here will be delicious. I've been here three times, and this is one of the the only restaurants that I crave to come back to. Definitely a classy place that stands on it's own. read more

Michael's - Fra diavlo seafood mix - Italian Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

See all